Justin Gary is a Pioneer | We Talk Magic, Ascension & Lord of the Rings | BGSS ep_025
Transcript
Exactly. Exactly. They pay me $30,000 to by winning the prize, the pro tour, and then they ban the card I won with.
Oh, yeah.
Happy to do that. And we found that the one ring did break the game when I could acquire it on turn one. Tim
DMs me on X on, you know what, what was Twitter, I think, still at the time. Anyway, uh, and I was like, "No way. This is not for real." Uh, I didn't believe it.
I'm a sucker for deluxification and cool ways to store it and cool boxes. Stop it.
I told you I don't have a job.
Absolutely. And sadly, I will not reveal them on this interview.
My guest today won a Magic the Gathering national championship at 17. He was the youngest ever at the time. He designed for Upper Deck. He created this little game called Ascension and founded Stone Blade Entertainment. Also literally wrote a book on game design. We talk band Cards, Broken Rings, 15 Years of Ascension, deck building, the new Lord of the Rings Ascension game. Folks, this is Justin Garary.
I appreciate you uh making time to come on here today.
Yeah, it's my pleasure. I love talking about games. So,
yeah, I was um uh I think I might have mentioned I was listening to the Tim Ferrris podcast and first of all, what an incredible opportunity there. like in 2023 you were able to go on to the Tim Ferrris podcast which just blew my mind. I was like what? I think you know for people that don't know Tim Ferrris like 1.7 million on YouTube and then you know tons more on other platforms. What was that like? Oh, it was it was so surreal. I um you know so the way that that went down is um actually a year earlier uh I was on it was New Year's Day. I was on the beach in Santa Mara, Colombia, and just relaxing, enjoying my time. And then Tim DMs me on X on, you know, what what was Twitter, I think, still at the time. Anyway, uh and I was like, "No way. This is not for real." Uh I didn't believe it. And uh but I looked and and checked it out and turns out it was. And he had been listening to my Think Like a Game Designer podcast and was a fan. And this just, you know, completely blew my mind because if you notice, the format of my Think Like a Game Designer podcast just basically aped his. Like I just thought this was a really good idea. So I kind of just copied him.
Uh and I told him so and uh anyway, you know, we ended up chatting and he had, you know, some interest in working on a games project and I helped him out with his project for a little while and then he mentioned it might be cool to have me on the podcast and I, you know, trying to like, oh well, okay, if you think so. I could do that,
I guess. You know, if you really want me to. All right. Um, so yeah, it was a real it was a real highlight and milestone for me. I mean, his book, uh, the 4-hour work week, I'd read it while I was working as a game designer, uh, at Upper Deck. And, you know, that was kind of my dream job was to be the game designer. And that book really helped along with a couple of other factors me decide that I wanted to quit and start my own business. And you know, so he was very directly influential in my career and the fact that Stone Blade is now celebrated 15 years uh with since the initial release of Ascension and uh now we're doing the Lord of the Rings Ascension and you know all of these different paths that uh may not ever have existed without him. So to be able to come on his podcast and you know share some of my insights and uh to be a part of that was a really big honor.
Was it Coyote that you helped on?
I helped Well, he there was a variety of projects. Yes. what what ended up becoming Coyote, but there was a variety of different game ideas that he had. And I kind of helped him work through the early stages of what type of game to make and how to approach the game design process. And it was really fun being on the kind of, you know, the flip side of like, you know, Tim Ferrris is very famous for, you know, kind of breaking things down into their like constituent parts and like finding the sort of most efficient way from here to there. So, it was fun being like the expert interviewed by him on the other side where he's trying to break down the game design skill, which is exactly what I tried to do in my book and in my podcast. And so, it was fun to sort of see uh you know, kind of have that back and forth. So, uh you know, helped him with the process in general.
For anybody that wants to know your story and usually I try to kind of get the guest story out, but you and Tim went through that so incredibly well. And I I was I'm obviously intimidated interviewing somebody that was interviewed by Tim Ferrris. That podcast is incredible. And and there's some really great stories. The magic story and like the retribution. She needs to be a movie. I need to see that in some sort of screenplay or something. Because as I'm running running this morning, what listening to it for the second time, I was kind of like, "Oh, I could just like see this as a geeky Rocky moment, you know." Right. Uh, so
yeah, it's great. And yeah, I mean, hopefully maybe we can link to it uh in the show notes for people that haven't heard the episode, you know, I won't recount the whole thing here, but it was,
you know, there are these notes that I have learned in my life as I you learn traits about yourself, right? Right. So I, you know, I started off as a pro-Magic player and had some big successes and some big failures and I faced those failures in ways that were uh they were very painful, but I had this sort of determination to drive to kind of write the wrongs, you know, and that
that mentality has replayed itself in my life so many different times, you know, whether that be losing the US National Championships when I was 17 and coming back to finally rein them six years later, whether it be, you know, having a game project that launched but didn't do as well as I wanted and then coming back and rebringing it back to life as I did with Soul Forge and Soul Forge Fusion. Um, having different versions of how I've grown and regrown my company and re-imagined different aspects of what uh I've done uh in a lot of different aspects of my career. And uh I think that that tenacity sometimes works against you, right? It's it can it can lead to this sort of uh
internal demons uh for lack of a better term where you do feel like you know kind of driven in a way that may not be healthy but it's also incredibly powerful. And so I've learned as I've noticed those patterns in my life to try and what I call this, let's call it the nerdy references, right? I like being powered by the dark side or the light side of the force, right? The dark side is the quick and easy path. It's powered by anger and fear of not being enough of like letting your failures define you and trying to kind of constantly prove yourself. And a lot of us out there can probably relate to this. We, you know, that's a powerful driver. It will get you pretty far, but it's not a very healthy way to live in the long run, right? doesn't uh lead to happiness and fulfillment. And then there's the light side where you're pulled by the things that you want to add into the world, the things you want to create, by joy, by okay, this is really exciting and pulling me forward. And that is also a powerful form of fuel, but it takes a little longer to get that spooled up and to use that as a sustainable way to kind of create.
And for somebody that doesn't know Justin Garry's early story, it's the youngest Magic Champion, is it world champion? Uh, ever? I was I was I was the youngest US national champion when I was 17 and then I won the world team championship six years later.
Yes. But that came with a failure which was the first US loss, right? And then six years later you got Retribution and and an in talk about like an incredibly this is where I was thinking like this has to be some sort of a movie like the amount of pressure that was felt there on yourself because it it feels like a storybook moment but we know in life it doesn't always work out like a storybook moment like were were you feeling confident even after your uh your mulligan?
Yeah it was. So so you know so again to give a little bit more of the context since we're getting it right. And when I was 17, I was the US national champion and then we were the only US team in the history of Magic to not win the world championships, right? So it was like this big big failure to me. And then it wasn't until 5 years after that, finally a US team loses again. So now I'm not the only loser. They lose to the German team. Then the year following, Worlds is in Germany. And so now I'm flying into the, you know, into the den as the a member of the US national team to go and take the title back. Uh and so wi when going into that this is plays that determination role again like I I flew my teammates to where I was living in Boston where I was working with the your move games teams. We kind of we lived together we ate slept breathed magic for like six weeks or something before the event. Uh and so I was very very determined to kind of make sure that we didn't make the same mistake to really push hard for it. And it was, you know, when I won, like when I won the US National Championships, it was completely unexpected. It was like just this kind of really cool, joyous thing.
When I won Pro Tour Houston, it was another one of those things where I was like, I had trained really hard. I'd worked really hard, but it was also just this like really joyous, like I can't believe it. Winning that World Championships, every step all the way to winning that World Championships was like a focused grind of like don't mess this up. And like the winning, the feeling of winning wasn't like elation. It was like relief, you know? It was just like I could let go. I did it. Like this is just it had been it had been such a albatross around my neck for the last for the previous six years uh as this this kind of big failure uh that I was so grateful to finally let go of. And then the jubilation fill in and then you know I had I had friends all swarm me at the stage and like kind of just had this you know huge moment and it was like okay cool like now I can chill. I did it. And honestly, that was like the beginning of the end of my magic career, right? Like I I I think I played for not that much longer
because I did everything I set out to do. You know, I had I kind of checked all the boxes. And and it's another thing that I've sort of realized in life is that, you know, there's these windows where the thing that matters most to you in the world and is the center point of your life after a certain amount of time, you know, six, seven years, you know, some seven to 10 years, somewhere in that range, like you're going to play out your karma in that space, whatever that looks like. And it's time to be able to open up to transition into something new. And that's not always easy to do. It often feels like you're lost. It can feel like the things that you know that that that how you defined yourself, your identity is at stake, right? Um and so being open to that, I've now gone through that transition several times in my life. Um and now I kind of can recognize a little sooner and be like, okay, uh now I need to be open to what the universe kind of wants for me. And and a tip I use for this is like life has yes phases and life has no phases. And what I mean by that is um when you are when you're really focused and you know what you're supposed to be doing, you pick the things that are most important to you, you're in a no phase, which means you should be saying the no to pretty much everything that is not like one of your top three priorities in life. And the the success comes from relentless focus.
But then when you run play that out and you're not fulfilled by that anymore or you've done you're ready for something new, then you got to go into a yes phase where you start saying yes to everything. You start trying all kinds of stuff. You start doing things that are sort of weird that probably won't work. And you now keep exploring and opening up until you find that thing that now suddenly resonates and kind of the universe is sort of telling you, yeah, okay, this is the thing. Then you close back down into a no phase and really focus on that.
That's so funny you say that. I am very much in a yes phase and I'm outside of uh you know, I was recently laid off of a job that I've had for 23 years at a at the same company, worked there forever. Um, I've very much focused on that and my kids. My kids have kind of grown. They're in the late middle school and then up into high school ages now. So now I'm in a in a time in my life where I don't have the the excuses of really focusing in on on them and that particular job. Now I am all about trying to say yes. In fact, that's exactly how I described it yesterday. Um, interviewing Peter C. Hayward who is uh just going to crowdfund rolling deep and uh that's that's exactly the explanation I gave is I'm trying to say yes to absolutely everything in my life to see what the universe brings me and I'm not this woo woo guy but I just have this like drive right now to really see what's out there because I've never really done it before. So that hits home big time.
Yeah. Yeah. Especially Yeah. If you've had a career for that long and kids that's a you know it's a massive massive commitment. And yeah, for those of you out there that are allergic to the woo language of let the universe speak to you, like you don't need woo language here, right? You have a set of unique skills and uh a internal traits and experiences that are providing you that are making you uh well adapted to some combination of things in the world. And you can't know that lock and key fit until you find the different, you know, try the different locks to see where your key actually fits, right? It doesn't require a magical force in the world. If you believe in that, great, no, more power to you. But if you don't, it's like it's still a rational, you know, expand, explore, exploit strategy that that YouTube for gamers out there.
