Targi Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about target which is a 2012 release card game designed by andrea steiger and published by cosmos this one is a strictly two player only game and it's a worker placement game where you're trying to get as many victory points as you can by the end of the game so the board or the the game state is going to look like this we have this grid of cards you've got these outer cards which are always going to remain the same from all throughout the game but the inner 9 cards are gonna change as the game goes on so you're gonna have as i said it's gonna be a two player game you've got the blue player and you've got the white player and you are going to take turns and depending on who's the first player in order to deploy your workers onto the outer rim of this board now at any time during the game there is going to be the the kind of dummy piece here that goes around the outside and blocks certain spaces off as the game goes on so in the first round it's going to block off this noble card and in the next round it's going to block off this one and so on so let's talk about how the game actually plays out so as i said you're going to take turns deploying your workers onto the outer rim of this grid so let's say for example the um the white player places their first one onto here then the blue player might place it onto here and then the white one might go onto here and the blue one onto here and so on you have to respect the fact that you can never go opposite where your opponent is so say you know the blue players here the white player couldn't go
here for example however they could go here and then the final piece is going to basically um be pretty limited on where it can go so for example it could go go here okay so that's once that's done you're going to start evaluating all the different um spaces so first thing you're going to do is you're going to take the two markers that you've got left in your supply and you're going to put them in the places where your worker pieces kind of um cross over so you know if you've got this work here in this work here so it crosses over here and the other white marker is would go here because again this axis and this axis will cross on that spot and the same is going to apply for the blue player and once that's done starting from the first player you're going to start to take the resources or the actions in which you've deployed so for example this white player could take uh one two even three of um of this resource from the supply and add it to their um to their pool like so but if you ever go on one of these tribe cars because you've got two different types of cars in the center you've got the the um the goods and you've got the tribes and you can afford to pay for the criteria here say say for example i could pay um two of this resource two of uh sorry one of that resource to the bank and i could take that card and put it
on my tableau so throughout the game you're going to start with nothing but you're going to have the potential to build three rows of four cars and you're gonna have to start from left to right and as you can see you've got lots of different types here on what they can do um you've got these kind of um these camp cards you've got these oasis cards you've got these camel riders you've got these like pools and the not only do they give you a number of points so you've got this symbol here which means that they're going to give you that many points at the end of the game but some of them will give you ongoing benefits or end game scoring criteria so for example um you know when i bought this card earlier uh this one says like from now on i could pay one fewer of any goods required to add camel riders to your supply so whenever i put after i bought this card every other card cost me one fewer if it had this camel rider symbol on them but some of them will give you points at the end of the game um depending on a number of things and some will just give you pure points like this for example so this would give me three points any cards taken will be replaced by the opposite type of card so as i said you've got the tribe cards and you've got the good cards and they will remain face down until the next round starts and they'll be flipped over so you've got a new grid state to play with and that's going to be basically how the game is going to play out of course everyone's going to resolve their actions and the order in which you do those actions is also going to be important because you may need some resources to buy other cards that you've you've already got these markers on okay so that's going to be how the game's
going to play out of course i said the game is going to end once somebody has built their full tableau of uh 12 cards or when the um the marker here travels all the way around the board and gets back to the top tile here now something i should mention as well is that whenever this um this marker goes to one of these raid spots you're going to have to discard a good or even a couple of goods or then three goods or a gold and once you do that or you're going to have to do that or you're going to have to sacrifice a number of points so you've got a bit of a tension there that you need to satisfy or suffer a penalty so let's take a look at what some of these different cards do so you've got the noble tile here which means that you can place the card in your hand because at any point in the game if you can't afford the resources to buy one of these tribe cards you can keep it in your hand ready to buy later but if you want to buy it later then you're gonna have to visit that noble tile you just got the straight up goods you got the trader here which means you can exchange goods for gold or two types of goods for one other good so it gives you a bit of flexibility you've got this fatter morgana card here which means you can move one of your tried markers from a card in the center of the center area to another unoccupied spot so if you've gone on this spot here you've got a lot of freedom to move this mark around onto a particular card that you want and you're not subject to that grid reference you've got the silversmith here which means that you can start trading
in um in goods or coins to get victory points and um something i should say about these cards as well is they are double sided so if you don't want the text you can always use the um the symbology on the reverse side which i actually think is a bit better you've got the caravan card here which lets you draw the top goods card from the draw pile and take it what and whatever is depicted on it you are you get gold or victory points and you've got the tribal expansion card which means you turn over the top tribe card for the draw pile and you may display it if you can pay for the cost so it gives you a bit of a lucky dip there in order to add more to your tableau so that's going to be how the game is going to play out of course to play at the end of the game with the most victory points is going to be the winner not only are you going to get victory points based on the cards but also on different things on your tableau so if you ever have four different symbols on a row you're gonna get two victory points or if you have a four of the same on a row then you're gonna get an additional four victory points so let's talk about how i feel about target so first off worker placement games don't normally work the best at two players because uh they're normally too open and they're not kind of restricted enough and make people can really do their own thing and not have to step on each other's toes now target completely takes it out of the equation this is a really tight game and your options are really squeezed as the game develops as more of these workers are placed down of course you cannot share a grid reference with another player and you can't go opposite them either and as more workers are placed down that
