Skip to main content
Loading video...

Magical Athlete Review — More than Candyland 2.0

Transcript 21:22

Is this the weird resurgence of roll and move? I initially thought this was like Candyland 2.0 because literally your turn is rolling a d6 and moving that many spaces on this bright board. But after playing this a couple more times, I'm actually kind of impressed. So yes, magical athlete is just dumb dice rolling. Roll die move.

The twist is is that your magical athlete racer has a unique ability and for every game you will draft four racers to use upon four different races. And on two of the races, you'll go on this really wild one that can reward you for going backwards. Huh. This just isn't a deep game by any means. But this 30-minute party game, I felt like it deserved a decent dive. It's playable at two to six players, and we played it at these player counts to the side. But before going more, this video is brought to you by Uprising: Curse of the Last Emperor, a fantasy 4X that's cooperative. It's for one to four players to pilot a rising faction, complete with their own units and unique leader. The goal is to lead this uprising against the empire who rules from their central capital. But then there is a far greater danger beyond the frozen seas, the hordes of chaos. And each side will continually spawn their special legion and horde units. What this means for gameplay is that you have to fight the empire and chaos at the same time and sometimes stand to the side when they fight each other. You win at the end of the game when all players have more points than both horde and chaos. So, not an easy feat with managing the growth of a faction, picking up gobs of dice to roll, and the difficulty always just smacking me in the face. Uprising definitely had me leaping up and down with many climactic combats.

Okay. All right. Okay. Five hits. No kidding. This game is challenging. Like, it kicked our butts all three times we played it. So, it's definitely for those who enjoy a tough puzzle. Anyways, for more on Uprising, check out the game found link below. Now, back to the video. How to play Magical Athlete. Goal is to get the most points after four races. A race is just a board. Go from start to finish. To get points, you usually want to get first or second place in a race. But before racing, you will first draft your magical athletes. With most player counts, you'll perform two stake drafts to pick four racers. At the beginning of each race, all players will select one racer secretly to race with, then reveal them. Spawn them at the start, and the first player rolls, and that's how much they move forward. It's that simple. There's not really any phases in this game. Abilities will go off when they say they go off. Sometimes you have a choice. There's simple stuff like tripping others or doing things when passing others or giving buffs to movement. When the first and second place are achieved, the race immediately ends. Discard all remaining figures and flip the board to the next track. Pick another racer secretly to race with. You can't use your previous racers. They're tired and don't want to race anymore, unless you can use an ability to clone them. Anyways, after the fourth race, count up all your points to see which player wins. Pros, this is a really cleanly presented game, and it being so vibrant just matches the general vibe of it. Wooden pieces are everywhere with wooden dice and screen printed meeples with different sizes. They also came in these paper bags to help organize and that really fits this retro theme.

Having no plastic bags just feels like a breath of fresh air. The board is ultra intuitive. I mean, you don't even have to open the rule book to understand what landing on these spaces are. You can move this way or get extra points. And the rule book is pretty and really easy to go through. It's like a story book. I'm actually surprised they have the fiddly details and character quick fact. It's some nice quality of life. Like it even covers the edge case if there is infinite loop. Nice work. But we have to talk about all these racers which are the heart of the game. These magical athletes and you get 36 of them. They're all mostly unique. But even if some are similar, they all have a lot of character and resonance. Resonance is well, you see a thing and it does exactly what you think it would do. So let's get into them. The hair who moves fast for plus two movement to all his roles, but then gets cocky as when he's in first he doesn't want to move. a banana who trips people who moves past it. So, they skip their next turn as they have to get up. There's the big baby W who doesn't want to share spaces.

So, look how big he is to suggest that. Then there's some weirder ones like Sisphus who starts with four points, but then when he rolls a six, he loses a point and has to go all the way to the start. That's his punishment. Or the lovable loser who wants to be in last to get points. Whoa. Point generation Midame. Or legs who says, "Dice optional. let me just walk and move five spaces guaranteed or mouth who even has his name stand for something who just kills who he goes on. We'll be referencing those characters and even some more as we go on cuz there are 36 of them. The next gameplay pro is how some of the abilities let you do some simple predictions while drafting. And then you're also doing this mind game racer select where you want to pick certain racers when they pick certain racers. Like mastermind you predict who will win. If you're right, you get second. Well, if you're drafting and you see someone else take a really strong racer and the others not so much, maybe you take mastermind. Oh, actually, if you're good at predicting, use Twin as you can bank on someone else's strong racer winning a race. So, you copy him for the next race. Or you can draft Egg if you see that, huh, there's a couple strong racers left in the deck. I'm going to draw three and see if I get one. Yep, there we go. This gets paired with selecting the right racer for each map. So, you might have a reason to pick racers that give you the option to move slower on wild wilds to get the VP granting spaces. But then when other people realize you might be sandbagging, they can just lock in fast racers to try to end the race quickly. So, you're in this cheeky situation where you might want to farm the Wild Wilds on race two, but then you might want to also save those racers for the important third and fourth races when the most points are

given out for second and first place. There are some soft counterpicks, too, like how coach gives plus one to everyone on his space, including him. So it hurts heckler who needs people to move one space or take the best of a card without the downside. As a copycat, you can take the blimp's ability to move an additional three for the main move. But then when the blimp is no longer in first, you don't take his downside. Or if you think someone's going to sandbag with lovable loser to farm points, you can pick cheerleader to make the racer in last move too. So you don't get to be last anymore. Hooray. Or use the hypnotist to warp that snail to you. So granted, it's not a game of countering the counter picks because there is pretty low agency in a race once you've locked in your racers, but it's cool that once you're familiar with the characters, you can draft accordingly based off of how other people are drafting, how you think they will use those drafts, and also what map you're playing on. So the weird map Wilds, is a great idea to add to the game as it does add a bit of a wrinkle in the can clause of racers. So you have to worry about not tripping or if someone else should be allowed to continually go backwards to maybe get points. So, it feels a lot different than the vanilla race or how suckerfish can avoid tripping by choosing not to use the suckability if someone else trips, even if it is good distance. It just makes the push your luck of choosing who to suck from the start with the suckerfish just a little bit more interesting. Or if you think other people want rerolls on wilds to not trip and then to not move backwards, you could take the dice monger. He will allow other people to roll. It's just that he will get to move up a space for free. And it's just immediately funny how rolling a one is good from the get- go. With 36 racers and one map where you can move forwards, you can move

backwards, you can get points, you can trip, all just off the spaces. Yeah, not only is there good replay-ability in this game, but there's a lot of silly that can happen. So, the last pro to wrap this up, which is probably the most important pro, is that this general package of magical athletes, leads to a lot of fun ability intersections for some really goofy times without really asking too much from the players. Let's look at the stickler. He says, "No, no, those are the rules and requires people to move exactly to cross the finish line." Well, so if the hair is within one space at the end, and he will always plus to his movement, he just can't win. Or how the stickler can also prevent the coach from winning if he's right at the end because the coach must always move two spaces of minimum. In fact, he makes everyone on his space move to minimum so he can prevent everyone from doing the stickler win on this space. Huh. He encouraged people and then the encouragement made them lose. The party animal is a fun dynamic with duelist as a party animal moves everyone to him.

Whoa, it's a giant party. Well, the duelist can yell duel when with someone else. So, a duel goes off and if he doesn't win the duel, then that person moves up and then the duelist must duel again. He might actually want to lose the duels until he duels the party animal to make that party suck. But uh uh if he loses the duel against a party animal, they have a party in front without him. Or if you just want to kill your enemies, use the hypnotis to warp mouth to you, then hope he lands on them next turn. Uh hopefully he doesn't eat you, though. Oops. Or maybe you just make up a silly pact with your buddy to manipulate turn order with the skipper as the person after skipper can use the dice monger rolled to try to roll a one. That way, the skipper gets to go right afterwards. So, the turn order starts from him. You cut out everyone else from taking a turn on a round. Some things are just super simple and absurd. You can double gunk. So you have copycat copy the gunk so that everyone gets negative -2 to their move. So if you roll the one you move backwards or as a centaur farts past people he moves them minus two spaces. Well that can cause mouth to kill someone and the romantic loves it. So he gets to move two spaces.

He gets happy from the mouth eating up someone. I guess he gets happy from that. He finds it romantic. Consent cons. We found some wording on some interactions to be a little bit ambiguous at times. Like what is considered winning a race? Is it first or second or just first? Probably just first. But then getting second gives you points and also triggers end of the race. So you could argue it's first or second, right? But usually when you win something, you think it's just first place. If mouth kills something like mastermind, is their ability no longer valid to finish second? We're assuming so, but it doesn't say they have to be on the map to have this happen. Or if mouth kills Seisophus, do those points disappear? Probably not because it's worded on the Sisphus fact that he can continue to lose points even if the initial four has run out. So the four points he gives you are permanent. But really, whatever, right? Like if you're playing this game, it's so lighthearted.

You're probably just going to house rule something quickly and move on. I mean, this is a game where it says if there's a tie, you celebrate together. Yay. So yeah, you can just call me the real life stickler during this section. Then something that is also pretty nitpicky is that there's some characters that are just so insanely strong. Scoocher is by far the best character in the game as he lets you move one when another racer power happens while other racers are usually activating when it's not your turn. So you get free movement not on your turn. What's more is that he gets additional movement for the gunk. So it's guaranteed movement off of everyone's roll or there's some mandatory abilities like party animal. The party animal must go off. So Scoocher gets to move again. Why is Scoocher not at the very least restricted to once a turn? Because all the cool ability combos we talked about in pros will make him move an insane amount. Some other characters, Suckerfish, giving you the option to move with someone else. So yeah, I'll just take a free turn. Oh, if he's latching on to a scoocher, well, I think you know who's probably going to get first and second, or Flip-flop, letting you swap places with another racer.

Well, heck yeah, I'll just swap with whoever is in first. Now, of course, you may say this is more of a feature than a bug to keep the game weird. I mean, it even says in the market material that each racer has a deeply unfair game-breaking power. However, it seems like some are more unfair than others, right? It could feel like, oh, whoever drafted early in certain drafts just has a really high chance of winning at least one race, and that matters a lot in higher player counts. But, of course, anything can happen with the die rolls. We'll get back to the imbalance in a bit, though. The biggest gameplay con this game inherently has is that it does have some inherent soft player elimination based purely off of luck. What do I mean by soft player elimination? Well, it means that you're not technically removed from the game. Like, you're still playing, but you have no chance of winning. And usually your turns are pretty boring. So, here, let's say you're in the last two places of a race, and you have no crazy abilities to catch up. So, you're not really doing anything besides just praying for sixes.

You just roll, pray for six, then get a six. Okay, whatever. On the vanilla map like this one, you can't even hope to luck sack into landing into points cuz there's no points on the map to get. The worst is when you're already last place in points and you're in last place on the final race. So yeah, you're just not doing anything. You're just waiting for the game to end. And this stuff again can be through no fault of your own. Like you may have drafted halfdeent characters, but if you just roll badly, too bad. It's really the problem of making the game mostly reliant on roll and move. There's no catch-up mechanics within a race. Like the game's never going full shoots and ladders of having people randomly go to spaces that ports them back to the beginning. Doesn't really happen aside from Sisphus, but that's a player ability. So, the people who are ahead in the race most of the time will keep their lead. Bonus points for feeling bad if you picked a character that needs people around them like banana, mouth, or centaur. If you get these and you roll badly, it's like you don't even have an ability. What is the solution? Well, I couldn't really think of a clean one at first besides making the game shorter, but the next point might actually cover it, which is how magical athlete is actually the best mechanically at two and three players, which is really unintuitive. Like why would you want lower player counts for this silly roll and move party game, right? So in two to three players, you get two different athletes per race, which actually solves the previous gameplay cons. First is that you have two racers to spread out your roles. So if one does badly, it's okay because you have another racer who might be in contention to win or at the very least doing their ability. So there's less player elimination possibility layered on top of how with less other players on the map, there's less downtime between turns. In two players, there's another

