Skip to main content
Loading video...

10 great Roleplaying games other than Dungeons and Dragons

Transcript 18:50

brought to you by boardgame Atlas comm the fastest-growing boardgame community in the world kia or akoutot and welcome to my top 10 favorite RPGs of all time and Dungeons & Dragons now I know this channels mostly about board games but throughout my entire board gaming life I've also been a role player as well and to me the two hobbies have always interconnected and overlapped I've always liked board games that tell stories and have always liked a little bit of crunch in my RPGs is this the list of the ten greatest RPGs of all time almost certainly not I certainly haven't played all the RPGs that are out there and this list is totally tainted by my personal experiences and the stories I've been involved with throughout all of these games so let's start with some honorable mentions and the first of those will be to the Fantasy Flight Games role-playing game team who developed both Dark heresy and the Star Wars Age of rebellion edge of the Empire and force and destiny role-playing games I've really enjoyed those lines and I'm really sad to see that those might be discontinued another honorable mention is exalted it's basically an amazing heroes through the roof big swords big hair and being able to do karate moves to smash mountains I haven't played this one enough yet and we've just started a campaign and I'm really looking forward to playing it more and the last honorable mention is conveniently far future which is a game a friend of my dad made when we were in high school and early university now conveniently far-future was a comedy game is very silly and it predates the TV show Futurama and the hilarious thing is when

Futurama came on TV it was basically conveniently far future as a TV show so the point was some of the first episodes in the first season were stories that we had done and conveniently far future campaigns and one of the cool things about their game is a group we used to play it with I still the people I test and play games with today so let's move on to the top ten and Dungeons & Dragons and we'll start with Dungeons & Dragons and I didn't want to put this on the top 10 list itself not because I don't like the indeed fact D&D was the first RPG I played I picked up a red starter box for I think my twelfth or eleventh birthday after a family friend had seen me reading fighting fantasy books and said oh you like those like Dungeons & Dragons and I've played it on and off ever since 30-plus years and I've played all editions of it except the most recent one fifth edition as well as a myriad of D&D based computer games from pools of radiance and death Knights of Krynn through the balders gate and Icewind dale games but there's not much to say about D&D as there's been so much talk about it so many people who played the game and I don't really feel like going into too much detail here aside from to say that D&D was the game that got me into role-playing games and the reason I'm probably still playing role-playing games so let's go on to the top 10 list proper and we'll start with a game that takes entirely too much work to play and entirely too much work to run and that's shadowrun now shadowrun is a combination of a cyberpunk setting and your traditional fantasy D&D tropes instead of just hackers and cyber wear and bionics and

Street Samurai you've got all that and magic and Dragons and elves and I don't personally mind playing shadowrun but I absolutely love running shadowrun this is one of the games I've been the GM the most and I've run six different campaigns over the years using the shadowrun second and third edition books the best things about shadowrun are the heists you can pull the great missions the Mission Impossible style feeling you get of the game we've got to break into the hidden facility hack through the systems get the gym and get out of there without getting caught by the authorities the downside of shadow run is that the rules are nightmare especially if someone's playing the Decker which is the hacking character or the rigger and wants to do all the complex electronic warfare stuff it's a game that requires a lot of overhead and a lot of mechanical work which in some ways is a bit of a pity because it gets in the way of the fun planning and execution of these fantastic sci-fi James Bond Mission Impossible style adventures now I have a love-hate relationship with paranoia because the number of games are played of it they've been really really bad but when it's been good it's been great and when it's been great as when players have taken it a bit seriously paranoia is set in a post apocalypse when you're in a locked place called alpha complex where a super computer controls absolutely everything you do the only problem is the computer is absolutely and totally mad it's paranoid and so is everyone else in the complex its enemies of communists and mutants and members of secret societies and every single character you play is a

member of a secret society and a mutant and you have to keep that hidden or making sure you keep an eye on the other people in your team when done right it's a darkly humorous incredibly sinister experience combined with just absurdist comedy like some great moments are where you get given a machine you're told all right you have to drive this machine all the way over there and the GM hands you a diagram of an incredibly complex machines console all of these buttons and levers and dials and no instructions and you have to sit there and go I press button 36 I think that might be the stop button turns out it's the ejector seats now this game's disappeared for quite a while but it has come back recently as a computer game and I have been playing that through and they do successfully nail the tone of paranoia next up is the second RPG I ever played and that's Call of Cthulhu now I have a lot of problems with Call of Cthulhu mechanics I'm not a big fan of d-percentile systems they always feel a little bit clunky to me particularly when you've got a very important clue the players need to find and they've got like 60% library use and they fail and there's not much you can do about that as the GM aside from budget what I like about Call of Cthulhu is that the characters are just people they're people in the world encountering extraordinary things and all the campaign's of this I've played have been quite serious they're not the Arkham Horror grab the tommy guns go have the great old ones and go into the lair and everyone empties machine guns into them until they're defeated there's always been stories of people investigating

terrible terrible things and recently we play through the entire tatters of the king campaign which took us 16 or 18 months to get through the character I was playing also wrote short stories about our various adventures and I cataloged those throughout the game to act as a record of the story we've been telling and the cool thing about Call of Cthulhu is you can tell those personal horror stories about what happens when an average group of people come up against extraordinary problems next up is game I've played entirely too much and that's the original world of darkness vampire not only have I played in multiple tabletop games of this I was also involved in LARPS for years and what does vampire well it's basically a superhero game but your vampires and I know there's a lot of people who say oh it's about personal horror and tragedy and losing your humanity but most games are played in and certainly most of the LARPs i was involved with were about politics they are about super-powered beings living in the shadows with powers fighting a shadow war against each other for primacy and position in a weird way it was like an organized crime game you and your clique we're trying to build up your own power and infrastructure and there are other people always getting in your way we did play the odd game of vampire that did focus on the day-to-day struggle of new vampires but it was depressing and not enough ennui I'm sad kind of way just in a druggie repetitive dull kind of way doing every single feeding check struggling with the day-to-day thing of being a vampire was

like being a millennial you're wondering where your next meals coming from and it didn't seem like escapism it just felt like work and vampire LARPing for the fun high points it also lead to some really bizarre social behavior people took that game slightly too seriously and I don't think I've ever seen any social activity be more destructive to social groups than a live role-playing game of World of Darkness vampire but still I have fond memories for the setting the mythos the different clans and a lot of the characters that I played in it and it'd be curious to check out world of darkness vampire there's gonna be a brand new game coming out on the PC later this year that looks pretty damn good next up is an odd little game it's called the quiet year and the quiet years closer to a board game that in most role-playing games are because you start with a blank map and you turn over event cards and you narratively decide what's happening based on the cards you draw and then you draw those things on the map and the idea is at the end of the year these horrible baddies are going to turn up it's a post-apocalyptic sitting and you're a community preparing or what's about to happen and based on the story you tell off each card the map of your location and your setting evolves and I found this a uniquely creative and exciting group activity so when it came to run a Star Wars campaign a little bit later I used an adapted system of the quiet year to build the sector that the game would

take place in each player would draw a card and that would determine a different feature of that world whether it was a populations by on what kind of people who live there or significant NPCs or a story element they'd like to see included in the campaign and that shared creation of what became telathen sector for us created a really rich and vibrant world that everyone can belt quite familiar with like the characters grew up in that sector because they'd helped design it they felt like they were part of it and I think it's one of those games that if you're a creative person and you've got a group of other creative people who you like telling stories then it's worth giving a go just once it might not be one you play all the time but as a one-off experience it's fantastic now the next one I had mentioned Call of Cthulhu earlier how I didn't like the D percentile system in it because you've miss out on important clues and clearly I'm not the only one because there is a system out there called gumshoe and someone adapted that system to cthulhu and called it trail ofCthulhu and in trail of Cthulhu you have skills but you can spend them to do stuff so when you come across a body for example that's been attacked in some sinister and grotesque and horrible way and you have a level of forensics well say you've got several levels of forensics the person running the game can go do you want to spin some of your forensics to dig deeper to get an extra clue and that means the agencies on players to determine what extra information they get and when they will succeed the combat system is a little wonky and not to my liking but the investigation

system felt better than any other game I've come across because you could spend the time and the energy to succeed and if you were an expert in something say chemistry and you came across a chemistry challenge you could pass it if you wanted to because you're an expert at it you're not reliant on just a simple dice roll and it just made the story feel organic as though it came to you naturally based on what your character did and what their skills were and I really like that about trail of Cthulhu the next up is my favorite game in the original world of darkness so we've already talked about vampire there was also a werewolf game where you were massive werewolves protecting Gaia from corruption and blight it was wraiths where you were people had passed away recently but had it is tying you to the material world and it was changeling where you were Fae creatures and there were a bunch of others like mummy in there but none of them look quite as mind-blowing as World of Darkness mage mage presented so many unique ideas one of them was that mages was simply people who could enforce their will on reality and that set up the entire conflict within the game that one set of mages called the technocracy had worked hard to define reality as static and controlled and run by technology because that's how their magic worked and most of the players were of the traditions which was traditional magic the war was over belief and what defined what was real and that idea was just a great hook the other thing that it did really well were there weren't spells as such each mage