does leave you with very few options which you can take which some people might like i personally had a bit of a problem with it because i felt that the choice was taken out of your hands a bit too much now i understand that people will kind of fight the corner of this game saying that you know that's why you need to prioritize your actions however i do feel like you know while of course you need to prioritize things i do feel like you need to have a plan b or a plan c whereas this one that is kind of taken out of your hands so i do think the game is a little bit too tight and a bit too restrictive for me for some reason it just didn't sit right and it didn't feel satisfying for me when i have so few options by the time i placed my third worker now additionally i tend to really struggle or something i've noticed recently is i tend to struggle with games that offer you small gains so for example this one you do quite a bit of work in order to acquire these resources and to spend them on these tribe cards which are often quite expensive only to get two points or of course if you fulfill the additional criteria you can get another couple of points but i would have liked it a bit more if these points were a bit more seductive just offering you big chunks of points rather than just a couple because i find that you do a lot of work for a very few points in this game and again something it's probably more of a personal tasting i just i don't know if it's a psychological thing but it just didn't fi i just didn't find it very satisfying in in terms of how you actually gained your points in the first place also the tableau building i thought was
pretty uninteresting um not only because the plat the different abilities you can get are pretty are pretty boring to be honest things you know such as you know when you buy cards you have to pay one for your resource or when you gain when you take a certain good you get an extra good that kind of thing it's all been done a million times and there's nothing on here that i found particularly interesting or kind of game breaking or that incentive wasn't there for me to you know really go for it so yeah these are all just kind of variations on each other and offer you different ways of getting discounts and things which i just thought was pretty bland and additionally the you know the idea of having to collect all the same types of um cars in order to get a few more points at the end of the game was just again not very satisfying for me so as you can probably tell this one is kind of going a bit down a rabbit hole which um is leading towards uh a game that i didn't enjoy and i have to say that is true i i don't know why this one just didn't didn't connect with me i didn't find it fun i didn't find it satisfying and i found it a bit of a chore as the game go as the game went on now mechanically the game works perfectly fine there is nothing i can complain about about how the game works and how it operates so everything does work perfectly fine um it's more of a personal taste thing and i can't criticize the actual design of the game i just didn't happen to find it fun so you know you know take it take it into consideration that this is a personal thing that the game just didn't connect with me and didn't excite
me so again i do like the mechanisms i do like the way this grid system works i would have liked to have seen it being on a bigger grid maybe being an extra card or two wide and um and longer so that your options just you know you still have to prioritize things but at least you've got a backup plan should you need to go a different route and somebody blocks you off because a lot of the times as well people will see that you want a particular type of card and of course they'll just place one there just to stop you having it and again i know people would appreciate that and like that level of play interaction and that almost not take that ish but that taking things despite my um might appeal to you whereas me i just found it a bit tedious and a bit demoralizing to be honest um time investment you know the game does probably take around 45 minutes to play maybe up to an hour and i think that's a little bit too long in fact it's i would have liked to have seen half of that and perhaps that's another reason why it didn't quite satisfy me i thought it dragged on way too long and by the time i was you know even a quarter away or a third of the way through the game i was well and truly bored i found i i had achieved very little by the time it got to that space and i had to wait number of turns before the marker got round to the end game um endgame trigger so yeah a bit too long for me and um the choices within that time frame just weren't good enough uh the replayability is okay i mean there are a ton of different cards here um you know you can see this huge deck of tribe cards there's a bunch there
but i kind of revert back to my my um comments about all the cards feeling a bit too similar to one another there are just variations you know saying whenever you buy one of these cards and get a discount this one there's another card that's exactly the same but with a different type of card so there isn't a big scope in terms of what these cards do differently and i would have liked to have seen more creative options and more creative um cards be put into the deck player interaction reverts back to that thing about you know prioritizing things blocking people off from the spots that they obviously want and you know if you do enjoy that type of thing then you know you cannot avoid your opponent being in the game and you are going to stand in each other's way you're going to block each other off either you know deliberately or inadvertently and so it's certainly not a multiplayer solitaire style game if you want player interaction then this game is going to have plenty of it however it's not the type of interaction that i tend to enjoy aesthetically the game looks fine i suppose it's pretty boring on the face of it i'm not a massive sucker for um for artwork and stuff but you know all the production is fine the cards are more than adequate in terms of their quality and the symbology is generally pretty good i do like the fact that the um the border cards here are double-sided so if you do want symbology or if you do want the text then you can pick and choose which you want um so yeah that's that's a working addition and i think that should be used more often but yeah absolutely fine in terms of the resources and the uh the player pieces
so no complaints whatsoever in terms of the production other than the artwork could have been a bit more um a bit more interesting so unfortunately target isn't a game i can recommend i'm a bit disappointed about it to be honest because i know target is widely renowned as one of the best two-player games ever designed i was really excited to play this one because i thought that many people can't be wrong and i'm not saying they are wrong it just wasn't a game that's for me i didn't find it fun i didn't find it interesting i found it work i found it a bit of a slog and a bit of a i said a bit tedious just grinding these resources and buying these relatively uninteresting cards just for a few points so um i understand this is probably going to be a unpopular opinion but i have to be honest and um you know i have to be true to my own taste and i can't recommend something that i personally don't enjoy so while mechanically the games sound and i'd love to see this mechanism used in a bigger more grandiose game that can potentially you know accommodate more players um again yeah it works well but it just wasn't for me and i didn't find it fun and certainly isn't a game that i'm going to want to explore any further so sadly a big miss for me that is targi uh if you have enjoyed the review please hit like and subscribe my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye