Phantom Epoch review (review copy provided)
Transcript
Hey everyone, this is Mike with the OneStop Co-op Shop and today I'm doing a review of Phantom Epoch, a one to four player sci-fi campaign dungeon crawler. And disclaimer that I got a review copy of this one. Phantom Epoch takes a lot of pages from the Gloom Haven book. Your two to four adventures with different classes will be playing unique cards for their class to move and attack standy enemies around the map to achieve objectives. And these maps along with all their special rules are in foldout booklets that are put together. and you're trying to complete missions across different planets, level up your characters enough to complete the narrative campaign. So, let's discuss five key things to know about Phantom Epoch. But actually, before I get to my number five, I wanted to kind of add on to number six. And usually I don't talk about components very much, but I love this. So, how both the character minis in the game work and the standies for the enemies is that they click in these little spinning bases with numbers around them. And you keep track of the life total of each figure just by spinning these around the base. Look how smoothly that works. You can also put their status effects in these little extra holders here. Yeah, this is a genius system. I know it's extra plastic. I know it's probably expensive, but I kind of want every game that uses standies with life totals to do this from now on. Anyway, let's go on to the actual list for the game. So, first we're at number five point, which is a mix for my taste, is the progression of the characters in the game. So, each player will control a basic class, and that'll give you a unique deck of action cards and also your inherent range for attacks. But, you can then gain potions and temporary items. You can get these minor boosts for attack and defensive abilities. You can also get armor in different spots, and these things are tiered, so you get better and better ones as the campaign goes along. And you generally earn one point every mission to eventually pay to buy new action
cards that can swap for ones already in your deck. And those options get increased drastically when you unlock one of your advanced classes, although I won't tell you exactly how that happens. There's also a little bit of unlocking on your spaceship itself, although that doesn't happen as often. These are cool options. The characters do feel unique. The advanced classes are awesome. The reason this is a mix for me, and this applies to base Gloom Haven 2, is that it can just feel too slow, at least for my taste, especially once you've filled all of your slots out, it'll often be two or three or four plays before you get something new for your characters. You're not getting kind of a new toy to play with each scenario, and that can make the pacing of progression drag. My number four point, which is also a mix for my taste, is the campaign structure and the narrative in the game. So, first of all, the narrative itself I like quite a bit. It's told in little sections like this, both in a secret book and in the missions themselves. And while I won't give any spoilers, the story does go in unexpected directions, and I really liked how it ended. So, I think they're doing some cool unique things here. What I didn't like as much, and again, this is also a problem I have with Base Gloom Haven, is the actual campaign structure because what happens is when you complete missions or have certain events or other things, you will unlock certain missions on the three planets you can visit. And you can generally choose to go to any unlocked mission the next time you play. But like with Gloom Haven, there's nothing to really tell you which mission represents what. It's very hard to remember which one allowed you to unlock which other mission. So, it's a little bit hard to follow the side quests and the core narrative. Things get a little bit dispersed, at least more than I would like. My number three point is also a mix. Sorry for so many of these in a row, and that's the dice luck in combat.
So, the core actions of the game are controlled by action cards. I'll get to those in a second. When you actually get to attacking somebody, you roll a dieice. You start out with two different dice you can choose from. And the number you roll is the base damage you'll deal modified by the action you played or by enemy defenses. And there are critical sides which will pierce through armor and give you special bonuses. And there are fumble sides. And this is really where the negative side of this is focused. The fumbles don't just cause you to miss your current attack, but they also cause you to miss every other attack you might have played for that turn. And especially for certain classes that rely on making a lot of attacks, it can be devastating. But something important to point out that almost brings this back to a full pro for me is that first of all, they do have a lot of items and abilities you can get that mitigate your luck and don't make the fumbles as punishing. But the big thing that's pushing me more positive on this is that the company said they're going to publish an official variant that allows you to have the fumbles not be as negative or like treat them as just a lower number instead. That's how I've started playing in my second campaign with my son and it's made things way smoother and more enjoyable. So again, this could be a full pro depending on whether you use that variant or not. My number two point, which is finally a full-on pro for the game, is the scenario design and variety. So, first of all, I am a huge fan, if you don't already know, of books being the maps, and especially this way where you have all the narrative, all the setup, all the special events that happen. That's great. Love it for smooth play. And each scenario does have a lot of changing events, new things spawning, rules changing, new threats emerging. I love that the three different planets each have their own feel, their own terrain to traverse. And I especially like the way objects work in the game because
they're all destructible. They can block range attacks that go through them. So it really adds to the tactical puzzle and movement. And even though the scenarios are mostly, when you get right down to it, about just killing a lot of enemies, they do have some nice variety in there. There are some scenarios that are about survival and holding enemies off. Some scenarios that are about quickly moving while enemies chase you, some where you guard an NPC, lots of different boss battles, and there are a ton of them to play through. you won't play every single one in a given campaign. And then on top of that, they have these little training missions that reuse maps in different ways. Really fun. Nice variety overall. My final point, which is also a full pro, is the actual action system, kind of the core card play of the game, and I'm lumping a lot in here. It was tough to get this down to five points. So, the enemy activation is pretty slick. For every enemy on the board, you have an overall type card that gives their core stats.
And these come in four different difficulties if you want to ramp things up. And each enemy is a combination of a species and a class. So you'll use one card from their species, one card from their class, and when they activate, they'll resolve them from left to right. And the class cards differentiate based on each of the four colors enemies can spawn in. So like here, the red, well, there's not an archer, but the red enemy here would do a full draw. Somebody else might fire fire arrows. It's a clean system. You don't need a billion decks of cards to manage because the separation allows them to keep the number pretty low. You get a lot of variety in what the enemies are doing, and their initiative value is the sum of their actions. While for a player, you can play as many cards as you want up to a certain limit. And the combined value of the cards you played as your initiative value. Lowest initiative goes first. So you have some interesting choices and whether you do less on your turn but get the jump on enemies and defeat them before they can attack you or get out of range or if you just go ham and do a ton of stuff and wait for them to come to you. Now the cards don't have the whole top bottom gloom haven thing. They are not nearly as complicated. They're mostly just about moving and attacking in different ways.
But because you can play so many of them, there's still a lot of fun combos to discover. And they do give you a lot of flexibility in that every single card can be changed into a movement and one card around can potentially be changed into an attack if you realize the cards you played were totally the wrong ones and you need to adapt what you're doing. So not the deepest system in the world, but it's fast, it's fun, and it works. So overall, you might want to check out Phantom Epoch if you like combat focused dungeon crawlers, if you want a straightforward experience with some fun character options and quick play. But on the other hand, you might want to avoid this one if you're looking for a really deep narrative. If you're looking for strategic play on level with gloom haven because this is quite a bit simpler or if randomness especially die rolls bother you. You might get frustrated. And if you want to see the game in action, I had a playthrough of the first full mission recently on the channel. Good gaming and I'll see you at the next