had different things they could influence so for example you might have a forces mage or there's sufficient ability to control lesser forces what this means is you could control light electricity that kind of thing how you manifest that was really open to your interpretation and the more you can make the effect look like it took place within acceptable reality the better it was for you so yeah you could summon a fireball and blast people with that but onlookers don't believe that reality doesn't believe in fireballs but the same character can hold a gun and shoot at a car and conveniently have the fuel tank explode dramatically in the same way as a fireball but the audience believes that reality believes that and it led to a lot of really creative decisions by players my favorite ever game of mage was actually a technocracy game where we were very very low-level technocracy agents and we were basically the x-files we were going around finding monsters of the week like ghouls and zombies and mole men and dealing with them and that brings me to the next game which is monster of the week now this games based on the powered by the apocalypse engine but I've not played other games from that setting my only exposure to it is monster-of-the-week and this game is if you like Buffy if you like Angel if you like supernatural if you like those urban fantasies we're a group of archetypal characters take on a different big bad monster each week and try to defeat it and put it back in its box or whatever whilst you of the week would be a game you'd absolutely want to check out a lot of the things I really like about it is the player generation is really simple there are archetypes well they call play

books which are double-sided character sheets which come up all the information you need to play a character of archetype within the game for example one of the archetypes is the chosen which is the Buffy type character where you'll picked by destiny to be a champion against evil or if you're more of a Dean Winchester type you could pick the wrong who's a character thats had everything taken from them and won't let the bastards take anymore it's a really simple game they can almost just pick up and play straight away the archetypes just pull you in and what can I say I just love the idea of monster of the week as a game the second to last game is the third ever RPG I played and that is Star Wars by West End games and the reason I'm picking this one ahead of age of rebellion or the one that was based on DMD is the west end games d6 system was just really fun and really easy to use and there's like a 13 or 14 year old it was one of the easiest games to run it also came fantastic supplement books the Rebel Alliance sourcebook for Star Wars west end games is one of the best RPG source books I've ever read it deals from top to bottom on how to run a resistance terrorist organization how cells are structured how you fight a regular war it was like a military treatise just written for Star Wars whoever wrote that clearly did their research and knew a few things about organizing a rebellion or organizing an insurgency what this version of Star Wars didn't do very strongly was the force but that was fine it was set in the period between Star Wars and Empire Strikes Back and at that point in the

history they hadn't built up this great Jedi mythology the only Jedi characters were the odd alien who had some full sensitivity or or very weak force users who escaped the purges so the game didn't need a robust complex more system force users at the time we're really just Yoda the Emperor Vader and Luke so you focus more on stories about people on great adventures and they put out so many amazing supplements and in a weird way the Star Wars Western games RPG is the source of a lot of Star Wars Canon even today by was doing a Star Wars story not based on force use I'd probably pick the West End game system it just uses d6 it's that easy and the last game on the list is the only role-playing game I own absolutely every supplement I got every book they ever put out and I was absolutely gutted when the end of the line and that's in nómine now in nomine is a game about angels and demons it's about the ongoing cold war between heaven and hell over people's souls now bear in mind I'm an atheist so my love of this game isn't based on any strong faith-based grounds I like it because like vampire was a game about supernatural entities in the modern world but unlike vampire the stakes weren't just personal it was about making a better world or dragging the world down it was about epic sweeping fantastically high level things happening and one of my favorite games I ran at this who's literally about the apocalypse was called the final trumpet and the players went through all of the stage gates

leading up to an apocalypse trying to avoid it and the stakes of this campaign were literally the earth but probably my favorite thing about innominate is its central metaphor and that's the idea that all of creation is called the symphony and everything is music in some way but humans aren't tuned into that music but supernatural beings are and everything in the game uses this musical metaphor each angel has certain powers based on how they tune into the symphony so Seraphim can tell if you're lying a cherubim can tell when the person they're trying to protect is being harmed because they hear it and when supernatural beings do things it creates noise in the symphony so demon can't just walk around killing people just indiscriminately because everyone in town will hear this so it leads to players having this great power but not necessarily being able to use it they have to be smarter an angel just can't punch someone until they redeem they've got to set up the things around them and work them towards that path but it has to be their own choice and I really like that in the game I like the game so much that I almost entirely rewrote the rulebook myself creating my own personal take on how I thought the in nomine universe would work better sadly this game was never properly supported by Steve Jackson games and the quality of the books they put out publication wise was always a bit substandard but still if you're looking for a role-playing game it's a little bit different that has interesting stakes and allows you to play on very adults and very strong themes of in the modern world and nómine is a little bit different and it's

something a little bit special so that was my top ten list of RPGs I've enjoyed plus Dungeons the Dragons let me know if any of those RPGs sound interesting to you hopefully that gives you some ideas of games you might want to pick up in the future and if there are any RPGs you really love that I didn't mention mention them below in the comments and you enjoy this video like it subscribe to the channel and support us on patreon

Progress saved