Puerto Rico Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm talking about Puerto Rico by Andrea Seyfarth now this is a board game for 2 to 5 players takes about 90 minutes to play and dates back to 2002 now Puerto Rico was an extremely influential game on the hobby it was ranked number one on BoardGameGeek for many years so it was very highly regarded and I've critically acclaimed and considering was 18 years old and this game is still in the top 25 games and then I think that's a pretty impressive feat now obviously the objective of the game is to get as many victory points as possible it's a euro style game and the kind of theme or the idea is that everybody or every player involved has their own kind of bit of Puerto Rico and you're trying to kind of colonize that area by you know planting plantations building factories I'm getting colonists to trying to produce goods and try to ship those goods off to get victory points Puerto Rico has a very kind of unique filter or a unique vibe where not only do you have to look after yourself quite obviously trying to get as many victory points as you can for each of your actions you're going to be very worried about what you do because every uh kind of actions you take you've got to be careful about how well your kind of opponents are going to benefit off taking that action because the game uses this kind of very clever action selection mechanism which is actually one of my favorite mechanisms in all board games and I think it kind of stems back to Puerto Rico as a kind of as a kind of foundation for that
mechanism where you have a bunch of kind of role cards and you're going to select one of them when it's your turn but you're not going to be the only one who takes it every other player is going to get to take that action as well but the benefit by taking action is that you're going to get a kind of a unique or a kind of small or amplified version of the action so for example one of the actions is to take buildings or to build a new building by paying coins and if you are the person to choose that role then you're going to get a building at a discount so you've got to be as efficient as possible and it really is a game about nuances because the margins for error are very kind of or should I say the margins to gain more than your opponents are very kind of marginal and you've got to be very kind of you know exploit every single point you can get out of this one which is a different vibe and it's not it's not a particularly swingy game you know you've got to be very careful and very calculated about how you're going to gain even if it's slightly more than your opponents do each turn so the game is had boiled into that very simple mechanism about choosing one of those role cards and I've already covered one of them which is to build one of the new buildings and these buildings are extremely useful because they can really take you down a different path than your opponents they're all very powerful obviously have different kind of costs depending on how beneficial they are and they all have victory points associated to them for in-game scoring and they do all kinds of different things such as you know increasing your kind of capacity for storing things or making things more
profitable when you sell them in the market or what maybe building factories to kind of combine with your plantations so you can actually manufacture the goods in the first place and all kind of things like that so another action you can take is to I think it's called the mayor where you can take new colonists from the from the boat and add them to your plantation or to your to your region and you can apply them to your factories and your your plantations and for every kind of combination of the two you have you can produce goods so also having workers in these different places is very important because without the workers then you're you're not going to be able to do very much at all and but the benefit by taking actions that you get to take one more worker than the other players so again very useful and that can be that a small margin to be very very young you know beneficial long-term another one is simply to take money another one is to sell goods and if you choose that towel then um you get to sell for kind of I think a one more profit than you'd normally get and the market as well as quite interesting because once you sell one type of good nobody else can sell that type of good so again you can be very careful about when you're going to use it you know spruce up if I had a coffee and everybody else has coffee and I'm the first to choose it I might choose to sell my coffee for you know a good profit but then nobody else could sell their coffee and they'd have to sell somewhere cheaper or maybe get shut out of selling anything at all so again very very good very careful what other players are capable of at all times another thing you can do is that
you can buy plantations or or just pick up plantations which is added to your kind of filled area which basically determines which you can which kind of goods you can produce and you've got like your indigo you've got corn which is the actual only good that doesn't require a correlating factory with it so while it's the cheapest it's very useful because you don't have to you know you don't have to have a complete accompanying factory to go with it and ultimately when you sell everything using the captain action all the goods are worth the same so the only kind of benefit of having the more expensive Goods is that they're going to be worth more when you sell them but in addition to that when you do sell or when you do ship off goods for a victory points the obviously depending on the play account is going to be a limited amount of boats available and only certain type of goods or only one unique good can go on each each boat so if I had indigo and the person to my left had corn so I load all my indigo into one boat the next person loads all their corn and then the person after that might not have any corn or indigo and have only got tobacco for example and then they've got nowhere to load their goods at all so they're going to get completely shut out of that action so again all about being aware of what you can do and how you're going to benefit that margin more than your opponents can on each and every turn and that's basically how the game is going to go you're going to all take a pic of your role card one after one or take the
