Skip to main content
Loading video...

On Mars: Alien Invasion - Discussion

Transcript 25:45

thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for the on uh the Alien Invasion expansion fort on Mars This is specifically going to be going over the Cooperative uh version uh if you watch the run through we did the outbreak chapter and a few years back I did on Mars for the channel as a solo variant but I played it with a buddy of mine right so we actually played it cooperatively then because prior to that we had played on Mars multiple times but always felt that it's like this feels like it should be cooperative right a lot of the mechanisms and the competitive are like well I can use your attacks I can use your buildings like if I have a scientist right um so you share a lot but it's still Whoever has the most points so it's like well why go through the rigmarole and you're paying them but it's never a lot yeah we use someone else's stuff it's like you don't even really pay them it's just you get a win from the supply like I don't have to pay you anything if you use a scientist on someone else they can take that executive Action for free as well so but again it's still one of those things it's like it's weak on the call like um it doesn't cost me almost anything to do it right it's like it's one of those I mean it is a nice element of on Mars because it is a very tight game that you could it'd be this this game would

be awful if people could gridlock tax oh I'm going first I get this only I can build you know it's like that would be super shitty so when this expansion was announced I was very excited because I was like oh yeah perfect okay a Cooperative expansion that makes sense but then he made it somewhat Cooperative right where chapter one is one verse many and then chapter two and three are cooperative and then chapter four is solo right don't care much for the Cooperative nope I did uh I agree with you I thought I was going to enjoy the Cooperative more because I felt the same way um I mean I get the kind the conceptual is you're all buying for what I call power Prestige Point opportunity points yeah which makes sense so you you're still cooperating with each other but it's that Vibe for power inside a corporate office right yeah um whoever's gonna step on the others to climb the corporate ladder right yeah and that's what the base game felt like to me um but the Cooperative it felt like we knew exactly what we needed to accomplish yeah I knew how to accomplish it from the beginning of the game and it was mostly just managing the resources to accomplish the goal right yeah so here's here's where I'm at I think

and I mean call me biased or whatever I think if you want to play this cooperatively play the solo variant with someone else right I mean because here's why I actually don't like the expansion the theme of it there being an outbreak whatever so like I actually the first version chapter one is about someone playing aliens attacking right and it's like I feel like that would have been a lot more fun Cooperative right why make it was just weird it's like okay you put your eggs in too many baskets where it's like oh I'm gonna do one versus many I'm gonna do Cooperative it's now solo and now it's like okay so now you have all those and none of them are good right I yeah and then just so the outbreak it's kind of like I think this was announced right around covet he's like oh that's a good idea let's do that on Mars but here's why I actually don't like the Cooperative nature as much as I was excited about because you do nothing with the other game components right we then build I mean yeah you built one uh mine that let you do but that was really it's like you kind of use that other stuff to assist you in in this overall objective you got that one specifically because it was an executive action to build buildings which we needed for that mission right but like all I did was get my tech all the way up you know get the building because it was an objective because it was an objective but it's like I didn't feel like I was creative I didn't feel like I was actually doing any I wasn't really playing on Mars

that's why how I meant by I felt like from the beginning we had the solution it was just how do we get to that solution right where like when we played on Mars Just competitively it was well you're doing this I'm doing this and I haven't changed my plan because of this right here was like it literally was kind it wasn't fed but was I know how the problem needs to be solved and it's just do we have the resources the time management skills to do it yeah and that was really the only thing it's like I thought the I mean the infection Trek was kind of there but based off the rules it doesn't say like anything about that they can't work right like that would be a little bit different if it was like oh the they're infected you can't use them right um it's just it's more like if you're gonna use them that runs the risk of it infecting other people and then it speeds up this track uh I mean I think at the highest we might have been at eight or nine but some of it was also like we got to the point like um very early on you have building that could produce medicine I got a building that produced medicine so anytime we went back we were producing medicine yeah um collecting these cards produce more medicine yeah yeah and so it's like you know it kind of got to the points like because I thought oh mess is really scarce resource and I was like it's not no no not really I mean I have a stack of it I have four medicines

