Manhattan Project: Energy Empire Review - JonGetsGames
Transcript
welcome to jnit games today I'll be reviewing Manhattan Project energy Empire this game was designed by Luke Lowry and Tom jolly and this is a worker placement style engine building game but you only get to activate parts of your engine depending on what part of the board you activate with your workers you are going to be building this engine larger you're going to get more workers and specifically get more and more energy as your infrastructure grows first I'll explain how the game plays and then I'll jump into my review here's an example of a player area at the beginning of the game they start with three workers and two energ but as the game goes on they'll have the ability to generate three more workers and up to 10 energy total but they'll build into that later on players now need to decide what country they will be representing for the game and they'll do that by taking two of these cards and picking from one of them along the top they'll see their starting resources which might also be extra energy dice or workers at the beginning of the game and down at the bottom they will see their requirements for bumping up on the United Nations track so let's say this player chose France they can flip this one over it gives them a handy dandy player reference sheet and lastly they draw two achievements pick one of them and it'll be some endgame victory points which I'll talk about later there is one other part of setup that I want to explain before we jump into the gameplay now that is all of these different Stacks that have these little pollution tokens in them and this is going to vary based on the player count in a hypothetical three-player game we have five in each of these stacks and then over here we have the event cards there are nine total of these green early events and six total of these red late game events you shuffle them up you pull three out out of each and those will be the ones
you play with in the game on a player's turn they can either work or generate and I'll explain how working works first so they'll take a worker and put them out onto one of these worker placement spots which you can notice by this little symbol with the the person with the helmet and when they put this worker down they will immediately evaluate the uh action for that spot so for instance if they went right here they would immediately generate one Steel in general all of these actions are pretty self-explanatory for instance this one right here would allow a player to put a oil weld down onto their player board in order to generate three of these oil barrels this right here would let them spend one of these oil Barrels in order to get a couple plastic a science token and they'd have to put a pollution down on their board then over here we have a spot where they can take money but then if they uh choose to take even more money their opponents will get some money they can trade oil barrels for money and then over here they can also generate science tokens they can convert s tokens into recycling actions as well as generate new workers for themselves down here we have the power plant action spot and this is special because because it's the only way for players to generate more of these energy Dice and they'll be rolling these later and I'll explain how that works but as you can see they just spend the required resources in order to take the associated die lastly we have these three very large Market sections and this is where players will be able to purchase these buildings and put them into their Tableau now when you go into this area you can only buy the buildings associated with that colored spot so here would be the industry Market this is the Commerce market and over here we have the government and the price to purchase each of these buildings is listed along the top it'll either be money or a certain number of the
associated resource with that area so with industrial you spend money or steel and once you buy one of these cards you then slide the remaining ones over and refill the row immediately let's look at this building in a little more detail we see in the top left this three star which means that this player will get three points at the end of the game for having this building and importantly in the top right we see that this building is going to give them pollution it's going to be a regular pollution and it has to go into the air for their area and if we look at their um starting area everybody starts with one pollution in the air and in the game whenever you take pollution for any reason except for events you need to grab it from the top of these Stacks over here on the leftmost side and then you can put it down in any of the correctly matching spots on your player board in general it makes most sense to go farthest to the left and you'll notice that we just covered up a one star which means at certain parts of the game including at the end of the game this could potentially be worth points for us as long as it's not actually covered up by pollution and most importantly the player now has this building in their tableau so that they can do actions with it after they do a work action by putting a worker out on any of the spots on the board they can then activate as many of their personal buildings as they want to of the matching Associated part of the board so since we put a worker in the industrial portion of the board we can activate all industrial buildings we want but if for instance the player also had a government building they would not be able to do anything with this until a future turn when they do a work action in the left third of the board whenever you activate your structures you'll notice that you can spend either energy or workers to evaluate this action and some buildings have these two different
