Skip to main content
Loading video...

A Carcassonne Parable for Game Designers: Gathering Playtester Feedback

Transcript 10:31

in 1999 Klaus Jurgen a wide-eyed first-time designer attended his local game group with his debut board game Prototype inspired by a visit to a fortified City in France the game was called carcazon and five of Klaus jurgen's friends had kindly agreed to test the game for him I'm Adam Porter a game designer from Wales and this is a parable for board game designers the play test session went well three of the players loved Klaus jurgen's prototype but the fourth Hilda wasn't so sure it needs to be more strategic she said I like to get the old gray matter working give me some more options I want to make meaningful choices Klaus Jurgen had a lot of respect for Hilda she was the one who had introduced Klaus Jurgen to the board gaming Hobby and she had the biggest board game collection Klaus Jurgen had ever seen she was something of a Canadian a connoisseur of games her critique stuck in the designer's head house Jurgen spent many hours over the following days pouring over his prototype reworking it to satisfy Hilda he returned to the group the following week with a new version of the game carcasson now featured more scoring opportunities Inns and Cathedrals and Hilda loved it but another play tester Otto wasn't Keen the game feels bigger more tiles more features but I feel like we're just all doing our own thing I want more interaction with the other players now our designer was a people

pleaser on week three Klaus Jurgen returned with a new iteration carcazon now featured a princess who could Turf nights out of cities and a dragon who could eat opponents playing pieces more interaction and some great opportunities to mess up your opponent's plans Otto was delighted he loved to watch his opponent suffer but but Friedrich wasn't so Keen Friedrich was a sensitive guy he didn't like attacking other players for fear of offending them and he liked being attacked even less take that mechanisms as so 1997 Klaus Jurgen It's 1999 there must be other ways to build interaction into a game khaz Jurgen didn't sleep well that night he wrestled with friedrich's feedback and an Innovative solution sprung into his mind in the early hours and he set about creating the first ever Cooperative board game for adults in Mists over Carcassonne players would work together to fight off ghosts overrunning the medieval Town week 4 arrived and our designer was Keen to show off his work but the play test group were baffled if turned into a kids game Otto proclaimed we're not in school now nobody plays games to work together Friedrich bit his tongue he quite enjoyed the spooky Co-op version Hilda suggested that Klaus Jurgen researched the hot new games from Reiner knitsia Modern Art Medici and ra

Dr knitsia builds strategic interaction into his games without needing to resort to gimmicks like cooperative play the insatisfying Friedrich our designer had disappointed Otto and Hilda Klaus Jurgen decided to incorporate a nitzia style auction into his carcazon prototype week 5 saw the introduction of bridges and bazaars when bazaars were added to the map a selection of tiles were auctioned off to the players who bid using the only currency in the game victory points Otto and Hilda loved it but another play tester was non-plussed manfred's favorite game was another from the current hotness Warhammer Quest Manfred was all about theme none of this makes any sense he said Castle's a dull and why should I care about sticking boring old Farmers onto Fields over the following play guests Klaus Jurgen tried many themes to satisfy manfred's whims in amazonas he had players racing boats down the Amazon River in Gold Rush players mined for precious metals in the American West in Safari players gathered animals and built watering holes but Manfred was as fickle as the wind after several weeks of dismissing Klaus jurgen's efforts Manfred explained to be honest mate I'm not really into board games I'd rather be watching Star Wars but Klaus Jurgen wasn't one to shy away from a challenge on week nine our designer presented his play test group with carcazon Star Wars cities were

replaced with asteroid belts Rhodes became trading routes Cloisters became planets Midway through the game a man Lent over from another table his name was Heights and he was a familiar face at the group though Klaus Jurgen had never really had much to do with him what your game needs is more action people don't want to spend their Leisure times thinking they Just Want to Have Fun Otto and Hilda rolled their eyes but Heights continued undeterred instead of placing their little people onto tiles they should shoot them on with a catapult Heinz returned to his game of looping Louis and Hilda whispered to Klaus Jurgen ignore him he doesn't like real games but Klaus Jurgen believed any feedback was good feedback and he dutifully noted down heinz's suggestion for later consideration ilsa was the quietest and youngest of the play test group and she spoke up for the first time I've got to be honest I love the original concept but I can't keep up with all these alterations you've bolted bits on which don't fit they might make it more strategic or more thematic but they don't make it more fun I preferred it when it was simple now Klaus Jurgen had a soft spot for ilsa he wanted to make a version of the game which she would enjoy so he set about stripping everything back streamlining the experience and focusing on very simple set collection build vegetable patches and stables for your animals walk down paths to earn bonus points and on week 10 Carcassonne over hill and dale was a

huge hit with eelsa but Manfred Hilda and Otto really weren't satisfied Klaus Jurgen this is a serious step backwards our designer was a calm level-headed man he wasn't easily shaken but these play testers were getting on his Wick week after week he went out of his way to deliver the game that they asked for and week after week he just got more criticism he couldn't satisfy everyone at the same time and he felt like his game would never be good enough for the first time Klaus Jurgen lost his call enough he said I'm very grateful for all your advice and support but I don't know whether I'm coming or going here I'm gonna make the game that I want to make and with that he walked out now it was still early plenty of gaming time left Manfred Shrugged and suggested a round of Magic the Gathering Hilda wanted to try out the new hotness Reina canitzius threw the desert Otto fancied some trading and negotiation so he opted for Settlers of Catan and ilsa wandered off to play men charges Hyde slingered by a nearby table where Wolfgang was testing his Prototype game princes of Florence what it really needs Heinz explained is blindfolds on week 11 Klaus Jurgen returned to the group with his final iteration it was carcazon unaltered from week one after 10 weeks of robust testing and scrutiny Klaus Jurgen had learned to follow his Instinct and returned to his original concept more confident than ever in its

value of course none of this happened as far as I know but I can't help but relate Klaus Jurgen Raiders design processes to those of the designers at my local game Design Group pulled from Pillar To Post by diverse play tester feedback and returning each week with a wildly different iteration of their core concept Raider has shown us the vast scope of a board game idea the massive range of possibilities to stretch that Concept in One Direction or another there's a Carcassonne for every taste a buffet of delicious mechanisms and delectable themes it can be hard for a designer to know which bit of feedback to follow the playtesters are all so convincing so experienced and so sure of their opinion the skill designer needs to develop is the ability to stand back and gather feedback collecting all viewpoints before deciding which path to take it's really a good idea to Chuck your prototype out after a single play test to rework it so much that it barely resembles your original concept it's far wiser to record data from each play test including any observations and suggestions from your play testers and stick with that concept for several tests if you receive the same feedback over and over again from different groups that's the time to make changes each iteration of Klaus Jurgens game was a solid development and each one of them was somebody's favorite but the designer should keep their original intent in mind why did they start on this process

other playtesters observations helping you to progress towards your goal are they taking you further away Klaus Jurgen had a Clear Vision for his game from the outset an accessible Tire laying game about building a map of fortified medieval cities in France his play testers didn't share that Vision they wanted to design their own game a co-op game a Star Wars game a dexterity game a take that game none of this is a problem if you do enough play tests one person's opinion feels important in the context of a small group especially if it's coming from someone you respect but effective play testing means watching many groups with varying experience and tastes playing your game and watching their emotional response which aspects of the game made them laugh when are they scratching their heads at what points do they get tense did they ask to play again is the experience what you wanted it to be receiving play test feedback is a skill and one you get better at with experience listening and reflecting is vital humility is an essential trait but so is self-belief there are times where you need to dig your heels in and trust your instincts the challenge is finding that balance for more advice about play testing follow the link

Progress saved