Wait, is this a Trajan reskin? Ostia First Impressions
Transcript
hello and welcome to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this video I'm going to go over my first impressions of AA now this is a game that was kickstarted back in 2022 I believe and was fulfilled last year and so this counts as a game from last year and has received a lot of Buzz lately so I wanted to demo this and give you my first impressions so to quickly go over what this game is about as well as including the expansion material from the pirate expansion that I want to talk about you are essentially using a mkala system of action taking where if you're not familiar you pick up the pieces that are in a sector you gain resources based off of that sector and then move your pieces you know one by one until you place your final piece in a certain sector and then you get to take that action that's a very simplified approach to what this game is all about but you are using these actions to do many things such as build buildings onto your uh little Tableau here you are moving your ships across the ports of ancient you know Middle Eastern Mediterranean ports here you know all represented by different cities and uh you are hoping to allow access to be able to take buildings from these places to be built onto your Tableau and elsewhere but also to get these ships over to the end end of these far away lands to gain Victory
Point conditions to to earn you are also uh doing a little bit of set collecting with these orders you're spending resources to fulfill orders based off of these cards and then you're also advancing along this track to based off of the uh number of items that you collect as well as the different buildings and ships that you have as well you are gaining a certain amount of points uh more so if you advance farther along this track now with the Pirates expansion a few additions are made to the game where you have pirates on your ships and I'll go back to the main board here so you have these black and red ships you need to have a certain amount of military might to be able to repel and pass them and if you do so you gain treasure from them as well as you flip over events that will be randomized and take place randomly uh and then you also can over on your board keep track of those uh that military strength here but also hire legionnaires to help give you a foundational boost to your military might you have these disgrace tokens that are based off of these starting cards that give you some asymmetric powers during the game and you can get rid of these to gain essentially seven points at the end of the game and then finally you have this board over here where it serves as a randomized assortment of different buildings or
locations where you can build buildings in addition to your own personal Tableau which essentially gives you some efficiencies along the way so that's a basic overview of what osta is all about now let's get into some game comparisons so the first game that I want to compare this to is Yokohama first of all both games are of Japanese origin when it comes to the design uh hitashi hiashi is the designer of Yokohama and tatsuko chuo is the designer for osta I failed to mention that before but you know maybe this is an early impression to the philosophy behind some of these bigger Japanese games but when it comes to a more Euro style mechanism you have a lot of setup randomization to make each game feel different in Yokohama you arrange your modular board with the different uh districts of the city being in different locations really affect how the worker placement and movement is happening in this game versus here you have a lot of different tiles in in terms of these for example lighter or sorry darker uh tan orange uh tiles that give you certain abilities or endgame effects if you uh construct or pass these buildings and so all of this is randomized and so they'll be in different places if they're if they reappear from game to game they might be in a different spot so that might affect your uh choices for where to send your ships and what line to draw through them as well as some of these
tokens these will be randomized to if you land on them give you different resources that may or may not be useful from game to game as well and there are a plethora of other things that are different in in the setup randomization that I find very very similar between these two games so the next game that I want to compare to is Concordia mostly for its theme and setting I think both games are set around the same time frame and time period of ancient Roman Empire slm Mediterranean Merchants trading kind of theme right but also there's kind of an element of set collection in both games in this one you're spending resources to collect certain cards and you know hopefully if you collect the right amounts of icons that could affect how many points you get but in addition to that there is an element in Concordia where you are trying to collect a certain type of card as well and the more that you collect of that type of card the more that you will compound and score from them and I find that kind of similar in this game where as you progress along this scoring track if you do happen to focus on certain aspects of the game you will be able to get more points out of those uh particular icons and resources than any of the others and so track advancement is important in this game in a sense it's not really a track that you're going along but you're collecting cards in a set collection type of experience in Concordia so I guess in terms of theme as well as the feel for how the mechanisms come together to score at the end of the game felt pretty similar to that then finally