spots and what this means is you can spend one of these once in order to get the bonus in this case you would generate a steal for your player area but you would not be able to do the other one until you do another industrial work action there are also cards out there that just have a single spot that can only be activated once until it is cleared out with the generate action which I'll explain very soon and there are other ones that require you to spend two energy two workers or an energy and a worker to get the benefit but in general these are a much better action you may have noticed the symbol at the bottom of our nation card matches that on our structures and that means that whenever you do any work action on the board our nation is effectively wild and you can activate the action down in the bottom you simply spend the resources on the left in order to bump once up on the United Nations track so in this instance the player could use this one worker spend one science and two money and they bump themselves up on the track effectively generating themselves four points at the end of the game you'll notice that the points go up the farther you go although the gap between them get smaller until you get to this last spot which can only take a single worker spot and that is going to be 17 points plus at the end of the game whoever is farthest along um on this track even if they're not at the end is going to get a bonus of three points before I go any further let's talk about what happens when you want to activate a zone that already has a worker in it now this could be worker of your own color or one of your opponents and the rules are simple you are allowed to activate that spot as long as you spend enough energy to make your new worker stack higher than the previous one so in this instance this was just a stack of one so the yellow player is able to activate this because they spent the one energy if the green player wants
to come back in here and use this spot that's fine but in this case they would need to spend at least two energy with this activation it's also worth noting that a player can spend more energy than they need to in order to make it harder for an opponent to follow in on that action we've talked about a couple ways that players can generate pollution but let's now talk in a little more specifics of how you can clean it up this symbol right here is a recycle action and for instance this spot on the board would allow the player to spend one science to get two of these recycle actions and for each of these actions a player can remove one of their regular pollution from the board or they could remove one of their oil rigs whether it be on land or in the water or if they happen to have one of these really bad nuclear pollutions they can spend an action to flip it over to regular pollution and then spend another action to remove that from their board we've talked a whole bunch about what players can do with a work action on their turn but instead of doing a work action they can choose to generate and they're either going to do this when they've run out of workers Andor energy or once they just have nothing else they necessarily want to do now the first thing that happens when you decide to do a generate action is you look to see if you have at least two workers or energy or any combination thereof and if you do then you can pull one of these new achievement tiles from the board and these once again are endgame points that you can flip over and put into your achievement stack and then any excess energy that was not spent is going to be lost next they bring all of their workers home and ditch any energy that they use to activate any of their buildings and now they generate their energy die pool now this player for instance has a yellow and a green D you can choose to use some or all of your dice if you want and you could spend up
to five of your oil barrels at a one to one rate in order to get these petroleum dice which you can then roll uh once for this specific round and then you lose the option for the future rounds so it's a reason to keep generating oil so let's say the player decides they're going to do all of these dice they're going to roll them up and they see what the results are first of all we want to look to see what the biggest number is and we see that in one way they're a D6 there's a 1 2 3 4 5 and six on them and this petroleum die has a six the die that has the highest number is going to be the one that dictates if a player is going to get any pollution so they're going to get one regular pollution because this was the highest however if this yellow D had been the highest you'll see it actually gives them nuclear pollution it's also worth noting that if they had rolled a six with this green die right here then whenever you have a tie it actually goes in your favor and you can choose which of these dice is going to valuate for you on your pollution so obviously in this case they would choose not to take any pollution but whether or not a player actually has to put pollution on their board they're going to take one pollution from the top of this stack and they'll discard it if they don't have to take it or they'll put it down on their board either with the regular side or the nuclear side depending on how their dice rolled and lastly they simply count up all of their energy symbols in this case we see7 and that's the amount of energy that they get to play with in the next round it's worth noting that there is this handy table on every player sheet so you can see how much uh energy they'll get on any of the specific die faces for all five of the dice that can be rolled let's now talk about what happens once the last of these these pollution tokens are taken from one of these Stacks the player is going to finish out their action and then they will immediately evaluate the next of these events on the
track you'll notice that there are three of these green events at first and then there are actually three of these red events and the green events are generally nice to all the players and the red events are not so let's go ahead and flip over the first event to see what these look like the first thing to note up on the top is each player is going to score points for the number of uncovered uh pieces of their environment that is associated with this card so this instance they would get points for their air next up they would look to see this symbol and all of the uh buildings that match the symbol on that part of the board in this case government would get wiped from the board and refreshed so it's just one way to see more of the buildings and lastly there is going to be a Global Effect that's going to affect all of the players once again the green effects in general help players and for these red cards they are generally meaner for instance with this market crash uh it's going to be harder to build buildings and then we have let's see this one right here this is a Pand iic players will lose access to some of their workers and this last one over here nuclear fallout it sprinkles nuclear pollution all out onto the board onto the spots that people want to go to so this is a way that players are going to be scoring uh points one of the ways in the middle of the game six different times and a way for the game to bring in variety to each gameplay since there are several of these cards to choose from when you do setup lastly it's worth noting that players will not always be in the dark as to what new events are going to come out because whenever they do an action that has this symbol they will be able to peek at a future event look at it and then put it back down and then try to make decisions based on their knowledge of the future once the final pollution is taken from the track the last event will be evaluated as
normal and then all players are going to take one more turn including the player who triggered the end game and at that point the game will be over and they can go into final scoring at this point all players will add up several things to the score they've already generated throughout the game they'll start with their achievements which they can have a maximum of five of and each achievement can generate a maximum of Five Points each then they will add in all of the points for their buildings next all of the uncovered points on their player Board and they'll get these bonuses if they have completely clear columns associated with them and over here we see that they will also get points for the number of dice that they were able to make up to a maximum of five lastly they're going to add in their United Nations points which are going to equal the spot where their token is and an extra three points if they happen to be the farthest down on the track at that point they look to see who has the most points and they're the winner let's now begin the review for energy Empire by covering a couple positive points and the first of these relates to to the act of engine building and the novel ideas that come into play with this game and right for the get-go I want to say that I'm going to be covering the engine building aspect here and not really the engine running because that is going to come into play a little bit later on in this review but specifically talking about the act of creating the engine in front of you gives you a wonderful uh variety of interesting decisions because you need to think about what style of engine you are going to be building because uh you might go for uh several buildings in all the different colors which leaves you more flexible out on the main board because you could put a worker over here and activate these and put a worker over there and activate those versus maybe just going really hard on one of the colors which means that you that you will your um options
out on the board are going to become more restricted because you've overly incentivized one of the colors and that's just another style of engine that you can build yourself towards and it is fun trying to seek out the combinations between the buildings uh from the different colors or even just within a color and trying to have those combo um with each other as well as combo with the various options that are out on the board so there is a wonderful sense of um scaling and progression as you play through the game at the very beginning of the game there you have no buildings at all and you are going to ramp into having a whole bunch of buildings I think the fewest buildings I've ever seen anybody end the game with is like five or six and I've seen people end the game with like nine or 10 of these if they go really hard on acquiring those so there's um a great sense of um kind of accomplishment of really doing things and uh approaching a much larger end game you just have so many more things you can do in the process of actually building out this engine and I love the decisions that are inherent and the process of actually putting those pieces together positive Point number two relates to the actual workers themselves but specifically the two different types of workers in this game you have the actual human little worker tokens and then you have the energy tokens and they both behave a lot like workers in this various style of game now if you want to activate a location out on the main board you must use their little human workers but there's a neat little twist and that you can um bolster that uh worker by adding energy to them you might need to do this if you want to go to a spot where somebody else already is uh because you need to make your stack higher and you can't add extra workers