Yeah. Exactly. Uh exactly. So, so it is it is a it is a rational way to solve uh problems of uncertainty uh for those that are uh uh you know, want to just speak in pure game game theory. Right. I I very much feel like I've been brought to this exact point through my experiences and through um I don't know. I guess it's a confluence of circumstances that were, you know, maybe I've always been heading, but that confluence of these circumstances all happening at the same time and these different opportunities starting to kind of pop up. It it feels a little woo woo, which that's that's the odd thing. You know, I've never been like, "Oh, I'm going to manifest or whatever," but it kind of se feels like that. So, um, you know, I'm I'm embracing it no matter what you call it right now, but this is not about me. It's about you.
Sure. Sure.
Um, so take did your experience in Magic and you'd mentioned that playing the game, Magic in particular, has nothing to do with design, but were you able to bring anything out of that experience that you've kind of applied to your design career over the last 15 years?
Oh, of course. Yeah. I mean like there's so when I you know the way I talk about game design it breaks down into different phases right there's sort of engine design and engine development there's component design component development and there's pro um polish right those are kind of the five phases uh when you're designing you're trying to craft an experience for your audience and that is all about sort of the emotions and experiences that you're able to create through the tools at your disposal that's both rules and components and every piece that you're that that that the player experiences Um, and then development is making sure that those uh those different aspects come through in the right way. And that's where people traditionally think of balancing a game. Um, making sure that the strategies are, you know, competitive and that there's the right aspects of the game are emphasized. That latter part of development being a promagic player is super useful, right?
Like my whole job as a pro player was to break the game, right? My I I won in my my mind when I forced Wizards of the Coast to ban a card because of how much I destroyed everybody with it. That's that was a victory for me.
You're the hacker that the government hires to come in to patch their systems, right?
Yes. Exactly. Exactly. They pay me $30,000 to by winning the prize, the Pro Tour, and then they ban the card I won with.
Oh, yeah.
Happy to do that. Right. And so that that was my uh that was my mo mentality. And so then as a designer I can now take that mentality and invert it and say okay what would I do as a player how would I break this and then either you know give players that like carrot to chase but make sure it doesn't ruin the game or you know shift it to make sure that the the right systems are incentivized so that the you know the kind of the hacker is out there like me would be uh making the game more fun not less fun. Um, and so there's a lot of pieces that come into that, but but the fact that I can see the highle strategies pretty well and I can uh with limited numbers of play test games kind of figure out what's broken and what's not is incredibly useful because most of the games that I make like you know Ascension and Shards of Infinity and things like they're designed even though they can be played super casually around the kitchen table and a lot of people do or on your iPhone or whatever they are designed to withstand very high level competitive players and like that's why there's a the kinds of games that we make as at Stone Blade are intended to be played you know, hundreds or thousands of times. And I have plenty of people that send me screenshots of them playing Ascension and 30,000 games and 5,000 games or 10,000 games. And so building a game that can support that level of rigor. Um, and and not to to to knock other games, you know, there are some games where you play it five or 10 times, you have a good time, and that's it. And that's okay, but that's not what I'm interested in. And so my skill set from a Magic Pro background, including some of the people on my team who I've hired from that background, um are it really helps us to uh develop games at a high level with a small team in a very
efficient way.
Did you personally get a card banned in Magic from your uh in a deck you played?
Yeah. Um Oath of Druids I won the Pro Tour with. Uh Thawing Glacers is what I won US Nationals with. Um both of those got both those cards got banned soon after my uh my be a badge of honor, right?
Yes. Yes, it is. I wear it proudly.
Right. Were you the person that uh popularized that deck or did you see that in other deck lists that you then kind of made a tweak before those plays?
Yeah. I mean, those are both of those decks were my uh creations. So, especially with the Nationals one, like I didn't even This is 1997. Like, there's not like a you know, a lot of internet at this point, right? Like
it's like word of mouth.
Yeah. Yeah. And I didn't I didn't I wasn't I wasn't connected to the community at all. Like so so the way I got to US nationals like I just like hung out with my friends and played Magic on the weekends. They wanted to take a road trip up to the to the uh state championships. So I tagged I tagged along and I won the state championships. Uh and then I was supposed to be going to debate camp that summer, which is how I went off on that whole debate tournament story with Tim, which I
another great one which we'll save for the other podcast. Uh and uh and then uh and then but my parents couldn't afford to send me that summer. Um and so instead I ran a tournament at my local game store. Uh they I I was actually able to call up Wizards of the Coast and get it sanctioned. Like just call them on the phone and get it done. Uh this is
No, it does not. It's very different. Uh back and then I got so I ran in and enough people in the local community chipped in, you know, played in the event and I got enough money to fly to US Nationals. Uh but I didn't have again I didn't have a big connection. I just this was the deck this red blue deck that I had just been playing a ton that I loved and I just brought it to nationals that uh I had figured out I had figured out that thawing glaciers was pretty very good and they had just introduced the new mulligan rule where you could like repeatedly mulligan uh you know down uh that what they called the Paris mulligan rule. You could keep keep refreshing your hand with one less card each time as much as you wanted. And uh I figured out that as long as you had a Thing Glazers in your hand, it didn't really matter how many cards you had cuz it would make up any card advantage you lost. Uh and so I just abused that system to the best of my ability. Um, and then what's so you could still look up Gary Oath for my my Oath of Droids deck where I just kind of there were other people who had done Oath of Druids decks that uh but I had really optimized it uh to within an inch of its life in a way that you basically just anytime your opponent played a creature you had only I had only one creature in my deck which was the Cognavore uh which was power and toughness equal to the number of instance and sorceries in your discard pile. So whenever they play a creature if I had no out I would flip like 30 cards in my deck into the discard pile have a 3030 Cognavore on board and then just kill you next turn.
Well, okay. Do you play Magic anymore? It seems like you're still pretty well verssed.
No, I'm all the All the cards I'm referencing are old school cards. So, like if you Yeah. If you started talking to me about the new cards, man, I would be uh embarrassingly uh uh weak on it. Like I will like pay attention to the new stuff. Um I just had Mark Rosewater on my Think Like Game podcast. Actually, that that episode has not Yeah, that just aired recently. Um, and uh, got to talk about some of the, you know, the new design philosophies and everything, but I more now look at Magic as a designer, not as a player. Um, and it's it's in part uh, because well, I don't have as much time to really invest as I used to. It's very hard for me. When I play Magic now, you know, when I was at the top of my game, like it was a job. Like I would play six hours a day. I would like, you know, it was not a joke and I took it very seriously and I was very good. But when I'm not like that, if I just sit down and play a game, like, you know, I still have some decent instincts, but I'm way worse than I was.
And it's very hard playing a game where you like know that you could be much better than you are and you're just like playing badly. It's like it's pretty difficult to just like treat it as a casual fun game now,
right? It's one of those games you have to understand the meta. The meta is always changing. The deck lists are constantly changing what whatever you're trying to counter. And uh and it's out there on the internet where people are play testing against all of the newest results
instantly. That's right. To find it's it's it's totally changed. Um I would imagine
when when Tim asked you about what the magic is in Magic, and that's probably the the wrong words. One of the things that you said that I thought was really interesting was creating your own experience. You were just talking about building your own deck outside of the game. Is that the true magic to that game uh that that really kind of draws people outside of the the collectibility and all of that stuff?
Um well, Magic is a wide tent. Um there's a lot of aspects that appeal to different people. Um you know, so you yeah, you mentioned collectibility, you there's, you know, the sort of interesting of the strategy, there's this, you know, um the fact that you're able to build your own deck and some people can express different pieces of themselves through that, right? So this idea that when I create a deck, I am, you know, building this whole gameplay experience. If I'm building, you know, kind of an elf deck or if I'm building something that's optimized to stall the game and stop everybody from using any resources or if I'm using a, you know, burn quick destroy you as fast as I can deck, like that says something about me as well as about the game. Uh, and so I think that there's this these this funnel through which, you know, role playing games do this to some degree, but they're a little intimidating because it's kind of like what do I do?
I could do I could do anything. Um, Magic really puts that, you know, the the ability to sort of customize within a defined space, I think is something that people really love and magic created such an incredible foundation for that, right? the way that the mana and the resource system works, the way that there's, you know, the the sort of color pie that each color has a theme and there's some tensions around which themes you want to use. There's so much exploration space there um that it really can become a complete lifetime addiction uh you know for you in both positive and negative uh terms of that word you can afford it. Um, yeah. Yeah. Well, and and there's this there's this interesting phenomenon around collectible games, right? And I've again I've done I've designed a bunch of different collectible games as well as box games, but it was really one of the problems I tried to solve with Ascension.
And in a collectible game, there's this pressure that you constantly have to buy the newest thing and have the latest thing and keep up with all of the strategy just like we talked about, right? So, I can't It's hard to just be like a casual Magic player. It's always feels like I constantly need to buy more and do more and if I don't keep up then I'm out of date and my stuff my experience is not good. Now, the experience I have that I have around the kitchen table, the decks I had don't get any worse and the experience that we could have because new stuff is releasing, but there's a psychological element where it does feel that way. And Ascension was designed in part to give you that feeling of building a Magic deck, especially in this like drafting kind of format, which was what the Ascension Center row was meant to mimic um without having to have that feeling, right? You can play the base game of Ascension. You open it up, you play the game, it's complete, it's fantastic.
It's you you know you can play it a thousand times and if you want the expansion cool you can play the expansion on its own complete fantastic you can jump in at any point if you're a Lord of the Rings fan and you want to just play Lord of the Rings essentially you don't have to know anything about any of the past you don't have to know anything about the future you just play this box experience and you get like it scratches that itch in a way um because you are going to able to build your own custom deck because there's a lot of different branching paths that you can go down um and you kind of get to start on an even footing because everybody starts with the same basic deck instead of the you know oh well I have a thousand collection and you've got 20 bucks that
or I just found the one broken card combination that nobody knows about yet or whatever it might be.
Yeah, exactly. And so in many ways like my my game design career, not only of course was it foundational because of Magic. I would never be in the game industry if not for Magic, but also it is a lot of the games I've created have all been about scratching that same itch in a new way, right? Because Magic in many ways, the exploration and unknown part, like when I was 16, 17, first playing the game, I'd open up a pack of cards and I'd see a card I never saw before. Like I was able to go to the US National Championships with my homebrew deck and just win the thing, win the whole thing. I I don't I'm not sure anybody's done that in the last 20 years. Like, that's just not a thing anymore, right? and and so the the fact that the spoilers are out weeks before the set's done, the fact that everybody's iterated enough online that the the best decks have been discovered within two weeks after the set's released, that that that discovery process has been taken away, which to me was the real like the magic within Magic, right, to let use the the same term. Uh and so I think what I try to do with ascension and charge of infinity and the other projects I'm doing is even and soul for fusion, right? which which I worked on with Richard Garfield, the creator of Mass the Gathering, where every deck is algorithmically generated to be one of a kind. So every deck you buy is guaranteed to be something new.
Uh and so I've done a lot of things in and to varying degrees to to try to keep that spark uh in new experiences for new players.
So you've already kind of explained around benefits of building the deck within the constraints of the game, but I want us to back up. We're going to get into Ascension. I've got a ton to dive in there, but back up to when you first found this mechanic. Where were you? What was it like? What was the game? I think I know which which one it might be, but you know, let us know. So, where did where were you inspired to build a deck within the constraints of the game play?
I mean, are you talking about sort of a deck building game in general?
Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Of course. Dominion, of course. Right. Dominion was the was the first deck building game that came out. It took the inspiration of Magic uh to put it into a single box experience and I played it like a thousand times, right? Like I just like I dissected that game and devoured that game and I but what happened is couple things I noticed, right? So great game, absolutely foundational. Uh but what I noticed some challenges with it, right? because the game is preset up and fixed all you know you lay out 12 different cards that are like the fixed cards that are available that game plus there's some there's like another six cards that are always available and so there's a lot of setup and once I had seen the same pattern of starting cards it was just a puzzle to just solve it like I I knew what was to do I knew what the strategy was and it was a kind of a clear like step A step B step C and then just see how the randomizer plays out right so so suddenly it felt like I had broken a constructed format, right?
Where it's like this is the thing I know what to do and now it's boring. And so what I realized like, well, how would I solve that problem, right? And then that's where I had the idea, well, what if the cards were different every time? They changed every time. You could never predict what was available. And so that's where I had the core idea of ascension of changing an everchanging center row available cards instead of, you know, 12 fixed cards of piles of cards that would be there every time. And then I just took my own design ethos and tore apart a ton of things, right? I I don't like restrictions. So, I got rid of the one play one card play per restriction per turn. I got rid of a bunch of the always available cards and reduce that down by half. I got rid of like a ton of things that I just cleaned up to try to make the game faster. So, I used to joke that like you could actually like set up play reshuffle and set up again a full game of ascension and the time it takes you to set up and play a game of de set up a game of Dominion. Um, and then of course once we had the app that turned from a 30 minutes into, you know, 2 minutes, but uh, but yeah, so I tried to I tried to, you know, um, and then of course I, you know, had more fun with a a fantasy world I invented rather than a I'm still not 100% sure what the theme of Dominion is. So some
I couldn't I don't think I would pass the test if you asked me what that what the theme is.
Yeah. Yeah. So give it give it a theme and a flavor and a story in a world that was exciting. Um, accelerate the setup process. mimic a a everchanging world like you would have in a draft or a limited format where the cards are constantly changing and then take out everything that gets in the way is kind of the was the design philosophy that turned that got ascension. So, we were really the second deck building game to release right after Dominion. Um, I really kind of became obsessed with it and and did everything in my power to like make something that was awesome. And the funny part was when I started making it, I did not expect it to be a game I was going to release. I just made it because I really, really, really wanted to play that game and I busted it out with friends and they loved it. And then I finally another friend, Rob Dhy, who I used to be on the same Magic Pro Tour team with, who was actually the person who I beat in the finals of Pro Tour Houston, he and I were rooming together and the dream that you have when you started Pro Tours, you're like, "Oh, we're going to play each other in the finals." And we did. Uh, anyway, he finally said, "Hey, listen. This is the thing. You've got the ball. You should run with it. Like, make the game." Like, and I uh and you know, that's what we did. How old was Dominion when you started to play it? Like was this a new
I played it as soon as it came out.
So brand new.
As soon as it came out.
So from your first play, how many plays did it take before you started to design your fixes for the issues that you saw in it?
Uh hard to give you an exact number. Uh a couple dozen probably. Um,
I was a it was 18 months from when I first had the idea for Ascension to when it actually hit shelves.
So, it was and I had Yeah. So, it was a it was a pretty fast timeline for building and launching a game, especially building a company. I I didn't have a company even. I just figured that all out as I went along.
Yeah. So, I mean, you self-published this out of the gates, right?
Correct. Yes. That was the first game that
Yes. Everything soup to nuts. It was kind of wild when I look back at it and you know again the game itself was you know maybe six months of development to get it to like oh this game is stinging it's like it's in a really good place and then takes a year to get from there to like something you can actually put on the store. Uh, and so we I showed it off at the Gamma Trade Show, um, back in 2011. Uh, no, 2010, sorry, that was, uh, and, uh, and then I, you know, just kind of got a booth and showed my stuff and, and actually, I didn't even have all the right materials for prototyping. Uh, I didn't have something to track the honor tokens. So, I went to a local Michael's like craft good store and I found these little these little gems that were used in like fishbowls. I was like, "Okay, whatever. We'll use those." And these little shiny little red and clear gems which became our honor gems. And oh my goodness was that the best choice we'd ever made. Everybody that came by the blue is like, "Oh my god, these look so cool. Are these in the game?" Right? I was like, "Uh, yes, yes, they are." No idea how to get them made. No idea how to get the manufactured, but yes, they're happening. And uh anyway, the response to the game was was so positive that I was like, "Okay, I'm going to commit." And I committed to a 10,000 unit initial print run, which is like very aggressive for a new company, new thing. I basically spent put all my life savings uh based on the reaction that I had seen. Uh and then we showed the game off and had the early copies at Gen Con.
We sold out like immediately. We had everybody like not only did we have like people would take the game and then immediately move to a table nearby and just start bust it out and start playing and bringing other people in. We'd see people playing in the halls. Like we were the game of the show from a little like baby booth in Entrepreneurs Corner. Uh it was a it was a dream come true. Was 10,000 units arbitrary or just like all you could afford? You just totally you believed in it because of that reaction at Gen Con?
Yeah, it was Yeah, the reaction to Gamma is when I had to because I have to make the decision, you know, months ahead to be able to have product for Gen Con and release the game in, you know, a couple weeks later in retail. Um, but it was uh well, there's a it was pretty much all I could afford. 10,000 is a break point of your manufacturing costs as well. So it was kind of like okay like the difference between 5,000 to get to 10,000 is significant. Um you know you don't get another significant cost breakpoint for quite a while. And so it was like a combination of like you know the initial kind of pre-interest and excitement from the retail from distributors and retailers the right kind of level that I thought would make sense and uh and just a little bit of you know uh gut instinct and uh kind of foolhardy/fearlessness that you have when you're in your 20s and don't know any better. Was there a big relief going into Gen Con knowing that you had just put this insane order uh you know up and then you see this reaction or how did that or you just full confidence the whole time?
No, no, no. You can't help but have fear like this one thing I talk about a lot when I teach game design and I teach people like fear is always going to be there. Uh uncertainty is always going to be there. Like you need to learn to, you know, cultivate comfort with uncertainty and impermanence which was how I ended the the Tim Ferrris podcast. I think it's still a mantra for me. um you just need to be prepared that you don't know what's going to happen and you need to be okay with that and be able to sit with that. And so that was exactly the case here. And so what I do is I everything that's within my power and that I have control over I will do you know and so I did a lot of marketing up front and promotion up front and we you know got you know had our team very efficiently brought to the to the event and doing uh you know setting up everything we could to kind of promote the game and get it get it in people's hands. But you can't control that like magic spark of like people really just like loving it and sharing it, right?
The game industry lives or dies based off word of mouth and how much people like love your game. Like when people love a game and I'll speak for myself, right? You know, I I didn't I didn't play Magic. Like I was a Magic player. Like I that was a part of my identity. It's who I was. It's who all my friends played Magic. That's how I built the best relationships. Many of which still last to this day 30 years later or whatever. You know, it's like this is it's a it's a it's a core part of who you are. And for me, for ascension to now be that for people started that day, you know, now almost 16 years ago, you know, and and it wasn't until I saw it and felt it from those people in that space in reality that I knew that it was it was real and this was going to be a success. Up until then, it was all uh you know, fear and fire and just do everything in your power to make it work. when you were first starting to play around with the idea, was it is it true that you were using Dominion cards
to proof of concept?
Yeah. So, one of the principles I uh I I also teach and abide by is, you know, keep it simple, stupid. The the KISS principle, like prototype as quickly and easily and ugly as you can because that accelerates your learning process. So, my very first prototype for Ascension was literally just take all the cards you would normally spend the time doing out for Dominion and just shuffle them up and then deal the center row and see how it feels. And like it was clunky and ugly and those cards were not made for that and there was a lot of problems, but like but it was I saw enough of like, yeah, okay, I see how this could work and I see what gets in the way and this is this there's something here. And once I validated that, it was now worth the time for me to spend like building a file of cards and then prototyping those cards and printing those out and getting that to be done, right? It wasn't, you know, shuffle a Dominion set and shuffle it and play that takes you 10 minutes, right? As and and you know, create a file, you know, make that into something that looks good as a prototype, print that out. At the time, like you have to put the little prints into into cards with sleeves and then shuffle those.
That's hours and hours of work. Um, and so before I invest hours, if I can learn a lesson in 10 minutes, like 100% do that. And then from there, you know, you'll every as you validate more and more, then you scale up the amount of effort you put in, right? And so again, I spent the next six months refining that prototype, testing that prototype with different groups, getting positive feedback from a variety of different play test groups. And then and also many of them just like saying, "Hey, don't forget to bring your game." It was called Legion at the time. We didn't come up with the name ascension until later. Don't forget to bring Legion to our Magic Knight cuz I want to play Legion. Right? That's the secret, right? When you know somebody when you've got friends that are like not play testing because you told them to play test, but they're like, "Dude, I want to play again." That's how you know you got magic. And then uh and then once I had that, only then did I start investing in like, "Okay, now I'm going to like pay for real art and now I'm going to look into like, okay, what would the production cost actually be and how would I go about that?" And then you know so you I only scaled my investment and I didn't order that 10,000 units till after I was at Gamma and again like distributors and retailers like when can I order this how much can I order like you know I got I had a lot of even though it's like you know kind of risky and a little bit scary like I had a lot of data at that point to back me up and a lot of iterations to back me up to say okay this is you know I'm not likely to have to build my house out of ascension boxes which is what I would often joke but I didn't have any savings left after that you know uh But I had a pretty good I had a pretty good bet that it was going to sell, you know, if not all 10,000 units at the very least enough that I would be uh I'd be okay and sleep
under a roof.
So the card market was the or the center row was the very first thing that you were prototyping. That's the very first idea that you had. When did the monsters come into play? Was this a was this a magic influence or the creatures? I'm not sure what the right terminology is.