I would be remiss if I did not compare this game to trun a Stefon Feld game from years ago that just fell out the top 100 if I'm not mistaken but both games utilize a manala based system to take your actions with I could compare this game as well to five tribes but uh in terms of theme this one aligns more with Tron because in actuality the rule book for AA mentions the emperor trun and so this literally takes place in like the same time frame as Tran but in addition to that I just as a quick you know interjection for Impressions I feel like the elements of this mangala system is connected a lot more one to another than it feels like in trajan it's been a while since I've played this game but I did come away with the impression that trun and its action selection system was a collection of mini games as it were that felt a little disjointed one from another I think there is probably more of a connection among those mechanisms if I'm if I were to dive deeper into it but I just feel like on First Impressions it was a lot more connected in this game where for example uh collecting the resources these permits to move your ship was important to move along the track on the central board so you can have spaces to you know build your buildings from take buildings from and place them but also to gain resources to um allow for trading which is pictured in this section allow for
flexibility and what you can spend your gold on Etc right and then to get more ships out there you have to build more ships and so so on and so forth right and so it's uh it's all really uh smartly intertwined in osta where I felt like it was a little dinted in tran so going into the peer review for what others have said about game in the years that it has been on Kickstarter and for people to allow to see you know on tabletop simulator as well as in person some people said that this game felt pretty smooth to play as far as Pros are concerned has a lot of strategic depth as well and the progression is great so I feel like that's true especially when you have a randomized setup that can lead to different focuses from game to game that can feel strategically different from game to game and the way that this game scales as well I think is what people in in terms of the resources and the like the amount of ships that you have on your montala board can really create for uh an expansive experience when you play this game a lot of people enjoy the Malala mechanism and the production in person is pretty good as well however some people felt like the endgame trigger the the way that this game is very similar to how Yokohama ends so when there are a couple of different ways this game can end for example once someone has reached three of the four end uh ending spots on the central board I believe uh if some if all the mfor are collected as well Etc
so there are a lot of different conditions and so sometimes that can be surprising and leave people lacking as to being able to put together a nice combination you know to gain a lot of points at the end of the game a lot of people felt like there wasn't a lot of interaction in this game it felt like a multiplayer soliter where you were trying to solve the puzzle of your own mkala uh without a lot of elements to combat I I suppose more of the interaction is placing buildings on this pirate expansion board is one major um point of interaction if you pass a port anyone can build there if as long as your ship has already passed it and so so there's not a lot of blocking per se in on the central board right and of course the orders that you're trying to fulfill there's minor interactions there uh scoring can be pretty tedious I I feel like that is true because uh you know with the uh expansive track that you were scoring with you know you're you're kind of multiplying a lot of those points based off of the icons the number of buildings that you scored it's a high-scoring game and so there's it could take a while for you to calculate your score and I I didn't really dive into what these strategies were but some felt that there are uh strategies that feel dominant in this game so uh yep so the variability in setup can lead to unbalanced experiences sure that's just inherent in the nature of the game being set up as it is and you know for you to take advantage of if you
spot those uh you know differences then a lot of people mentioned you know they would rather play trun uh a lot of people also mentioned Crusaders thy will be done that is a game that I've played it's on board game arena and totally forgot it's another mkala based game where I feel like there is from what I remember a lot more of an interactive experience and so if that is something that you would rather have in in a game that utilizes aala then Crusaders would be a good one to try but if you I guess like a more multiplayer solitire version of of that and maybe you like myself have not really enjoyed trun as the majority of board game players do then AA might be up your alley but let's take that and segue into my first impressions of osta so with my criteria which I base off my reviews and first impressions going over AA I give it a 7.4 out of 10 I think the rules are pretty straightforward and pretty easy to learn especially if you're familiar with the mangala system and have a familiarity with a lot of these Euro style mechanisms I feel like the Strategic Avenues are interesting but it kind of going along with replayability I feel like this game can feel pretty similar from game to game once you kind of get a a hold of it and understand what you're trying to look for I I don't think there's a wide variety of different strategies that you can focus