right right and then so it's kind of like okay well we never felt the need to build resources we never felt a need to get the tax for the things because all we need to do is just bump this up to level two and then now we have our third building out we don't you you're never looking at what the other blueprints are why would you that's not how you're gonna win right so you're playing this expansion and you're just kind of omitting everything else right and I mean I got this expand this one I remember because I hadn't affected and so it was just to move someone over oh yeah to keep them up and effectively because I knew I was going back over so they're going to pop back into here yeah and it was like that's the reason because there's no negative like yeah the advantage at least what on Mars was you take too many blueprints it's minus points right here it's like no some of these times I should actually like I got extra resources I didn't need those that extra tree but it was going to affect someone if I didn't push them over yeah it was like so why would I just do it or you like sometimes it's like you because ships are points at the end and it's like sometimes an LSAT LSS objective is a bunch of points being how many ships you have it's like I really want to burn that like I want to like lose three points to jump over well yeah sure and then cooperation who cares yeah it's now the use of the many you know whatever benefits the many you

just spend it yeah um yeah because then the solo variant I mean there's obviously an AI that's running around taking spots taking texts taking blueprints uh gaining points the entire way because you're still getting points so you're still utilizing playing the actual game right but then if you just play with someone else then you just try and do your best together to try and beat the AI right uh and I remember someone commenting on that video going well you're playing with someone else it's supposed to be solo and I'm like uh because I do what I want and why is it like really that's that's gonna upset you I mean you're playing against an AI whether you play four people against one AI as one faction it's not like four individual people are playing against one AI right it's one faction one team is playing against an AI right and so and I thought it was fun I think we might have even still lost if I remember but if we won it was it wasn't by like a landslide right because the AI in in these games are still rough right but in here it was like there wasn't a there wasn't even any like outside sources there wasn't like aliens attacking or there wasn't like anyone there that take up spots where it's like it was just more of oh he was getting infected like the infection deck was so lame right I was like okay flip it over ah that's he's infected now because they got infected and it was like but it doesn't really prevent him from doing anything right I do think it would have

been a completely different game if you couldn't use those workers I was I was I looked it up I was like okay let me just double check right that and it says Nope you still use them as the cost and then if they get sent back to you they're still infected if they hop off so it's like okay so the risk is meant to be if I use this infected worker to go somewhere then that's just gonna that kind of infects that area right so if you send a healthy worker there then they get infected right I think and then the fact that oh I have you know if you had all your people right you know out and then you had one infected in a group of three then they're all infected and that ramps up the the track right but there's so many ways to mitigate that like taking a little bit unuseful actions to get rid of it or put a worker out wherever it was going to affect the least amount yeah you could see that it was plannable yeah you can almost like yeah you gained the game right um and that's where I felt like this one was where like normal on Mars I don't feel like you can plan incredibly far in advance this one we kind of planned for in advance yeah it was kind of I mean it did have its moments of like you know oh if I do this and you do this and you do this so we were able to play cooperatively right uh I just didn't really find it all that fun yeah I was like okay I'm happy it was as short as it was

um that's also true yeah that was my initial concern I was like it was it was whenever we got to like six and I was like huh is this advancing too quick and then yeah then we were able to kind of like math it out and go oh no actually I can do this you can do that and that's that's that I almost feel like there should be three objectives three objectives or like these cards move the timer and so you can't game the game yeah honestly that's to me that would have been better yeah is because again I would agree we hit sick like I saw 12 it's like okay this is not super long but it's still a lot of turns between us and then I got to six like man we've done a lot like Seth is almost done with that we have two of these we literally just gonna get that refreshed yeah it's questioning can we get refreshed grab it and then build again and are we good and then you know you're reminded we don't need to make compounds which again even when I was playing the bass I was like oh you gotta always build compounds right that's it's like you know saw me not doing that right oh yeah you don't have to um because I because there's no progress cubes right because because we went in like I specifically went and grabbed extra one and we were even saying it's like why didn't you grab horse like that also bugs me because it's like I mean I get it it's supposed to be kind of a chapter rest story even though the opening cinematic like reading thing reference chapter one right but they don't connect no to each other so it's

not like how well you do in chapter one it's gonna affect how well you do in chapter two and three and four it's just story wise but even then it's just it's a light source yeah barely it's like oh yeah after that alien invasion now there's an outbreak it's like okay whatever right so I would have much rather I guess it is module I just don't know why he called them chapters right I think that that's just kind of weird uh but yeah like it I think there's just something about regular on Mars because it is at the end of the day competitive to where how well I do is going to give me the most points and then I might be able to win and then this is just missing that portion yeah and I and I do think that going the outbreak route is probably I think I I don't like it as a Cooperative theme for this game right I I agree um the Alien Invasion should have been that should have been the Cooperative one what's the third chapter I don't remember and it's still blackout it's still big it's still complex um and so I don't feel like it change the game enough to make me want to play cooperative again yeah yeah that's actually a good point I mean if uh I mean I would recommend on Mars to anyone who likes heavy Euro games I think it's I think it's extremely solid but someone's like oh there's an

expansion should I get it I don't at least with this one taste of it yeah one chapter but I think it's also weird that if you're trying to sell someone on this expansion it's like they're not buying on Mars to play cooperative right and they're not playing it if they're if they really like the outbreak theme why would you recommend on Mars in this expansion and not pandemic right you know uh so so the the chapter doesn't work and then it's like oh like I want to play you know a heavy uh Euro V little uh lesser the game would you like to play one verse many no right well what if the expansion offered that okay no one's playing it and then one of them is a new solo new solo yep and then a second Cooperative so it's mostly Cooperative the other the chapter three is about blackouts uh all right it's just it's not bad like it's not the worst you know thing in the world I just think that honestly for how excited I was because I felt on Mars needed to be cooperative it missed the mark yep because I guess in my head I was thinking oh he's gonna use all these unique rules to make it Cooperative but we're still gonna play it like on Mars right and you don't don't at least what you're doing I mean you do have to you still have to build the buildings to bump this up to build up your Colony but it doesn't really matter like yeah you're not doing it for

any real reason except to just meet an objective right and the outside source of everything that the CH that the Cooperative like the the game going against you just wasn't I didn't even really find it thematic yeah it was kind of like okay there's some vague in the fact that you have to like so you have a pandemic but we have to boost the colonies like you know size why yeah yeah in a game that is super thematic right like you know colonizing Mars for just the base game super thematic of course yeah we're all working to basically boost up Mars and make it better yeah that makes sense here it was kind of just because you had to to accomplish the goal that we were given because we couldn't get enough with the blueprints yeah there's only two new blueprint cards it would have been it would have been much better if like for this chapter like it was like hey here's chapter two blueprints boom like there's new level ones new level twos or new level threes and uh and then now now you want to look at all of them instead of just being like well the the two blueprints are on the top right so they're gonna be out that's all you're gonna get and now we gotta get to level three out and you're not even going to use it right that's the thing is like in what world are you leveling this up first to get to the level three building to actually utilize the ability I don't know

because that's what I was thinking it's like when you look at them you're like oh yeah vaccines I would be super helpful right like if they were getting pumped out um that they never get you know they never get uh but why are you going to build this one and you know build this and two other hospitals first right yeah um I mean yeah I just don't know it's like I don't know I mean because the I don't know if we're just missing some key element right but because you don't have to survive as I mean you you have to survive at least 12 rounds um unless you lose but by that point you're gonna I mean if this was the first objective you aimed for then maybe because then you have that one okay the IU if you go for that one first you have to bump The Colony up and then if for some reason you're not getting the tech I don't know that because that's super easy too it's not the hardest thing in the world to get a tech all the way to the end yeah uh it's it take I mean if that's your goal in a regular game of on Mars it takes some time and you have to hope that others aren't also grabbing these before you can right and that's a thing like in a regular game you're competing for a resource right because it's Cooperative I'm not going to go for those tokens and even if we did there's two of them anyway yeah I'm but realistically I'm accomplishing something else because you're going for that yeah and that's

