Tawantinsuyu: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over Toantin Suyu: The Inca Empire. Now, this is actually a re review because I have covered this game. I think I have a solo uh runthrough of it as well, but I covered it many many years ago. I want to say this game came out in 2020, so peak COVID era. Uh, and I am currently in the process of kind of replaying through all the T-series games. And back when I had covered this, oh, I'm also covering the golden the golden age the expansion. I don't have the box anymore, but uh back whenever I originally had been playing this, I think I had given it a 10. I want to say that I really, really liked this one.
Yeah, it got a 10 from me. Um, and there's a lot of things to actually really like. At the time of this recording, I had just played to uh Teayot Walkon. And uh so it's going to be very fascinating to kind of see where all of these line out, you know, whenever I've played them all together in the T-Series. I'm actually going to have my own ranking of all the T-series games. Uh but this one is still extremely solid. I do remember specifically thinking that this was the most complex T-ser games. Uh, and at the time uh, of all the ones that I have played, I do still think that this one years later now kind of has this feeling of overcomplexity.
There's some elements to it that I feel are weirdly underdeveloped, but then also some other elements that I don't think just mesh that well. And they rectify this a little bit by actually giving one of the best player aids that I've seen in any worker placement game. Even 6 years later, I still come across games that have, you know, subpar player aids. And this one does not have that. So, while it is a little overdeveloped and over complex in my opinion, uh it manages to ease players into that by having a a fantastic player raid. And what do I mean by it being overdeveloped? Well, there's a couple things. This game could have easily just been uh your standard worker placement game where you have to manage different segments of the board. And not only you need so many things in your uh you know preemptively before you can even place a worker. And so you need a god card in your hand that matches an icon that you want to place a worker. Okay, that's fine. So you have to so where you can go kind of depends on the god cards in your hand. All right. Well, that's fine. Uh because there's m multiple ways for you to get god cards. Uh after every festival, you get to draw some.
Sometimes you get to play them uh for their abilities at the bottom, but mainly they're used for you to discard so you can place a worker on the spot. All right, that's fine. But then you have to manage where your high priest is at. This is just kind of not even really a worker, just a a mele that is in a segment. And I should say that one design flaw that this game is very annoying at is the game is broken up or the board is broken up into five segments. Uh, and there's no I wish they would have just put lines to really separate where certain actions are. Uh, because some of them are not quite clear and I think it's just a design flaw. Anyway, going back to where you place workers. So, you need a god card.
Okay. Well, then you also have to keep in mind where your high priest is at. If your high priest is and and they give you a diagram for it for you to be able to do all the math, but if you're in and if you're going to a section that your high priest is in, it's significantly cheaper. Okay. So, but then the g the board is broken up into three sections. So, the further down the hill you go, the more resources it cost. If you go to the first section, it's free depending on this is all where your high priest is at. If you go to the second one, it costs two resources, uh, well, food, uh, which is either corn or potatoes. And if you go down to the very bottom, it cost five. So, uh, but then if you go to an adjacent section, it costs one more. So, if you go to the first adjacent one, it costs one. and you go to the second adjacent one, it costs four. And if you go to the third adjacent one, it costs six. But then if you go to the opposite side, it increases it by three, I want to say.
Yeah. So if you're not, if you go to a non-adjacent one, it adds three to that. So goes to three, then five, and then eight. So not only do you have to keep track of that, then you have to keep track of the god cards. And then every colored worker has a different ability. And they're not that complex of abilities really. Two of them are the same one. If it's green and blue, if they go on a green or blue spot, they get an extra task because every spot you place a worker gives you a certain number of tasks that you can perform, which will be three. There are three actions next to it. It it makes sense once you start playing it. But coming back to this game after so many years, it it feels like one of those games that just doesn't it doesn't flow as well. I know remember uh whenever I had originally played it, I was thinking, "Oh man, I love all these extra layers.
I love how all the workers have different abilities, but this last game that I just played was a refresher for me and a a teach to uh my girlfriend who was, you know, nice enough to play this. But I know I remember as I was teaching it, I kept saying, "And is as if this game wasn't complex enough, all the workers do something different." And they just didn't need to add it. It felt like this was one of those games that they just kind of kept adding more and more to try and differentiate. And all the tea games are radically different from one another. They might have some similarities. The similarities from this one to Teot Walkon is in Teayot Walkon there are three eclipses and here there's three festivals.