on essentially looking at collecting different buildings putting out different buildings a lot of different uh ships as well and or you know the the set collection elements along the way as well as these endgame uh opportunities with these ships right I think the additional Maps or sorry building spaces that you have with the pirate board adds a lot of variability to this game and I think the initial setup for this game can create for a different puzzle each time you solve it you know but essentially I think taking the same kind of actions and kind of rinsing and washing through it uh in this setting doesn't create as drastically different you know a drastic difference of how this game kind of plays out in the long run another game that I thought of that kind of utilizes a mkala that's kind of hidden is Arc NOA right and so in Arc NOA you have your action cards that are lined up from 1 to five in terms of power and you can simply just pick the you know the card under the fifth action spot and just utilize that for its most potent action right every time and kind of go in a cycle or Rondell right as you take those actions but a lot of that game has one variability based off of a different and large amount of cards and the different maps that you play on as well offer that sense of variability that leads to a lot of Mastery and in this game it's very similar to how I feel about Yokohama where a lot of the setup
Randomness is done so by these tiles but a lot of I guess the that's that's the extent of what this game is going to be when it comes to the differences from game to game you're not going to have a modular board other than these tiles you're not going to have other like the the set collection cards aren't that you know they're they're just turning resources for some others and for points right and so it's not terribly exciting I would say that you can gain a lot of ongoing abilities in Yokohama that are seen here in these tiles as well so it is comparable but I feel like there's a lot more of that setup Randomness and interesting variability in Yokohama compared to osta so for me it's it's less fun of a game than I think Yokohama would be in the long run but I do applaud this game for being a pretty streamlined version of some of these other games like uh Crusaders uh trun Yokohama and approaching the the way that a lot of those games might you know it might be a little bit too hard of a puzzle to wrap your head around when you look at the game state right at the beginning of the game versus here I feel like it's pretty it's a lot easier to step into and understand what you need to try to do in this game and what your order of turns may be one comment that I agree with in in the board game geek comments is that this game can have a pretty similar start every round because you know you have a little bit of
variability setup variability in where some of these ships might be but you know you start pretty small and pretty predictably as you try to just move your ship across these different routes and once you do so then you start to compound the amount of resources that you can get the amount of buildings that you can build with more ships that you put out as well and it can really snowball into uh you know having really big turns and having really cool combinations one AC in particular that I want to mention is the administration action where you can essentially take two different turns on the same turn and so this really mitigates the uh I guess the not the randomness but you know just the way that perhaps your Mand uh your mangala uh Rondell can be kind of stagnated at times where you take up a lot of cool actions and then have to rebuild slowly if you save enough ships to either pick up from or land on the administration action you will be able to utilize some of those other actions that maybe you would want to do back to back or you know if you if the the way that the ships are aligned if you can't take that certain action immediately then you can hopefully have that Administration action to kind of take a freebie while turn to do what you want to do and so I thought that was an excellent addition to this game that really makes the monola shine but other than that you know and that's kind of why I give a mechanism strength of eight I think that was really neat I do agree with a lot of people saying that the expansion really
adds enough complexity to this game to make it uh more interesting on playthrough and I'm glad that I played with this at first I would recommend that as well otherwise the base game is you know somewhat interesting and an okay to learn from but I think in the long run this new expansion really adds to this game so yeah a lot of people prefer trun over this game Crusaders as well a lot of people who enjoy those games say that this one kind of felt like second best or third best to those and me personally I I would rather play Yokohama than AA but I think I would rather play AA over those other monk hola games you know even five tribes I I just find this game a little bit more engaging it's a lot easier for me to wrap my head around what's going on uh it probably won't serve as a very skillful game in the long run but it would be a fun game to return to if someone suggested it I guess that's where I'm at so those are my first impressions of osta let me know what you think about this game if you've played it thank you for Consulting with me today hope you schedule an appointment with your board gaming doctor real soon and I'll catch you on the next one take care