Battle For Rokugan Review - Stands With the Best of the Year
Transcript
the thing that makes battle for organ what are the most satisfying games we have played this year is that technically all you do this game is you look behind your screen carefully pick one of the six tokens that you've been hiding under it and plunk it down on one of the provinces on the map do that twenty-five times and and jobs are Goodin as they say here in England because that's all you do in this game that's this just nothing just just plunk it down that's it really alright that's the review done tell you what we should get one of those awesome sushi things you mean the ones where you put the rice in the omelette and the best word it's not even only it's right and then you put many good rice inside and it's exactly like dessert isn't Japanese culture amazing you mean like how it was a country that developed almost entirely without Western influence until after World War two when their viewpoint of culture was entirely smashed and they ended up in a weird post-colonial limbo torn apart by the juxtaposition of past ideals influencing increasingly from Western culture and capitalism no I just meant that this Inari was really good safeguard what was under that token oh I will never tell
do you know what I will tell you what's none of that token but we have to make a little bit of a deal I will tell you what is behind this token if and only if you listen to a line talk about ball game box sizes for about a minute or so you know I don't really like advent calendars they're big and stupid and every time you open one you get an applet or a rubbish toy and vast expanses of disappointment every new box being a world of excitement board games should in theory be the antithesis of this but all too often you open them up to find that they're just 10% game 93% stale oxygen and 2% cardboard spacer so you know things are getting good when a company that is notorious for giant boxes filled with stale oxygen and cardboard spaces gives you a tiny thing filled with cardboard a big beautiful map that would take most map based board games to task and deck of cards and swanky screens that you can hide your bits behind in the time of long ago when we still didn't even know that Kevin Spacey was a creep and modern board games weren't really a thing card games and role-playing games were a thing and legend of the Five Rings was one of them Oh buff I mean it was a role-playing game and a card game is what I'm trying to say brave samurai bushi of seven or eight or nine different clans or more if you count minor clans for in battles of Honor for the daimyo Masters of the
brave Crabbe defended the Empire of rock agon from the evils of fooling shadow much sorry we are the tapes cut off so I'm just one second skirt oh yeah sure work you got the gist it's cultural appropriation and before you even say anything about the very well researched enriched setting and how the entire method is based on quasi Japanese Chinese and other Asian countries history culture and mythology before you say any of that save yourself trouble cuz baby I have been there and I have come out the other end but maybe just maybe battle for Oregon manages to sidestep some of these issues whilst the setting of legend of the Five Rings as a whole is problematic and the cultural equivalent of staring at a Japanese restaurant or a pagoda with cherry blossoms and going wow what culture battle Farakka gong issues most of these issues by being fairly abstract there is no more problematic whitewashed artwork there aren't really any more peculiar naming conventions it's just it's just is what it is and whether that's better or worse we're gonna leave that up to you to decide because we're not really an expert on the subject and now that about 20% of you have dropped off I should really tell you what's behind that token but I'm not going to not just yet because you see placing this token
down putting it right here that is the beauty of battle for Oakland its excellence its magnificence the gentle bend of the index finger as you slide the chip towards its destination that is the game's dirty little secret and what makes it one of the best games of this year are you sure about that Edgar it's not even five years old nor is it on BoardGameGeek stock 100
here's the deal in battle for aku gun you will play one of the seven clans such as the crab crane pig cocker spaniel unicorn and spaghetti which are almost identical aside from a special power granted to them a starting location and a unique powerful token your goal is to have the most honour at the end of the game which is just a convenient term for victory points which can be acquired by controlling provinces will honor flowers controlling complete territories and fulfilling your super secret objective what we immediately loved about battles or Rock you're good and what makes it different from the game of thrones board and which beat entirely unfair to say this is a spiritual successor to is the way that initially your provinces are distributed sure if you're playing the pro plan then you will start fanning your diplomats in the crane clan at all but after that everyone in turn will start claiming other territories and you're pretty much free to go anyway you don't have to stay within the crane clan territory you don't have to claim somewhere it's adjacent to somewhere you've already claimed you could go and get somewhere on this wonderful island you could go in the spooky shadow land you don't even have to stay on the board they'll actually know that last one isn't sure at all which makes sense if you start as the unicorn clan but your secret objective is to control coastal areas then you're pretty stuffed if you have to charge across the entire country just to get a drink of water and it makes each game feel like a new puzzle even if you play with the same clans and with the same players chances are you'll format you're playing an entirely different game and I know I know we still haven't told you what's under that token but first we just have
to explain how these tokens work otherwise it won't make any sense right battle for Rock agon is actually a very simple game on your turn you have to attack something or defend something let's say you're attacking with an army which is the most basic token if you're attacking you place it on a border of a province adjacent to one of your provinces each border can only ever have one token meaning if you want to attack someone with a concentrated force you have to be clever about your angles equally you can place an army token on your own province to defend it and you can place as many tokens to defend as you like after everyone's placed five tokens one at a time the round ends and all the tokens get flipped over if you managed to amass more numbers attacking a province you win and take control of it however if the defender has more or ties with you they keep the territory and increase its inherent defense bonus and honor value to spice things up and keep it uncertain at all times there is different kinds of tokens to show your opponent's are never sure of what is actually going on first you have the naval tokens which can be placed on any coastal province as long as you're placing it on the coastal border and you don't even have to be adjacent to it then you have the shinobi tokens would you kind of like that but even better because they can be placed absolutely anywhere in raqqa Gong and they don't even take up a border slot then you have the blessing tokens which can be placed face-up on any army token you control or naval or shinobi and please token up and finally you have the brain and the peace tokens which are
just awesome because they remove an entire province out of the equation and finally finally there is that token that I did place at the start of this video Oh token and tell us what it see what Elaine doesn't know is them I used my secret unicorn clan ability to swap two tokens places and actually the token that I play is right here she's about to find that which brings us to our next two points typically this game is symmetrical the only difference is that your choice of Clan will give you a special token and ability but these two elements of variants will turn this game into an electric oven placed right under your seat if you like to play defensively and to borrow a video game term a turtle up then the crab clan will reward you for successfully defending your provinces by not just giving you more points but I'll also make that area incredibly much harder to attack but if you focus too much on one area if someone is bound to play a raid token which is this game's version of an atomic bomb whilst they're certainly comfort in adopting a strategy that you're comfortable with your choice of Clan might make battle for rockin a more palatable experience you're not sure about playing a game where most of the information is hidden imposing the informational spies that is a scorpion
clan will let you peek at one battle token once per round making your machinations more informed and definitely more devious this thing is genius do you know why because it doesn't do anything each round you will have access to this one wonderful bluff token and then you can place it any way you like but when you reveal the tokens it will simply not do anything theoretically practically you can use it to save some more stronger tokens for a more important round whilst simultaneously diverting your opponent's attention to what is effectively nothing than that it is but a piece of lint in a pocket full of knickknacks you can actually start wars and Michael Ruiz with what is effectively about as effective as guff oh my god did you see the army over there over there just just over that you know what I've seen the size of it and you're a little bit but I did you know what I bet you could definitely take it on just go go here's the cool thing about battle for rocco gun right the game technically lets you cheat was this only one bluff token technically any token can be a bluff token it doesn't matter if you place an army token as if it was a shinobi because when you reveal all the tokens all that matters is that the ones that are illegally placed they're just gonna get removed and not do anything so you can
cheat however much you like oh why does it smell of goth this game you bet this game is mean it's meaner than milkshake in a pickled egg and I know why would you put milkshake in a perfectly good pickled egg but unlike some games that are mean and are silly like flux or munchkin this game gives you control at the start every player is given three cards to scout cards and shedinja the scout cards will let you sneaky peek under token and the shugendo will let you sneaky peek and then remove that token furthermore if you control an entire territory at the end of a round you will get that special territory card in the game that is simple and based on static numbers then any exception is going to be bonkers and you bet these are bonkers but the best twist that this game presents is that once you use a card that's it it's gone forever you can only use it once per game so they are like little treasures that you want to prayed like you're robbed ruler and the card is Michael Flynn and in the case of shugendo and scout cards you can absolutely save them to that most important battle and make sure that you are the victor but the territory cards as soon as some even takes a single province away from you that card is gone there's nothing great auntie Mabel used to say use it or lose it baby you might end up with a card that doesn't do anything relevant for your specific situation but that ha here is where the magic happens
even though the rule book doesn't say anything specific about non-binding promises or forming allegiances that we found that that was happening naturally throughout the course of the game playing a card that helps your opponent can be just as powerful providing that they then promise not to attack your key territories and besides sometimes it could just be really funny imagine having a province that is well secured and landlocked and then someone turns it into a harbor which means that all the naval forces can now attack it okay one final thing before I tell you what's under that token look we clearly love this game but after a good year of tearing games if you do not tell me and the audience why isn't that that token right now I swear to all things mama I'm gonna get you see on you geez calm down okay okay I promise I promise and you it's only fair and you can sit here and all the way until they finish this scene and then right after I finish this in you'll be here you'll be watching me right I just I just think it's fair that only tell people that first of all there's some luck issues in the game because you don't draw every single token every game and you might be left without drawing your best ones and that also this game much like honesty is inish you just either get it or you don't or how bad it is being the first player on the last round and how unfair because everyone saves up those chicken Jo and scouts cards and uses them on the
last one or that it is not so great with two or three players not bad it's just that there are many better games out there for that play account but and as soon as they tell people that this box costs only 40 pounds and then that price everyone should just pray it's pretty much right now go well I'm