action and all to try and produce as much good as possible and ship them off on these boats but you've got to be very careful because after every time you use that captain action or somebody uses it all of your goods apart from one are going to be discarded and that or that's if you don't have the relevant warehouses to store your surplus goods so again you can be very clever about when you're going to ship stuff off when you know your opponent has got a lot of things stored up and just completely make them throw all the way which can be pretty nasty but you know sometimes you need to do that it order to win the game so yeah I love the the simplicity and how the the depth of the game is boiled down into such clean-cut role choices and you're always involved in every choice because you know if someone chooses something you're still going to get to do the action you've got to be kind of aware of what you think other players will do at the same time as well because if it's your go and you want kind of want to do two things but you're confident that the person to your you know another player is going to choose they all kind of your secondary option then you can kind of you know cater your strategy to your needs and just hope or you know make an edge two educated guess about what other roles players are going to choose and also player order is very important as well so you've got about all these different things in mind when somebody's selecting a role card I don't think that's interesting as well is that when all the different or every players taken an action and all the role cards that
aren't used acquire a coin on top of them as well which makes them a lot more kind of them you know it makes the incentive to pick them up in future rounds a lot kind of stronger because money is a very strong resource in this game and it's extremely useful for building up your engine you know trying to get all those really powerful juicy buildings which are very scarce because there's not going to be enough kind of duplicate buildings for everybody so if somebody buys I'm a certain type of building you might be completely shut out of getting that type of burden which can be very devastating to your plans you know if you don't have the warehouses you're going to have to be very careful about not storing up too much goods some of the buildings are so interesting such as you've got the wharf which kind of lets you have your own dock when you can sell stuff and not be so dependent on what's available on the boats you know you've got things that let you kind of automatically take colonists when you take your quarries and buildings you've got the big buildings which are endgame scoring which can kind of give you bonus points based on whether you have a certain amount of colonists or and for every point you've acquired you get another amount of points or stuff like that so you've got the points from the buildings you've got points from selling stuff and you've got the points from the end games going from the large building so a lot of things you can kind of focus on and you can do well by focusing all the different strategies but I think having you're having an interest and all these different kind of ways to get points is is the key to victory in this game but yeah so mechanically this game is is absolutely faultless it works so
well so smoothly it's easy to digest and it just ticks along very nicely the balance of the game is wonderful again it's going to be something to wrap your head around for new players I think more kind of Savia more experienced players are going to pretty much run away with the game in terms of it you know of winning for those initial players but once you get your head around how the game works and if you're playing the game with you know people with equal experience you're going to have a very balanced and unfair game every time it's home investment as well is very good there's literally no scope to lose interest here because you're always invested in what other people are going to do about what actually want to take and when play a water all that different stuff it's all keeping you engaged at all times and there is very little downtime anyway replayability wise you know there's always going to be the building's going to be taken to different orders you're going to have to be forced to do different things and try different things each time you know you might want to get a kind of a stronghold on a certain type of resource and maybe shut out other players of that market so when you do put when you do use that captain action to sell your goods you can kind of make sure that you're the only person who can load stuff onto that boat and you know secure yourself that way so it's about finding little gaps in the market and exploiting them which is really useful and it's going to basically tail it or force you to tailor your strategy to how the other players are behaving each time so always going to be something else to explore I'm