Yeah. Yeah. No, monsters is the right terminology. So, so what happened is um I uh you know, one when I started making my own version, I just defaulted to that being a kind of fantasy battling theme just because that's my you know, that's my ethos and I I kind of you know, it made sense that there would be kind of monsters. But then I also I encountered an issue which is like I I wanted to get rid of the play restrictions. I wanted to get rid of everything that gets in the way in Dominion, right? I didn't like the fact that I was restricted and like play only one card a turn or now I have to do things to get around that. But what I and I did that I did that even in my first version of play testing with Dominion cards. But what I found is like it's a lot less interesting if you only have one resource and no other thing to to no other access to play with. So in Dominion there's actually like your your you know kind of coins that you get to buy stuff and then the number of actions you get to take in a turn and you actually are playing with both of those. So by removing the action restriction, I came up with the idea, but what if instead I just added another dynamic resource? And so ascension then has runes, which let you buy new cards, and power, which lets you defeat monsters. And so that created a nice dichotomy of like what's the difference between a monster villain type character and a hero and or weapon that you would use for yourself. And so those kind of ideas co-evolved. Once I decided I wanted to do a fantasy theme that you could relate to, I the idea of there being some kind of villain monster thing made sense. How do you differentiate
those and was one question and then how do I create enough tension in the choices I make in the center row? Um, and having two different resources and cards that cost those two different resources was the answer to that. And so that is how the kind of idea of monsters and ascension came to life as a both thematic and mechanical um concept that married together really well.
Yeah, that two resources is another I mean you introduce that card market which is a staple now in deck building games, but the two resources also seems to be a staple. I mean like Clank is one of them. Obviously they're they're using one of them for for movement. Um there's got to be a bunch of others as well that I'm not going to remember off the top of my head. Are there any other contributions that Ascension made that you saw others that um that kind of copied and built on top of later on?
It's a good question. Um the center row multiple resources for sure. I think that the what else is like a core innovation. Um I think that I think we were the first ones to do permanence that you can buy that are not just in your deck but that stay in play. Um I don't think anybody else had done that before. So what are constructs in our game?
Constructs. Yeah.
Yeah. Um I think those were the bigger innovations overall. Um yeah I you know we've we've we've um we've innovated a lot of other fronts over the years and introduced new different types of mechanics. Right. to every set we release. Now, we've done 17, not including the 15th anniversary edition, which will be coming out soon, and of course, the Lord of the Rings trilogy, uh, which we're crowdfunding soon. Um, but, um, yeah, I think those a lot of those things became fundamental building blocks for future, uh, deck building games, which we've used obviously as well in other games, right, with Shards Infinity, uh, we developed about eight years after the start of Ascension, and that was built with like, okay, what would I do now from the ground up? And it's more of an aggressive player attacking game. We introduced the idea of a mastery track where you like level up and like that improves the power of even your starting cards such that even the generic boring starting cards can become g gamewinning cards on their own uh if you have enough mastery. Um so you know we I introduced the you know the idea of like a kind of miniatures uh you know tactical game layered into a deck building game with Ascension Tactics. Um, I try to, you know, push the boundaries and and kind of add to the design conversation over years as I learn from others and, you know, take the building blocks that others hand me, uh, in the work that I do.
In 2011, I believe it was Storm of Souls, you introduced the event zone. Were you trying to that that affected both players simultaneously? Was there something that inspired that or were you trying to solve some some form of design problem you had seen uh, come up earlier? you know, the first three years of story arc and set releases in Ascension were things I had already designed before we even released the first set really.
Um, so the idea of you know, event cards were in the early prototypes, trophy monsters were in the early prototypes, like a ton of stuff that was in the core game that I just thought was really, really cool.
But what I've learned and you know what I knew, I'm grateful I knew even then is like when you're releasing a new game and you're really innovating a lot, you need to clear out everything that gets in the way, right? So the game, initial Ascension game did not need events. It did not need trophies. And so I pulled all of that stuff and saved them for future uh moments and future releases where the story arc of what happened with Samuel, the fallen god, and why he fell and what happened in the aftermath of his defeat and then the sort of redemption and uh choices the players have um that that takes place over the course of all the way through um Darkness Unleashed. uh was was a story arc that I had built and a bunch of mechanics that I had built uh really from from the first, you know, six months of working on the game.
It it seems like it was this game has constantly been evolving. you're constantly adding um new mechanics and I've just recently kind of found Ascension in preparing for this and started playing online and saw all of these different um expansions and I expected just different cards. But it they all of them h all of them had a a really different feel as I went through and played them and but in 15 years there's two things that have really stayed the same, right? It's the five card hand and honor is your way to win. Although the five card hand might be changing, which we'll we'll talk about it. Um, were were those the two things that that were just non-negotiable you weren't really ever going to mess with?
Well, um, so the the core whenever I work I think about making expansions for a game, I think about what is the core tension? Uh, what's at the heart of the game? And I need to make sure that any new expansion mechanics always either intensify that core tension in some and give you a different way to look at it or they provide a counter tension in which I will like relieve the what you what you see as the tension of the game but in exchange I'm giving you another new pain point another new trade-off.
So um when I uh so so it's all about making the center row interesting and why do I make trade-offs with the center row? Um, and so, uh, for example, right, when I have, um, if you look at, uh, the War of Shadows set, uh, there's a night and day mechanic where every card, uh, is either a night card or a day card. And if there's a majority of night cards in the center row, then it's night. And if there's a majority of day cards in the center row, then it's day. And different cards in your deck will be turned on with bonus powers depending on night or day. And so now I'm not only buying cards in the center row based on what do I need for my deck right now, but I'm also might be buying to change what time, you know, whether it's night or day. And so that now creates this new tension in the center row. Uh in contrast, uh Dreamscape where we introduce the idea of the the you know, the Dreamscape set cards that I have set aside um that nobody else can get to that are like I can summon using a new resource called Insight. And that's one of the biggest tensions of Ascension is that like there's a card in the center.
I really want it and somebody else is going to take it before me, right? It's so annoying and you're fighting for it, right? That's the core tension. So, I've now relieved that tension by giving you this bonus cards. But to be able to get the insight resource, which is a resource that's a token that you like, you spend it and it's gone. You have to be able to get those from cards in the center row. And there's a limited number of those things. And so now I'm chasing that new dream quite literally. Uh and uh and so that creates a new tension and moment to to to circle back to your original question about why the five card hand is always there. Um, you know, the whole game is balanced around that core set of resources in uh in the starting deck. In fact, so there's a big jump point, for example, between what power you get from a five cost card versus what you get from a six cost card because it's possible for you to get a five cost card in your opening hand in ascension, right? You can get a five five and and so so the we need every one of those cards needs to be balanced around what if somebody buys this on turn one, does the game survive that? How does that feel? How does it break? You know, does it break? And with six cross cards, I know for sure you can't get it on turn one or turn two.
The the fastest you could possibly get it is turn three. And because every deck building game is an exponential growth curve, um you you you have to be very cautious about any early turn accelerants. They they they they get out they get out of line really fast. So that's why we don't change the five card starting hand because if you want to be able to play you would have to rebalance the whole game and or that that set would no longer be compatible in a way that makes sense with every other set. So we don't want to do that um at a fundamental level as far as honor tokens goes in racing to honor to victory. You know again it just there are plenty of other things that you can like mini quests and other things you can do to kind of help you win. But again, like having some variation of victory points, honor totals, not just the beads, but the cards you purchase, means that no matter what you do in the game, it's always advancing you towards victory some way or another. One of the great strengths of Ascension is that, you know, even though it's a game that really supports high level competitive play, you can play with people of any skill level and you can still have a really good time because I will feel the process of my deck getting better and having exponential growth and I will gain a bunch of points and like move forward along the track and then when the game's over, okay, it's over. Let's count the points and see who wins.
doesn't feel the same as like if I play you in a game of magic and I'm a lot better than you, I'm just going to like raffle stomp you across the board, right? And you're going to like, you know, or or playing someone in a game of chess who's a grandmaster. Like there's no fun to be had there because you're just going to get your you're just going to get completely demolished and your and your options are going to get are going to diminish and you're going to be directly attacked at every turn. And so instead, uh, Ascension is very much a less direct attacking game. Like yes, you're fighting over the same resources in the center row, but for the most part, I get to do what I want to do. you get to do what you want to do. We have very very few cards that let let you interfere with the opponents directly and so it's a much more fun experience that anybody can jump into. I can play with my my partner or my parents or you can play with kids and that all works really well. So all of those things become, you know, kind of opportunities, strengths and constraints for how I think about designing future ascension sets.
So you mentioned balance. It's got to be incredibly difficult and you went into balance on on the Tim Ferris show as well, but it's got to be incredibly difficult as you expand your card base more and more and more taking into account all of the previous cards that you had designed that could possibly be mixed in. Talk a little bit about how you approach that and how you approach balance and is it about achieving balance? Is is that a misnomer?
Yeah, so the the term balance is a misnomer. Um, people think that balance means that every strategy should be equal and every card should be just as good as every other card. And if you made that successfully, you would make the most boring game of all.
Exactly. You can interchange the word with boring.
Yes. It is not that is not actually what people want.
So there are different things that you actually want when you want balance. And and by the way, I learned this from making stupid mistakes on that side. Right. When I first transitioned from becoming a game from a game pro player to being a designer, I started working on the versus system trading card game and I was working with a lot that's a Marvel and DC comics trading card game and I was with a lot of other pro tour players who came into this job and we were working on the Superman set uh and we over nerfed the hell out of it. Everything was very balanced. Nothing was broken and it was very boring. We just we made a mistake and I I I learned that lesson. That's just not how you design games. So um so uh I understand people having that instinct but what I mean what you what balance means is uh a couple things right one uh that there's no single strategy such that if everybody else knows that you're doing that strategy they cannot defeat you right so that there's a there's some counter strategy available um rock paper scissors being an example of a perfectly balanced game right if I know what you're going to do I can always have a strategy to beat you
um it means that the strategies that are superior are that are generally fun strategies, right? So, it's one thing to say that like a giant fire breathing dragon is a little bit overpowered and if I'm able to draw it and play it and kill you, that's like one thing. It's another thing to say like a stasis counter spell strategy where I stop you from playing any cards and deny you resources, right? If that's the best strategy, then that's a much worse game. So, you would balance if you're going to you're going to error one side or another, error on the side of fun.
Mhm.
And um that you want there to be a curve of discovery for players so that when I'm playing a card that might seem a strategy that might seem good to me at first, I can then and maybe even is a good strategy amongst a low skill set player group. then there's opportunities for me to then discover a new strategy that I didn't even see before that now is really cool and now I want to try the next time. And so that discovery curve that lets players evolve and grow and learn as they play is another important part of balance for games that are going to, you know, hold your attention over, you know, again, more than five or 10 games that you're something you're going to want to play for a lifetime. And so it's it's a, you know, no single degenerate strategy that can't be defeated. It's a uh push the fun when possible. It's a steady learning curve of discovery for players at all skill levels. And uh within that uh I would also just add a little bit of humility because honestly you're never going to get it all right. As good as I think I am at this job and my team of you know six people that are working on this. Uh they're not as good as the the tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands out there uh that are going to play it constantly. So I do my best. Um I I air on the side of fun. Uh, but I also recognize that you've got to listen to your community and sometimes you're going to miss and that's okay, too. Uh, so that's kind of how I think about balance.
Well, that's a good segue. I was going to ask, have there been any cards that you've had to put an Arata out on because they did truly break and and there was no counter? I guess that's hard in a game where you're only looking at um a sixc card uh, you know, market and you don't necessarily always have access to all cards. Yeah, I've never had to break I've never had to like, you know, with Ascension that's never been the case. Um, with Soul Force Fusion, I did have to do that. Um, we were we we ended up erratting the rules of there's one card combo that let you like play a giant level three card in level two of the game that was busted and we actually just modified the rules to make it clear you can't play level three cards during level two of the game. Uh, which was the intention anyway. So, it was kind of a, you know, somewhat a way that we got around a problem case. Uh but when it comes to Ascension, so I was lucky. I got to actually fix my mistakes. Um so you know, Ascension when I released it, um you know, it was certainly it was more than good enough. It was nothing that was like so bad that that it was obviously the game was super successful.
Um but when I did the 10th anniversary edition, I tweaked a few cards. Um and most of those were cards that were actually underpowered that needed a little bit of a a boost. Um, in fact, there was a there was a card, Druids of the Stone Circle, uh, which was let you, uh, was a four cost card in Lifebound that let you put a card of cost three or less, a hero of cost three or less on top of your deck from the center row or from the always available pile. Um, and what I that card play new players love that card. They want to buy it all the time. Uh, and it's like they they're super excited. It seems super good. In fact, it's a trap. Uh, and it's kind of not it because it doesn't give you resources normally. it disrupts the resource flow of your hand. So, you're not going to be able to scale up to those five and six cost cards as easily. And so, you kind of get trapped in a situation. And so, what happened is a lot of new players got the card they're excited about and they had to like get beaten over the head learning it's bad.
And so, we ended up making that card better. Uh, now it hits cost four cards cost four or less, which is actually now pretty good. So, now the new player has a can have a good experience with the card they think is really fun to play with. Um, the one of the only cards we actually nerfed uh was Arbiter of the Precipice. Arbiter of the Precipice is a four cost card that was worth one honor that would let you draw two cards and then banish a card from your hand. Now, this card uh as anybody who's played a lot of uh deck building games to this point knows uh banishing cards or getting cards out of your deck is really really powerful because it's a fun a deck building game is a function of not just what good cards do you get, but how often do you draw those good cards and every starting card is presum every card that's worse than your best card gets in the way of your drawing your best card.
So therefore you you know getting rid of cards can be almost as good as getting getting new goods.
I will buy those cards every time I see them.
Exactly.
Sophisticated Yeah. So sophisticated players know that new players hate that. They don't like getting rid of cards. They don't understand that getting rid of cards is a good thing. They like their cards. They want to get more cards. And so um Arbiter the preface at a four cost was very easy to acquire on turn one. if you got it on turn one, the percentage of games Z1 was substantially higher than others. Uh, and so, uh, and also it it overly favored the sharks in the pool instead of the, you know, the new players who wanted to play the game. Uh, also it had a different problem, which is that had one honor, um, because that's how we balanced it. We said most cards that cost four are going to be worth two honor or three honor. This one, because we knew it was good, we made it only worth one honor. But the problem is that that didn't matter at all. If you were buying it on turn one, you didn't care about losing that honor. And what it meant is that a card would actually sit on the board if it's late game and the time to banish doesn't help you. It actually, you know, so the honor matters. So then it would just sit on the board. So it was actually a double whammy. And so what I did was I increased the college cost to five and I increased its honor to three. Uh so now it's actually an efficient buy later, but five for three is a decent deal. And if you buy it, you get lucky enough to buy it early on a five quest hand. That will happen sometimes and you feel good about that, but you're only going to have three three resources on your next turn. So, you're not going to have quite as good a start as was possible before.
So, subtle, right? Not a massive massive change. I don't think I missed I don't think I missed hard. Um, but I did a little bit where I was like over the 10 years I saw that there was an opportunity to improve. I had the opportunity to do that. And so now every future edition of Ascension, I think we're on the fourth edition now, uh, is very uh, well situated for uh, allowing uh, you know, making that making that fix. Have you gotten a lot of player feedback over the years about balance in cards and maybe they're just don't have an understanding of like the full picture? I would imagine there could be really um really easy to get a a perspective on a game like yours where there's so many cards and you're only seeing a sliver of them at a time. Does that tend to happen or or maybe in the early days?
Oh, everybody's got an opinion, my friend. Everybody's got an opinion.
People tell you what cards
Yeah. people will be happy to tell you what cards are wrong, where you got things wrong, where you badly, where something's not balanced, where something's broken. Uh, and you know, uh, great, have that discussion. I love seeing that discussion. Um, the nice thing about having Ascension in the app is that I get to see for sure, right? I get to know which cards are correlated to winning, which cards aren't, which cards are purchases there, and and I and we've done a shockingly good job on this one. So, I I don't have to guess anymore. Uh, I know that our game
You have the data. That's great.
Yeah, I have the data. So that's nice.
Yeah, that has to be a little bit frustrating. I mean, this happens in in all games, especially in early plays, people make these um these kind of like wide sweeping statements around balance on the game, fun on the game, depth of the game, all of that stuff. But, uh especially in a system like yours where it is so incredibly deep with content, um it's it's uh it's almost impossible to actually have a well-rounded perspective on your game. But I guess that's also their perspective is the truth as well and that's got to be kind of a difficult balance when there's so much to explore in your design.
No, that's 100% right. Like player perception is reality, right? Regardless of whether like you know, you know, and I used to not I used to they used to be like, "Oh my god, this thing is totally broken or like this strategy never works." I'm like, "Sit down and play me and I will crush you with that strategy. Like I will show you and and great, but that's I can't do that with everybody, right? that's not a good strategy for selling your game, you know. So, um, so the truth is even if I know, even if I know with certainty, right, through the app, you know, through the play testing and through the app that the game is 100% balanced, but every player thinks it's not balanced and they report that and they don't have a good time, the players are right and I'm wrong, right? Like I I need to have a game that has the perception of a good experience or else the game's going to die. Um, Richard Garfield was on uh he I forget which episode, it might have been the first time I had him on the podcast. He talked about this game uh Spectromancer that he made and it had this the community like really really thought that this one strategy was completely broken and it was complained about it constantly and they again also had the data that the best players never even use that strategy. It's actually terrible. But for a new player because that strategy was easier to use than others and they didn't they weren't sophisticated that strategy was dominant. So if everybody was super new there was one strategy that you could use to crush everybody. But if you were any good at all, that strategy was like a C-tier strategy. And yet that really hurt the game and it actually cost the game, you know, a tier of success it might have otherwise had. And so understanding how your game is going to be perceived by players at different
levels is really important. And and again, the goal is not to have everybody agree that the game is balanced. In fact, like I I love the debates and I love the discussions. Like people complaining about a game and chatting about a game and talking about the cards and like that means they're invested. Like I'd much have rather have players chatting.
That's a problem.
If they're silent, if they're silent, I'm dead. That's what real failure. That's what the real struggle is. So So do not um Yeah, I I I am I'm totally fine with that. I mean, my hope is that people are respectful when we have this conversation. But other than that, I have no problem with people, you know, disagreeing and debating. And I love seeing that feedback. And uh you know it it makes me a better designer again even when I it's it's it's one of the traps as a pro player to only see through see things through the lens of the top you know of a top tier competitive player. In fact I've wrestled with this with Lord of the Rings. Um you know it's still been a debated topic um because with Lord of the Rings it's so important to us to have like deep flavorful experiences to be true to the story. Like everybody on my team is a huge huge fan of Lord of the Rings. I've read the books multiple times, watched the movies god knows how many times, you know, and and and so I want to make sure that we get the story right. And then there's a lot of things that the story might dictate of like having unique starting powers, right? Like having different areas where like I'm Legolos and that's different as a starting deck or starting powers than you would be if you're playing, you know, Aragorn or as Froto or whatever. And uh but having unique starting powers makes the game less balanced. And for a competitive player, it might push them away and like how do we deal with that? And there's a real tension there. Um, and and you know, working in a cooperative mode and building different ways that people can play. Like there's a lot of interesting things where I want to make sure that this game like Magic is a is a big tent and appeals to players of all different sizes. If you come in from and you're just a Lord of the Rings fan and you've
never played Ascension and you don't care about any level of strategic high level competitive play, you just want to feel like you're in the Lord of the Rings, I want this game to appeal to you. If you're a core ascension plan uh Ascension player that's coming in and you know is not necessarily super excited about Lord of the Rings, you just want a great core game experience like you'd expect, then I want to be able to deliver that also. And and there's a constant tension there.
We're going to pivot to Lord of the Rings in just a second. I want to get back to criticism and a recent criticism I heard on Ascension was that my hand is obvious on how I should play it. I then I started playing Ascension. I started playing with all these different um your expansions all on the app and I thought that that was couldn't be further from the truth. And this is a recent interview I did with another another content creator. I always had to pay attention to order of operations as I was playing those cards. I don't have any great um examples off the top of my head. But have you heard that and do you agree with it maybe on an early versions with no expansions? Um I just that hasn't been my experience and I think I have 20 games. Yeah, I I do not uh yeah, that doesn't resonate with me. I mean, I think like the the interesting choices and tension as you play with every choice every turn where you have to decide how do I spend the resources available to me, that's the heart of the game. And if I have not delivered on that, then then I've messed up, you know, and again, not every turn is going to be easy. You know, some turns are going to be like, all right, well, I only have I only have two choices make,
especially the starting cards.
Yeah. And and and and the game those games are supposed to ramp up, right? that it's intentional like and it's a great it's a feature not a bug that like my first choices are going to be more limited and then things get more crazy and more you know more challenging as the game goes on. Um but uh I would I would contend that most people who would make a claim like there's not interesting choices to make with your with your hand in this game are not uh are not looking closely enough or they're they're just kind of and you could play it that way too, right? You could just play like I believe one of the reason ascension is so successful. Yeah, exactly. I believe one of the reasons ascension is so successful as a as a phone app is because it's like you can play it, you know, almost ritualistically and meditatively. Like you could just kind of play and pick some cards and just play and kind of see what happens. Especially if you use like if you do the play all uh option where you're like playing all the different sets together and it's just kind of crazy and wacky and like you know uh I think I think that's a fine experience too. But if you but but for high level strategy there's plenty of it uh to chew on as you play.
Yeah. I mean, I think I think the core interest in Dominion is picking out those cards, right? And and and that that I think is the core uh like contribution that has held true across all deck building games since Dominion is it is super fun. And if you don't find it fun to grab new cards, it's probably not going to be the game for you. But I did notice that it was important in order of operations in a lot of cases on how I played my cards. Is that a a distinction of ascension? Is that something you were you were trying to design around as you added new cards because it did matter in some instances?
Yeah, I don't I I think the order of operations for playing your cards is something I don't try to make a central focal point. Um I think it's sometimes it's interesting, sometimes it's annoying to me, right? So like um for example the unite power in ascension uh if you play another lifebound card uh it triggers right and we designed that such that it works forward looking and backwards looking right so I play theite card first and then I play one later and we did that on purpose to reduce the tension on order of operations um so that you don't have to like worry as much uh about that and so I think it's sometimes there are mechanics that it's either too annoying or too uh too much cognitive overload to have to remember throughout the turn. So, we make it matter right when you play it, resolve it and move forward and then order of operations matters.
Sometimes there's mechanics where it is uh it's just important that uh that they get played in a certain order. But for the most part, I actually don't try to emphasize order of operations as the critical thing. Now, which card you buy in the center row and whether how that impacts your turn because I did make it so that you know whenever you buy a card from the center row, a new card flips up immediately to replace it. Now, that was a design choice because I think it's more exciting and it changes the nature of your turn. And so that order of operations, okay, do I want to buy a card first? One of my favorite memories I have I had, this is with early on in ascension. I had eight resources, eight runes to buy stuff with. And master Dartha is in the center row, which is a draw three card, seven cost cards. Great card. And uh I had a uh I didn't have any power. I just had eight resources, but there was also one cost card that I kind of wanted that didn't matter that much. Uh but I'm like, yeah, you know what? I'll be smart.
I'll buy the one cost card so that I could see if maybe a better seven comes up. Well, I had just added in the new promo card, the rat king, uh where when the rat king shows up, it covers the entire board in rats and the the the monsters on top of every card on the board.
Yeah.
And that means and and so I bought the rat king. I was like, "Oh, cool." I bought I bought the one cost card. The rat king shows up. I'm like, "Oh, cool. New promo card." And then it filled the board with rats and that meant the seven cost master that was covered with a rat. So, I couldn't buy it anymore. My seven runes were completely wasted. And then I was like, "No." And so, it created this really high drama moment, right? Which didn't work out for me as a player, but as a designer, I'm like, "Ah, beautiful. This is this is great."
Operations does matter in that sense.
Yeah. No, I do that all the time. I often find um that, you know, I I need to defeat monsters and there's none there. So, I'm like, "Okay, what cheap card can I go buy first to see if one will will drop into the row?" So yeah, I've absolutely seen that and uh and use that all the time just to see what else is there. Or if there's I have a bunch of coins and there's nothing that or a bunch of um currency, whatever it's called, uh and there's a bunch of uh and there's no cards that I necessarily want, getting a cheap one out of there just to see what will drop in is an absolute strategy for sure.
Um let's pivot now to Lord of the Rings. I reached out to Alex of um Game Found Co. the moment I saw this u Lord of the Rings IP is obviously everywhere but it's so incredible and it's and it's everywhere for a reason in board games and it and it struck me uh to ask you how difficult was it first off to get that IP for Ascension and it really triggered when I was listening to your story about pitching was it the World of Warcraft game
uh and and were there any parallels to that story. That was another inspirational story that maybe you can revisit here if it's uh relevant.
Yeah. Yeah. Happy to talk about that. Um I'll start with Lord of the Rings. Um so uh this was this is very different than the way the World of Warcraft story worked out. So what happened is um you know I've been working on I've been working on Ascension for you know a long time
and uh I do things to keep myself interested right. I just kind of design stuff. So, I, you know, I designed pirate sets that were a huge departure from standard ascension. I've designed all kinds of different cool things that are like fun for me. And so, I just kind of on my own was like, you know, what would it, wouldn't it be cool to do a Lord of the Rings ascension set? And so, I just started designing it for fun. And I was like, worst case scenario, you know, I can reskin it, right? I'll do like Lord of the Rings mechanics, but I could just put it in the world of Ascension and Vigil and figure it out. And so, I designed it and I started playing it with the team and people really loved it. And it had this core mechanic of corruption and fighting over the ring and like all this stuff. And it was like, you know, again, after a couple months of like, hey, this is really fun. There's something here. And so I just then decided to post on social media and say, hey, who has the Lord of the Rings license and how would I get it?
Really? That's your opening move. Okay.
That was my opening move. And you know, fortunately, I've, you know, again, I've been in the industry a long time. I've got a lot of very well-connected friends. So they were like they connected me to the right person to talk to. So I I mentioned the idea. They seemed excited about it that year. So that was like January of uh 24 25. Uh and then uh I pitched it to Yeah. January 25. And then I I was able to finally get a chance to pitch the game uh at Gen Con in real life. And it was like a full, you know, full scale pitch. I had a really nice prototype. had everything ready to go. Got them super excited about it. It took months and months and months of negotiating and contract stuff and everything because it's a big it's a big property and working with Asbetay and working with Middle Enterprises and so the process took forever. Uh but it was never,
you know, it didn't feel like it was in doubt at any point like they I had a great game. I had a good connection to get to them. They loved what I made. It just took a long time to do and so we just kept working and it gave me all more time to work on the game and continue to refine the game and get it to where it is today. Uh we're continuing to work on it today and build out all of the remaining thing because we decided to be very ambitious uh with this crowdund. We're not making one, not two, but three entire games
all in one crowd fund,
which is terrifying and exciting at the same time. I must admit
it is. It is. Well, it's really it's actually really cool because I, you know, in Ascensious history typically speaking, we build sets in blocks. usually two sets that are really designed to play well together, but we pretty much complete the entirety of the first one and then make the second one like within the constraints of the first one with like, you know, some idea what I want to do. But for the most part, they're just separate projects. But this time they're all working together. So I did make, you know, the Fellowship of the Ring game first, but then it was like once we decided we're going to do them all, we started working on two and three immediately and then those like backwards informed. So we made some changes to the fellowship based on some stuff that you won't won't make sense until you play the two towers and then when the fellowship when Return of the King happens like everything comes together. So it's actually created these really beautiful synergy moments and opportunities uh where there's sort of through lines of mechanics where you'll you know all the sets obviously are designed to play together. They all bring something new to the table. They all shed a different light on what was happening previously. Uh so it's actually I I think it may be our best set of ascension sets ever. certainly the ones that are most uh well situated to play together and evolve together.
So that is the proper order of play individually and then put together.
That's what I would recommend. Yes.
And these are totally separate standalone. They don't work with any of the other ascension cards because of the new mechanics.
That's not true at all actually. Um, so they are every set is standalone and we did change the faction names to better correlate to Lord of the Rings. So there's uh, you know, the McKenna or the dwarves, the lifeg of the elves, the enlightened of the hobbits, and the void or the humans.
However, your everything mechanically fully functions with every other ascension set. So if you want to shuffle them together, you just know need to know and and the frames look identical. So the human frames look identical to the void frames. So you just need to know the human means void and void meana and you know and so then everything works 100% together. So we did design them to be cross-co compatible but we wanted to make sure that our number one priority was that the story and the flavor and the world of the Lord of the Rings uh comes forward. So so we made those changes to to make that reflective.
Did that take a lot of kind of negotiation and back and forth with the uh license holder? Was there or that you're kind of on your own to do all of this?
Well the license holder cares a lot that you're doing this right. Um, and but they trust us to do the game, right? Right. So, so we this was a game design decision. We made it. They supported it. Um, we never had an issue there. It's I mean, the team both at Asthma and at Middleear Enterprises are great. Uh, they really care about the quality of the product. Um, the review cycles do take a very long time. Uh, this game's going to it's going to take us a lot longer to make than any Ascension game we've ever made. uh it already has and it will it's going to take it's easily going to be at least twice as long of a development cycle because of the review cycle process. Uh but it's you know we're leading to a great project. Um and so far you know we've been very aligned on everything with the vision of the game and they were very impressed with what they saw from the initial game design and the vision for it. I've been really happy with all of their feedback.
They gave us some really good feedback on how we're doing our collector's edition, what we're calling the saga collection. It's like uh originally I was going to do like a kind of treasure chesty type thing, but they had this idea of doing it like a like a bookshelf bookcase idea. So each of the games in the collector's edition will be like a leather bound book that you pull from the case and open up and it's got the game inside and the full case holds them all and has like images from the Lord of the Rings. It's so freaking cool.
I'm a sucker for deluxification and cool ways to store it and cool boxes. Stop it. I told you I don't have a job.
Yeah. Well, you got a few months. We're not launching till July, so you got some time. Uh but yeah, it's it's and that was an idea that came from uh from the lensureer and I thought it was so amazing and we ran with it. So So everybody's helping make the project better.
So let's talk about the actual new mechanics. Maybe we start with the corruption track. That seems one of the most interesting ideas to me. this push and pull between good and bad and it can both be good and bad. So, you know what's what's this new mechanic?
Yeah. So, so at the heart of the Lord of the Ring story, right, is this idea of of corruption and temptation, right? The ring itself offers you power in exchange for this corruption and that's going to pull you uh onto its side. And so and then and does does the the the friendship and the fellowship and the the the goodwill of the of of the you know the heroes survive um this this this one doom. And so the way we chose to represent that um as you're showing the one ring on the thing right the one ring is a is a indestructible construct that exists in the game. It does not show up uh until you reach a certain point in the corruption track. So, the corruption track, all players start at zero corruption. Um, and the track goes up to 15 corruption at the top. Uh, there are a variety of effects uh that will cause you to gain corruption. And a variety of effects will give you the option to go either way. Um, so right now, like there's a Froto card that starts in everybody's starting deck uh that allows you to gain or gain or lose corruption um using the ring bearer mechanic. There you go. Uh and so you have a choice. Do I want to gain corruption or not? And why would I gain corruption? You could see on Frotos, he actually has corruption thresholds that give you more power the more corrupt you are. I love this. And there are a variety of cards that work this way, right? So, you literally get power by via corruption. So, there's plenty of reasons to gain gain uh gain corruption throughout the game.
Uh and there are uh the Eye of Sauron event cards that show up from the deck uh that show up and cause you to gain corruption or do nasty things to you if you're already too corrupt. Uh, and so there's this constant tension throughout the game. And then at the end of the game, at the you, uh, depending upon where you end on the corruption track, uh, Sauron takes some of your honor. And so if you're at, you know, low corruption, he might just take a little bit. But if you're all the way at 15 at the full corruption, Sauron takes all of your honor. And Sauron can actually win the game. So like the players might the players are too corrupt. So you compare your honor totals to Sauron's total. Uh, and so if he has more honor than the players, then Sauron wins and the the heroes lose. Uh, and so version or there's just a little bit of a semi co-op in that instance.
So there is both there's that and there is also a full co-op and solo mode that we have developed for this game. Um, and so we we are uh this is actually, you know, because I think Lord of the Rings as a story, even though Ascension is at its core a competitive game that tells a cooperative story, right? Like Ascension, we're all even in fully competitive normal ascension, right? We're all attacking monsters together. We're all recruiting heroes and trying to gain honor. It's all like a positive story of us working towards the same goal. The winner of Ascension is whoever is like doing the best job of beating the bad guys, not like beating the other players. That being said, we really wanted a much more full, visceral, cooperative experience to exist in Ascension. So, there's an entire other game mode where you all get to play together to uh to to try to defeat Sauron. Uh, one of you plays as Frodo.
Uh, there's an event deck that a separate a separate villain deck that in between the player turns flips over the nasty things that happen. A lot of them add corruption to Frodo. If Froto ever gets to the top of the corruption track, all the players lose. So, that's your main thing you're trying to avoid. uh as you kind of move through and there are people specific
going into the Froto track.
How does that work?
The the corruption track every so every player takes on an identity in the game. You can pick any of the any of the fellowship
in the cooperative mode. In the cooperative mode, one of you has to play as Frodo.
Uh and then the rest of you can play as whoever you want. And then you're all given specific quest goals to complete
and the the villain deck and you actually have a shared turn. So instead of taking individual turns, you share a turn. You're buying cards from the center row at the same time. You're able to kind of collaborate and talk about what you want to do. Um and then the villain takes a turn and the villain does nasty things to the players, uh including adding more corruption. And your goal, you have to complete a certain number of your quests before Froto gets to max corruption. And that's representing your completing the the journey and uh destroying the one ring uh before it's too late.
I wonder if that's going to be the preferred way to play just with with the the theme of the game. Like how are you thinking about about
Yeah,
that design
and I don't know and I don't know the answer to that question. You know, obviously I do think a lot of people will play that way and I think for Lord of the Rings fans coming into the game, I do think that will be a preferred way to play because it's not as you know aggressive. It's more telling that same story together. Um the challenge is that obviously there's a little bit more uh a cognitive overload that because you have to learn how to play Ascension and you have to learn the cooperative stuff. So it's a little bit more it's a little bit more complicated. Not a lot more complicated. And honestly that's the thing my team has been working on. In fact, I'm going to be testing again right after this. Right. We're constantly looking like the core of the game is fun. We know how it's going to work. It it's there. But we're constantly looking at ways to like how do we streamline this? How do we make this more accessible? Um, but because I do think it's going to be a very common way to play and might be the preferred way to play.
So the everyone starts with this Froto card
or is every but everyone also has separately an identity
that's not necessarily is there as identity?
So in the cooperative mode there is asymmetry in people's roles and that's as I was talking about earlier. actually still debating how much asymmetry we want to introduce in the competitive go game. Do we want to keep that more pure and your your kind of separate identity is just cosmetic or do we want to add more mechanical variation? Um so there will be mechanical variation the co-op mode because different starting positions in a co-op game is perfectly acceptable and you're all working on the same team. Uh, but in a competitive game, if you do introduce that, you're intrinsically going to make them, you know, very, very, very hard to balance asymmetric starting positions. One, and two, I really don't like when a mechanic and a new starting position railroads you into a very a more limited play pattern, right? So, for example, Ascension: Dawn of Champions, um, a lot of people love it. Uh, it's a you start with a champion in play. It gives you certain bonuses whenever you buy cards of a specific faction and unlocks new powers and cards for you. But what I found is when I play with I it's my least favorite one to play with after a dozen games or so because when I play with a certain champion, it just tells me I need to buy cards of that faction.
So it limits the number of like realistic choices that I have in the game. So it's not as replayable. That's what I call railroading. Um I have to stay sort of on the tracks of my character. Um, so I I'm I'm still wrestling with how much of that I want to do. I have some ideas. We're testing a bunch of different ideas. Uh, but there will be unique powers for the cooperative mode. Um, and there may be unique starting positions and starting powers for the competitive mode. U, but I haven't made a final decision on that yet.
I love asymmetry and I really I I actually enjoy the opposite of what you said. I like to be railroaded into a specific play style because a lot of times it gives me and maybe not necessarily in ascension, but in other games it gives me a puzzle to solve. It gives me it gives me a push towards some levers that I need to pull and try to figure out how to get the most victory points out of somebody else. The other benefit that I see is sometimes with new players, it helps them focus. When you have a game with so many different things going on, sometimes it's hard for a new player to kind of focus in on like what do I do? espe your first turn in ascension like what card am I buying like I don't know especially if they're if they're new to the game um but then you know asymmetry can be an arbiter of complexity and and do the exact opposite to a new player so I get that there needs
yeah there's upsides and downsides there's a lot yeah it's not an easy it's not an easy question and I do think there's a lot of value to it um my my instinct right now is that I want to add it but I want to do it in ways that are um you know I don't want to just uh walk into the trap sometimes I want to have my cake and eat it too. For example, um in Shards of Infinity, uh in the first release, we did not have asymmetric powers, and I realized that because the way the game was released, we had these giant character cards that represented your health and your mastery. It really felt like you should have unique powers. And I decided to add them in the expansion. And when I did, I created what's called the relics of the future. And the way the relics work is as you, you know, I've already mentioned mastery is kind of like your level in the game. and you could like slowly increase it and increases the power level of all your cards. When you get to level 10 and to mastery level 10, you get to unlock your relic cards and every player had two relic cards that were very different divergent strategies. And by the time you're getting to 10 mastery, you're kind of somewhat already into the game.
And now you get to pick which of these two strategies, uh, these two really powerful cards most syncs with the strategy that you chose to adopt. And then that gives you new powers. Plus, there were cards in the center row you could acquire that were unique to you. And so that was a way I was really excited about to make every character feel unique to give you some direction saying, "Okay, well cool. I know I've got this card in my deck, so I'm going to build towards that, but not to force you down a single path." And so in my best case scenario, I will come up with a version, a vision of something like that for ascension that let you feel the unique powers that gives you advantages of like, okay, this gives me some sense of how I should play, but doesn't force me down one single path. One of the things that I'm most interested in, we and I foreshadowed this is in your five card rule. This is the this is breaking it with the one ring. How has testing been around balance with this ring? Are people constantly grabbing this thing back and forth? Like what's what's been the the the themes that you've seen so far?
Great question. So, there's two answers to this, right? is you are exactly right. And we found that the one ring did break the game when I could acquire it on turn one because it got me to six resources quickly. Lets me draw an extra card and it broke the game. So what we did was we actually have there's a spot on the corruption track uh that the ring is hidden until a player gets to three corruption. And as soon as any player gets to three corruption, whoever the active player is takes the one ring and now it's in play. and now anyone can grab it. And so we actually built a moment, a storybased moment, right, where the ring is found.
Uh, and use that as a way to solve a mechanical problem, which was the ring showing up too early is too good. Uh, and so that happened. Now, so that's that was a way we solved that problem. Now, when it comes to the fighting for the ring, this has been really interesting and has been great. uh playing with a lot of diverse play groups amongst my competitive sophisticated play groups. They know that getting extra cards is super powerful and so getting an extra card every turn with the ring is really really powerful and there's a bunch of extra bonuses you get for being kind of corrupt. So it's often worth it for you to like push the corruption level a little bit.
Yeah. What's the card that's in your rule book that gives you a bonus? Is it the smith?
There's a variety of different cards that give you bonuses. Um yeah, the Arabore smith here, right, gives you gains power uh when you buy a mechanic con or you buy any construct from the center row if you've got enough corruption. Uh there's a lot of dwarven corruption effects, right, because they delve too deeply and they have a lot of their things that can turn on. Um and so um there's a uh so there's a lot of things that that can tempt you and push you into gaining corruption, but there are many players for whom they want to be the pure honest, you know, fellowship character. Uh, and so we have certain cards that allow you to reduce your corruption and give you benefits of being at low corruption and finding the balance point where the each of those players and each of those play styles is valid and that you can choose to be someone who's going to go corrupt for a little while and then find a way to get yourself lower corruption later or get enough honor points that it's okay that you're giving some honor to Sauron or a player who's going to try to remain pure and stay at the low end and have some bonuses and get some bonuses that way.
um and and then the kind of different effects and cards that will push you in one way or another. That's where we play with this core tension of the of the corruption track and and the temptation of the ring. And that's really the heart of of Ascension the Lord of the Rings, especially the Fellowship of the Rings set.
That that is outside of the IP. This corruption mechanic is what got me really interested. I love this idea of pushpull of this this I don't know pushing a track to get something that benefits you but if you hold on to it too long it might screw you at the end the full pure-hearted person might be running behind but it might make up at the end when Sauron takes those points like I love that that push and pull is that hard to balance in this game when you're actually designing it making them all viable is yes it is. Yeah, it's challenging but you know yes it's very challenging to get it right. Uh we've spent a lot of time on it. Um you know this is where my 15 years of doing this really helps uh at balancing ascension sets and we have the team iterating and in fact we're even going to let players play test this as well if they want to. Uh we'll post a version on tabletop simulator when the campaign's live. Um you know we'll still have opportunities for people to give us feedback and make some final tweaks and changes before we actually go to print.
Um, so this is actually one of the benefits of having a a big player base and uh excite, you know, letting other people kind of weigh in and uh contribute to the game. Uh, but I actually think we've done a pretty good job. I think Fellowship is very close to to like fully done done. Like the balance is very good. It's it's there. Uh, Two Towers and Return of the King, the core design, the core mechanics are good, but the balance uh still needs a lot of work. There's still a good amount of like, you know, final tweaks to be done. Are there big mechanics that haven't been revealed yet that I didn't see in the in the rule book for these other two sets?
Absolutely. And sadly, I will not reveal them on this interview either.
Are they are they meant to be a surprise or they're just going to be revealed during the campaign?
Yeah, we're going to reveal them slowly on the ramp up to the campaign. Uh, and then um because they're, you know, so the I will say I'll say so that the you know, the corruption mechanic carries through all the sets. That's still at the heart of the whole experience. Um each one of those sets layers on something new and uh another way to tell great stories in the world um that both influences and interacts directly with the corruption mechanic um as well as provides some counter tensions. Right? Exactly as I I I've I've revealed to you how I think about these things earlier with ascension expansions. I think about it the exact same way uh with the Lord of the Rings. Like each one will stand alone and be strong on its own. Each one will reveal a new aspect of corruption and a new way for you to think about it. Uh, and it will all play well together uh, in a uh, a glorious full box set that you could have on your shelf very soon.