your focus right it's like okay those are our two objective I can do this one you can do that one okay that was that was that right I don't know and I and I I don't like sitting around and talking about like ways that the game could be better because it's not it's not that way yeah so yeah this is just kind of an expansion that I don't want to explore any further I don't have any interest in the blackout chapter or the one verse many for sure even though that theme sounds the coolest right the theme sounds great but yeah it's like you know what I think I'll just keep with my vanilla on Mars competitive and if I want to play cooperative I'll just play the solo variant with someone else because that was that that was just I highly recommend that if you're looking because it was just so much fun to kind of come up with ideas and and utilizing certain blueprints to outdo the AI right uh versus whatever this was so if we play with more than two people I know that fourth Clips what happens when that board flips does something worse happened to us um no that's the alien bore so I think it's just we must just have less time where was that chapter two um oh and uh yeah so that's for the solo uh so this stays on on 12 but in a three player game it starts at 10 in a four player game it starts at eight okay

okay and then technically you could flip this and make it 12 people get infected uh which I mean yeah that I mean in a higher player count game I can see this game being harder because that's more people for the infection deck to go through right and in fact and that's more people going going around therefore getting infected so this could just be also one of those that it's like not great for two it's like stupid as a Cooperative yeah which I don't like like the greatest Cooperative game scale for a number of players I think pandemic if we're going off the outbreak theme scales super well for two three four five whatever however many people you want to have um yep so yeah with a disappointment that sucks uh all right well on the scale of one to ten boy would you give on Mars Alien Invasion at least a chapter chapter two I keep debating it's four or five honestly for me really yeah best because I don't want to play again so I think it's a four four can't yeah um I'm I'm gonna give it a five I think it's a whatever expansion uh at least that that particular chapter um I mean hell even whenever I was first because I I backed this obviously immediately when I saw that it was being announced and then we never came in I was like oh it's not fully Cooperative at least not

not the whole thing which was I was like whatever but I mean it's serviceable I wouldn't say oh buy on Mars to play it cooperatively right like I think that you can especially with how expensive these games are it's like you can get way better Cooperative games and if you're wanting the theme then get the seven expansions of pandemic right that completely fit this so right yeah I think I'm sitting at a five I can definitely see a four if I were to go off base like disappointment of like damn it but yeah that's why it's like a five because it is still on Mars it's still a good solid game but just because I don't think I think if somebody said hey do we want to play on Mars cooperatively it's like no let's just play on Mars yeah so that to me is why it's a four yeah and also because in most Cooperative games there's ways to Scale based off oh man this was actually easy oh let's go to the next difficulty because of the expansion the way it was made it's so limited yeah the only thing is oh instead of 14 it's 12. right that's that's really it or have more people so even if we found this like easy it was like I don't know that it also didn't have that crunch time at first like we never got to six I'm like huh but then yeah from that point on halfway I was like oh no never mind we got it yeah like there's but we can do enough steps to be able to

just get the blueprint we need just to whatever just it's it's it was just a checklist yeah instead of like oh man like because I've had crunch times of pandemic right I'm like okay like we started doing things you're like nope nope we okay let's move it all back let's think right and because of the randomness of pandemic like because it's a deck of cards that then randomized where tokens come out here this wasn't painful enough yeah and so the randomness of this didn't cause stress on what the board state was right yeah I mean again I think that infection deck if it decommissioned like if it was like oh if you have an infected worker here then he no longer produces right an effective worker here but then they couldn't do that because because of the of the nature of the infected person that infects everything right that's then you would just wouldn't be able to play right uh but what they could have done again is instead of infecting all of them it infects one other person if they wanted to go the decommission route so if I had you know three people here and one of them was infected okay he's useless but instead of infecting all of lithium I turned heat infects one right so now two of them are useless and then now it incentivizes you to want to go out and get medicine and be like I want to stay over here there's a medicine over here let me come back get the medicine heal one so that now I can do whatever right uh oh I really want this guy to be able to work and be in

the mine so I want to use it to heal him so I can shuttle and get my ma get my mineral right I think that would actually put a lot of crunch but yeah I I think I think this is also a weak element of just a number of infected workers that's that's just it yep it's whatever so uh so yeah I'm still uh yeah I'm just gonna give it a five I was like oh man I might lower it it is kind of a one-offer expansion how many fives five five still not not great uh so anyway that's our thoughts on on Mars Alien Invasion or outbreak uh last time we think of the expansion in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day industry hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved