Carnival Zombie: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked we are doing a no run through review for carnival zombie second edition uh boy was this not worth the wait the four-year wait um so i we've had this conversation before on what's worse um a painfully like boring game or a objectively bad game and an objectively bad game i think you can still have some fun like like you know crap movies like sharknado that people still can like enjoy versus things like the new prey that's just like a whatever like uh this was two and a half hours of watching um there's not even anything to make fun of it because this is good like and that's that's that's kind of where i'm at for this game is like i find i find this game boring and repetitive and kind of tedious but it's not bad like i can see a lot of people really getting into this uh and i remember backing it probably my thought process it's been so long was oh i don't like zombies but this seems like a really cool theme yeah and it is and the way that turn structures work is fine but i'm just like
over here falling asleep during the night phase where it's like okay yeah i'll attack okay drop the cubes all right let's do that all over and over again yeah most of the night phase seems to be set up and moving things around on the board very little of what do we need to do in order to survive because it's obvious most of the time there's not much strategy yeah yeah i mean everything's coming at you from all sides so there's not a whole lot of strategy about where to use our powers there's there is some i will definitely give it their song but yeah i mean it's not like the game doesn't like play itself like it's not like it's it's not that kind of just there's you have no agency anything you do yeah it just doesn't feel it's not exciting yeah and i'm i'm wondering if the cubes have something to do with that like i get why they did that because it's just way easier for the game to function that you pull from this bag oh yeah from the abyss rather than making individual monsters that are harder to kill right you make tons of them that are easy yeah and here's which is typical for for defense mode what sucks is this game came out way too late yeah like this is it's 2022 by the time this came out it was it should have came
out in 2018 um in the first edition i only remember when that came out but at this point like take project elite which i don't know five of you have played is a real-time tower defense game okay and that game is phenomenal because it works kind of a similar way you have miniatures for the scrubs that you just mow down but then occasionally you have bosses come out and those are a little bit more you know uh you know they're more unique kind of like how it is here like they have special rules and they're a pain in the ass when they do come out but the game just flows so fast that you're just constantly like feeling like a badass and here every time a new night phase would start it's like ugh how many do we have left three we have three nights the hours left um and so this is kind of where it's like why why is it so long and then you just look ahead and you're like oh my god we have two more whole days left to get over there and then we have the finale it's like no i can't spend eight hours playing this game all right so what are your guys's thoughts exactly what you think there's not a lot to the game it seems like um the this wasn't developed by a well-known company i it seems it has a very thick feel of not
being polished no being from a an eastern european country or something like yeah i say that but then awaken realms is really polished so i it's true that's not really a good example but it seems it doesn't seem like it was made in the united states i could be wrong it just has a feel it's it's disjointed the rule books just join in yeah the rulebook is all over the place player cards are disjointed this could very easily from someone who just has common sense be cleaned up and i'm not gonna [ __ ] on the game i think it's i think it's okay i don't like i generally don't like games that have well this guy does this little thing because you look over here and then you got to look up in the book what the little guy does and then this guy does this little thing and this this little box of cardboard over here does a thing but you got to read what it says because it doesn't say on the tile right i'm like i don't like that i mean if you really enjoy a game and you play it a lot you're going to memorize that [ __ ] eventually but like walking into a game i realize that they want to make something um not language reliant but yeah it's irritating to play it's irritating to learn i instantly am kind of like okay what's going on um but it has some interesting stuff going on i haven't played a lot of tower defense games it has some cool ideas uh the cubes and placing them out could get really laborious after a while especially after having do it before in a row right um well then you do it then you go to the day phase which is