going to have a different vibe every time you play interaction is brilliant in this game I mean the new answers between how everything comes together and how you're going to use things is is what this game is all about and there's although that is they're very kind of you know there is a touch of meanness and you know spiteful you know interaction in the game I wouldn't say it's too much I mean you not directly smashing other people's things there's no you know there's no to destroy other people's buildings really think that it's about being clever and savvy and knowing how to exploit the situation to your benefit and to UM hinder your opponent's aesthetically this game looks very basic I'll be honest this isn't a lair production which generally is very kind of functional and you know nothing will be on that list no there's not really any bells or whistles that being said I think we you know that the tiles are stuff are pretty clear of what they do you know there's not too much it's not too much more digging every time or anything like that it's it's very functional basic components you know the cardboard is pretty flimsy the game looks pretty beige and dull I suppose if you're if this isn't your cup of tea you normally into your kind of high production it's going to look quite boring but for me it's got a kind of a a bit of a charm to it and I think it's that that retro feel does the shine through but ultimately I think the the gameplay Trump's the visual appeal to it but I suppose if you had a nicer production of it then then you know that
would that would help so know production-wise it's it's it's functional but pretty basic and theme-wise I actually do like the way the theme works I think it works and comes together very nicely you know bringing in the colonists to into your plantations know getting the plantations filling up your factories shipping them off for profit I do like the way everything works but I think there is a bit of a stigma with this game with the whole kind of colonists kind of theme to it you know the exploitation of slaves and stuff like that I personally for me it's a board game it doesn't really need to delve into that territory so I'll leave it at that and you know you can have your own opinions but personally I think it works well assess up and tear down time as well I mean there's a lot of different building and stuff which do take a bit of a bit of time to get everything in position in that kind of communal board but you know the game is more than warrants to set up is there's not too much and it's not it's not a barrier to entry to playing the game so I love the way the game ramps up as the game game goes on you get more kind of powerful with you acquire these buildings you produce more and more and more you feel like you're doing more on each time which is always important for a euro game the game scales very well it works all player counts and because of the way they're the wrong selection works everybody's always engaged and something I'm quite surprised on is the game actually works really well at two players I think initially the game wasn't recommended for three for anything below three players and I don't even think the original version had a I'll had that kind of option in the rulebook but I had played the game with
two players and it works extremely well just the role selection works little it's slightly different where you take a few roles each each round so yeah don't be concerned it does work very well the two players and I work all the way perfectly well up to five players and and in comparisons to other games I mean I can't quite put my finger on anything this is quite like obviously there are a lot of other games that use the role selection mechanism but I have not used them in such a euro kind of capacity you know games like Twilight Imperium music I think in Rising Sun used it there's but yeah that mechanism is something I absolutely love and would love to see it more and more and more yeah overall this game is an outstanding design it is wonderfully just creative and everything forges really well and player interaction is fantastic you're always going to be engaged just paint your things to think about you're going to want to do lots of different things at the same time which you can't sometimes you're going to feel you know slighted and frustrated about what other peoples have picked but you're going to do the same to them the game lasts I think the perfect amount of time it's an hour stays welcome and again it's all about the nuances there really aren't that many games out there I suppose I'll rephrase that by saying all games are obviously subjective to how good they are everybody's going to have their own opinions and tastes and stuff like that but I think there are a few games out there that are objectively extremely well designed and just brilliant for me poor Pato Rico is one of those
objectively brilliant games it is just an absolute masterpiece on how it's come together and you know there's a reason why it's stayed relevant for so long and you know for a games of 18 years old to still be I think it's ranked number 23 on BoardGameGeek is you know it is not that something like that doesn't happen for no reason and you know playing it myself now I can completely see why or all the buzz about this game has been so strong for so long it really is a game to sink your teeth into it's going to be reward or it's going to reward a repeated plays as you get better and more savvy about how when in when and where you use your actions I think the barrier to entry is surprisingly low compared to something of this complexity so again it's a game of deep or it's very deep game but we're very low kind of fiddly las' or you know it's not got too much many complications but it's got a lot of nuances and and stuff like that so yeah this is a game that just sings to me I've really enjoyed my place there I'm extremely Cavuto exploring it more at all the different player counts trying different things trying the different buildings and yeah this is a fantastic game so definitely check this one out if you haven't I mean most eurogamer's have played to Porto Rico but I was kind of kind of late late to the party I guess I've only kind of recently picked this one up but yeah really enjoying it so far and it gets an amazing rating from me which is an 8.5 out of 10 but I
suppose I'm still pretty new to this game I've got a lot more to explore with it but I can see this one going up and creeping up maybe into my top top tier of games so that's Puerto Rico definitely a classic and just a brilliant design so that concludes my review of Puerto Rico if you have enjoyed it please hit like and subscribe my channel and check out my other videos too for ever now so I'll see you next time on chairmen of the board bye