Carnegie Roundtable Review - Friendly Ties Podcast
Transcript
foreign and welcome to the friendly ties podcast today we are here to talk about the board game Carnegie I'm here with my friends John and Anastasia hello hello
Carnegie is a game that came out kind of is interesting you could say that it came out this year but I played this game for the first time uh in 2021 with John because at the start of the year January yeah it's been a while because it was on Kickstarter and um John has if you're if you're curious you want to know more about Carnegie you can watch this tutorial play through uh which he was prepping for at that time which is why you know we played it back then and uh I actually played a lot of Carnegie after that because they put it on board game arena in 2021 and then it changed the game based on people's plays of it and then actually it kind of released the final version which came out later this year and John also has a video where he does a playthrough with friends not with Anastasia or myself I have other friends he plays with uh they do a two-player game of that that you can you can check out both of those videos on his channel uh so Carnegie is is a it's a Euro game it's a I would say medium heavy somewhere between me I'm meteor medium side I would say and it is it is an action following game it takes exactly 20 turns the person who's kind of at the top of the order of that turn is going to choose an action and then everybody's going to take that action that turn in the game you're going to sort of expand out your they're called projects but it kind of it almost looks like a rail game map where you're sort of like putting discs down to connect a network on this map you're going to be
building out your company where you have kind of different action options that will uh affect these sort of four different actions that you can take throughout the game and you're going to be making donations throughout the game which essentially is just the game's thematic way of saying how you're going to do some end game scoring yeah that's the kind of brief overview but uh this game has been popping up hot on your channel John it's uh it's not only those two videos but it almost went for for two consecutive months of game of the month for you I think that's true yeah yeah I do a vlog at the beginning of the month talking about like my favorite game experience etc for the last month and yeah I've just been playing this game a lot in fact that's been a common theme uh so I got my I backed the kickstarter I did a sponsored video for it and I thought the game was so interesting that I was like hey Nick it's January 2021 I guess and I was like let's play this game like I just made a video for it and we both liked it you went on and you played it like 50 times on board game so how many times have you played it like I want to know like what is the number question you keep keep the conversation going a bajillion times on board game arena I didn't touch it again until I got my Kickstarter version because I actually backed it I paid money for it I was paid to make a video and then I was like I want to pay money for this game and then I've played it uh 10 more times over the last two months uh five of those times have been in the last three weeks and then so right now we're recording on a Sunday morning last Sunday we taught it
to Anastasia for the first time and Anastasia how many times have you played Carnegie now well I have played it nine times in the last week including staying up until 1am last night playing it with you John so I I played 11 times total and you've played nine times and all nine of yours were in the last seven days six days it's just crazy so obviously I had to catch up it's a bit of a brain worm it gets into your mind I was just gonna say that if Anastasia if you keep playing at nine uh nine per week you're gonna overtake my 70 games of this pretty soon 70. holy crap 66 online and then I would say probably about five-ish uh like with you on TTS or something yeah yeah yeah it definitely warms you you know what's crazy though about this okay so like speaking of this January 2021 play like I want to like call this out for a moment because I was there like I didn't play with you but you know this was in the middle of the pandemic this is when we were playing games on TTS all the time which we we still do but we were playing them so often that like rooms would just be open and like if you were bored you would like just come in and like listen and like hang out and I like specifically remember this I had I don't know what I was doing that night but like I wasn't playing with you guys and I remember that I like showed up at the end and I was cleaning I remember like I was cleaning and you guys were playing and it was you did like final scoring and then you were talking about it and I was just listening and hanging out and I I kind of remember your feelings on it kind of being
somewhat conflicted it wasn't it wasn't like you didn't like it but it was like oh that was a that was an interesting experience but I don't know what it is but like I need to play it again I want to say this I felt at the time they were like a little lukewarm not not like that they were bad it was just like oh I need to explore that more but there was nothing that you said to me at the time that made me be like oh yeah I like I gotta make a point to like learn that and play that but like I but you also kept telling me Oh I think you're gonna like it so I like like okay like I put it like I hung it on a tree right and I was like all right we'll get to that but all that has happened over the last year is and then suddenly you guys started talking about this game Non-Stop and I was like what is it what is it about this game that is like that has gotten you so much because that first play it just didn't feel like it was going to become one of these games that like and then for John in particular like these last two months like it's just been like oh shut up about it car yeah I know and I so I've got to admit to you guys when we went to learn it or when I went to learn it last Sunday I really wanted to play it but I had somewhat I don't want to say low expectations but I just I was like I just didn't kind of know if it was really gonna grab me and and like happen in that first play I kind of felt the same way this is this is a game yeah you were not happy in that first place no no it wasn't yeah this is the game you have to play more than once like I got a weird game
it is a weird game wonderful we're going to talk about it for probably the next hour it's like Buckle in but it it is one of those games like I don't want to say it like again I I don't want to be be too harsh on it it's not it's just that first play you just you can't possibly take it in you're just you're gonna kind of like fall on your face and you're gonna be like this game is weird I think I said the same thing about Arc Nova actually at the time and now I love Arc Nova so like it's just one of those games that it unfolds it's like it's like a flower it just like opens itself up like I I don't know someone else take that and run with it well so one like Arc Nova is a game that that pulls from a lot of other games right A lot of people say like Nova is really nice Innovation but it is not an invention right it doesn't have new mechanisms in it when I explain the concept of Carnegie like someone takes an action and people follow it's like oh it's Puerto Rico it's race for the Galaxy I've played this kind of game before and I really don't think Carnegie is like I actually do think that it is quite a fresh take on what Euros can look like and I think part of the reason John and please correct me if I'm wrong here I'm making an assumption but I think part of the reason John why you like it so much is it is a euro game with that shared incentives component that you love so much about the rail games that you've been really into the cube rails games and everything in this game is so deeply interconnected between the players that it just it moves in a
way that has this co-oper competitive you know yes yes what is that word yes yeah honestly I just I have co-opted the term uh semi-cooperative for that feeling like I think like some people talk about semi-cooperative games but like with the idea of being like it's Cooperative until Suddenly It's not or something like that that's how I think of it but that's interesting put that on here yeah I I agree with you Nick that is definitely part of the reason why I enjoy it and I think there's a couple different reasons for it um also fully agree that this game feels it's one of the freshest Euro games I've played in a very long time I'm honestly I mean maybe since Anno 1800 uh did I play a game where I was like wow what the heck and then people like well what's the game like and you're like you're like oh it's like terraforming Mars and it's like Civilization New Dawn and like a lot of games you can like rattle off a whole bunch of things oh it's like work replacement but with Carnegie just saying it's a lead follow game is it's honestly almost a misnomer because of you know if you're really deep into the board game Hobby and you played a bunch of these you're you're instantly going to false comparisons like Puerto Rico for example right you know in Puerto Rico the active player chooses an action everybody gets to do that and then printed on that action the active player gets a benefit they get a leg up on everybody and that's always the case um now that leg up might not necessarily be good for you in that exact moment but like honestly it's been so long since I
played Puerto Rico I don't remember the specific actions but you just you as the active player get the best version and everybody else gets a subordinate one Boon link is also similar you as the active player you get like half you get the full action and everybody else just gets a half action in Carnegie there's none of that in Carnegie the way the action selection works is you you say okay we're doing a uh construction action everybody can construct but the way the game works is for every type of action there's four different types of actions they're all mechanically identical in that everybody looks at their own player board and you have little Department tiles that match up these icons and if a construction action happens then everybody activates all of their construction departments and this is where the game can get kind of asymmetric with the strategy and whatnot because I might have different construction departments than Nick does but if I choose the construction Department I don't get a natural benefit like just about all of these other lead follow games do in fact it's very possible that I could choose the construction action and Nick has more construction buildings than I have and they might be better prepared to utilize this so maybe I will only put two discs down on the board constructing them onto the map and maybe Nick puts four of them down and then I probably shouldn't have done that right but it's just really interesting that this game takes away a the natural the active player gets something better uh interface and I think that's really where the shared incentives come into play because you have to figure out what action has a
emergent benefit for you because the game doesn't just have it printed on the card like most of this type of game does right like it's entirely possible for you to take an action that's actually better for your opponent like or for your other opponents like not only possible but you're going to do it repeatedly and then after the fact smack yourself in the face be like why did I do that exactly like and and it's so funny because I remember I I think it was after a couple plays in that I started to say to you guys like it doesn't remind me of any specific game but it reminds me of the feeling of a lot of different games but like if I said them to you you'd be like like what like which I'm gonna totally do right now but it like this game almost reminds me more of Concordia than it reminds me of of Puerto Rico like even though there's like there's this action follow the this this element of take one action do one specific thing there's just something about that that reminds me so much of Concordia and the strategy Concordia being uh my if not probably still probably my all-time favorite game there's a strategy in Concordia that is so much about knowing the actions that your opponent has and knowing the actions that you can take and trying very carefully to play your cards in a way that are good for you but anticipate what your opponent's going to take and what they're going to do and kind of like open things up and that that is the same feeling that I get playing this game it's like what am I
going to choose to do that benefits me but then what is John going to choose and but what's so cool about it is adds an element that we both get to do both things so no matter what you are always doing something and that actually like Nick you said it just takes the action follow idea and makes it into something so fresh and so new that I don't even know I can call it an action follow because it's not even like one person's doing action and you're following it's like you're both doing the action the advantage being that one of you gets to do it for exactly turn order and just saying that the action happened if nobody picks construction for the entire game which is possible then no nothing gets constructed like there's no there's no gamified incentive like if people keep skipping construction it's not like you're putting money tokens down onto it to until somebody finally takes it like you could literally go the entire game and never construct probably not going to happen but the game says sure I mean if you want to play the game that way maybe that's the way the incentives fall out for you this game ha I think I've mentioned before how much I love a build your own asymmetry component in uh in a lot of Euro games and this game very much has that I could just try to like copy John's strategy exactly like build the same buildings and try to like move the same meeples there and like largely that would probably work except for at some points I have to decide first so you know it doesn't doesn't work perfectly but you can play a version of this game where everyone is playing a very similar very tightly tuned kind of game or you could play a version of this
game where you're like you know what I'm gonna be really good at management I'm gonna build a freaking huge company that has all these different options in it and when I do I get all sorts of resources and everyone else is crap at it but if I do that inherently it means that I'm gonna suck a little bit more at the other actions and so the two of you might then lean into I'm gonna be heavy researcher I'm going to be heavy construction and this this like component of I'm deciding how similar or different I want to be from other players means that this game is going to play out really differently entirely based on the choices that the players are making in the game yeah absolutely absolutely and and John and I were talking about that at the end of our game last night like John described it perfectly as he was going this game is like fencing like it's like everything you do and because it's so close you're never gonna make any huge moves you're never gonna like run away with something and something that you do maybe you get like one turn where you manage to like you do an action and you you manage to get it so that your opponent didn't have any uh any employees to be able to do that and you're like oh good like I kind of got that little edge here or I put them on their back feed or I did this but it's still pretty tightly wound because of that element of those choices and that the ability to react so subtly to what each other is doing so John and I were like looking at our ports and and I actually beat John last night and we were trying to figure out what gave me the game and as we were going through it it was like well what if what if we done
this or what if this card had been here what and the thing is I was like well if you've done that then I would have done this and then the game would have played out completely differently for the rest of the game and he's like well what if I had done this and I'm like yeah but then I would have done this and if you've done that like I would like the fact that the game can mold itself in such that there's like no one component my takeaway from that whole discussion was like there's no one component that you can say at the end of one of these games that you're like if only I had done X Y and Z like that's not there's no it's impossible because the the the back and forth of it as you said Nick it's it's such a tight system that is that is essentially the whole game is like these shared incentives that play out in this this very semi-cooperative way which I I'm gonna have to try to adapt that term because I've never used it in this way but I guess that like it just it's not how I think of it it makes sense to me doesn't mean yeah come up with a better word then I need a new word incentive works right it showed incentive works I guess but it doesn't feel like that either because there's no stocks like usually when you say here's shared incentive you think stock markets and all that kind of stuff there there's there's none of that in this game I guess I don't think of it as like a benefit like Cooperative I feel like you're trying to do something together like is this like sort of like oh you have to take my action with me like this is like did you bring everything for the class like did you bring it in the class yeah every single action you take this game is did you bring enough for the class but they're your opponents so I
have an analogy I'd like to uh belabor for a second and I want to see what you two think about it because uh so I played this game you know quite a bit obviously not nine times in one week but um I've taught this game to a whole bunch of people so I have a lot of experience of seeing new players to the game and I've seen uh some new players fall flat in their face I've seen other new players beat me in their very first game which is you know an ego check uh but I've seen a wide variety of things and and as far as analogies go I I see this game as as you get better at it it changes in its feel like I see your first couple plays of this one as dancing like together like you and your opponents are all kind of doing this uh you know modern ballroom dance but like it's it's a weird one like the very first time you're gonna be kicking each other's shins and like falling down on the ground at the same time and just being like wow I'm terrible at this dance or at least a lot of people are and you and you end it and you're like holy cow that's it looked like an easy dance like from afar I watch other people doing it and I was like oh yeah I get it but then I tried doing it and I just I fell flat on my face and then you play a couple more times and you're like okay I'm starting to get this dance like yeah like I'm doing the HR action to move these people around then you're managing to send people out and then Nick's constructing and then we're all putting discs out and we're all just doing this dance and we're almost like cooperating trying to get little edges here and there but we're just so effective all of our scores are getting bigger and bigger and bigger and then what I've noticed is
like as you start to play it enough times like you know known like three to five range it varies from person to person it's almost like you're dancing now but suddenly everybody's starting to pull out knives just to work into like the fencing analogy a little bit like it like goes organically from like dancing to dancing showing each other's swords but not really using them to then suddenly you're just like not dancing anymore and you're just fighting with swords and and that's what I've kind of noticed as it goes on so that's why like some of these games do feel Cooperative because like we could just ping pong back and forth like all kind of doing the things trying to get our small edges but then so from my experience I'd played all these games teaching a bunch of new people seeing like people kind of figure out these dance moves and then a few nights ago I played it with Nick for the first time in a year and a half uh the very first time I played this was with Nick it was Nick's first play as well and he of course won that first play but then we played it I guess that was a week ago when um Anastasia it was my first game yeah yeah and and ice like every other turn I was just like oh my gosh like Nick would do something that was so not dancing with me and I'm just kind of getting used to playing this game and like going with you yeah yeah exactly and they could do a thing it'll be like that never even occurred to me what the oh my gosh that makes so much sense and I would realize that I had gotten comfortable being good at the dance like I've won this game like like the actual first place points
in this game over half the times I played and I started to get this kind of ego about it because I I try not to but like you can't help it like you keep winning you're like oh I guess I'm good at this game and I think I got really good at the Carnegie dance and then I played with Nick again and I was like oh I suck at the Carnegie Knife Fight Like win this game when everybody is kind of shared incentive and stuff like I it works with my brain and I could really do very well um but then I kind of fell flat on my face um playing against you know Nick that one time and I learned a whole bunch of new things which is cool it'll be like my 10th game and be like oh my gosh there's so much more to this game but to kind of like end this this long thing that I'm saying here Anastasia played that first game against you know me and Nick I kind of full fight in my face because like I thought we were dancing here and I'm good at dancing and apparently it's a sword fight and then Anastasia played this eight more times over the week almost every one of those plays against very high level ranked people on board game people I'd call Nick Nick Jason Nick one more time but I I played Nick clones so to kind of end this I don't think Anastasia's ever done the Carnegie dance you learned Carnegie fencing right out of the gate and and then when we played last night we were like literally it's a 20 action game we were the second action and I paused the game and talked for like 10 minutes because I was like oh my gosh like like just seeing the things that you were doing I was like crap yeah like playing against Nick all these smart decisions and I was like
I regret everything already in the game was only just started what the heck is going on Nick had taught me this thing to do so so like let me show you this dirty trick kid well yeah this is the thing okay you know we talk a lot about Nick winning I love Nick Nick knows this but oh my God in this game Nick is bleep this he's and in the in that first game you know I just wanted to say this like this game so it's 20 action four types of actions you think when if you don't really aren't thinking any better you think every action is going to occur five times right obviously right no no no no no no no not only are they not going to occur five times maybe they they could but it's entirely possible that they won't they also are not going to occur five times in any given order you could have five of one action in a row and then you do another which you know if you've played any you know worker placement game that involves like constructing an engine you know with your basic like higher produced construct you know research and those aren't the actions but you know that they they they're versions of them here you kind of need to do those in order to execute them like you need to like get workers and you need to build buildings to then be able to do things well in this game you don't need to do those in any order the order is decided by the other players and Nick does this thing which he did in the first game which is he just like he'll take the same action
again or he'll take the action that like no one needs except for him and so like suddenly you're like oh my God why would you do that again like that that's so bad and he's like well you know it's good for me or yeah it isn't even that good for him but it's way worse for you yeah so last night second play-in Nick had taught me this thing which is there's an action that is very commonly taken at the beginning which is called management which is essentially to build another building on your board you do other things but early in the game that's kind of like the first turn that's like you build your own symmetry essentially yeah you build your asymmetry and when the first time you take it and Nicki taught me this thing there's this kind of mechanic where you can you can choose on some of the buildings whether you send workers out to the board and then you get better better stuff for them or you keep them on your company and you get less good stuff but if you keep them they stay there and they can work for you again and so he was like he did this last week he was like why would I send them out because you sent yours out so I'll just keep mine here wait for you to send yours out and then I'll just take the action again and then you won't have any workers to do it and I'll then get to send them out so not only do I get the sendout bonus I also get to keep them bonus and I got to do the action twice and you got and and I was like that's genius I feel like I can see you like putting the oil in your mustache and like twisting it as you're explaining this this is the problem because John you're
so right I didn't learn the dance because I played with Nick the first time which is by the way why I then played it nine times guys like I didn't I didn't play at nine I mean actually I mean I did really enjoy it but part of that like John said to get through those early games where you fall on your face is you're like why am I falling on my face right so then I like had to play it more to figure out why I was falling on my face and then suddenly you know to survive I needed to learn all the dirty tricks which are not dirty they're just they're they're just they're they're running straight for the knives right yeah yeah so yeah so John last night the first thing he does text management he sends all his workers out I leave mine there and then he's like what are you doing and then we had a 10 minute talk where I was just like what was it just holding my head my hands just like that makes so much sense um I usually thought you were like upset with me because they were like I think I was upset with myself for not seeing it but I was like I thought we were dancing I go onto the board then you go on to the board and then I leave the board and then you leave the board what are you doing staying behind oh yeah again I genuinely did have that feeling to go with John's metaphor that like he went out to dance and then like I turned around and like knifed him in the back and was like I found someone better in conclusion it's not Pride and Prejudice it's Game of Thrones watch out y'all and to that point actually I remember when this game first came out there were like a couple threads on BGG about like what's the highest you've scored in this game uh but that's not really the point because I'm not playing this game to score the highest like you are in a lot of Euro games or it's like I want to score the best it's I'm playing this