virtually like a group activity you all decide where to go as a group um and prepare and pretty much recover like and get items to prepare for the night so and the day phase goes by so quick because it's like okay i'll search boom okay it's an item okay i finally got one all right so then there's that then you go through that then it's like day phase and then it's just like comes to a screeching halt of where you have to okay that's three well first you have to shuffle these and place them out uh oh how many oh we have two okay well then these two come out and then we get these stay out in between scenarios no no those would those come off and then say because you're at a whole new location yeah and then you go all right let's start in north one or south one there's that having fun like while one person does this because the complexity is not the strategy level is not that difficult i can see this especially later on whenever you have eight different what are these called fortifications fortifications the bad ones yeah the obstacles going out i can see it just happening where it's like oh okay they did a thing there's nothing we could do to stop it because you're gonna have you're gonna have a limited amount there's always gonna be something that takes precedence over everything right um and then it's just the boss the bosses follow you from night to night if you don't kill them but that's the thing it's like the bosses
were just kind of there i never felt like an overwhelming presence of like oh it's like initially they have that oh [ __ ] that's a big deal and then it's like okay focus fire and we killed it yeah nicely i mean kind of like in left 4 dead if you've ever played left 4 dead where it's kind of like when those unique ones come out yeah you do all focus fire and then they're taken care of and if you don't then they're a problem so it does make thematic sense that they're not super hard to kill uh but yeah it's uh i don't know i just think tower we played kingdom rush you remember that super fun time the app that's that was made into a board game yeah um that was a tower defense game and i was like why would anyone choose to play this over the app i don't i don't get that right like because we didn't know there was an app at the time the cat did she looked it up um and started and then she played it she's like oh my god this is way better uh and that's kind of that's kind of the problem the fundamental problem of board games tower defense as board games is it's just so monotonous when you're doing it physically right and there's not enough here at least for me to justify the fact that you do the same thing every single night like nothing changes from night to night except where some obstacles might be and you might have some different items but your actions are still the same your actions still come down to all right i'll shoot okay
let me drop them there oh man they're back yeah i'm gonna try to take it oh it was so close and then we had all those back and so you just go through the motions to get to a finale and i feel like that this is the game they wanted to make the different scenarios because these are all unique and they have a bunch they have a bunch of different different finales but they like for some reason this wasn't enough substance they wanted you to have the campaign feel of building up to escaping out of venice see and for me it's kind of the opposite it feels to me like they played castle panic and then said okay so how can we make this a lot more complicated yeah and call it a sophisticated game right and and they added them layers of complications they had it on a whole separate game and then they added a whole separate mini game yeah and then they added more randomness yeah and then okay because castle panic you know people play it a couple of times it's fun it's cool but it's very limited and then it gets relegated to the kids yeah this is well maybe we can make something really complicated for grownups adults the adult castle panic and and and let's let's mash together three or four different games and then it's all working toward a goal which as i understand i don't even know
what the end goals are but two of them seemed like oh you made it duh there's yeah there's there's the boat which is you take the um you take this you take the the pile of corpses thing and you flip it then you have the boat and then you assign okay someone is on the helm someone is on the the crow's nest someone's on the bridge and then you take these shuffle these up and then you put three in each whatever pit or quadrant uh and then you're trying to align these to the quadrant you're escaping from so like if this one if this one was in the first cave you flip it okay well that's south too so or that's south so we need to get this one and you can do actions to move them over so you're trying to basically get it to where you have all three cards of the same direction that's how you escape okay um all the while zombies are coming in and attacking the boat and you have barricades you put these all around and that is your boat's health gotcha so it's a completely separate game pretty much yeah it's some similar mechanics right and that's the thing is like so you're right they they took this and they put everything and just threw it it was was like threw that the wall to hoe and see see what sticks yeah and then they picked up all the stuff that didn't stick and put it in a box um because the different scenarios remind me of robinson caruso but the whole game of robinson caruso is that scenario right like i don't feel like i'm missing out on anything by
choosing to play a scenario it's like oh these are just how we win this team uh this time but all the components are still there and you guys have played robinson crusoe so it's like it's that's what that feels like but in here it's like oh well you can just play a scenario yeah but you you're not doing the tower defense stuff right like you're not doing any of that so you're not playing any of this you just pick oh well let's do the boat oh okay yeah we just try and escape off the boat right and i find that so bizarre from a from a design standpoint it's like hey do you want to play a campaign where you do the same thing over and over and over and over and then you get to go to the fun stuff or do you want to do just the fun stuff but you're missing out like you're not utilizing a lot of the i mean really anything yeah yeah so i'm just so baffled by that as a decision it's like the individual characters and their powers and their items i mean that's all a cool idea but that adds a whole level of strategy to a fundamentally random game and so that just seems like a weird crossover that doesn't work for me yeah i never felt like the characters were defeated enough no i mean they have the rules to play i mean you have you have your sniper you have your medic give your heavy gunner captain who commands what other people do um your explosion expert or the engineer or whatever and then i i don't know your
rogue mobility yeah mobility so they're all there and they all rode candy right i was like okay yeah you have your ranger you have your healer you have your tank uh wizard wizard yeah so i they all i guess i could i can't say they all didn't feel different i just didn't care yeah like this wasn't one of those cooperative games where it's like oh ooh like if i do this and you do this then we can do this really cool thing yeah we did that a couple of times but i didn't like well yes we did combine actions to do something but i guess i never felt like it was exciting right and that's kind of where everything kind of boils down to is like i don't really have any particular gripe with this game like if someone were to but i i was just so painfully bored and like nodding off from playing the game but i'm the one running the abyss so i have to stay awake i just i can't imagine there's ever a scenario where someone was like hey do you want to play cardinal zombie and then i'd be like yeah it's like whoa and maybe i'm kind of curious to see because it has a gold seal of approval i just from what yeah from the diced hour probably from all those years ago and i will even say you know the artwork is very nice yeah the figure is very nice
although i would at least want colored bases or painted colors oh yeah like i do differentiate these these would be they're big for paint and many people will yeah and that's okay with me yeah because you've got your paint scale exactly yeah when did the original come out oh yeah i was looking that up um 13 or 14 probably i remember seeing the i can see that being rated well if that's based off of the original yeah i'm very curious if they just took that seal from the first and the first because i remember tom vessel really liking this when it first came out there was demo copies of this new 2013 like two or three years ago really because there's videos online i remember yeah 20 posted 2013 is when this came out yeah uh i'm just i don't know i and the theme i mean the theme is is weird yeah but i i like it i think it's a cool theme because it's never done like i i if this was generic zombie or [ __ ] or one of those words like the people are the real enemies it's like shut the [ __ ] up like get over yourself yeah i i actually i i like the theme at the beginning and actually after playing this i i kind of don't i think it's because you can't like relate to any of these characters because you're just like i don't know yeah i don't know what the [ __ ] is going on i don't know what stories about like so as i understand it i watched it i watched a video i think of the original yeah so the the concept is
people are in venice partying um carnival i i don't know if it's mardi gras as we call it yeah you know it's some kind of a big public event party and and then leviathan uh raises the dead and brings all the zombies in um and so we suddenly have to fight off zombies so all of our character cards beautiful artwork but you know we're all in our party clothes yeah with our assault weapons well you know like you bring two apart my grenades and stuff we kind of look like zombies ourselves but how do you know that without watching the video exactly exactly yeah it says ancient manuscripts speak of a leviathan it's basically it's talking about the leviathan as as the big bad because yeah he's the one bringing everyone to dead uh and you're trying to escape venice hence why you have the boat the aircraft or the bridge but you can also if you get the holy hand grenade or the holy bomb now uh is you can fight it and you can kill it and but that's that's what makes me so mad about this game is this stuff seems fun the scenarios seem fun hell i could even kind of see doing one maybe two nights of this to build up and be like yeah we're escaping like you do in left 4 dead as you're running through the city going from area to area until you are able to escape or back for blood if you played that same company but it's like to get to the fun game you have to play the not fun part is that just so that we can get items to
