Skip to main content
Loading video...

Gunkimono Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 12:06

hey everyone today I'm taking a look at gunam mono which is a two to five player tile placement board game designed by Jeffrey Alice and published by Renegade this one takes 45 minutes to an hour to play on average uh before I get into my review of gunam mono I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor k.c. who am I go to online retailer here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so the main board for gunam mono is going to look like this which is essentially split into two halves uh the right hand side of the board here is where you're going to be playing your tows into trying to score victory points by connecting groups of colors together and in the left hand side you're going to be trying to climb these tracks to get these pagodas down and potentially score victory points when you reach the absolute Pinnacle there's going to be a number of tiles which are going to be um determined depending on the player count so the fewer the players the fewer the tiles going to be used in the game and somewhere towards the bottom of the stack there there is going to be an endgame trigger tile each player is going to get given five of these independent um little tiles here these little single pieces which they can choose to use throughout the game but generally the tiles are going to look like this and each player is going to get given three at random to start with and you can see each half of these tiles almost like a Domino um has one of the colors depicted on it so the objective of the game of course is to score as many victory points as you can and

essentially you're going to get points in one of three different ways so on a player's turn you are going to choose one of your starting tiles let's just say I chose this one here without thinking too much about it and I'm going to place it somewhere on this bit here so what I'm essentially trying to do is trying to create groups of the same color orthogonally so let's just say I did um let's say I did this like so now the only restriction is that you cannot cover exactly over the um the color beneath it so I could not do that because this one and this one are identical but I could do this now the reason I've done that is to try and create the group of oranges here so I've got a group of three therefore that would give me three victory points however if you don't want to do it like that I could choose to take these Pagoda symbols and climb up the track here so let's go back to the T I've just placed so my two options are or I've got multiple options are to take the three points or to climb up to up the pagota track of that matching color so the orange track that one so I could go like this or I could get the two points here by matching these two kind of Samurai symbols together or potentially climb up one up that um Pagoda track so let's just say um I took the two pagodas here and I took two victory points here and once you've placed your tile you're going to replenish your hand back up to three from the supply there and then going to of course fill that Supply back up with another tile from the stack now

throughout the game you can also choose to play these single tiles as I explained before you can either expand an existing region so maybe I want to put these archers here now i' have a group of four alternatively um of course as more tiles are placed you're going to start stacking these tiles and the way this works is that you can vertically well you can put them on top like this but you can also use them as a kind of a bit of scaffolding I suppose by putting them face down and then placing another tole on top like so so we've talked about why we might want to place these Tils and line them up to get victory points because you can see here um as the game developed you can end up getting quite a chunk of points like you got all these archers lined up that's 1 2 3 four five six seven points or with a single placement and potentially more than that if I managed to connect these up as well so it very quickly starts building on each other and you get more and more points but let's talk about why you might want to go up the Pagoda track here so as I said in in well by forsaking those victory points you can choose to climb up these tracks here by going up this certain color now when you move all your pieces up to certain points in the game like for example in a three playay game once I get all my markers to this row then I get to place one of my pagodas on the board what I'll do is I'll choose one of the spots so it'll be silly of me not to put one here right now now what this means is that this region now belongs to me and what that means in addition to that is that I cannot choose to take points by placing

on that region anymore and neither can anybody else so by placing archers here would be completely void um because you're not going to get the points at least not instantly however and once I place my tile any Pagoda I have is going to give me a number of points based on the surface area of that symbol So Not only would I get to place my tile potentially get the points of a place and climb up the tracks if I wanted to I will also get the output based on the surface area of this type so I'd get that 1 2 3 4 5 6 seven points at the end of my turn just passively and when you start climbing and climbing you can potentially unlock your second Pagoda and when you reach the Pinnacles of these columns then you can get these Victory Point tokens which will range depending on how quick you get there so you can see here that the first one of each type is going to be worth anywhere between 11 and 15 points on the reverse side and but if you kind of dragging Hills and don't get there very quickly then the bottom one will get you between one and five victory points okay so let's share some thoughts on gunam mono and for me the standout thing about this game is how simple that turn structure is just play one of your Tils either take the points or the honor points to climb the tracks and then you're essentially done you know just replenish your hand and move on so if you you know if you regularly watch my content you'll probably know that I'm a big fan of Simplicity and elegance in games and this game is pretty much Elegance personified little to no rules bloat whatsoever very straightforward rules that anybody can comprehend and