game to score the Delta from the other players I just need to have a better turn than you and if I can have enough better turns than you for 20 turns then I'm gonna win and it doesn't matter if I win with 100 points or 200 points um it could be anywhere in there based on like what's what's going down and like how we've laid things out so also just for folks listening to like the nice version right The Pride and Prejudice version of this game is like you take management you build build your asymmetry then you like construct some people so that you send projects out on the board which now everybody has income maybe you do some research so you can open up your options of like other things to do again now everyone's then comes a little bit better and then someone takes Human Resources you send your people out and then you reset this Loop and you do that cycle again maybe with more or less management depending on how much people want to build out their companies throughout the course of the game and if you just go through that Loop everyone's like raking in tons of money tons of Cubes I have all these options different things to do but you could play versions of this game where no one wants to Blink people are playing to like like wait for each other I think one of the actions in this game that's the most dangerous action to take is human resources because when you take human resources you are the first one to move your people out and say this is this is how I've set up my company these are the actions that I'm good at and then the players following are going to do that after you but because you were first that turn you then passed the
first player token and they're gonna choose what happens for the next two or three rounds of the game depending on how many people you're playing with and so by taking Human Resources you put yourself in a situation where you're inherently on the back foot you have to act first and they get to decide first right it's a bad situation to be in and so sometimes you can get into these like weird Wars of people staring down each other I played a game of this like a couple months ago with some strangers online it's a three-player game and like one player was so mad at me that I wouldn't take the action that I needed to take because up to it was up to Loosely better for him and then he got he got so angry about it like in the chat usually like board game arena like people just like play their own thing and like move on their lives this person was like raging at me in chat and then he proceeded to tank his game so of course the third player one that's how these games go um and like we just like wouldn't cooperate with each other and it was like a stilted very painful game where the third player was like okay well I'm gonna do this kind of crappy action on the side because at least it's something to do yeah and it was just like it was one of the most brutal games of Carnegie I've ever played um but you know there are other times even when you're like being very nasty you're doing the dance with the knives out you're still at the end of the day like saying look I want to research I want to put things on the board I want to have a high income I just want to do it a little bit better than you so there's nice versions of this game where everyone's kind of like
doing the dance as John calls it there's nice-ish versions of the game where I'm doing the dance but I want to make sure I'm doing it better for me and then there's just like straight up I will not help you like if it's better for you you have to do the work and like people can like really dig in their heels in this game which leads to some very strange board game States yeah yeah I I do want to just take a minute to uh talk about some of the mechanics just a bit to make sure everybody's kind of on the same page about the the flow of these actions because you mentioned you know when you take this action like construction you activate all your construction buildings but the real key to that which is what Nick was going off of is you only do the actions on those buildings if you have people on them and there is this flow that leads to talking about income which I really would like to start digging into where you have these people on your board it's an orthogonal you know Square grid essentially and you move them onto departments and when they're there you can pay some money to activate them and then they can they're essentially actions now you can activate them when you do those it's almost like in a work replacement game it's almost like putting your employees out you're like telegraphing what worker Spots You're going to take like you're almost like committing to those spots right like it's it's programming I never really thought about it honestly until about 40 seconds ago when Nick was talking about this but this game is is a programming game because you you have these potential actions and then you have to spend an action to program which is the human resources to move these around
slotting them into little pegs so that they're ready to be activated later on and then like Nick said you're telegraphing to everybody what your program is and it's it's completely visible you can see what everyone is potentially going to do but then many of these actions remove that programming Peg that worker from that space and you put them onto the board and this is where where income comes into play because and I really want to talk I mean we've talked so much about the the feel of this game but like some of these mechanics are super cool and one of my favorite parts of this game is income so you have this match with the United States it's split into four different areas and when you do when you send people out to the board you might be forced into a certain spot or maybe you have a choice but this is a 20 action game and in every one of the 20 actions the first thing that happens is you move this Pawn down this action grid and it's going to show one of the four areas of the United States or it'll say donation but the primary thing is if you if you say do the construction action before you even construct you move the pawn onto the spot and maybe it says Midwest now everybody who has a worker in the midwest who they've sent out to the Midwest removing it from their board can pull that worker back and that is the only time you take your income and I'm not going to go into too many details because it's a podcast and it's hard to to visualize these things but the more tokens of the buildings you put on the board the more income you get when you pull these people back and then you also gain some extra income based off of some research and development you can do in these areas but there is this cycle because when you bring them back they go into a neutral
hanging out in the lobby spot on your board where you then need to do another human resources action to program that worker back in so there's this flow they move out of the lobby into a department they move to the department out onto the board and you hopefully put them on the to the board onto a spot where an income will happen so they come back and they give you stuff but like most Euro games that have income if you think income you're like oh there's probably an income phase and when income happens everybody gets their income and maybe some people get more income no this game also brings a knife fight idea into even getting income where you might go on to an area intentionally put a worker down into a region of the United States that isn't even that good for you but you're the only one there because you know on your next turn you can fire off an income on that spot and then you get a marginal benefit over everybody else so so not even just picking the action that you want to do it's just the other perks that go along with the actions that also feed into this trying to get these tiny benefits and I hope I didn't go too into the weeds but I feel like this is one of the reasons why this game is so hard to describe you're like oh it's a lead follower game but realistically it's a competitive Knife Fight income game and if you lose the income game if you fail on income you lose like I I could be wrong on this I've only played this game I guess 11 times now but income is being ready to capitalize on income is how you win that's how you you fall on your face if you don't catch incomes you do a bunch of cool stuff if you do I think that Drilling in on that binary aspect of income to me is the very clever
mechanism here it's that if I get an income you know I get the income for whatever my research is for that region on the board some little perk but then I also get the income for everything on my board so it is depending on how far you are in the game and how developed your board is it can be the difference between like nothing and a lot of stuff and so setting yourself up to like do those flows and make sure that you hit those like trickle income points is very important in the mid to late game at the beginning of the game you can maybe get away with doing something else or um in a game actually that I was playing with Anastasia she focused on getting a lot lot of meeples onto the board in one section not because her base income was good but because everyone that she picked up was worth a lot of money and so she used that as her as her piggy bank which was actually a very clever way Anastasia of of circumventing income in other Fashions so there are multiple ways you can interact with the income and that is very cool too yeah absolutely and I did that last night with John too um you know we were actually playing with uh the expansion which I think we'll touch on a little bit later but it it I had a building that essentially gave me money for every other management building I had so I was using management to I think by the end between that and some other building I had like every time I take a management action I was like making like 27 dollars in this game I can't see my face meaning like oh my
God yeah it was a huge amount it was it was bomb and it was awesome and like and and so I was like so flush with cash but then of course we had no buildings that made uh cubes with the two main resources in this game being money and cubes are the cubes representative of something is there they're called good resources sorry okay my little white cubes I'll call them Goods uh so yeah so anyways I needed to to then create a good uh income on the board but I want to take what you guys said and there's two things I wanted to kind of comment on and the first is is that idea of you know you have these 20 actions we talked about that there's four different types and then as John you just said the income every income is different and I will say in my first play or two that was the most overwhelming thing because John programming is the perfect analogy for this is like trying to plan where to put people knowing when they'd come back that's true like putting on the word is also like programming I didn't even not knowing when they'll come back trying to anticipate what actions will be taken each one gives a different income you don't you only have so many meeples especially at the beginning and so it's like that is that can be a real brain twister and that I think is the hardest part of the game or at least for me that was the hardest part of the game to in my first few plays to kind of kind of grock right like I was just having a hard time thinking okay where
do I put people when are they going to come back what actions might take what is what what actions are other people going to take and and how do I compute all of that quickly and then as I quickly learn to kind of what you were saying Nick is that speaking of this idea of like dancing there really is there's a flow to this game where you want to put people out you want them to come back but you want to leave them out so long enough so that they get more for you because you've built more so that generates more income off of your own personal board and so there's there's a timing aspect to that too that it just takes again to go back to that idea you got to play this game several times to really allow it to unfold it just takes time to like kind of allow that to happen but that also goes back for me to what I was talking about when I was saying you know how I don't feel like these games all the mechanics feel incredibly fresh but it does have the feel of other games for me and the the two other games that it feels like and these are these are going to seem like massive stretches here but the first is this game reminded me a lot of Messina 1347 it they're completely different games they play differently they want different things Messina has huge opportunities to pop off this game does not this is very tight like I've even seen that as a criticism like you can't just like go crazy and pop off on things and and you can and you can't but like not in the same way that you can and and in in a game like Messina but that flow of making your things work and
getting your kind of engine going and getting things to kind of come together at the right time and that idea of the limited actions the 20 actions that you're going to have and Messina is very similar in the eight rounds that you're gonna play and how are you gonna make everything that you need to happen happen over this like finite amount of time and it just that's I I really love that I love that and Messina I I really like that here I like that element of trying to get the timing of that right but they can also lead to a lot of kind of like not so great feelings and that's kind of my one kind of criticism of the game is in this idea of the knife fight which it makes the game sound almost more aggressive than it is because you do have like a lot of control in what you are doing it's not like I just want to kind of clarify that but it also means that if things don't work out for you you can especially early on when you don't not overly familiar with the game you can really fall flat on your face and that's why this brings another comparison for me which is I I mentioned this game a lot it's Grand Austria hotel which this game is nothing like other than in feel in that that is also a game where you can fall on your face to a certain extent and Nick and I also played recently Royal Palace and it reminds me of that too where you can kind of get yourself in a situation that you can't undo but in in Grand National Hotel there's a lot component and I'm gonna equate that luck component to this idea of you don't know necessarily what your opponents are going to do and yet you all are going to take you know kind
of from the same from these same actions and that you know you kind of need things to work out for you in order for your things to to happen the way you want them to happen and there are going to be moments where you didn't and you need to adapt and you may not be able to you may not have the people that you need to do or you may not be like they're just that that can happen and you kind of have to I'm curious what you guys think about this you kind of have to like be okay with having some of those not so great feelings that come it's not always going to be like a high I think right in this game totally I'm gonna agree with one thing and disagree with another so you brought up Grand Austria hotel and the luck and the like knowing what other people do in this game and there are a lot of games where I actually really agree that a form of luck is what other players will do I would argue that in Carnegie what I really like about this game is that I should be able to look at someone's board and have a sense of they're going to take this or this right like those are really extra options that are there because it's very there's I don't think there's any hidden information nope there's no randomized components in the game like you can look at the board and figure out what's going on which can have an AP problem we'll come back to that later maybe um but I also deeply agree with you that this game can have game plays that have very bad feelings uh and the the thing is that there's there's no rubber banding in this game game there's no kindness in this game if you are hyper
Vigilant it's gonna work you have control over everything that kind of happens in the game right like you don't have control over where the decisions other players make and that can come out to not work out for you but it's not like you got a run of bad luck or you know this thing just didn't like happen out that way like most of the time you were like I didn't think of that or like I didn't consider your perspective of doing this thing or in the study that I told earlier like I didn't consider that you would then essentially like dig in your heels about the situation about it right there's a certainly a social component in all games right so like you can't anticipate those things necessarily uh and then you can really kick yourself because you can be like oh I should have seen that you were gonna do this or like ah like if I had just put this there first instead then I would have been better and you can you can really get oh yeah upset with yourself self about how you did this game because it really is not a lot of things to blame except for yourself you know whose fault it is because it is maybe I should have called it risk mitigation like totally more than that that's really what I think it's a comparison I'm making between Austria so that's that's a great Point Nick that leads me directly to uh John from 11 hours ago uh I said last night uh we finished like 11 hour
ago I think it was 10 hours ago one sleep ago uh we Anastasia and I played this two-player game and uh I I enjoyed the game this is my 11th play and we had some expansion stuff and again we'll maybe talk about that soon but I found that first third of the game to be I had lots of feels bad moments like for the exact reason you said I'm like oh my gosh I can't believe I should it was so obvious Anastasia was gonna do this and knowing that I should have done that but I didn't and I don't want to ask for a take back because that just feels antithetical to the feel of this game like sometimes we do take backs when it when you're genuinely just like I misunderstood a rule but for this it was like no okay that makes sense okay we're rolling with it this is one of those few games that kind of doesn't like want you to take take backs it's so tight because like the butterfly effect of everything I ever felt that before in a game we played until this one I literally last night I was like if John asked for a take back right now I uh I'll say yes but I really won't want to yeah it has that it has that feel right it's so it so depends on what they do so yeah so we were like a third of the way through the game and uh in Anastasia had this Bonkers uh management engine like she said she's raking in at this point you know like close to 20 bucks like like seven rounds into the game which is just an astonishing amount of money in this game and and so I literally I told I was sitting there trying to figure out what action to do and I said what would Nick do right now