What's your favorite set? You have to pick one.
That's not fair, man. That's not fair. It's like, who is your favorite child? You have to pick one.
Oh, yeah. There's one. But it changes all the time.
Yeah.
Uh, that's a good answer. That's a good answer. Uh yeah, I like a lot of the sets. I think the one that stuck with me that's the most fun um is Rides of Vigil. I really like um it introduced the treasure mechanic and the energy mechanic uh where you could uh created some really powerful V uh wheel spins of what could possibly happen. Um because you could end up with a card that had a bunch of treasure stacked underneath it. Uh again, it changed the way you think about the center row because I might want to buy a card just because it gives me a lot of treasure. uh even if it's not the best card for me, the fact that uh each treasure that you played generated energy for you and some cards could get like superpowered crazy effects if you got enough energy. It let me do like a lot more powerful like very rare harder to achieve things than just cuz previously I pretty much had to restrict everything on cost in the center row, right? Which there's only so much room to play. Like once you get to seven cost, eight cost like it starts to become like useless or it sticks in the row for too long. But by having cars that could have potentially a low cost but a high energy threshold, they could do something small, but if you get to the right moment, you could build up to something big, that was really cool, really fun to design for, and still is really fun to play to this day.
Well, I wasn't actually asking about overall. It was Lord of the Rings, but that's good to know. I'm going to go play that right after this.
What's the favorite Lord of the Rings set? No, I let you keep going because I'm I'm new to the game and I'm actually really enjoying it. So, uh, you know, it's hard. It's hard when you first get into it, like especially in the app where I have, you know, all these different things. It's like, what do I play with? So, I'm gonna go check that out.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's not It's not fair. Yeah. The Lord of the Rings one, I can't I can't I can't have a favorite yet because they're not all done. Um I think that the core of the corruption mechanic is like 100% like I love it. And Fellowship of the Ring plays like super well. I already just want to keep playing it. I have to force myself to not to play other versions of the game because it's more important to test those now than it is to play this one. Like it's it's it's really fun and I really love it. Uh and I'm confident the other the the core mechanics of to two towers in Return of the King are great also, but the games are not as like fully polished yet.
Yeah, corruption seems to be the the the driver of of everything. Is was your idea for this pushpull mechanic? Did that come first or did it come out of you trying to adapt it for Lord of the Rings?
Well, it I started again as I mentioned I started coming up with the idea of my start point was what if I were designing a Lord of the Rings essential game. Uh that was how I kind of got into
But you never had this pushpull idea kind of sitting back there wanting to get
No, I I can't No, I came up with that idea from from the the Lord of the Rings theme. How would I represent this? what should it be? And then I had just done the last Ascension set was Ascension Legends, which had tracks on it. It had tracks that you moved up uh on the legendary track. So every time you bought a card of a certain faction, you moved up the legendary track of that faction at certain tiers, it would give you boons and benefits the higher up that track you were. That was a really cool mechanic and had a lot of fun, but there was no going back. Like it was only go up, you know, number go up. Uh, and so I think that certainly also informed my idea here. I had I had had this idea of a follow on to Ascension Legends, which I'm sure will still come to life at some point, of like a Ascension villains to pair with Legends, and that there was some kind of like monster villain track. Uh, and so I think some of that inspired this, but the idea of like it was really a thematic first uh, question, and so the idea of moving up and down a corruption track felt like a perfect fit. The reason I ask is I I've been talking about this with a lot of the designers I've I've been interviewing and recently I interviewed Danny Garcia. He's done Barcelona recently coming of age and voinage puzzle and he started his career starting with a mechanic and now he's starting with theme and using that as kind of like a guide in his design. Have you historically started with mechanic or started with a theme and trying to adapt?
Yeah. Uh I am a mechanics first designer at my core. um that's always where I kind of have lived and over time I have intentionally as I did in this case challenged myself to start with theme and design theme first and uh because I think there's value to both and there's it's a it's a you know complimentary kind of seessaw in many ways right like I'll start with some mechanics and then I'll have a theme idea that'll layer on it and then the theme will suggest some new mechanics and that'll push a certain way and then a new idea for mechanic will adjust a suggest a change to the theme and so there there's always back and forth But like my my default is I'm I'm a mechanics first designer over the last decade or so I have consistently pushed myself to start like you know with Ascension the Pirates sets were very much theme forward. This Lord of the Rings set very much theme forward.
Obviously when I'm working with major brands like Gundam and and Lord of the Rings and others it has to be theme forward.
So
there's a lot of uh a lot of both but but if I have to pick one uh I'll default to mechanics more often.
You mentioned Legend. So, I'm really enjoying Ascension right now. Do I need to go get legends? What is that? Just as a as a personal uh as a a selfish tangent real quick, why why do I need to go get legends if I'm enjoying the app right now?
Well, I think Ascension Legends is really I I had a lot of fun with it. Again, it's it does the same core thing if it changes the way you think about the game and the cards you purchase based on what is moving on the you know, on the legendary track. Um, and so which boons are available to you, how you move on the track, where your opponent is on the track, and how you might want to prevent them from getting there. Because if you get every on three, six, and nine, you get a special boon for whichever legend is at the top of the track. But if you make it all the way to 12, you become a legend yourself. And now you get to acquire or defeat one card of that faction for free once per turn, which is
incredibly powerful and cool. And the game will end pretty soon after that. And so there's these like really cool, intrinsically aspirational things to do. Um, you'll notice in legends that that different cards have the threshold mechanic uh that like if I'm at six or more on the lifebound legendary track, I get a bonus with this card, which you you can see where that inspires the idea of a corruption track. So, you you you know that playing legends, if you if you're really excited about the corruption track in Lord of the Rings, playing Ascension Legends will give you an early taste of kind of where the origin stories of that are. Yeah, because it it is um it's making me sad doing all of these interviews with about games that are coming in the future. I get all excited about them. I was just I love Rolling Deep. I was just playing it on TTS and and was gushing about it yesterday, but then I just got sad. I was like, "Oh, I want to see all of the unlockable stuff. I want to keep going on on all of this." So, at least Legends can give me an early taste of that corruption track. I like that.
Yeah. Yeah. And we'll be, you know, if you follow the campaign, we'll be putting more stuff out there. We will have a tabletop simulator playable version of the game. You know, the campaign is what we're like less than two months away now. So, coming soon.
Yep. And let's see. So, beyond the Lord of the Rings campaign, I know this is a huge project for you. Is there anything else that Stone Blade's working on currently that you can talk about?
Yeah, we have another uh deck building game that I'm really excited about called Grassfed. It's a farmtotabletop game. Uh it is also on Gamefound uh and it will be releasing it. will be fun uh uh we'll be launching that this fall uh in harvest season. Um and we actually the story behind this one's phenomenal. I actually partnered with a real regenerative farmer who has a farm to tabletop restaurant in the greater Seattle area and has a chicken uh you know organic chicken farm in Seattle out there.
No, I'm not in Seattle. I'm nomadic.
Oh, yeah. Yeah, I'm nomatic. here. Grant Jones is is there and he's the one that he came he he approached me about this idea and I did come to Seattle and I met with him and I ate at his restaurant and I you know saw the farm and I saw his game and I loved the idea and it actually teaches you the principles of regenerative farming. You start with a basic typical American farm with corn and chemical fertilizer and you're able to evolve it through purchasing cards out of a center deck like an ascension uh to turn into something that has sustainable freerange animals and uh rotating crop growth and and the you win the game actually by increasing the soil health on your farms. Not just by like earning money and you know surviving but you find a way to create a sustainable economic farm that improves the soil health. And so it teaches these real principles. a portion of proceeds are going to uh support these causes and to actually help save the planet. Uh the game is super fun and brings some new innovations to the to the deck building space. Uh you actually have simultaneous turns. Uh you earn money as a persistent resource. Uh this this idea of soil health and and and you're restricted not by any playing card resources, but but by the number of farmlands you have, and you're only able to play one of each card type on each farmland. Uh so there's a lot of really cool stuff. The game is super fun. I I love the idea of being able to take what I do best and use it to help the planet and help teach people. Uh it's nice to take a break from, you know, wizards and warriors every now and then. Um so I think it's going to be a great game.
Odd realworld themes for whatever reason. I just I think they're so fascinating when people can uh take something that you would never think of making a game about and somehow, you know, put mechanics together that that help you kind of like I don't know uh put yourself in those shoes for at least for, you know, 30 minutes to an hour. Uh that's awesome.
Yeah. Yeah. It's really fun. And again, it's just one of those projects that I'm I'm super proud of already. I'm excited to get it into people's hands. It's new. I don't expect it to be as big as Lord of the Rings, of course, but I do think it's going to appeal to a lot of people that are not, you know, maybe wouldn't pick up a game like Lord of the Rings or wouldn't pick up a, you know, a Sword and Sorcery kind of thing because it's very accessible for families and it's educational and, you know, I so I'm excited about that project as well. Um, and then I also hinted at this was not a Stone Blade project, but it's a project I designed. Uh, that's the Gundam Assemble uh miniatures game. Uh, you know, tactical miniatures game that's going to be coming out in October. uh is another pretty massive uh game that I'm very excited about.
Very cool. And where do you want people to go after this?
Well, if you're interested in the Lord of the Rings Ascension, go to gamefound. Uh you can search for Ascension or Lord of the Rings. You'll find uh you
Yep. There'll be a link for that. If you
Great. Yeah. I mean, if you want to find out more about the stuff that I'm doing for, you know, teaching game design, um you can go to uh justgary.com or my Substack uh justsubstack.com. I post articles and podcasts every week. Um, I help teach and you know I have a a design lab course. You can actually learn directly with me uh in a discord with me and other designers working on your projects. Um, the links will all be available from the stuff I've already mentioned. Um, stoneblade.com has all the Stoneblade stuff. Um, yeah, I've I try to be uh as accessible as possible and uh you know, very excited about the many cool projects we're working on and I'm really excited and passionate about, you know, obviously talking about games as you could tell from this, you know, multi-hour conversation, but also helping other people to, you know, live creative fulfilling lives. Um, you know, it's been a mission of mine now for the last decade. Um, and I've been able to hire a lot of people for my game design course. I've been able to watch them succeed in their crowdfunds and get jobs in the industry. Um, so honestly for me now, uh, that's kind of as rewarding as as even my own project success.
Beautiful. Justin, this has been an honor to be able to interview you here. An absolute board game legend, card game legend. This is uh, this has been pretty cool. Pretty cool. So, thanks for giving a small channel like me a chance.
Oh, it's been my pleasure. Really enjoyed the conversation and hope we get a chance to do it again sometime soon.
Wonderful. Good luck with everything.
Thanks, man. Cheers.