slight layer of agency as you get to choose which racer does a turn all by themselves at the start of a game. And then when you normally do your turn, you get to choose which order your racers go in. So maybe you want to give more targets to leap toad over or have another target for third wheel or use party animal first to move his ally up to him so that ally moves one up, then party animal gets the movement buff. Just giving a sequence agency adds so much. So yeah, by having two racers that go on your team back to back really makes the racer imbalance not feel as bad. It really dampens the feeling of, oh, he just got scooter, so he just wins. I read of a house rule online where everyone gets to use two characters, but with five plus players, that might be too many abilities going on the board, but uh I don't know. Uh I guess you can test it and get back to me. I mean, what is that like 10 racers at a time with five people? 6 7 8 9.

It's a lot of dice rolls, too. It's a lot. But man, this game is not really asking for heavy testing anyways or heavy balance anyways. And it's impressive how it works with so many different abilities without breaking too hard. Scoring. Now, it's time for a recommener score where we try to critically evaluate the affforementioned pros and cons of this game with the caveat that we cannot be fully objective in our critique. And so, for only $30 MSRP, this is going to get a score of a recommendder score of 8 out of 10. It is great. Magical Athlete is a game about just creating absurd situations from rolling dice. And there's a lot of variance with a die. I mean, it's 1 through six, right? There's also not that many rerolls possible, so you're mostly expected to just hop on for the ride. It's sometimes less about piloting the guys than just begging them to go faster, like, "Please roll higher. I want you to roll higher. I want you to roll higher." They'll mess up. Others will mess them up. The map will mess them up. And maybe someone totally unexpected will roll sixes twice and just win. It can't happen. So, I mentioned that I thought this game was like Candyland 2.0, know, but upon playing it more, it's more like gambling with different objects and animals and things and just seeing who will be the ultimate racing champion and just kind of observing sometimes. We would say it's not mechanic driven. Rather, it's very character-driven with the universal mechanic of some choice being a snake draft at the beginning of the game. Then some people, usually not everyone, but some people will have characters with a canned claws. This magical athlete is a re-implementation of an older magical athlete from about 20 years ago. And while I haven't played it, that one was

listed at over an hour on average, likely due to the fact that you were initially bidding for athletes, whereas in this remake, you just simply draft them, which lends itself to shorter game time. But is Magical Athlete really 30 minutes cuz I haven't brought up time yet? Well, in two out of three games I played, it wasn't 30 minutes. It was more like 45 minutes. But that difference is pretty negligible because if you think about it, this is four races you're doing and there's no guarantee a race will end quickly. Like look at Wild Wild. There's a lot of backwards and tripping spaces. And then the race outcome is pretty much determined by your character load out. So some character loadouts will lead to faster game states. Some of them will lead to just people tripping each other and going around in circles. Why is this game so popular right now? Well, I suspect it's a bit of a push back against trying all the new board games which are all about crunchy mechanics and tons of decision-making. This game doesn't worry about all those things.

It's a hearkening back to why people might have gravitated towards board gaming as a kid, just picking cool dudes and grabbing out the old d6 and seeing pieces do their thing. For how simple Magical Athlete is, there's plenty of silly, campy stories to witness. And it can just be really refreshing to people. And it's especially inclusive if your game nights include non-board gamers or kids. Heck, you might just want to play without the draft or without four plus people.

I I'm relying on your roles.

You got it. with the same description as you.

Oh, wait. That's right. Yeah.

One, two, three, four, five. We're back.

Our final assessment is that if you really like roll and move games in their simplest form, and you're okay with some people just falling behind on some races because of some roles, because you're just focusing on the cool abilities of everyone firing, not just you optimizing points, then yeah, go for it. You're going to get so many weird scenarios with the value of this fairly self-explanatory yet very quirky lot of 36 racers. And now that you're informed about buying this game, and if you do buy it, you can't seriously complain that this game is too random, right? My personal score for Magical Athlete, my enjoyment of this game is going to be a five out of 10. It's just average. It's okay. First off, I actually don't like this art style at all. It almost feels like I'm in some sort of TV nightmare looking at the cards and bored. It's just way too over-the-top goofy, and it just doesn't work with me.

As for the game play, well, you guys know that I like games with more agency than this and that this game has so much luck. But I feel like actually the worst part about it for me is that I don't really feel like I'm controlling an athlete. When I'm playing Magical Athlete, it feels like I'm watching a sport like on TV where I've placed bets on certain athletes to do things, sports betting. But then this watched sport of a race really has no depth. There's also very little strategy. Of course, there is something to be said on how this seemingly obsoleted role and move is still kind of fun at times because of how many quirky interactions happen when two characters both trigger their thing and play off each other and I'm involved and in some contention for getting at least second place. It's just fun dopamine hit. I don't really expect from party game like oh banana triggers then scoot triggers plus one. It just releases some feels good. Oh wow, our things did something. And if you pick the right characters, you get to do more triggers which is nice. and getting to play the dice man trying to convince people to reroll on their turn was some actual agency. It's probably the most fun I've had throughout an entire race.

But of course, as often as characters are interesting, they can also seem interesting and then barely trigger, especially in my five player game. And then so me and some unlucky others are just left just dice rolling for gameplay and you roll bad. It sucks. It just sucks to see other people doing their cool thing, just bouncing ahead and you're just rolling ones and twos and not doing anything. Oh, great. Yeah, the race finally ended. Good. I wasn't doing anything anyways. So combine the possibility of some surface levels fun stuff happening with the possibility of yeah not really doing anything. This is boring but at least the game is short and yeah averages out. I'm just okay with this. Like sometimes there's decent player interaction with abilities. Sometimes there's none. Then 30 minutes for gameplay feels about 10 minutes too long. I totally agree with Alex who declined to do a personal score who said that the dice rolling repetition is like a waste of time. I would extend upon that and say it's actually pretty poor component meeting gameplay as you have to roll again and again and again. But hey, that's just my personal preference.

Personally, I would want this game to be three races max and then have the map scale up in weirdness because who cares about having a balanced map with gameplay like this? If it's going to be so silly and a race, maybe add in some type of real-time element. And the snake draft feels kind of disjointed for me because there's a lot of effort spent to draft the best teams and then try to guess others racers when selecting yours as you consider the map for payoff that is just roll and move. Like that's it. Like sometimes when playing I don't even need to read your ability because I'm just doesn't affect me at all. I know your thing is strong, but it doesn't affect me at all. Like couldn't they have added another mechanic for your razor to do? Like maybe decide to roll I don't know like eat something and roll more or like exhaust their card and do something. I don't know, interact with their space more. So, this is a three out of 10 for five players, which means that how most people are playing this game is not what I enjoy at all. But for two and three players, oh, you get to use two characters and combine them. So, yeah, this game opens up a lot more.

Ultimately, I'm going to give the game the benefit of the doubt as I look through the abilities. Yeah, they're charming. I can see the fun connections going on, and I feel like I will get asked to play this in the future, and I probably won't say no. So, yeah, I'm just going to settle on a five out of 10. I don't know, maybe at the end of the day, roll and move with no mechanics is just this chicken noodle soup for a lot of us. And I mean, yeah, there could be worse than this. Turn brain off, turn auto battler program on, and just just roll dice and do thing. Anyways, that's the video for Magical Athlete. Please let me know what you think. I've played Hot Streak and I might be doing a video on that. So, yeah, let me know. Um, yeah, maybe I should do a Candyland review one day. Anyways, thank you to our patrons for making videos like this possible. We also got our Mad Labs of Cardboard here. And yeah, we got a lot of big videos coming up. So, talk to you guys then.

Bye-bye.

I got 15, too.

So, it's a tie.

Yeah.

Yeah. Actually, it says in the rule book, it's a tie. Yeah.

Progress saved