I just want to do a construction action because I've got three people ready to put three discs down onto the board I've got income ready to grab and if I put those discs down my income is gonna be better but Anastasia is also in a position to put three discs down to the board and sure I'll do it first but she'll do it second and I was like you know what I I had this feeling like I'm losing right now like Anastasia is totally outplaying me like she's been in an incubator for the last week like like a montage just like like fighting against all these incredibly like good Carnegie players do the music yeah cue the music absolutely like I played her last Sunday and it was like she fell on her face and then like I played it last night and she just knocked me the heck out and it's just like what are these moves so I was a third of the way through the game and I was like okay I'm gonna do a nickname and I did something that I never would have anticipated doing instead I did an HR movement in a moment when I could actually do a couple and she didn't I pulled everyone out of my base research and development which is something I've never done before and I moved them all into construction which is adjacent getting it laying down so they're ready to like do a double build onto the board and uh that I won't go to the nitty-gritty for why that was a bit crazy for me but it felt crazy it's something I've never even conceptualized before sounds crazy in the stage of like what the next turn Anastasia was definitely gonna just keep cranking that ludicrous marketing engine that she had and um because she had just HR totally up my back feet yeah totally suddenly again yeah yeah in order to move more
people into the construction to anticipate the thing that I was about to do and and that that changed the texture of the game so much and so then that middle third of the game I was everywhere like I had people programmed for every single eventuality that Anastasia could do and it felt and it suddenly like the game was like yeah like I'm getting it like I'm I'm playing like Nick like I'm figuring this out like no matter no matter what you do I'm right there and there was a few turns where Anastasia was like what the heck do I do like no matter what I do it's great for John but then we reached the last third of the game where I had been flexible I had been like in a whole bunch of places and suddenly it became apparent that I was poor and a huge part of the points in this game is donations um there's a whole bunch of them uh the first donation costs you five money seconds ten thirds 15 20 25 30 it just keeps going up and goes crazy tough it's tough being a millionaire it is really right and and you have eight natural opportunities to do donations throughout the game and I realized it was too late in the game like I was sitting on like six bucks the Anastasia had like 28 and I was like oh like I'm better than you on the board I'm better than you on a couple of other things but you are going to run away from me with these donations you're just gonna put more she had a donation discounting building out and and so suddenly like all my bobbing and weaving kind of felt for not because the entire time that I was everywhere ready to anticipate all of Anastasia's actions trying to put her on the back foot to stop her from running this she was just getting a little bit more money a little bit more money and then that last third
of the game that's exactly what happened she got three more donations than me and beat me by 20 points and every donation can max out at about 12 so she beat me by essentially two donations and your donations being your like end games it's like a choose your own criteria like two points for every token you've put down on this part of the board you buy them yourself there's no like set and well there's a little set in game scoring but the donations are like the one extras you pick for yourself yeah and and the last and I ended that game deflated and like I was sitting there and I literally we had this conversation I was like I'm trying I'm at war with myself in my brain because part of me is like am I unhappy because I lost and I don't want that like I don't want to be that gamer who like only enjoys games when they're winning them and I think maybe part of it is that I have won this game a bunch because I got really good at the Carnegie dance and I started to get this ego that like okay I'm good at Carnegie and then I realized you know can once again that I'm bad at the Carnegie uh Knife Fight essentially and the other thing that really seeped into my brain as I was sitting there trying to figure out why I was I was kind of kind of upset not not actively upset but like you know why am I not like oh good game you beat me awesome I think it's because of the strategy levels of this game and and where my brain has shifted over time um and what I realized is I think I might be enjoying Carnegie less now that I think I'm good enough to the point where I should be good and like I think I was loving the exploration I was loving the dance I think I preferred dance Carnegie to
Knife Fight Carnegie but Knife Fight Carnegie is is better Carnegie like I feel like I graduated to a whole new Echelon of the game and I'm like I'm not saying I don't like this game but I'm like maybe I I like this one less because again going way back to what Nick said before like if you're in a tough spot you put yourself there and I was in a lot of tough spots and I was feeling negative about myself and like really kicking myself about it I think because of this expectation like this is my 11th play I should be better than this and and it was just a strange headspace to find myself in I ultimately I did enjoy it I woke up being like yeah that was a really good game and obviously I got outplayed and that's totally fine I don't mind being outplayed I was mostly just upset with myself and yeah it was just an interesting thing for me to mull over I want to pump you up briefly because actually I I really love that story and thank you for sharing that's very interesting but the thing that I want to pump up about it is that I I mentioned this before I think it's very hard to catch up in this game like this game is about like maintaining parody and then like getting your edges most of the time if you're behind and you feel like you're behind it's very hard to like if you just kind of stay the straight and narrow you're screwed you're just gonna lose to the player who's already ahead and so I love the fact that you recognize that and said I'm gonna throw a grenade in this and see what happens and like it didn't work out but the fact that you were trying to like shake things up is fundamentally I think like a completely essential process to how you can try to break parody in this game and and in a lot of games in general I think it's a cool story even though it didn't work out like I love that you did I mean maybe I
lost my 20 points instead of losing by 30 or 40. uh like I think ultimately it was better for me to do the thing that I did even though I didn't end up closing the Gap yeah I mean the strange thing too is if you just kind of kept playing the straight and narrow maybe you still lose by 20 because that's just kind of the Gap there but then you have no chance of like hail marrying into into like uh into like an end play and this you actually gave yourself the opportunity um for that right and like giving your opponents the opportunity to like stumble somewhere is also I just think like such a core gaming strategy um when you're when you're playing from behind yeah but I do think that there's something interesting in this game about where the joy comes from because I think you make such a good point John in that it's gonna sound like trying to find a way to say this but like I took a lot of enjoyment last night and in the the one play the one out of those nine times I played it I'd only won once before um the pre the play just previously to John and I had played against a new player on bgs Stranger but BJ told me it was their first game um which I mean obviously I believe they could have played it in the past but I took a lot of enjoyment about around the spaces where I I kind of got you like I kind of had like gotchi moments you know like moments where I was like oh great John doesn't have any people I can kind of like like stab him here like that's
horrible but like also like oh you fell into my trap it's the thing I wanted you to do exactly like yeah like I I set this up so perfectly and like and or whatever like there was just like a lot of satisfaction in that and I do think it brings up a sort of an interesting like existential feeling because I like I said It felt the same way in in the previous one I had where I was like oh they don't know that they shouldn't do that like and I'm like oh my God who am I like who is this and so I don't know I just think it it's interesting because that's why it kind of reminds me of Concordia a little bit which is not how I feel in Concordia and all the time necessarily but there is a real Pride I take in like finding ways to make my strategy work really effectively that kind of either blocks out I don't say blocks out the other person but like kind of gets those edges on the other players and I think that that is a place where a lot of Joy can come from this particular game and I think that speaks to the idea of the like for lack of a better term the semi-cooperative nature that you you you are doing kind of the same things you are looking for those little advantages because it is so tight that is like the little spaces in it but I do think that makes for an interesting thing because I definitely enjoyed those games where I was able to get those little wins I think more than the games where I just felt like I'm constantly in my back foot this totally sucks I've made a in some cases I've made a game altering mistake even like a misclick you know on BGA like I've like
and I'm just stuck here in the in the shreds of my company you know miserable and I had to play like that I had like a totally miserable play where like I just screwed it up and there's something interesting in that that I I hope continues to kind of um evolve over multiple plays but I think for me this is a game I only really want to play with people who like really know this game and I think that's maybe because Nick has ruined it for me now that I've seen the the Deep strategy game that's the game I really want to play that's the game that's the game that is the game that brought me to playing it nine times in the last week that's the game that makes me be like I want to do better how can I get my score into the 160s how can I be playing at this level like I want to figure I want to unlock this thing and and then that speaks you know we talked a lot about this in our last episode about when we're talking about the world board gaming championships it's like you know Nick has influenced a lot of the way that I like playing games because he's shown me I credit you with this Nick you've shown me this world of plain games to get really good at them to figure them out to finding games that are capable of playing 70 times and still enjoying them because they have so many parts and pieces and they play so differently and and it's a little addictive and so I but it does make for
a game that has an interesting space in my collection because this is definitely not a game I think I could just pick up and you know play with my partner or play with my friends who've never played it before it's not it's not that kind of game for me this is a game I only want to play you know with I guess I have people who really who really know it and want to play it Knife Fight Style so there is something about this game that we haven't talked about yet that John I know you have this but I think your opinion of this game Anastasia is a bit Modified by the fact that you've played it primarily at two players and maybe once or twice at three players I think that Carnegie is a fundamentally it's the same action flow but the the way that you approach the game is fundamentally different at two and three and four players um and John I know you've played it at all those player accounts so I'm curious if you agree with me but like the two-player game is murder I actually don't like playing the two player game generally because it is just Delta it is just can I out fence you in a three-player game or especially in a four player game it is a lot more like I am going to make the primary decision 25 of this game which means that I need to be ready to do things I need to be ready to kind of like flow with the board and it's more about like the timing or the jocking for position of like which action I'm gonna take at which time and what does that mean for someone further in the four player game and the four player game only every player gets a a
disc that says once per game do whatever you like you don't need to follow the leader you can just do your own thing which allows you to break parody it allows you to change your tactics it allows you to set up cute plays which I think is really really fun so I actually think inherently the four player game is a nicer version of the game because if you say I'm gonna play this game net negative or like zero sum and two or three of the other players say well we're going to play you know kind of cooperatively then you lose like you need to be able to play this game and go to go back to John's dance analogy like you need to be doing the same dance that everyone else is doing and if we're playing Pride and Prejudice dance game then your goal is to do that a little bit smoother and if we're playing we're gonna knife each other game then your job is to knife a little bit harder and I think that the the four player version of this game is much friendlier um and play smoother that's a really good point that hadn't even occurred to me but yeah I played four players probably three times three players many times and two players also many times I have 11 plays now and yeah it just it leans more into the being flexible and being adapting when there's more people you know in two-player game I make a decision you make a decision I make a decision we go back and forth only one other action happens between in a four player game like you said 25 of the time it's a 20 turn game you're gonna make five decisions and then roll with 15
other decisions that other people have made and that really pushes you towards that uh that that you know being flexible so yeah maybe I just prefer higher player account Carnegie because of the kind of game it uh lends itself more towards I mean I still definitely enjoy the two-player game it just it can lend itself towards feels bad moments and there's definitely feels bad moments in in a four player game as well I don't want to deny that but yeah the game is excellent in all those player counts it just it is it is different I will say though that the interesting thing about playing three player which Nick you're right I've only played three player twice and those are my first you know once with you guys once I'm BGA those are the first two times and and then two player every time since it's a little faster also just opportunity but one of the things I took away from the three player game was that you you don't come around to picking the action anytime soon so I felt a lot less control you know of course that was the game I was like falling on my face but you know it can be really difficult to anticipate what's going to happen you know and how am I going to adapt to that which I think makes you to what you're saying right is it friendlier you have to kind of be set up but it also makes it harder for you to have any control like kind of over what you're doing like if you didn't move your people into the right spots like you could go several actions before you can fix quote unquote fix that right yeah yeah I mean exactly and I think that's why yeah I think you're agreeing with me here that the four player game is I need to set up so that things don't look bad for me over the next three actions right
like there were the next three decisions and that's that's part of it like folks are more inclined to play defensively because they have less control over the game and I would actually argue that that is more fun but if you're here to like really outplay your opponent then the two-player game is going to be smoother for that and that's not to say that a four player game doesn't have those moments right like the ability to to to cheat once per game is is actually massive like it it you can your entire game plan can be based on like oh like John's going before me in the turn order he does this I'm gonna cheat on his turn so now it's my turn and I make the decision and I'm the only one who can do this of all four players on the table so this is gonna be amazing and like from there hopefully run away with it uh I do want to very briefly touch on replayability you know a bit of a buzzword in board games and whatnot but like how this game you know the basic game of the version of it it has the 16 different departments that you can add onto your board um and uh the donations are always the same but I've played this game I guess nine times with the base game and then two times with some of the expansion components that came with the kickstarter and I found that essentially every one of those plays with the base game felt totally different from the previous one I've only tried the expansion stuff because it was there and I was kind of curious not because I was like personally feeling super exhausted by it part of this game involves drafting uh tile during setup that
you're kind of reserving and I've tried to draft a different tile at the start of every game or at least for a while to to see the different flows of it and I've been really impressed by how you know just playing the bass game over and over again can still make different uh game states that seem really similar and Nick I mean I imagine just about all of your 70 plays have been base game only um yeah I mean I've played with the expansion departments a chunk but mostly base game the other thing worth pointing out for me though is because I played the old version of the game like before they sort of made the edits for the official game that got out so I would say like maybe I don't know half of my games and I'm kind of just making up that number where like played with the old version speaking of replayability John I think that this is a game that does have that endless replayability for the variety it's a game you want to play nine times we talked about the levels of strategy you can get to the game you want to play 70 times but I played the game like nine times within like four days and you know I I felt like suddenly I'd seen every building and I was I was I was kind of bored with it I felt like I had I felt like I had I'd had enough I'd gotten what I wanted out of it I kind of felt like okay like I've seen I've seen enough I understand the game now and I could see myself getting better I could see the places where I had weak spots I was like I can't figure out donations okay I figured those out I can't figure out the map I couldn't figure that out and then I was like I don't know like but I felt like the buildings for me were the were
the weak spot where I just I wasn't excited about them I didn't see you know I've said this before I love strategies that I can like pull out I can see at the beginning of the game and I'd be like Oh I'm gonna do that that that's game you know we talked about this dead reckoning oh I'm gonna I'm gonna play these cards this game so I didn't really see that and um then John and I played last night he said let's play with the expansion I almost said no but he was like but he was kind of started pitching it and I was like all right let's do it so the expansion has new buildings it's not that many right is it like eight new buildings no 166. 16. wow okay it has a bunch of new buildings they all have what I at least the ones that came out in our game which is only about five of them they all had really interesting new Dynamic strategies that I felt like added elements at the beginning of that game I felt like there were two paths to take where I was like oh this combo would be cooler this combo would be cool and and I think this is super key new donations because I was also bored with the donations they were like there's the there's a bunch of them but it became fairly apparent very quickly that there's a couple of obvious ones that kind of everyone kind of goes for and you're like okay I gotta take that and I've said this about a lot of games in the past where I'm like you know I said this about Messina 1347 I was like I'm afraid that there's gonna be like a route that you're gonna fall in that you kind of have to do and I was starting to feel that a little bit with Carnegie I was like if I don't put this here if I don't do this you know well you you might not you know playing the game well enough to do well and I think that those new donations it was bomb so
the kickstarter version ships with all this expansion content we keep saying expansion yeah like I said it's just a series of modules new departments you can add a new uh donations you can add in that kind of thing it's shipped with the expansion version the retail version doesn't have it it's my understanding that there are some ways to acquire it uh like as a individual thing but I'm not super versed in that so I don't think it's a Kickstarter exclusive but I think for the most part that is where the expansion currently lies so we don't want to like belabor the expansion too much but um it is cool that all that stuff was in there and I enjoyed the variety that brought even though I have enjoyed playing the bass game over and over again it was also fun to be like oh this is shiny after you know seeing largely the same set over and over again yeah I hope I hope that it gets released or if it's available or even if you can just add some of those elements because I do think for me personally playing it that much now not everyone's gonna play it nine games in a week but I do think that that's what I was missing I was already I told John I was like I am so glad we played this game I was all ready to come to this podcast and say you know yeah it's a good game it's solid I'll play it anytime I'm really you know I enjoyed it I'm it's good and now after that play last night playing with the new stuff I was like oh this fixed the sort of sameness that I was like afraid I'd fallen into and maybe maybe I can get some of my friends to I mean speaking of someone who has taught this game to many new people I have seen them fall in their face and be like that was the best game I played in a while still see a glimmer in the eyes so like it's been fun it's genuinely fun
to introduce this game to people that's part of the reason why I've talked to so many people because I'm like oh you know my friend Matt is gonna really like this oh my friend Claire's gonna really like oh Anastasia I mean for months now I keep talking about it we've got a like private Discord server where we plan from the Thai stuff and I can't be like played Carnegie again it was freaking great I can't believe Anastasia hasn't played this yet so I felt very validated when I played when I taught this to you and then you played it and even though you didn't have a very fun first play just seeing you go crazy over this last week I was like okay I'm not I'm not crazy there's a very boorish aspect to this one for sure I know but I didn't even think I enjoyed it like I was like doing that that but I was like I still wasn't convinced I still wasn't I was I know I know that sounds insane but I just wasn't okay it was literally it was that play last night it took me 11 plays and then I apparently I just I you know it takes me a lot of dates to get down the altar so yeah I mean Carnegie is a game that I have not been able to shut up about for a long time and it's been really fun watching uh Anastasia's you know Montage over the last week training montage um and it's been fun playing this game a whole bunch like like I said I played five times in the last three weeks or so I think and I as of this moment I'm considering this the best game that I that I've played this year and I've been kind of feeling like that for a minute just because I'm throwing that down he's throwing it because of the the freshness of the feel and and just I don't know I've just
really enjoyed playing and again I won this game a bunch and so part of me is tempering it like okay maybe you were just liking it because you kept coming out on top and then suddenly you're not winning and now you're like oh maybe maybe it's not my thing as much I'm gonna figure that out but it's just incredibly fresh like it's whenever anybody asks me like oh what's a cool game that's come out this year this is the first game I talk about because and they say what's it like and then I'm like well that's why this game is so exciting because it's hard to describe and I'm really glad we had this conversation for like a hundred reasons but one of them is like we always we learn more things about this game talking about it and it never occurred to me after 11 games and talking about this one Ad nauseam with friends forever that it's a programming game on top of so many other things and like that's my big takeaway from this discussion like it's almost more programming game than it is a lead follow game and that just that just speaks so much to the game that not only each time do I play it do I feel like I see new layers and depths and be like oh my gosh I see a hazy thing like a hundred people owe me I thought I was already near the bottom but I'm not even close but even just discussing it every time I talk about it I I kind of come up with some new way to look at it that makes me be like man this game is just cool yeah it defies it defies a lot of the sort of like norms and I think that's what makes it stand out the thing about this game is it's very rare for me to fall in love with a game that doesn't spark me on the first play usually there's something in the first play of it that like just gets me and then I'm like oh that's so cool I like I gotta figure this out
and and I know that you guys are looking at me like what are you talking about you then played this game nine times you know six of which were in the next two days but that almost was like a frustration like I need to figure this one out why don't I understand it like kind of level I wanted to see it and so it just it's very interesting for me uh to come at it now and to be like oh this one's like really digging its claws in but you know what I what sparks me about it is is changing I think that probably has a lot to do with the fact that it's such a interconnected game state of how you got semi-cooperative again still not the word uh way of of playing it just makes for such a different experience um but that's so tied to the way we play it but man it is a good game it is a really um I still have a couple reservations about it mostly just in that kind of like sharp edges and replayability but you know I guess in like a couple of months when I'm like a master at it I'll be like oh this is the best game ever play me okay uh okay so that that's uh I think that brings us to the end of Carnegie here this has been a fun Journey one of our this might be our very likely yeah let's see so much to say honestly we could have said so much more there's like whole mechanics that we didn't really even harp on we spent a lot of this conversation in the emotional space and I think that's because Carnegie is a is a is a very logical game that generates a lot of emotions
um and and I I think that's just the reality going in it it's definitely worth checking out if you're you know into uh medium or slightly heavier games but you know keep in mind that that first game is is probably going to feel really weird and so give it give it the double shot I think you'll appreciate it um but thanks for being along and if you if you want to see uh you know again John has has both uh uh play through with directions and then an actual play with friends so you can kind of watch the game being uh played live if you're curious more of it yeah you could experience a full play without playing it if you really want to uh watching the video but you know that's not everybody's bag yeah and please uh check out the YouTube version of this and leave us some comments especially I'm dying for a new semi-cooperative word so um I would love that give us some options and we'll uh when we find a winner we'll use it forevermore so yeah and thanks for hanging out with us