work to help with completing the final scenario because that's all we seem to be accumulating yeah that's that's pretty much my guess i mean there's really nothing that denotes like oh if you did this so like the holy bomb i mean well the holy bomb but also you have to get his item agreed you're taking damage by losing barricades over time right so it's balancing itself out so it's just to play the game more which which again feels like a strategy game with way too much randomness this also seems it seems like it didn't need a second edition i was thinking that too i can see your player characters being like a nice addition but the boss zombies don't need to be there this game's not i think they were in the original i don't they don't need to be in there for that either honestly i don't think i didn't they're nice the actual the miniature quality is nice yeah they're detailed i mean this is this has some weight to it this is this is really cool yeah uh the insert's actually not bad i'm very surprised like it it functions uh pretty well like because basically you take this out and then there's like a little divot here for like all the bags and then you just put this over it so that's good it's not because some of these were it's like hey here's minnie's in there like every awaken realm game is like okay well this inserts useless because i can't or cuz i give you you know 40 stacks of cardboard yeah uh but you're right i'm trying to i'm trying to figure out because i don't know what took them so long probably the miniatures
honestly if they and and that's what they promised so they have to follow through with it i get that but like if they didn't have all that [ __ ] if they had lessened what they were producing my guess is because of an interview with production supply problems from what i understand miniatures are the reason that they wait for china for things if they didn't if they didn't produce that [ __ ] they could produce a lot of that [ __ ] here so you eliminate all these issues by removing the [ __ ] miniatures from yeah and they come with it has standees yeah like so they come with sandys which i kept in case i wanted to get things paint if i were to paint my cubes i told you i played i played the boys board game yeah the gen con and completely different thing than this but uh a a more enjoyable game way more thematic and it has a ugliest fuckboard in my opinion i don't think the board is very interesting this board is much better than this game i can guarantee you that game is cheaper than this game um it's competitive it's not cooperative um and the minis are completely unnecessary in it like you right standees and it's it's it's immersive with what you're doing like the story makes sense you know what you're doing he gave this like a two-minute explanation of what was going on it's like okay i got it and that explanation is on the book and you understand that going into it yeah um this just is disjointed i don't know why leviathan is is raising the dead is it maybe that's a thing leviathan in my experience has been like a water creature i don't know i'm sure i'm sure there's a story that's why venice is i mean venice is sinking and it's going into the sun yeah yeah that's that's what the found foundation tokens are supposed to be is sections of the city are sinking yeah yeah i think i
think part of the theme problem is they assume a greater knowledge and understanding of venice and that area of italy and like which just doesn't carry over i mean it's i think it's for a european audience they have it in here actually for each number like has like so we were in let's just say four um this age san giovanni and paulo basilica this ancient imposing building is the mausoleum of the doges of venice he arrests the ancient leaders of the city offspring of a few aristocratic families which led to glory and then to ruin the daughter of the sea special action no so it's like they have they have like history and they have theme into it it's just so left field of a theme that it almost seems like pretentious kind of yeah yeah i see that we're not like other zombie games we're just like other tower defense games bad but our theme is different and that's that's that's the thing is the theme is going to draw people in because it's like oh my god like this is so different and then they're going to play the game and they're going to be like well themes right out the window except for the costumes but i can't i can't roleplay i can't get into character when i can't pronounce anyone's [ __ ] name or i don't i can't read it or i'm over here and i'm like what do you bagool is that your character you're like brighella
and it's like okay heavy gunner guy just do the do the same thing that everyone else is doing except maybe a little bit better yeah yeah it's like all right because i remember during and even the daytime actions are repetitive all right i guess i'll search it's like okay i'm just gonna hold on to this deck okay infected get it get an item item item item all right we're done it's just and then it's long yeah this game is this game is long all for now that i think about it yeah just to get items to do a finale and to lose barricades and to lose barricades and maybe get some survivors but the survivors are only useful uh if you can get 10 of them and have the medic kill them all to win the game now they're useful in other ways but they are but no that's that's easily the coolest way but yeah they prevented damage because you were just like oh god you just throw timmy a weird theme idea is we've got the survivors we saved the survivors now we're going to sacrifice them pretty much that's their only reason yeah i'm like um are we the heroes like i guess now we're just trying to escape every day and every night is four hours yep no no don't call them hours then yeah yeah that's yeah even i thought that same thing when i was like wait what because it's like if it would make sense
it's like oh it's you're preparing at the sunset and then into the night but that's like wait four hours of night yeah like mechanically it works thematically it's horrid yeah yeah i can't even get into the zombie theme which to be fair i don't like zombie games um out of like out of all of horror zombie would probably be at the very bottom um even whenever they're infected and you know they're fast it's like oh no they're not zombies they're like romero zombies it's like whenever like was it 28 days later when they're fast yeah it's just like okay whatever the dress zombies like who cares yeah so yeah the [ __ ] the survival horror element did not come out to me at all no and i think it's just because you you're the miniatures stay there like they don't do anything except for being in it and occasionally you might go ho ho-ho right man that was exciting yeah i really felt like we were whole like in the tower defense like project elite is a perfect example like you feel like starship troopers or you feel like whatever where you're just mowing down hordes of enemies and feeling like a badass using some special laser weapon to like beam rifle down you let you feel that here i never felt like we were like holed up on these boxes [ __ ] les miserables style just but shooting down onto zombies and as
they were encroaching on us and like clawing at them i never felt that why instead of having that like having a meter that you could fill where you could take an additional action or i mean i see this game i like deck building but i could see this game and then it's not my job to to come up with more interesting elements to make this game work right this game is a deck builder if you were taking your actions from a deck that everybody had their own private deck from would be interesting though yeah i've been sure about other interesting [ __ ] that they could do that isn't so [ __ ] random but yeah and it was also weird you were mentioning kind of the items and and stuff like that every character has their own deck of items which i like all i think that's unique they're all tied to the character but what's also [ __ ] weird is like i'm gonna go do a search action only for me though i found my ritual cup it's like well or a barricade but it's just so weird that as an they it felt like they were trying to come up with stuff to do right like well we want a day and night phase well what [ __ ] do we make them do on the day like have fun no no that's that can't be it what if we have them search oh for like unique items so you can distribute throughout the group no feel barricades how about everyone's selfish and they're only going they're searching for their own stuff it's just so weird that that's that's how you get your own items like you're right i think a uh a deck builder would have been better because at least it would have been a defense deck builder an interesting concept
well it's better than whatever the hell this is tower defense nap time where you hit everyone gets a like you play this game with people who just got off like a really long shift so whenever it's event like eventually their turn they can finally oh and then you know they get a few quick season uh yeah the pile of corpses is gimmicky as hell it's fun to do but again it's just more of just we need just something else why not just throw a dexterity element in there because who cares those idiots who are going to buy the game they're just going there instead of having a set limit or instead of having like a maximum or something that most games would have it's like oh let's throw an element of random chance yeah they think they can control they think it's cute because that'll be the only exciting part of the entire night phase is that when you kill them it's just like oh man i killed three like that was the most fun i had every single night was was dropping those [ __ ] cubes on to try and make a game out of it uh because this was not doing it for me yeah but i also think you're right most other games would be i think i want to say arcadia quest but i know there's been other games where it was kind of like a small competition of like if i kill these then yeah it goes on the meter like that's the oh i killed him so like it fills up a track and it's like oh now i filled up the track i can remove stress or i can you know take an extra action no none of that you just drop them on a
