Trench Raid First Look & Overview | World War 1 Solo (Solitaire) Wargame | Compass Games
Transcript
Hi everybody, I'm Zed Lutz and welcome. Today we're going to take a look at Trench Raid from Compass Games and designed by Lisa Smidman. In this solitire World War I game, you lead a 10-man team of raiders up into no man's land and potentially into the enemy trenches. It's a variety of different missions, a ton of different random events, a campaign game where you can level up and your characters with experience if they survive on raids. A lot to look at. Let's jump in and get started. So, here's Trench Trade spread out in front of us. Let's do a quick overview of the game. So gameplay uh this is a soliter game. Now you could play it two player, three player cooperative, but the heart of it is really solitire and there really isn't a way to play this opposed. So solo war gamers, this is a game for you. Now the gameplay length, it mentions about 1 hour per raid and there is a campaign game that is uh a suggested length is five games, five raids long. So that would be 5 hours plus a little bit of time kind of managing the events between a raid. So probably about 6 hours if you want to do the full campaign game. Now, the historical length, each raid would perhaps taken several hours to complete, and that leads us to a turn length of probably five or 10 minutes per turn.
So, the unit scale is uh individual man, but uh and again, you have a 10man patrol. So, you're going to lose men. Men will get captured, incapacitated, wounded, sent home, they'll get killed, all kinds of things will happen. But the counters on the map is basically that your patrol moves as a unit. So the patrol is one thing on the map that has 10 single individual men in it. Let's talk a little bit about the key mechanics in the game. As we mentioned, the raid is the essential element of gameplay. And in your raiding team, you will have 10 men. Now, there are different raid types, a dozen altogether. So you what type of mission you're going to get is going to vary from one raid to the other. And a big part of gameplay are the random events that happen. We'll talk more about those as we look at the game in detail, but uh as you're exploring the map, stuff's going to happen, right? Um we mentioned the campaign game, which is suggested length is five raids long, and that connects immediately to the RPG elements of the game. Each of your individual soldiers has skills and stats in particular areas, things like courage and throwing and fighting and shooting and speed, and you're going to be assigning those at the beginning of your campaign. There are also special skills like pugilist and strongman and marksman and cricket player which enhances your throwing ability. There is a equipment element to the game. So things like gas masks and pistols and bags of grenades and wire cutters and trench periscopes and things that you're going to be bringing with you on the raid to help you accomplish your mission. Another big
part of the game is kind of the mapping fog of war uh exploration event as you're moving through No Man's Land. So, we can see the map down below, but there's also a lot of the hex's in the game are the types of specific terrain you encounter as you move through No Man's Lane, usually or sometimes trying to get to the enemy trenches. So, it could be wire, could be more trenches, it could be shattered forest, it could be destroyed buildings. And so, as you're exploring No Man's Land, you're running into different types of terrain and mapping that terrain as you go. Combat and most of the events and actions in the game are dice based. So, you're going to be throwing a certain number of dice depending upon your character's skill, looking for fives or sixes, which are successful roles, and there are levels of difficulties to the task as well. So, an easier task, you only need to get one success. A very difficult task. You might two might need two or three successes. Um, kind of influencing that is a luck system. So luck allows you to roll character dice rolls for a number of different times and you're going to be burning through that luck to avoid adverse events and also to be more successful on your missions. And lastly, there's a post raid stage if you're playing the campaign game where you're going to evaluate what happened to your patrol members that went missing or once they got wounded or they get sent home or they brought back into the patrol for subsequent raids. So a lot going on, a lot to look at. Let's jump in now and take a look at the rule book. Let's take a look at the rule book here. So this is 8 and 1 half x 11 glossy color. It's 32
pages, but that's a vast overstatement as the last dozen or so pages here are uh pictures of the soldier cards and then the counters and then there's example of play here. So it's really 24 pages of rules that you go through and a lot of the rules really are kind of event like some of the explanations for the various events. So these four pages for example in here are uh the examples of the kind of the the events that can happen on the main board and then there's what happens in enemy trenches. So a lot of kind of procedures and uh kind of processes that you do as different thing happen different things happen on your patrol. Altogether I would give this game complexity going to go probably a three out of 10. None of this stuff is hard. Um I read through probably 75% of the rules. I haven't read through all of the events yet, but I've read through about 75% of the rules and I really didn't have any questions as to how to execute any anything or wasn't confused by any of the verbiage.
