Skip to main content
Loading video...

Pillars of the Earth Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 15:08

hey everyone today I'm talking about The Pillars of the Earth by Michael Rennick now the purpose of the earth is a board game from 2006 takes about 90 minutes to play and is for two to four players now worker placement games are huge in today's market it really is a convoluted and crowded space of gaming and this one is pretty much accredited as being one of the forefathers of that genre and I can't really think of too much that predates it you know being 2006 Oh Jean Rousseau I guess the question is does this game hold up to today's worker placement games so the theme of the game is based on a novel at a TV series I believe I don't know too much about that but the idea is that you are collecting kind of resources and trying to contribute to building the Cathedral it's euro game you're trying to get as most as many the victory points as possible and yeah let's talk about how the game actually plays so as I said it's 2 to 4 players and what you're going to do is you're gonna have a group of little meeples I believe for master builders which are going to be kind of your worker placement aspect of the game and you are going to originally start the game with a group of different cards and those cards do different things such as converting different resources into points and that's going to be how you going to get your points because you might have these cars that say convert to sand into one point and you can do

that say three times and the same applies to word in stone and stuff like that and as the game goes on you're going to collect more of these cards and get slightly better ones maybe instead of converting two resources into you know Institute into one point you might be able to convert one resource into one point and do it more times and that's kind of how the game is going to kind of scale and cave-ins throughout the game and kind of pick up pace and you know snowball to get more and more points as you go but as I said you're going to start with a group of meeples and there's going to be seven cards out of a few more that go out face-up and then you can take turns kind of collecting those cards and those cards are going to cost a certain amount of Meatballs so say some might say our pace people in order to get for sand and you're going to take turns at that and not only going to use up to get to get new kind of resources you can use that to get improved cards as well as I said to get those ones to convert X resource into X points and they're going to cost you coins obviously once that's done any kind of spare work because you've got are going to go on to a worker piece on the board which gets you money and money's important because it kind of can help you prioritize you placing your workers with your must builders as I said once those cards have been collected you are going to go on to the main phase which is the replacement phase everybody's worker is going to go into this bag and you're going to blindly draw your master builder or a master builder from the bag and place it

on one of these spots on the board and the sooner you draw out those workers is the sooner you can place them but if you're quickened to come out of the bag it means you're gonna have to pay more in order to pay in order to play that worker straight away to see I drew my my knee pull out or my my master build out it would go on the seven spot and I can choose to either pay that seven coins to place my work straight away and obviously get priority or wait until the next person comes out and there could cost them six and then five and then four and then three and also they can choose to use that it ought to pay that action to go first or not and what's all those all those drawers have been done they're just going to go through in the order they were drawn but it's going to be free so again you've got that I love that kind of balancing of yeah I can go quickly now and get this what I really want but I'm gonna have to pay for it and the balancing is quite cool as well because obviously if you you know it's got to be cheaper if you're drawn out last but again you're going to get last priority so really nice kind of in a nice way of balancing out as I said the how much you're spending and the prioritization of getting the work placement spots you want so let's talk about some of the spots do so every round is going to be an event that comes out and you know like with a lot of games now you can going to be like a positive event such as getting resources or you know not having to pay tax and stuff like that or you get a negative event which is gonna obviously be bad things and there's one spot on the board that you can go to which lets you kind of mitigate that event if you

want to what if you don't want to you can take metal i metal is extremely precious which i'll talk about in a minute you can also choose to collect these start bonus cards to add to your tableau and again you've got X limit of cards you can have I believe it's 5 cards you can have and you're going to have to kind of carefully decide about which ones you're going to keep and which ones you're going to get rid of because you're going to lose some bonuses if you get rid of specific workers or these worker cards so you can this two spots I think like two different cards there's also spots where you can just get a straight-up points you know two points or a one point spot there's obviously all the different resource spots GPU sand and your your word and your stone and but that's already been decided by the card draft and then you've got a tax kind of spots where you can go there and not have to pay tax because if you don't go there you're gonna have to roll the dice and have to pay certain out the coins depending on that dice roll the initial spot you go to you also get an additional metal but anyone following that just doesn't have to pay the pay the tax you've also got a spot where you can take some more kind of dummy workers for the next round so you can get more mileage of collecting cards and there's also a marketplace as well where you can you know buy and sell goods depending on what you need a couple more car buying spaces for to improve your engine and

that's pretty much it so again you're going to be just taking your turns prioritizing what you want and ultimately at the end of each round you're going to convert all the resources you've collected into points by using those different carts and that's got to be the basic in the game player you got to pay that play that I'd be five rounds it might even be six doesn't quite pop into my mind right now but again that's that's basically the flow of the game and so it's a pretty light game there's not too much going on I said the metal is important because towards the end of the game you know more powerful cards come out and the ones that are kind of in the final round lets you convert the methyl you've accumulated into kind of big points which you're gonna get a lot more kind of you know a lot more jumpier point kind of divisions as you go on but yeah that's that's the further game of said is it's pretty light there's not a mountain of stuff going on I would put this in the kind of gateway genre of worker placement games and that's it really I mean in terms of its meaningful decisions I think the the worker placement aspect is is pretty good because I normally complain about a lot of these games where they're so kind of loosey-goosey where you can kind of just do what you want anyway because every kind of space bounces out if you can't go somewhere you can always go somewhere else but this one there is quite a bit of tension to get the cards you want sometimes you know if if you really don't want to pay tax you have to go to these spots and to get that metal is extremely important so those spots are quite you know keenly sought-after and which is quite nice the initial kind of collection of those cards is quite

important because when you when you get the kind of better conversion cards genève such as the one-for-one cards you can you kind of find yourself going down a certain path and then I think the kind of strategy kind of plays itself because you just want to collect the you know if you have a one-for-one conversion card you just going to collect that a certain type of resource over and over again to get the most points every round you can carry over I believe it's five resources from round to round which can be quite important but again it's not it's not massively important because again you just can use those cards to convert straight into points if you can so I think in terms of decisions that way about how you're going to get your points it's pretty obvious there's not a lot of different kind of strategies you can do and basically focus on the sand focus on the word focus on the stone try and get as much and methods as you can for the endgame and that's that's pretty much it in terms of its you know pathways to victory balance of the game it's good I mean all that all those strategies get a pretty pretty bad start the only thing that does kind of feel a bit weird is that the conversion cards all the different resources are different costs so the sand is a lot cheaper than since down but the conversion cards are pretty much working the same which is a bit weird because you know what you're converting now one stone into one point why not just convert once and into one point because it's cheaper but I suppose

only there's only X amount of those cards out anyway so everybody's going to have to kind of you know be a bit more flexible if they can and I really do like that mechanism of drawing me workers out the bag I think that's what makes this game feel more unique than anything else other than that it doesn't really stand out above the crowd the there are some different kind of mechanisms that feel a bit kind of a weird way to go about things I mean I don't personally like the card draft at the beginning because it feels like it's an extra layer to the game that doesn't need to be there if it was a bit more fiddly than it needs to be and it could be streamlined just that one step more and you also find yourself a really awkward kind of denominations of workers because you might want to I think you only have like ten or eleven workers to start with and if you buy say a card for 7 then you're left with like four workers left and there's pretty much nothing you can do with this worker so sometimes you find yourself not having much to do on your turn in terms of the time of the game I think it flows pretty nicely I think an hour and a half if you want any longer than that then I wouldn't be happy but I think it's not doesn't out States welcome too badly up time the game as well is not too bad at all you know turns are pretty obvious and what you have to do replayability wise I didn't there's a lot of different cards you can have in the game I think you're going to see the same kind of cards each in a game in and game out so every game is going to feel pretty similar you're not going to find yourself kind of going for wild strategies because they're just not

there to explore and it's kind of one of my main criticisms of the game is the kind of as I said the kind of snowballing effect it just feels pretty static because you know I said the first time you're converting to goods into one point the second round you might be converting you know one good into one point two times then you'll be finding it the third line to be one point into one good three times and then four times and then you might chuck a bit of metal in there so again it feels like it's not very interesting in gee how you going to get your points it's always pretty obvious you're gonna you know get all as many resources of a certain type you can and just spit them through the machine and there's a bit rinse and repeat and it just doesn't have that kind of you know dynamic feel where you're really building towards something and getting huge points getting a real kind of huge payoff to your investment it's very kind of small gains and you know every now and then if you're paying slightly better than the other players you might just get trick along a bit of faster than everyone else and get a few more points it just doesn't feel like your engine is going where it needs to go and it doesn't feel ultimately satisfying in my opinion but something good to say about the game though is that it does look wonderful I think the board game itself is all the you know the game board itself is lovely I think it's one of the best of Hubert's have actually seen of this genre I really do like the way it looks it has that kind of realism look to it like that kind of micro drawings it looks really cool and the artwork is fantastic the people kind of on the car to stuff aren't so good but the board definitely makes up for that component quality absolutely fine and the theme itself is

pretty much standard euro I suppose if you're into the book and stuff you might get a bit more out of it but you know cut the resources and convert them into points in order to build a cathedral completely firing me I love my euros just nothing out of the ordinary there whatsoever and the setup and teardown time as well is no issue at all so yeah overall it's this is a game that I think it's it's not held up well in terms of today's market there are so many more worker placement games that I play over this one but if I was kind of rating it on its own merit I would definitely raise it positively I think it's a well-designed game but again with this market is so convoluted I just can't rate it as highly as I as or as it probably should get because that lost so many games out there that do this better now I mean even in that kind of Gateway genre this one I think has been you know it's been replaced I'd rather play something like Lords of Waterdeep or even like to go really recent something like architects of the West Kingdom if I was going to introduce the worker placement game to someone and that being said I think this gets does that proper you know proper credit to be one of the forefathers of the genre it holds up surprisingly well in terms of how old this one is you know it doesn't feel like a really old game but again it doesn't feel like it's quite as good as some of the games that come out now again if I was racing this when it initially came out I'm sure I would print you know rate it pretty highly but

considering we have paid after all these other games then it just didn't kind of set me on fire I would like to have seen that kind of bag drawing worker mechanism be put into a new game I think that'd be quite interesting to explore with a different framework around it but on a so merit just didn't really interest me too much it's a bit light for me just a bit too static in a bit not really interesting enough again I wouldn't really recommend it as as a gateway game in terms of other games being out there but yeah it's certainly a finely designed game and it's just very much you know standard game nothing really interesting there to really rant on about so yeah I can't really recommend this one if someone recommends if someone suggested to play it I would happily go along with it I'm not going to be you know shying away from playing it again because again it's pretty well put together but I'm definitely not going to be reaching out to or asking to play it anytime soon so that's a Pillars of the Earth it's a fine game gets about you know a six out of ten for me certainly not bad in any context but in a gig marketplace that's so saturated this one just doesn't hold up as well as it could so and that's my thoughts on Pillars of the Earth you have enjoyed the review pset like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too forever now so I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved