Origin Story Game Review
Transcript
Your inner superhero is ready to emerge. Gain allies, equip gadgets, and harness powers in Origin Story from Stonem Games.
Thank you for joining us at Tantrum House Studio D. I'm Melissa D.
And I'm Kevin Dp. Origin Story is an engine building trick-T game for one to five players that is designed by Jamie Stegmire and Pete Whistinger. It takes about 45 minutes to play and it's published by Stonemire Games who sent us this review copy. In this video, we're going to give a quick overview of the game and then discuss our opinions. If you're familiar with mustfollow tricktaking games, the basics are the same for Origin Story. The deck has numbered cards and four colored suits. Players have a hand of cards and normally they'll need to follow the lead suit. The highest card of the lead suit wins the trick. The yellow cards though are the trump suit and will win a trick, beating out the other colors that were played in that trick.
Origin Story is played over five rounds. Your goal is to have the most points by the end of the game. Here's how a round works. Each player will receive eight numbered cards, three story cards, and for the first four rounds, a stamina token. You'll choose one story card to lay on your player board. Then you'll choose what to charge with your stamina. The story cards and the special power on your player board require stamina to activate.
Then everyone simultaneously chooses an alignment for the round and reveals it. Either hero or villain. Heroes will get a victory point for each trick they win during the round, and villains will get four victory points if they manage to earn zero tricks that round.
Each round, you'll get a new hand of number cards and more story cards to add to your player board. You keep the played story cards from the previous rounds, building up your powers. The last round, you'll choose a superhero card to play that usually gives you a lot of points. And then you play that final round.
The game is over at the end of the fifth round. And whoever has the most points is the winner.
Now, that was a quick overview of the game. We're going to separate the review portion into our four C's, our thoughts about the components, our critiques, our commendations, and finally, our conclusions. Let's start with the components. So, for most trick taking games, you don't have like a main game board, but in origin story, every player will have a player board. And this one's kind of cool in that it opens up and it sort of looks like a comic book story as you go from round to round. So, I like the fold that it folds open. It looks really cool.
Yeah. And it has a spot for each round, the card that you play that round.
Good.
So organized.
Yeah. I like the components. It feels really good. So, the main components in this game are going to be the cards because it's a trick- taking game. You do have a deck of the numbered cards for the tricks that you're going to be playing,
which I really like because uh the arts not all the same for the different colors. Um so, even within a different color, like the yellow deck, you have uh the fists looking at each or sort of looking at each other and then eventually they they open up. So, they almost get more powerful the higher the numbers there,
right? the subtle distinctions in the art as the cards get more powerful and higher. In addition to uh the numbered deck of cards, you have the story cards, which basically are your power cards, the ones that you'll be laying on your board to up your abilities. And then there's an event deck that you will be pulling an event from during the game. So, three main decks of cards when you're playing the multiplayer game. Then you have the superheroes, but that's not really a deck of cards,
right? Mhm.
The other main component in the game are the score trackers. Uh they are double-sided, and it's kind of interesting that as you go up on the on your score, we've um we even had players say, "Well, what about when you switch to the building side, the cool thing is the way you build it, uh the numbers stay the same. So, as you move up, the numbers will continue to move up on both sides." So, yes, good, good job keeping your score no matter what side you're on.
And then there is a wooden component as well, some stamina trackers that are
little wooden speech bubbles. So,
all right, let's move on to our critiques. So, my first critique, it comes up more, I think, in the higher player count games, especially with five players, but it can be a little tricky to keep track of all of the powers and abilities that all the players have and how that could influence the hands and the round and trying to think through all of those options. Sometimes it's hard even to remember all of your own powers and to make sure that you are activating them and thinking through their ramifications.
I totally agree. There is one game I specifically remember that I'm like, "Oh, yeah. I have to remember I had this specific power because it will it could influence what I want to do on a specific round or during that game." And I forgot to use it because I was so interested in playing my trick cards the right time, looking at other people's power. someone activates their power and like oh you know it's sort of like you know you have to rethink what's happening and that makes me not think about my own board. So because it because it plays pretty fast it's a pretty quick game. There's a lot just to take in and sort of have to figure that all out at once,
right? And some powers only activate at certain points like if you win a trick or if you're leading a trick or when someone else leads a trick. Yeah.
So, it it is can be a little chaotic and a little bit for people to really wrap their minds around, especially if they're not familiar with trick- taking games already. I think this works better for people who already understand the base level of how to play a tricking game.
Definitely more experienced trick- taking players probably will enjoy this a little bit more.
Um, the art in this game really I was not a fan of personally. I like watercolor, but the box cover specifically did not draw me in. It's like I feel like this is a comic book superhero theme. I want to have that comic book theme. And even like the back of the um the story cards has that sort of idea going on with the cape. And I think, oh, that's kind of cool. But then you turn it around, I'm like the art style doesn't work for the game play. It's not that I don't like the art style. I think it's that the art style with what I'm expecting in the game. I want more comic book art in that. So even like this here looks the origin story type face that screams comic book to me. This does not scream comic book to me. Um
the backside looks a little bit more
maybe a little bit more that. So I have these sort of competing um visions that are going on with visuals that are going on with the comic book. So, and even the even this the
Yeah, I would not look at this box. Even when it came into the in the mail, I'm like, I don't know what type of game this is. I'm not sure what's going on. The title was kind of hard to see up in the the top.
Now that I've played the game, it makes sense, but I don't know that someone looking at it in a store is going to have any idea of what this game is about. Yeah, I'm kind of sad in the sense I want that to I want people to get grab their attention and be like I know sort of what I probably will get. Maybe I don't know it's a trick taking game. Maybe I don't know what the game is about, but I
looking at a visual of like a comic book, I'm like, "Oh, that's a superhero." Like if I see something like that, this doesn't scream that to me and I want it to. Okay. I I think maybe they were trying to go for a broader audience than the traditional comic books, but
comic books are huge. So,
okay. Um, this next critique that I have, it's not a personal critique, so it's not a problem I have with the game, but um,
basically, if you're the type of player who wants to have a lot of control and be able to plan things out and follow a plan, you may get a little frustrated. We have a friend who played this with us and he was like
he felt like he was getting thwarted all the time because of all of the powers and things that can happen, the events. There is variableness and it's some randomness in the game. one because it's a card game, but then with all the powers sometimes your powers will really synergize well and then in other games it's like
well I can do some stuff but it's not really affecting my score.
So duel it's that will they synergize or not synergize and then what about everyone else's power? How is that going to affect what my game play? And that could really throw someone else. just want a trick. Someone has a power that can reverse time and make that not happen again. So, um
I don't I didn't personally mind it.
I I also didn't mind it,
but we did have someone in our game group. So, I appreciate Melissa that you're saying there are people that like maybe not as much randomness.
Mhm. Like a little bit more control. I think there's still strategy and you can still lean into things
and make good choices, but you have to be adaptable. A lot of adaptability in this game.
Yeah. Which goes to the superhero theme. So, I think going into it, maybe that that game or this type of game is not for our friend,
right? And he's like a bridge player. And I think that has a lot more control and strategy and and thinking things out. One more I guess I wouldn't really call it a critique I call it a caution is you do have to build the um score trackers and they all pieces and even on this says on here ensure you attach the numbered wheels with correct color facing up and the correct side. So there's instructions even on like the punch board to make sure you do it right. Let me just say
it was even doing it myself and knowing that I had to do it correctly. I still did it wrong. I had to take a few apart.
Yeah.
And then I think you reattached it and still did it wrong the second time.
Yeah. The way the arrows I don't know. I don't know how to even make it even more clear. It was even told me to make it correctly and I still did it incorrectly thinking that arrows went the certain direction and I misinterpreted what it meant. So I'm just warning you. I'm cautioning you. making sure you you do it properly. So, um you don't have to take them apart and put them back together cuz it's one, two, three, it's like three different three or four I mean four different pieces going together to make sure which we said in our component section to make sure that the numbers are the correct
right side up and when you flip it they continue to be the right side so that when you move up that you're not moving down on the other side.
Right? So, yes, double check the first one before you keep making them.
All right, let's move on to our commendations.
So, I think my favorite part of this game are the story cards, the special powers that you're going to be playing down onto your board. There are tons of them.
Yeah, there's a whole stack.
And each round that you get a new card, you draw three and you keep one, discard the other two. So, you do have choices. Now, sometimes all three are awesome and you wish you could keep them. And other times you're like, none of these are super great, but they still let you do things. Some of them will give you points. Some of them will give you powers that affect the tricks that hopefully will make things easier. Some of them can like give tricks to other people if you're trying to be a villain. So there's a lot of variability with them and you can start shaping your gameplay and how you choose your alignment based on those story cards.
I think we may have hinted at it, but sometimes they synergize well together and be like if you do this with one power, it could affect another power, which I find that very interesting that you get even more powerful,
right? Like I think there are some that increase the value of certain suits.
Yeah. And then there are some that give you points if you lead with a certain type of
or even a card that says these cards become another suit. So it's like oh now these cards are even more powerful which is really cool.
Yeah. So you can definitely find some cards that really work well together.
Yeah. I will say there are some cards that are really really good and there are some cards that aren't. But I think that's okay. You want you don't want all the cards to be the same. So you want some balance in that. And I do like that you get your hand of cards for that round before you choose your power. So if it's like, oh, red cards are super powerful, but I don't have any red cards in my hand, I might not choose that power,
or I may choose it hoping that later rounds I can activate it. So I do like being able to see my current hand before I choose the new power.
And you're not getting all five at the beginning. So, you actually are sort of building up throughout the game, which I think is interesting, too. So, you're adding one story card for one round, you're adding another story card. So,
yeah. And you have to charge the card.
So, you have choices on that. Mhm.
So, there's strategy in that. You might not have enough stamina to activate every single card. So, each round you're deciding which cards, which powers are most important to me this round. And sometimes you choose correctly. And then other times you go, "Oh, wow. I really should have chosen that other power cuz that did not go the way I was anticipating it to go.
So the score, we mentioned the score tracker a number of times. This actually is useful in the game too because it helps you tell people what alignment are you going to be the hero or you going to be the villain. And the score tracker has a villain side and a hero side. So, what you're doing at the beginning of each round after you choose your story card, after you have all your hand number cards,
after you charge up
everything, then you're like, do I think I'm going to win lots of tricks or do you think I can win zero tricks? And I I like that you get to choose your alignment each round. It's not like, oh, I'm a hero for the whole game or I'm a villain for the whole game. So then simultaneously, people will then reveal, I'm a hero this round, or I'm a villain this round. They're like, oh, Melissa's also a villain. We're all trying to. And then the other person's like, "Yeah, cuz I'm going to get lots of tricks because Melissa and Kevin aren't getting any tricks." Which, you know, it sort of feeds into that,
right? Yeah, it is. It is interesting when it's lopsided one way or the other and you go, "Oh, should have chosen the other one cuz this is going to be difficult."
Or you're trying to as heroes be like, "I want the villain to win at least one trick." And then they don't get any points that round. So, you sort of fluff it off on them.
Yeah. The alignment brings in some interesting strategy to the rounds as well.
Uh, another thing that I like in games is when there are player aid cards, something that I I learn by reading. So, being able to read it as people are explaining or be able to look and see what's going on is very helpful to me. And the way they did it for this game is you are given two superhero cards at the beginning of the game and in round five you get to choose one of them.
Mhm.
Well, the backside of those superhero cards are the player aid, the round tracker that gives you all of that information. So, basically, they're just sitting face down in their slot throughout the game and you have that information available to you. And then once it's the last round of the game, you don't really need that information anymore. So you're going to reveal your superhero and
yeah, it's not taking up another component. It's not out on the board somewhere. It's already integrated into what you have.
One other thing that I really like in the game are the event cards. And
they only happen at one point in the I think it's at the beginning of round three. So, it's like sort of halfway through the game, maybe a little bit more than half, halfway through the game, you are revealing one event and that just for that one round can really change up what's going on for the round, whether it's maybe a way to get more points or a way to just change up what's going on. So, I like that not only are you doing things on your own board and then you have your superhero that you're working towards as well, but then you have that one sort of big event that's happening
and there's a whole stack of events. So,
and you're doing one per game.
It will take a long time to get through them all.
Yeah. Well, why don't we go on to our conclusions? So, in conclusion, we really haven't talked about player count. We actually have played this at two, three, four, and five player count. We haven't played it at one, but we don't really play solo games, so that's not really the point of this channel. But I think we like it at maybe the higher player counts. What do you think?
Yeah, I would say four is my favorite player count. Uh five is gets a little chaotic. Um and I think it's a little easier to play as a villain in the higher higher player counts because they're um the tricks are more spread out
and more people want to win normally.
Mhm. I will say two-player I not many trickt taking games play great at
unless unless it was built for two players. I agree.
And this one has a special mechanism for when you're playing with two players and I thought it worked fine but it's not what I'm looking for.
I didn't think it worked fine. I was like it's not worth playing two players.
Three, three, four or five and I agree. Four, four player. So anything else about the player counts? Yeah, I do think that some powers and some events are going to be more interesting or more impactful at high higher player counts and then some are going to be more impactful at lower player counts. So I I felt like even similar cards felt different depending on the number of players that were in the game.
I agree. I agree. I also like it at four as well. I I think just in general we enjoy trickt taking games. We play a number of them and yeah
yeah there's a lot that have come out recently a lot of great trick playing trick taking games
cooperative trick taking compet now this is a competitive trick- taking game but we like all types of trick- taking game I really do like what this brings to the table it's different than a lot of other trick- taking games that are out there. Yeah, this one I would bring out when I have people who are experienced with trick taking so that they wouldn't get super overwhelmed by all of the powers and the changes to the game from round to round. Um, so I think it hits well for people who enjoy trick taking and want that next level
and they're okay with a little uh variability and and adaptability
and a little bit of randomness, like a little less control.
Um, so I think we have people in our game group that fit that style and they've really enjoyed playing the game with us.
I I will say one other point about that because we didn't talk about player interaction. There are a few cards that actually hurt other players, but I wouldn't say that's the norm in this game. I would say most of it is sort of I'm powerful and I can do amazing things out or I can get points or my cards are really cool. There's not a lot of cards, but there are a couple of them that actually like actually um are specifically to another player like doing something.
So, but I will I just wanted to let you know about those,
right? It's It's not all contained just to yourself.
Well, we'd love for you to tell us in the comments what have been some of your favorite trick ticking games. Let us know down in the comments. And as always, please like, subscribe to Tantrum Mouse, and look forward to more videos coming soon. If you want a chance to play and potentially win a copy of Origin Story, we're going to have a tournal at Tantrum Con 2026 at the beginning of February. triccot.com. Captain.