Skip to main content
Loading video...

Gretchen's Garden Review: Everything's Coming up Gretchen

Transcript 12:08

Full disclosure, I am a terrible gardener. I have the blackest thumb you've probably ever seen in your life. So, when this one came across the office here, a game about gardening where I can do what I love, grow succulents, have a great garden, but it doesn't require actually watering the plants or knowing anything about them, I was super intrigued. I really like the look of it. It's going to be card game, which I I like that drafting element as well, quick simple turns. Let's take a look at how to play. This how to play is going to be a very brief overview. I will not be going into all the details and nuances, edge cases, or really going over the entire rule book. Just a brief overview for you to get an idea of the flow of the game, so you'll understand my thoughts, which we'll talk about next. Let's get going.

In Gretchen's Gardens, we are going to be individual gardeners here who are building up our collection of succulents. We're going to play over the course of 12 rounds. Each round is going to have its own weather card, which is over here. So, essentially, you're just going to play through this deck, but that means there are 12 rounds in the game. Each round, you are going to get one action, at which afterwards, we will have a cleanup phase, and then go into the next round. After 12 rounds, we'll go through and we're going to score each color of plant and all the plant growth, and then highest points will win. So, if it So, let's take a look at what a round looks like. This here is set up almost. You do start with two money. So, the money that you have is on your money plant, and it can hold a maximum of four. Each of the pots are going to have the maximum that is going to be up here.

So, you can see our money plant, which is going to be the currency of the game, can hold a maximum of four. So, to start the game, let's say I'm first player here, and on each round, you are going to first have a action phase. In this action phase, you get to perform one of four actions. So, you can buy from the shop up here. On the right side, you can buy a new pot, which there is a cost associated for each card. And on the left side, you can get a different flower, which again, you're going to have the cost on the bottom. If you buy a a plant up here, you would just take the plant, you pay the growth from your money money tree back to the supply, and you put it on a pot like this. If you would get a pot, then you're going to take a pot, and it is going to push your starting plant or your starting pot out one and take the outmost spot. In subsequent rounds, if you buy another pot, then same thing. It pushes that starting one out, and it is going to go right there. Now, let's say that I had from a previous round that I had a um let's say a plant in my starting pot.

You'll notice the same thing happens. That pot is going to go out, and you're going to replace it. You're going to repot that plant. Because when you come home from the store with a fancy new plant or a fancy new pot, you want to put your plant in it, right? You don't want to keep that old one. So, thematically, there you go. That's how I I kind of remember that rule. So, you're going to either buy a a plant or a pot. That is one of the actions you can do. Another action you can do is to cut another player's plant. So, let's say that somebody else has this snake plant over here, and I'll just pretend the player is there. And let's say that it has three growths on it. Of course, it would be potted in in their area. When I cut their plant, I would take one of the growths, and it turns back into water and goes into their their watering can, not my own. Goes into their watering can, and then I get to take one of these from the supply, one of the extra, and pot it anywhere in my in my um my own tableau here, okay? So, I'd get to pot it. That is how you cut. So, you take one of the growths, and it goes in back into their watering can, and then you take one from the supply. You cannot cut if a plant has been flowered. All right. So, so that would effectively lock that down. That's the only kind of exception there to that. So, that's how you cut.

The other thing you can do is to tend. When you tend, you take two water from the supply and add it to your watering can. Then you can take all the all the water from your watering can and put it out into your your um tableau here, out into your pots. So, you can tend. After you tend and you do the water or before, you can also replant. So, let's say I want to pull this one up and put it over here and I want to pull this one up and put it here because now I have matching uh pot and plant color. That'll come in handy here just a minute. So, you get to do two moves of displacement and you get to water your plants by getting two from the supply and then watering. You can do those two actions in any order. That's going to be 10. The final action you can do is you can uh flower your plant. In order to flower your plant, there has to be a couple things. It has to be in a matching pot of its color and the flower has to still be available over here in the shared tableau. If that's the case, then you can take that flower and you would flower that. This plant is now locked down, meaning I can no longer water and and add growth to that plant.

It also means that nobody can cut that plant. It's locked down. So, on your turn, you're going to do one action and then it's the next person's turn. After everyone does one of those four actions, we're going to move on to the weather phase. In the weather phase, you're going to collect water equal to the current weather phase. So, in this case, two. We would take two and I can place these anywhere out in my tableau, any pot that has a flower on it. So, here I could place it in this one. I I'm sorry, and has a flower in it. So, I could place it here, I could place them here, or I could place it on my money tree. Uh if if I can't place them where I don't want to place them out there, I can also always just put it in my watering can and collect that for a future round. In this case, let's say that I want to put one here and then I want to put one into the money plant.

After we do the weather phase, then we go into the growth phase. In the growth phase, any pot that is full will then I wouldn't have been able to have those there cuz it doesn't have a plant in it. So, any any of them that are full, let's say it's like this, then they would become growth. So, those would grow up like that. That is going to be the growth phase if it has matched its capacity. Finally, we're going to go into a cleanup phase. All of these cards are going to slide down. We would refill the market. We flip over the weather deck for the next round. So, you'll see you can always see what's coming up the next round and the first player marker is going to move to the next player.

From there, we start at the top. We go through the action phase, weather phase, growth phase, and cleanup phase. We're going to do that 12 times. Again, running this deck out, at which case we go to the scoring phase. In the scoring phase, you're going to count one point for each growth on a plant. Then, you're going to get seven points for each flower. Each of the different colors you will score in their own ways. So, for example, here looking at the snake plant, it's going to be worth five points if it holds as many leaves as the pot allows. So, it's in this pot, that'd be six. I would not get the five points for that. Uh the green is not going to have a special scoring ability. It just allows you to have six additional leaves. So, in this case, it can have two plus six is going to be able to hold eight. Each of these the plants are going to have a different way to score. You'll score those and then get two points per pot in your collection. Add all those up, the highest points are going to win. That's going to do it for Gretchen's Garden.

First up is the aesthetics of this game. I really like it. I do think it is very stylistic and I could see why people might not like it, but for me, I found it to be very charming look. It's very instantly approachable in that look. I love the idea of the different pots, and you're just using everything from a tomato can to an old boot, you know, I think that brings a fun style to it. Um one thing I didn't go over in the overview is the different ways to score. I showed you one of the sets, and of course I didn't go over over every flower, but I do want to point out that it does come with two different sets, an A set and a B set. That's nice for variability, and inevitably, I like one more than the other. Um but so I'm glad that it's there, and eventually, you can kind of mix match those as well. So, it has quite a bit of variability in that scoring. It didn't need to be in there like that, but I'm definitely glad it has it.

This game is deceptively short. In one way, that's a good thing, right? The The turns are going to be really quick. You do one action on your turn, and then it's the next player's turn. And almost all the time, ahead unless somebody takes that card you want or something like that, you know what you're going to do that round. I like that a lot, but that means in the entire game, you're only taking 12 actions. So, it's short, and it's quick, it's snappy, which is great, but it also it's just not much. It doesn't feel like you're doing a whole lot in the game. It means one round is going to be sometimes be 2 minutes if everyone gets to do exactly what they want. On that note, it's just the game length. The box says it's going to be 45 minutes. I played a three-player game where everyone knows how to play, and we played it in under 20 minutes. It's not 45 minutes unless you are really taking your time, playing a full four-player game, or that first time you're playing, because I do think that the rules are tricky, or finicky, I guess I should say. There's a lot of just weird kind of rules that are not very intuitive. Even after multiple plays of this game, when I was teaching a new group, I would pull out the player aid and have to go line by line and pull out the rulebook again. Hold on, let me make sure that I get this right. Once you get the game down after a couple plays, it's, like I said, quick, snappy, um really quick decisions and turns.

But it does take that full three plays. The first play, I feel like I was in the rulebook a whole lot, which for a four-page leaflet, it was just too much time in the rulebook to really understand the nuance of this game. So, I would no by no means call it cozy, which is what the the box and the playtime and the player age is going to make going to make me think it's going to be. I wouldn't call it cozy because there's too much of a learning curve for that first and second play. But then when you finally get it, you almost feel like, why can I not remember this? But it's it's the little things like if you cut someone's plant, where does that water go? Um which cards move out when you bring another pot in? Is it the whole thing? Okay, no. Which pots are going to change colors? It's only if it's in the base pot that if that one moves, it's just kind of funky.

Which in a lot of ways is good because that makes it stand out and it's unique, but it it feels more finicky and clunky in that uniqueness than an actual positive charm. So, ultimately, I'm going to come down at a six on this game. I think it is perfectly pleasant is the best way I can put it. I wouldn't mind playing it, but I have a hard time recommending it because I don't think it's very first game user-friendly. And then, once you do kind of get into it, you're like, oh, yeah, that was cute, that was fine. It's never going to like blow your socks off. But um but I also don't mind playing. So, for that, I come down at a six. I think it's perfectly pleasant, but not one that I'm generally going to recommend. That's going to be Gretchen's Garden. Thanks for joining me here today at the Dice Tower. I'm Camilla. We'll see you next time.

Hey folks, thanks for watching another one of our videos. If you like our videos, if you like our channel, you would love to game with us at one of our conventions. Check out Dice Tower Cruise, Dice Tower East, and Dice Tower West. Fantastic conventions where we play games with wonderful people, a humongous library, and lots of other events and stuff. Also, don't forget to check out our channel. Like and subscribe. I'm Tom Vasel.

Progress saved