Deep Regrets - TCbH Review
Transcript
From Moby Dick to Deegon to the fog, the mystery and utter terror of the ocean has loomed heavily in humanity's collective consciousness. And while over here in board game land we've had our share of pirates and peers and particularly grotesque merr people, wasn't until deep regrets that a game truly honed in on the abyssal horror and utter madness of trolling the ocean. Most rounds you spend beautifully buoys shaped dice to press deeper into the ocean and catch fish of natural or more foul inclination to eventually sell at port where you can instead spend a round purchasing gear extra dice for more actions at sea or even permanently mount your prize to catches for point multipliers at the end of the game six rounds where the value of fish held in hand mounted and unspent fish bucks are calculated to determine the winner. The brilliant fulcrum in which the game's thematic and mechanical conceit rests is regret. A deck of cards that is drawn through a variety of effects, but always upon selling the more foul fishes of the ocean. While the cards have values important to determine who has the most regret at the end of the game. More on that in a bit. It's actually the number of cards that you hold that situates you on the spectrum of sanity versus madness, which importantly impacts the maximum dice available to you and the
sale value of fish, both fair, i.e. real world, though still often upsetting sea creatures or fowl, the horrifying beasts of the deep you also find in the shores. Because of the general ongoing acrruel of regret, the game naturally encourages you to sink further into madness without much during game penalty with the affforementioned end result to be ditching one of your three mounted trophies. the point multiplier system, both clever and grotesque, for having the most at the end of the game, which is not insignificant, but overall just means that you got to keep a speculative eye out for making sure that you don't end up with the most total value when the game ends. And it's too bad that the game doesn't offer a viable path or incentive for exploring alternatives like a full sanity victory. But as it stands, the system is mechanically interesting and deeply thematic, which is really where Deep Regrets floats. An incredibly strong and evocative theme reinforced by absolutely disgusting yet gorgeous artwork and character designs.
Though, as a game, it's more fun than it is strategic. Sure, there are levers to pull, decisions to be made, but most turns you'll declare, "I'm fishing here." And either you can pay for the strength of your catch or get a consolation dink and leave it revealed for someone else to attempt before the end of the round. And with the scant six rounds and making port using up that full round unless you rely on your one-time use lifeboat to return to port mid round at heavy endgame risk. There's not really enough time or opportunity to get into a loop in the game. And as someone who craves strategic efficiency, I found myself wishing that making port was an action with empowerment and opportunity costs to account for on a smaller level rather than sacrificing the full rounds fishing fun of the game.
But that's not really what Deep Regrets is going for either. At its heart, it's a push your luck game where players spend time for a little bit of preparation, decide how best to spend their clams, and make wise choices about what they're likely to catch based on the depth of the ocean and the smartly foreshadowed small, medium, or large fish on deck. Flirting with madness at the fins of some particular unpleasantries that you may or may not regret. One strange turn that I didn't expect to love as much as I do is the solo mode where you're doing a survey to identify and catalog all of the oceans fair and less wholesome denisens. It's a campaign mode that fully scraps the madness track and instead you're just tasked with finding and cashing out fish without throwing them overboard due to madness. You journal your entries, purchase equipment upgrades, the same gear that you'd get through blind though mitigatable draws from three categories in the multiplayer game to eventually take stock of the whole ocean. It's cozy in so far as anything in this game can be described as cozy. Yeah, it really is. Contrary to its moniker, the game is neither particularly deep nor something that I regret. It's sardonic and fun, upsetting and enjoyable with enough gameplay hooks to keep me feeling invested. Even if fate's cold touch pervades every fathom of this ocean, there's a certain madness that calls a
captain from his rolling hearth and dry roof back to the sea, and deep regrets continues to call out to me. And that's our review. But let me know, what is your favorite fishing game, fair or fowl, of all time? and put it in the comments below. And as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for being such an awesome community.