on a cardboard thing and uh and then hope they don't fall off because then if they do fall off they go back on the thing and you take a stress yeah yeah anytime you're given a limited amount of actions you can choose from eventually they're going to go stale after replay that's true yeah unless the game is solid i mean because if you think about like pandemic is fully cooperative i mean you do have quite a few actions but you do the same ones over and over but you're engrossed in the strategy the whole time yeah and there's the game is so solid as far as the revolving elements whereas this is just i mean when you get to a certain point when the corpse file gets full you're just recycling the same because you're you're eventually going to knock over some every single time and there's more and more added so you're just gonna you're constantly gonna have things in the perimeter right oops and you're going to be taking out larger and larger groups so that's why i say if you had meters full then you're getting a reward for killing a group because you could kill a group of 50 of them and it's yeah yeah i mean just don't even attempt to drop them because in like you just put them right back out yeah i know there's i don't know who has the item i think one of you guys must uh there's there's an item that clears off the entire um yeah didn't you see uh but that's a one-time use and this is kind of like you're not gonna get all these cards i can even get maybe four or five in a full game yeah it's just
either thing that brought back things um oh barricades from the yeah it must be one of you too because i thought it was the medic because it was like i thought it was like i'm just a chloroform but that's not it it's uh no but that's the thing it's like a gravedigger would be the the item cards it's like in how well or how easy or hard a knight is is basically this could be how lucky your item card draws are there's a lot of it because imagine if like you know it's like okay you know we we i finally got an item for the medic and it's like oh the sacrificial dagger okay that does nothing like yeah we have to get all the survivors out so i guess prioritize those just just so we can win um but then there's also stuff like uh lambrosia's works this is just a passive when using your character's day ability recover a stress oh man okay so i can treat others and also heal myself i just don't like that i don't like the fact that some of these are more opportunistic than others and you have to weirdly go out and search for them it's just this is [ __ ] odd this game is weird this game is weird and and not fun like so yeah uh you guys have anything else on the i mean the traversal of the the venice map is whatever like it would mean more if we were more familiar with venice i would think i guess but even then it's like they're
they're gonna get into the theme if we had a clue oh cool i know that building i've been there it's fun to pretend we're in there defending it from zombies yeah but i don't i i see what you're saying and i and i do agree that but i mean that's why they have it here it's like oh we're in location seven that's um rialto bridge oh yeah it spans the grand canal which divides venison too ancient and magnificent a lot of small shops appear along its ramps a legacy of the city's trading uh opulence but even then it's like it's so specific that yeah i guess you would have to have some i'm from venice you know kind of kind of background to really get into it because i was gonna say well i don't know [ __ ] about warhammer 40k but i can still get into the theme but that's also just kind of your whatever sci-fi that you don't have to know a lot about it but it helps if you do uh it's just this game is weird yeah so on a scale of one to ten boy would you guys give carnival zombie second edition and to be fair we haven't played i haven't played first edition so i i can't compare contrast right what was in first edition uh i'm gonna say the artwork doesn't save it from being a three for me but dang okay wow okay yeah wow that's uh it's a lot lower than even i was gonna give it well don't let me talk you out of it um i'm at a five right now i mean that could change if i played it again but i'm not going to
so that's that's exactly where i'm at i'm at a flat five like i think this is as average as it comes as we were talking more and more i was like man i i might start disliking more stuff but not not enough to give me like a visceral reaction of just like ooh like i wouldn't play it again even if like because that's the thing is like i don't want to just do a scenario because that just seems whatever like i feel like i'm missing part of the game but i don't want to play the actual game to get to a scenario yeah so it's like if i won the tower defense i'm just going to play project delete if i want to play scenario based games there's millions of others but similar to this where it's a sheet i'll play robinson caruso if i want to play a zombie game which i never do dead of winter it's probably my favorite zombie game yeah so there's a bunch of them there are a bunch but like i said i don't i don't seek out zombie games if i want to play an affected game i'll play pandemic uh and i think that's that's where this game kind of falls flat it's it's worse than every like all some of its parts are worse than something else and then together it doesn't make a fun game and this is k this yeah this game is dated second edition to me feels like it's just a bougier version of the first edition so it's uh nine years old at this point yeah and the second edition feels like a nine-year-old game yeah
so five out of ten uh not the worst not what i was expecting to actually give it after playing it i was like but yeah all right well that's our thoughts on carnival zombie let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comments share and subscribe and everyone before whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you