you just have to add always one worker plus energy to at least get higher but hypothetically if you didn't want other people going to that one spot you could put more energy there although I haven't really seen that happen just to make it even more expensive for other people to go there but it is potentially an option but then when you look down at all the buildings that you've been purchasing throughout the game you you can activate all of those with your human workers or your energy worker and that means that both of these tokens are really effective and useful in a couple different ways and as you are actually playing through the game you have some pretty good decisions when it comes to how you want to spend these workers because you know probably like halfway through the game you might have three to um three to five workers it kind of depends on how you've been playing that one game and then you might also be looking at five or six energy uh production at that point and so on your turn you might be thinking when you're activating your buildings do I put workers down there or do I put energy down there and I really need to balance these things back and forth because if you use too many workers down there then you are going to limit the number of overall actions you can do on the main board because every one of those needs a human worker um but if you um spend too much of your energy down below and then just have workers then you're going to restrict the options you have out on the main board because you won't be able to go to where your opponents are because they've already got that spot in there and you have to get higher and if you don't save that energy around then that's going to be a problem so I love the fact that this game game has these two different styles of workers and I really like how they have strength and weaknesses between them and it is an enjoyable experience trying to figure out how best to utilize them as a resource let's now shift over into a few
neutral points and the first of these has to do with the other engine in this game and that is the energy dice that you are going to be acquiring and rolling every single time you do a generate action and these will give you those vital um energy tokens that you're going to be spending as workers in order to do all the cool stuff as you're playing so there are a couple different aspects to these dice some of these things I really like and some of these things I don't which is why we're in the neutral section with this the on one side I like that these going really hard and having lots of these dice does not appear to be a dominant strategy I've seen people play very well having just two or three dice at the end of the game going the whole way through perhaps using um the oil barrels which you can acquire with relative ease to just turn into one time use dice when they're doing the generate actions um but I've also seen people do really well when they um early on try to just buy five energy Dice and they just get tons of energy early in the game they work really uh well with that but of course you are spending a rather large amount of resources and time just getting those dice out especially considering there's only one spot on the board where you can go to actually purchase those dice it could be hotly contested so you're going to be giving up even more uh energy um tokens in order to go on that spot when other people are there so from an engent perspective I enjoy the process of figuring out which dice to actually grab because you know the yellow dice give you tons of energy but that nuclear pollution is terrible so if you get that yellow Dy you probably want to get several of the other ones to try to and dilute that down um it is uh interesting kind of syncing all these different typ of dice together or just saying you know I'm just going oil uh with the the brown and the black Dice and I'm just going to
take up one regular pollution every single time and not really worry about it so the flip side to the dice is that you have to roll these and this is a definitely a Euro Style game where with the worker placement and the engine building and then you get to this point where you roll the dice there is zero mitigation there's zero dice manipulation and you just deal with the outcome and then on top of that this is not the kind of game where the die roll gives you um branching decision tree and options but it doesn't you can't really roll badly in this game you can if you roll low that is bad if you roll high that is good for you um I guess if you roll high and just barely higher with your potentially bad dice then you're going to be getting that pollution but if you tie with your two highest dice which does happen somewhat often then it goes in your favor and you can use the die that is probably not going to give you ution so there I've definitely seen many occasions where somebody rolls a dice and they get the worst possible outcome they roll like maybe three or four dice and the next person rolls one or two less dice they get the best possible outcome and they get the same or more energy for that next round and it just feels it takes the wind out of your sales a little bit um because there is no way to flip those dice around and because there are some signs that are just worse than others like I feel like if they had done a sort of thing where um the the better dice um that give you more energy uh at the lower die rolls where they give you less energy maybe they don't actually give you pollution or just something like that to mitigate so a low roll is not necessarily bad it's just different in this game low rolls are bad they are going to happen and fortunately you roll the dice enough
that it usually averages out and it's not that big of a deal so I haven't seen it tank any one game or have somebody say I lost because I rolled poorly the whole time but I did play a game once where I had a yellow nuclear die and it seemed like that just was hitting at like a three or four every single time I rolled it and little blue Dy and my green Dy were always ahead of it and I just never put a nuclear pollution down and I don't remember if I won that game or not but I do remember feeling a little bit guilty as to how lucky I was being and I think in that situation at least one of the other players had one of those roles where they just rolled like one12 and the two was the thing that gave them um bad pollution and they're just like H you know that just it's really unfortunate in that mode and it definitely sets you back for the number of options you can do for that next wave of putting your workers out before you do another generate action and I guess if you have that really bad role then maybe you'll just do one or two actions and then generate again to try and roll the die and do better and just not um languish in that low uh energy uh state for too long and you can maybe grab an achievement so there are ways to play around it but at the end of the day this output Randomness with zero mitigation is going to turn some people off I don't hate it I also don't love it in this game it works okay but I feel like maybe it could have been done a little better for neutral number two I want to discuss the event card mechanic and these these are the six cards that are flipped over and evaluated when you get to those six different spots as you're playing the game the first three are nice to the players and the last three are kind of mean um I like the Thematic integration that these have where it's going to make one game play
differently from the next that also kind of tries to tie you into the world a little bit more you might have like a worker strike or a pandemic or nuclear fallout and um it's kind of neat to see how they mechanically work into the um the constructs of the game you know if you have nuclear fallout well then the ERS put nuclear tokens down and you have to take those if you want to evaluate those actions if there's a pandemic then everybody loses a worker for that amount of time and they get it back later because they were sick that all makes sense but the flip side is I don't know if they're actually interesting enough to necessarily warrant the inclusion of the extra rules for them as well as the extra variants now of course there is that ability that is somewhat prevalent it's out on the main board that lets you Peak at future events but I have not seen players prioritize that very highly and I have not seen people get overly penalized because of that uh it seems like when you flip over these events you are going to well you're going to score points for one of the three different types of environments usually one player is going to get one or two more points than everybody else but everybody gets about the same amount of points and when the game is over people usually have lots of points like you know scores of like 80 or even cracking over a 100 are somewhat common so six times in the game netting one or two extra points on one of your opponents does not feel like a huge difference and that is um the way that those scorings tend to work out it seems like people usually peek at those cards as um a secondary bonus for doing the primary thing that they wanted to do like they went to that location for the other thing but oh I guess I get to peek at an event oh okay now I know and maybe I'll get one extra point in the game
because I'm going to clean up my environment slightly differently than everybody else so I liked the idea of the events when I first read about them I thought oh you'd see somebody Peak and then you would play off of how they're playing because they have information that you don't have and I haven't really seen that actually happen so so I don't dislike any aspect to the events I mean there is the randomness of flipping over the tile and it could particularly harm you but in general they're Global and they kind of affect everybody and I've never seen anybody get really messed over more than anybody else at the table because of one of those card flips I just am pretty unenthusiastic about them in general and I think if you pull them out of the game it would not really affect the game state that much to a certain degree those first three events um they kind of Kickstart things they give you free stuff which will kind of um get engine going a little bit faster but I feel like that those little kickstarts could have been integrated into other aspects of the game by just making something a little bit cheaper here or there anyway I'm not going to be taking these out it's not a big deal I just feel like it was a bit of a underwhelmed underwhelming missed opportunity to make the events uh much more interesting and uh a provocative part of the game than they actually ended up being for neutral point number three I'll be discussing the various Nations that you get to be when you start the game and I love starting out uh pretty much any style of game with asymmetries especially Euro games it's just neat starting at the beginning of the game with your own little thing that you maybe do a little bit better than everybody else and it's going to dictate how this one play is going to be maybe different from previous plays that you've done and I like the inclusion of these different nations in the game but