understand and I do quite like that concept of what do I want do I want to just keep on compounding on those existing areas um and getting points now or am I going to forsake that to climb the track which will probably help me in the long term a bit better but bearing in mind that if I'm keep expanding these regions I might not be the first person to get the Pagoda there meaning that I'll create quite a strong ticking point for somebody else to keep kind of reaping the benefits from all the effort from the other players I also really enjoy the 3D aspect to the tile placement it's generally a mechanism I like you know a lot of my favorite tile placement games have that 3D element to it you know talking games like know ginopolis games like Acropolis even miabi this one has that so it adds a whole new dimension to the game you know literally um so you're not just spreading out but spreading upwards as well and that also kind of ties into the usage of these single tiles these are very useful tools because not only are they worth two big odas but they can very kind of precisely sneak into an area and just increase the points massively you know if I wanted to sneak my archer in there all of a sudden that will connect these archers to it and it' be worth even more points so you can use them a lot but Additionally you can actually use them as the balancing Shield or The Point to stack the other tiles on if you want to know prevent overhang which is obviously going to be a rule breakage so yeah I like the use of that and you have to use these quite you know quite Sav to get the most from them and despite me really enjoying and praising that simple turn structure and the Elegance of it for me that's pretty much where the positives end so

initially I thought that this game was going to be one of those games with a simple rule set but with a ton of hidden depth to it and on reflection and as I've played this more and more I don't think that actually is the case because this is so transparent and Abstract in its nature there is actually an optimal play each time and it's just going to be a matter of how long are you willing to spend at this board to find the optimal play to play the tile now some people are going to enjoy that but for me that is not actually where the gameplay lies and that isn't actually playing a game it's just a a matter of you know searching through the tiles or searching through the squares and finding what's the best place for me to play doing that constant mental arithmetic decide this is the most optimal Place therefore I will score the most points if I place it here and on top of that I thought the decisions were pretty obvious because you're probably just going to keep on adding to the biggest region again and again until some places their first Pagoda the person who places their first Pagoda is obviously going to put it on the biggest region um so it's quite formulaic in that path um you know the second person is going to place it on the second biggest region and then as soon as that biggest region is established everybody's going to spend all their efforts to keep attacking the runway leader because if you got a massive surface area and you're just passively getting 20 points per turn obviously you're going to spend your turn to break up that region as much as possible by you know splitting up and creating smaller and smaller surface areas and unfortunately because of that I don't think the decisions are really here and it does make the game feel quite repetitive and formulaic the time investment and up time are generally okay you know you are

looking at 45 minutes to an hour to play this one maybe a little bit longer than I would have liked you know 30 minutes would probably be a bit more you know to my favor um but it's definitely not one of those games that's going to go on you know Way Beyond its welcome and uptime as well is generally not too bad providing that you're not going to be too anal about getting the exact right spot and just keeping it moving along at a nice Pace the game also scales pretty well because depending on the play count the pagas are going to be put in different spaces the bonus tiles are going to be put in different spaces as well so that is all tailored towards you know how many people you're playing with I'm generally happy with the production of the game you know all the tiles are of a good quality they're nice and robust I think the game is nice and bright to look at quite an attractive game in its entirety really and all the wooden pieces feel good they're nice and chunky and like these little markers they're quite nicely cved and things so I've got no issue at all the production and in fact I think it's spot on for what the game is trying to do and be okay so let's share some final thoughts on gunam mono so initially as you know not to repeat myself too many times but I definitely thought this was going to be one of those games that is going to be simple to learn but difficult to master and that's turned out not to be the case with this game at all now each time I've played it I'm thinking to myself am I missing something here or are the decisions very obvious and that's even content out in the scoring because I've played very relaxed at times just shoving toes down without thinking much and I've ended up doing really well and winning the game um so it's like yeah I don't think I am missing anything unfortunately and I

think there's a veil here that makes you think there's more going on than that actually is that being said there is quite a lot of upside here you know I do like that multi-layer tile placement I love the idea of establish establishing these regions and then getting these ticking points that's really cool but the problem is you're always going to follow that same routine of just the first person getting the Pagoda is going to shove their Pagoda down in the bills region then everybody else is going to attack it and then it's going to be a constant bash the leader game and you're going to follow that process each time you play this one so unfortunately I don't think the replayability is really there I've probably played this one five times or so and each time or each game has felt pretty much copy and paste from the last one so there isn't really that breadth of options and each game is going to feel you know pretty much identical from the last so needless to say um I'm not going to recommend this game I think there's too many great Tire placement games out there even from the same designer you know Jeffrey Alice is a great designer and he's made fantastic Tire placement games such as citrus which is one of my favorites and for me gunam mono pears in comparison to a game like that but again if you love your pure abstracts not pure abstracts but close to Pure abstracts when for you it doesn't feel like work and it feels like fun in order to get that optimal placement each time then maybe give this one a look because it is clean and it works but yeah for me the fun wasn't quite there and the decisions were pretty much paint by numbers and that are my final thoughts on gunam mono

Progress saved