So, I think it looks like a pretty clean rule set. And uh definitely not something that's going to be overly complex or get you bogged down in details. One of the things I am curious about as I do read through the rules is and this is kind of you something that often gets talked about with this type of soliter game where you're going to be doing particular missions is how much uh player agency do you have in the game and that by that we mean how much are you determining what happens in the outcome of the raid and how much of it is stuff just happens to you and I think there is definitely an element here of stuff just happens to you can have some bad luck and have some add events that happen and some things that you just the dice rolls go wrong. So, there certainly is going to be an element of of fate to this game. Although, kind of reading through it, it does look like you're going to have quite a few few interesting decisions to make along the way. It's really hard to say more about that until we dig in and to start to play the game. Let's take a look at our three counter sheets here. So, these are all single-sided. And the vast majority of them here, well, I guess there's double-sided element to this one small section, but most of them are single-sided here. And the vast majority of them are a hexagonal in shape, 5/8s of an inch across. And they're going to represent, as we talked about, that kind of mapping of the terrain as you're going through it. So, for example, if you encounter this shattered forest type of terrain here, as you go through this hex, you're going to be dropping it on there. So, your patrol is your raid is going to leave a trail of kind of mapped terrain as you go through this. So, here we can see some uh destroyed buildings,
some shattered forest, some trenches. This is I think a field. I'm not sure what this is. The field dressing station perhaps, but I'm not sure why there's so many machine gun nests. Uh open terrain. Here are the characters. Here are the square counters that are going to be for your individual soldiers. And you're going to put these in an order, your rating order. And so, you know, one guy's going to be one and then you're going to depending on what you know, different things can happen to different people in line as you encounter different random events. And then these other two sets are very similar mostly. Again, here this is all different terrain types. So, we got pill boxes, machine gun nests, I think there's a mortar station. Uh, here's some cuts in the wire. If you cut through the wire, a lot of wire, and then the whole last one here is all open terrain. So, a lot of the terrain that you encounter doesn't necessarily have a distinguishing feature. It's just open terrain, and you're going to move through it. So, in a lot of places, you're going to be dropping down these uh open hex's as you go through that. And so, those are basically the roughly 300 hex counters that are in the game. Really nice counter set. I love the kind of the brown element here. And just that I mean the you know when I think of World War I trench warfare I don't think of anything green left over and as we look kind of at the map which we'll take a look at in greater detail in the counters. It really feels like it's captured that dirt and mud element of World War I combat. So the game comes with 10 soldier mats. So uh basically five two one two to each piece of kind of stock cardboard here. And this is a very glossy type of cardboard. Uh and this is the NCO one and this is your officer.
Then we've got bombers and you've got bombers and riflemen. And you can designate you have a certain number of each type of soldier that you have to bring with you on a raid. And then these basically are the stat sheets, the RPG stat sheets for each one of these characters. And we can see over here, for example, on the left side, these are tracking, you know, hand wounds and chest wounds and armed wounds and foot wounds, and you can get wounded all different places. Uh raid objectives as to, you know, where your raids are going to be. Then tracking your serious wounds and light wounds and that can lead you if you know you get a number of light wounds you can get incapacitated. Then over here we have the stats. So the RPG elements speed, strength, courage, command, shoot, fight, throw, luck and then you can pick a special skill. And then wound. If you get wounded, those are going to modify those and reduce your ability to be successful on the battlefield pulling out the number of dice that you're going to be be able to throw there. And then down here you list what types of equipment you're bringing with you. Um, each character I can believe think brings five pieces with them unless you have a special skill which reduces your number of things you can bring down to four. And then luck points here are the ones that you have remaining and you're going to kind of erase those as you use them up. So if you have, you know, five luck points that gives you five times that you can make a roll of your dice. Now, the way this works, the game comes with one of these uh dry erase markers, and you mark down all these things on there and kind of then erase them with this little eraser in between missions in terms of the things that are temporary. U the game does also give you permission to photocopy these. I imagine that's
probably what I'll go through. I'm not a very big fan of dry erase markers, especially if you're going to play the campaign game that's going to last five events. I might try it to see how it works, but I'm kind of thinking that I'll probably print these out and do it on paper, pencil, pen for the more permanent things. Uh, but that's a look at these and we can see each one. They're very similar, just different graphics in terms of that. But you're going to be filling these out. You have a number of points that you can assign the soldier uh at the beginning of their career depending upon what their role is and then uh working them out as they go through. So, you're going to see some increases to luck over the course of a campaign that's going to make them be uh more successful and have more roles as they go deeper into the campaign. And of course, you're going to see some of these guys get killed, in which case you're going to get replacements coming up. This is probably a good time to chat differently, too, about the 12 different mission types. So, there's a lot of different mission types here. Some of them seem more dangerous than others.
You know, a couple here, like some of the simpler ones is lay a gap uh kind of cut a gap in the enemy wire. So, you got to go up to the the trench line right before the enemy lines and cut a gap. You got to lay tape. You might have to rescue a lost pilot, kill an enemy sniper, uh bomb the enemy dugout, uh raid the enemy headquarters, capture an officer or um kind of ID enemy units by bringing back insignia and kind of uh yeah, the basically uniform elements that were going to help you to identify what units are in the enemy trenches. So, and that's not all of them. There's others, too. So, a good variety of mission types. Some I think are going to kind of like destroy and raid an enemy headquarters. That sounds pretty dangerous. So, I think it's going to be fun. I can see some of those missions. Definitely part of the fun of this game, I think, is going to be when things go sideways on some of the harder missions, too. There are a few other player aids.