I guess a lot like the events I feel a little bit underwhelmed by how they actually feel when I go ahead and play them uh the only they do two things for you essentially they dictate your starting resources and then they dictate the resources that you need to spend in order to bump up on the United Nations track so that is a special action that you have you their custom uh resource Styles just for you that nobody else is kind of vying for those specific resources but man that United Nations track is pretty boring it's just points there's no uh in-game benefits there's no bonuses or anything and in fact as you hit that track more and more the point um the points you get for those jumps gets less and less until you get to that final spot the one person who goes there gets um the Point bump and it's just it feels almost like a chore like something you probably should keep doing okay well I happen to have a a science and a steal so yeah and I have one energy I'll go ahead and do that you know kind of keep up with the packs I don't want to fall too far behind because there is a lot of points to be had over there but it's not like a fun interesting thing I'm not like oh yeah I'm pumping up the United Nations more that's fun it's more like oh I got to figure out a way to do that so I don't you know so I don't just lose because I didn't push that token often enough and the asymmetry between the ability to bump your token and your opponent to bump their token it feels kind of non even necessary like I think if we all had the same exact cost to bump our tokens it would evaluate somewhat similarly I mean I guess this is going to dictate how you purchase buildings so you're maybe slightly better at getting science or and steel so you can bump up
your tokens so there's a little bit of variety there but it doesn't feel that overly impactful um it almost feels like the more important thing is you're starting resources and specifically do you start with an energy or die or not not all of the countries do in fact I think many of them don't and when they don't they usually give you a few um barrels of oil so that you can spend those for your first few Generations uh generate phases in order to roll those Dice and get extra energy but it just kind of feels like every time I sat down to play it if one of my two options had a die on it I did that I started with a die it just seemed like a good idea it's an extra two points at the end of the game and it's just a little bit of infrastructure I don't have to focus on as much um in the earlier parts of the game or I just focus on it and I just have more dice than everybody and in general I tend to make more energy than them or you know they have to spend the petroleum uh use the petroleum Dice and maybe get more pollution so I just wish the asymmetries were stronger I wish there was maybe like an actual ability that affected some like maybe even just one spot out on the board it made it better for you so you maybe hit that one more often that other people did I wish there were bonuses maybe for the first person to get to different thresholds on the United Nations track or just everybody when they get to that one spot giving a specific thing that makes you you know get a little bit of a dopamine hit like oh gay that's cool because now I can do this and that as opposed to being like yay I now have three more points at the end of the game My score will be 85 instead of 82 that's not that great and just again a bit of a missed opportunity I wish the asymmetries were stronger and more interesting and lastly we have neutral number four and I want to discuss the surprisingly low amount of player interaction that actually happens when
you're playing this game it is a work replacement Style game and there is a bit of a precedent for this style of game of having lots of indirect um conflict and interactions as you take spots that your opponents want now they can't do that and you know you take things a way that they wanted now you know they have to totally change all their plans but in this game in general it felt like if my opponent to my right went on a spot that I really wanted to go to I kind of shrug my shoulders spend one extra energy and do it anyway you know it's possible that I'm out of energy in that moment but if I'm out of energy odds are actually good I'm just going to be doing a generate action anyway uh so that's not really going to impact me at all so losing that one energy could have a somewhat sizable impact on that actual play of the game you know I'm not don't want to downplay how much one energy could do it could be the difference between grabbing an achievement or not when you generate and that could be you know one to five victory points which could mean you win the game or not but that is a endgame thing that's way at the end of the game you're not really thinking about that there isn't anything in this exact moment that you're like oh man now I can't do this or that because of that maybe based on your engine you now can't put that one energy down and it means you're not going to get an extra money or two or maybe a steel like it will occasionally upset your plans a little bit but it never sends you back to the drawing board and times I like a game to occasionally force me to completely rethink what I'm going to be doing and not just get away with all of the plans that I was planning as I was playing the game now I do like multiplayer soliter games in general so this is not a critique of this game at all I don't mind the amount of interaction I was just surprised at how low it was and this also means that it's
kind of hard to catch uh to kind of slow down somebody who appears to be doing really well I have not seen a runaway leader situation in this game but I have seen plays of this where it seems like one person is doing better than everybody else and the game keeps going and the game ends and they win and nobody's surprised because and they don't necessarily win by a humous amount of points but they just kind of get in the lead and they just kind of stay there because you can't really upset people's plans that much you maybe make them spend one extra energy but especially if they're doing well and they're making an engine then that one energy is going to matter even less to them so this is again not necessarily criticism this might actually be a big positive for a lot of people who enjoy very low interaction with their Euro games and this might be you know if um the general amount of interaction in worker placement games is a bit too much for you then definitely look into this one it might fit your uh style much better than your average style worker placement game so it's just something I think you should know about when you go ahead and sit down to play the game let's now move over into the negatives and I only have one to cover but it is somewhat significant this has to do with uh kind of what I was talking about at the very beginning of the review the difference between uh building your engine and actually running it so I like the act of putting your your pieces together with your engine trying to make these combos with one building giving you resources to lead into another building into another building but I have seen a couple issues when it comes to actually running your engine and it specifically has to do with when you do a single color style engine because once again you can go heavy on one specific color of your buildings or you could kind of spread your uh Building colors
out between the three which is going to give you more options out in the main board the problem I have is that I think you are overly incentivized to go really heavy with one specific color um if you are just playing the game to win and not necessarily playing the game to try different things and the reason for that is because well when you activate one of those um one section of that part of the board you're going to activate all of those building types so you can be more efficient with your building activation if you keep getting buildings of the same color and it feels like once you get to the point if you're playing the game and you get like two maybe three buildings of one color and maybe none of the others it's so easy to just buy that fourth building of that color and then buy that fifth building and then just keep running your little combo because you probably bought these buildings so they worked well together because you're thinking about making some cool engine building and that is that's kind of fun but you get to the point where you no longer really build your engine anymore now you have like five six maybe even seven buildings with the same color and all you do is do a generate action and on your next turn you activate one of the spots of that color and then you dump all of your workers down and you dump all of your energy out out you activate all of your buildings and on the following turn you do another generate action and if you planned it well maybe you have two energy left over or energy in a worker in order to grab achievements which is going to give you points then you roll the dice get energy and on your next turn you do that action again and you just dump all your stuff out and it gets to the point where it feels like you're just cranking handle like you're no longer making decisions you figured out the optimum way to run
the engine that's in front of you and now you're just going through the motions like okay so I get two money and then I spend that two money to get the oil and I use the oil to turn it into plastic and then and you just you know what the little plan is and you just keep running through it and it feels like when you do this style of um strategy when you're playing the game you it feels like you do it too many times and it's weird to complain about an engine building game where you run your engine too much but when you stop modifying your engine and you stop making decisions about your engine then it just it almost feels like why am I here I built this thing now let's just see if this thing ends up outpacing and winning everybody else at the game and I'm just going to you know be a slave to my engine as opposed to me commanding my engine so I feel like the issue here is that there was too much incentivization to do that because of the action efficiency of activating those buildings I wish they had put some sort of Break In the game that had that slowed down the incentive for that third building of a color for that fourth building of a color maybe make them more expensive or add extra pollution or just I'm I'm really not sure I'm not necessarily a game designer but I feel like they needed something to push players into going into other aspects of the board because the other part is once you find yourself locked in on that little cycle you just ignore the two-thirds of the board and that's just not what you want to be doing I've enjoyed the game way more when I've gone when I forced myself to go with multiple different colored uh buildings across my uh player area but in general I've kind of felt like I do not as well as than if I had just gone crazy with that one color I've not played this game enough times to say that a one color strategy is dominant
and the multicolor building strategy is too weak but I can tell you that playing the multicolor building strategy is more fun but whenever I've done it I felt like I am not doing as well as that other person because they are getting so many of those achievements like they were going to max out to the five achievements at the end of the game um that's pretty much the only way I've seen people get to the point where they can do that as opposed to the people who do the multicolor ones because they're those multicolor building people are going to take two three maybe even four actions before they do another generate and each one of those actions gives you interesting decisions but it seems like when you get to that point in the game when you generate you get all those points for the achievements and then you get to redump into your huge complex cool engine that you built it just it just doesn't really seem to compare so I think I've covered this one enough I wish there was some um dis incentivization to stop players from going really hard on one color if I play this g game again and I do plan on playing this game more I will focus on not finding myself suckered into that little black hole of um just going with one color it's going to be hard because that's just the way the game seems to be pulling me but I will not do that just so I have a more pleasurable enjoyable experience it's now time to discuss the variability for energy Empire and I think that it's pretty average and it had a couple opportunities to break away and actually be above average when it comes to the uh asymmetric Nations that you can pick at the beginning of the game as well as the different events that get shuffled up and put out that um will make the the different uh effects on the game board differently from one game to the next but as I mentioned in the neutral points I feel like both of
those didn't quite live up to their potential when it came to modifying the game in interesting ways and so I feel like every time I've sat down to play the game it's been an average amount of replayability like like I feel like I'm playing pretty much the same style of game like I might be slightly more incentivized to go with steel in this game and slightly more incentivized in the next game to make some oil because of that Nation but it does not feel like any more than I would expect from the average Euro game I sat down to play with at the table energy Empire plays one to five players but I'm not going to comment on one because I just don't play solo games that much and I did not try in this game but I did play the two three and four player game and I can say that I think that three player is the best way to play this game for the somewhat standard Euro game reasons uh when you play this at two it does work but it's nice having a little bit more opponents around the table also if somebody appears to be doing well then having two people trying to um keep that person in check is a little bit better than a single person trying to do that the two-player game did play well it's got um a variant where essentially not variant but you put down um workers from a neutral color onto all the building spaces so you were always going to have to spend extra energy in order to pick up those buildings builds it just crowds the board in a little bit so that you have to deal with that but um I think when I played it at the four player game it was fine but it felt like it maybe started to get a little long when it came to uh downtime in general it was not too bad and I certainly wouldn't say no to playing this game at four players again but I have not played it at five players and I I won't I I that's a decision I've made it just feels like it's not worth having that extra player
like there's no incentive for having that extra player like it doesn't make my play more interesting I guess it crowds the board in a little bit more so there's more player interaction but that's just even more downtime before I get to take another turn there's nothing that you can do when it's not your turn so uh you know maybe you could plan things out but there's only so much planning you can do in this game I've never found myself you know having it come back to me and being like I still don't know what I want to do so um that's the reason I haven't gone up to that count um so yeah I would recommend it at two to four and three is likely best in conclusion I've played energy Empire four times at this point and I've enjoyed every single one of those plays but there's an interesting thing going on here where I feel like I'm not actually that excited to keep playing it like I do want to play it again and if uh one of my friends asked me to play it I will definitely sit down and do it because there's some really great stuff in here there's good decisions there's a really cool tweak on engine building but for some reason there are just several little things that just bring down the overall excitement level for the game and I think it is a combination of the asymmetries not quite living up to what I wanted them to be the events not really changing things up that much much there is very low uh player interaction like it definitely happens but maybe a little bit less than I would in general like for the game and then as I mentioned in that one negative it just I feel like I'm constantly pushing myself away from this feeling like just go hard on that one color just do it you'll be more um incentivized you'll get much more bang for your action by activating all those buildings and then just not actually enjoying the process of running those engines I feel like if those
little things had been tweaked if those um aspects were more interesting and if they put the brakes on finding yourself in kind of a boring engine to actually evaluate my excitement level for this game would be much higher because it's a really good game like all three of those things I just said feel like nitpicks like oh a couple things are not quite as interesting as I want and oh this one strategy is just a little bit too incentivized but when you add all those together it has a slight deflating effect on my overall impression of the game so I can't say that this is a bad game in fact I think it is a very good game with a couple little things that just kind of maybe it's like a death by several paper paper cuts in this case and I think death is an overstatement because I'm going to be keeping this game I do enjoy it and I I'm looking forward to playing it more in the future I just don't think it quite lived up to the hype and excitement that I had for it after the first time I read through the rules like seeing all these ideas with the events and with asymmetries and with this really cool take on engine building I was very excited to see how it all came together and at the end of the day I only liked it I didn't end up loving it at this point I I'd like to thank everyone who has been continually supporting this Channel Through patreon including all of these producer level pledges if you to would like to help uh the channel out by directly supporting it you could do so at patreon.com jongetsgames and I'd really appreciate it also if you'd like to see more in-depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and the monthly Vlogs that I put out please consider subscribing to the channel thanks for watching