Mostly, you have kind of a compilation here on these three single-sided player aids of a lot of the different charts and dice rolls that you're going to be making that are in the rule book. So, they've pulled those out and put them on three very handy player aids. You know, wound location, wound severity. This is all about wounds. Then we've got carry, wounded men back, if you're going to leave a man behind, what happens to that? Uh medical aid and success. What happens to blinded men? And then this is uh for events in no man's land rolling up as to what types of events you're going to be getting in no man's land. And again, all of these are single-sided. Then this is fantastic because I've played games before that don't have this. Uh, you know, this is an event driven game and there are two different categories of events. There's events you can run into when you're in no man's land and then there's a whole different number of events and types of events you can run into when you're in enemy trenches. Usually, when you play games like this, there's constant looking back into the rule book to find the descriptions and what you do for the different events that are happening here. But, they've pulled those out and put the 20 different events that can happen here when you're in no man's land all on this uh this one single player aid. Likewise, for the events and trenches, there's a smaller number for trench events. There are uh what looks like eight different types of events here for in the trenches. But again, they've pulled all of that information out here into one single player aid, so you don't have to constantly go rulebook diving. So, I really like this. I think this is going to really speed up gameplay and make finding events uh easier. The last thing to mention with player aids is there is a little bit there's an arrata sheet in here uh clarifications really most in all just a
number of small clarifications on the rules uh if and get that they have kind of tweaked since the the final production here mentioned that a lot of the actions are dice based so you know you're rolling for the the events in no man land are going to use this 20sided die and all of your skill-based actions are going to use these six-sided dice so it comes with a bucket of dice that you'll be able to use to execute all of those dice rolls and lastly our 17x 22 in map. Now, this is a vertical map. The bottom is over here on the left. I've just turned it horizontal so that we can see it a little bit closer detail on a video screen here. This uh we can see in the bottom here, this is the British flag. So, we represent, of course, British raiders. And these are the home trenches. Then this all area in here is no man's land. And eventually you run over here to the enemy trenches. And there are three layers to enemy trenches. There's the front trench, then the support trench, and then the farthest one on the right here is the reserve trench. number of tables kind of surrounding the area here to kind of uh kind of make the the high frequency roll die rolls. You won't have to look those up on tables or dive into the rule book for that. And we can see a lot of cratered terrain here. But as you're going through the cratered train, I don't believe you roll for events uh for terrain types there. You're not mapping that. That's already known. It's these open hexes that you're you're mapping as you go through those. Now, we've talked a little bit about the different events that are in the game. Um the again the two different types. So, I want to talk a little bit about some of the ones that are out there in no man's land cuz it's kind of an interesting list. We can have artillery. You can run into an enemy dog. There could be enemy raiders. Gas.
You could find a listening post. You could find a sniper. Star shells. You could find a one of your men could go missing. You can get lost. You could hit a swarm of rats. And I understand rats were a very sanitation in general was a horrible problem in World War I. Uh you could have run into some wounded men, either enemy or friendly, and have to decide what to do with them. Get a mortar nest, a machine gun nest. Oh, these are on the enemy trenches. Mortar nest, machine gun nest, a field dressing station or communications trench. So, a lot of different variety of things that can happen here, which makes me think that the replayability and the depth and the sense of narrative that this game can generate sounds really enticing. I mean, again, the real test is let's play it and let's see what it looks like uh and feels like as you go through this. But I get a sense that it's really going to spin a lot of narratives and uh create some really memorable stories as you're kind of leading your men through these the various raids in a campaign.
So, uh solitary rating of course for this one would be a 10 out of 10. Oh, should probably also mention victory conditions. Raids either are successful successes or failures, right? You have a certain mission to execute and either you successfully complete that mission or you don't. Um the there are also factors in for the campaign game as to whether a a soldier survives the campaign or whether a replacement soldier survives the campaign, whether they are mentioned in dispatches. If you do something particularly heroic, you'll get mentioned in the war dispatches heading back towards the homeront. And then you get a certain number of points at the end. And rather than putting that on an overall, you know, strategic victory type of scale, it basically says that's the the level of success that you had in this particular campaign. I think that's everything I've wanted to say about this one. I will be creating a gameplay video for this. So, I'll put a link to that as soon as it's ready. And I'd be happy to entertain questions about this game as uh as you have them there. I I understand I think my rough understanding of this is that there will be a some sort of uh Compass Games crowdfunding campaign for this one at some point in the near future. Um I'll add a link to the video description once details on that are clear. Thanks for watching everybody. Have a great day.