That's really it. I mean, you have this element of conquesting, which this is kind of the underdeveloped portion of the game where you have you draw these um you can draw these army cards and you can either play them for free for the abilities on the bottom, but you mainly use them to do a conquest action. And really all you do is you play these cards from your hand for a certain amount of workers who are the ugliest people I've ever seen drawn. and they and then you just look at a section of a conquest uh area and some of them say, "Hey, for the the very first one, you have to flip one face down and or but if you want to do the really high one to get the best rewards, you have to kill three people and that can just be a card that has two on it and another card with one and then flip another two face down and that's it. So, there's nothing really to conquesting really. What it does is a it gives you a an ability to get some semblance of resources. It can either give you statues or it can give you gold or resources or it can let you move up on the temple track or just give you straight up points. But then each festival you're rewarded with a with a pittance of points really because every time you conquest you have to get rid of um it's a casualty of war. So you take a mele from the village and put in the casualties of war. But for each person
who has conquested the most regions, you get points equal to how many casualties of war there are. So the more people are conquesting, the more points there are. So it is a slight, it's not even really area control because well, I guess kind of cuz if you have if you've conquested the most in a region, then you're going to get those points. But then if there's a tiebreaker, the one who got the least amount of rewards will get uh will break the tie. It But yeah, it just feels like something they had to throw in. Well, it's some ancient civilization and they had they were probably fighting, so I guess we'll throw in some war. And the expansion, the golden age, uh has a module where these segments uh actually have vassels you can assign to them and they have special abilities per conquesting.
So that makes conquesting a little bit more of uh you know appealing because now you actually get some special power for conquesting in that region instead of just looking and being like oh well this one gives me 11 points for just five cards really. Uh that's fine. That's easy. Then they also have this element of tapestries. Uh which funny enough now that I think about it a lot of these kinds of games really like tapestries. Um, and this is kind of cool. This is your set collection. This also is kind of like the Teotw walk on masks, even though these actually give you something. The masks don't. They're just points. But here, uh, the more tapestries you have, you can actually sync up icons and every you can do a merchant action or every festival you get a free merchant action and you can get rewards for syncing up icons. Uh, I like that. I do like the action system.
Now again on teaching the game, this board is just a flat board of icons and nonsense that it becomes extremely overwhelming whenever you're just looking and you're trying to think, okay, I don't even know where to go or I really want to do tapestries. Oh, wait. None of the tapestry icons are actually in the first section. So, I have to start going to the second section, and that costs a lot of resources. So, I need to somehow get a ton of potatoes, which potatoes are super easy to get, it's corn that's more difficult. But what makes this game still really good, is there are ways to do that. If you want to go after tapestries, but you need corn, okay, well, how do I get corn? Well, you can just do an action that lets you get corn, or you do a secondary action that lets you recruit people. And hey, this guy right here has corn, so I'll just discard him for the corn.
And they do a nice thing where it gets as the game goes on, resources aren't as needed uh because most people are going to start building steps and you're rewarded for building steps. You have four points for it. You get two, I think it's two potatoes and a corn for doing that. And then every time someone uses your steps to go down a section, you get a point for it. So, you're incentivized to actually build steps. And they're not hard to do. It just costs three stone. And stone is super easy to get. So, I like the fact that as the game goes on, what's also kind of cool is the meeples you're placing around the board, they don't go away. they stay there. So, you eventually will run out of the good free spaces that are closer. Most of the time, people are going to have built steps so that it goes it's easier to go down. And I mean, nothing stopping you from going all the way to the bottom away from your high priest if you have the resources to to blow. Hey, I have eight potatoes. Who gives a And spend them all. And hey, you can go down there. And also, you don't even really need to have the god cards uh matching because you can just spend a gold uh for instead of playing the god card. So, there are every kind of, you know, roadblock that's in your way, there are ways to go around it. And that's to me a sign of a good worker placement game. I
never really feel like this game is super tight. I've played Euro games where it felt like you were doing 10 things just to get uh you know just to get a piece of corn and and then you wanted to hoard that because it took so much effort to get so little you know and those to me are never really all that fun. This game still has to man has managed to be uh after all these years still fun. And they also do this really cool thing. They have passive buildings. they have uh uh production buildings and then with the expansion they have palaces. So I'm always a sucker for games like this that give you something unique from other players. With Teot Walkon, they have the technologies, but those are universal. Everyone can go get the same technology. You just might give someone else some points if you go to the same one. Here you can buy different buildings that are now, hey, here are my production buildings. I have ways to generate a bunch of stone. So, I'm just going to be building a bunch of steps.
Uh, or I have this uh this passive building that every festival I get a point for my longest tapestry. So, man, I was able to get five tapestries by the first festival. Cool. I'm going to get five extra points. It uh and there's a ton of them. And the expansions add e even more. So you have a lot of different types of uh buildings that you can go for. Uh so yeah, I really like that. And then the expansion. I mean to be fair, I would say this game never needed an expansion. I I've had this I mean when did this expansion come out? because I had it um in my um collection since it came out 2022. So for four years I had it and I finally got the chance. I don't know what just took me so long. I just never wanted to get this to the table. Um, but I'm glad to say that the expansion only it doesn't bloat the game. It adds three modules.
One of the modules is very simple to add and then they kind of ramp in complexity. So the first one was I don't remember what they're called. They are called so module one is way of the sun. This is probably the best one I would say that that got added because in the in the core game you had the temple track which was extremely basic. You had so many ways to just go up the track and you would generate points every festival. You get points for where you're at and then the resource to the to the left of it. But it's a static temple track. It gets you a stone or a potato or, you know, a god card or a gold. It's very very kind of whatever.
This way of the sun now adds the bottom half of the uh of the temple track, but it adds two sides to it. So, you can play on the nicer side, which just everyone, no matter where you're at, will you'll still generate a point, but you also get some uh some army cards. And then the more you go up, it actually splits. So, now you have some options on where you want to go. And the resources and stuff you get is just better. You can get a free statue, which is really cool cuz the statues make your god cards better. Uh you can get I mean, still gold. You can get a building just for free, which is really cool. And then the other side, a little bit more harsh. If you never move up on the temple track, you start losing points, but then it still has this broken up path that you can move up. So, I really like this uh module. Just I would probably never not play with this one. It's super easy to just toss in and give some variety to the temple track without having to have this overhead of here's some new stuff that I have to teach you. The second one was the that was the the vassels of the Inca.
That's the one that adds these conquest spots where you have certain uh vassel tokens that you can actually place on them to generate uh special abilities for them. Um that one that one I feel it still adds some variety and there's a good stack of them. In this last game I played, uh, I didn't throw them in because again, it was a teaching game. But the other I personally don't think conquesting was all that well thought out and this h that's why they probably threw it in as a module. [snorts] But it is nice that now you kind of have a direction of which one you want to go towards because there might be an ability for that for that region that you're going to want to go for. But for some reason, these kinds of games that add in this higher level of war element, I never really care for. I never really cared for the area control module for for Teayot Walkon, and I don't really care for it here. It always feels like it's an afterthought. You have all this extra resource management and worker placement stuff. And then, oh yeah, that's right. War over there. I kind of now that I now playing with the the vassels, I actually kind of just liked the simplicity. It's not super welldeveloped, I don't think, but it is nice to just have to think about how many work or army cards you need just to
get the two corn you want or something. Um, so that one out of the three modules that were thrown into this, this was probably the one I wouldn't really jump uh want to throw in all the time. Uh, and then the third one, the nobles and newcomers. This one I kind of have a mixed feeling towards. The cool part about it is now it adds another building, uh, palaces. And these work just like all the other buildings except that you need to recruit a certain color worker. And when you do, you can plop him on here. And whenever you do the action that matches what is on here, you can lay him face down to trigger it. This one is when you build a statue, you can pop him down and get two army cards.
But when he's face down or laying down, you would have to do one of the rejuvenate actions to be able to make him stand up. So, it's another thing to rejuvenate, but they also have this prophecy effect on all of them that you need uh you can fulfill for five extra points. So, the reason why I have a mix is I like the palace aspect. I like the fact that okay now cool these are once again I like the buildings a lot in this game but it adds these newcomers which are these you know half colored meeples that can count for one or the other. So this one can count for a white or a blue whether for placement purposes or whatever. But I kind of like the fact that you were limited on the colors that were coming out. You had the the nomad spots where that was kind of just a catchall of if the recruiting uh uh from people from the village wasn't working out. You had that nomad area that you could pull from if you needed to. Uh, but for to fulfill a lot of these prophecies, you basically do need to grab a nomad cuz this is the only way you can have a third worker because you were always limited on just the two. So now you can have one sitting off to the side. So you can have as a third one. So I like the palaces. I like the fact that you need a specific color to activate. I like how it's another trigger you can
get. Um, but again, it's just another thing on the side of the board you have to keep track of. So, out of all the modules from the expansion, I really just like the modification of the temple track. This game to me has always been I mean, I don't know about the Tobi or Tonzia, if I'm pronouncing those right. I don't know how complex those are. They're brand new. But this one was always the most complex out of the T-ser games that I played. And I never once thought this needs an expansion. So I would always say, you know, if you're looking to get this game, just get the core box because and unless you're playing this a ton and you're finding things to get stale, well then throw in the expansion, but this is not an expansion that I will be including in my games this all the time.
So, I mean, but to give them even more credit, they once again made a a player aid that you can that you can use for um for when you're using the expansion, which was very nice. Overall, I really I mean, this game, spoilers, is not a 10 out of 10 game for me at this point. This is, you know, both for the fact that I don't love to I I'm not as enamored with Euros as I once was six years ago, but I do think that this game is still extremely solid. However, I I also still think that this Euros have have become so clean or streamlined lately that games like this just don't really do it for me all that much. It's still good and but man, there's just something about it that feels more a little bit I guess overwhelming. It feels It feels like I feel like I'm going to be coming to work more than coming to play a game.
Out of all the T-series games, I would probably say this one just has that overhead of man, how much do I want to manage my potatoes and corn just to place a a worker to get two stone, you know? That that's that's a lot of actions is you're looking around the board and you look at a building that you might want to buy and it's like, okay, I need a corn. I don't have any corn. How do I get I just need one corn? Drawing from the army deck isn't going to I mean, that could do it for me. Okay, so I'm going to spend one of my actions or my turn to move my priest over here. So that on my next turn I can pop a worker down and oh wait I will I need a blue. Okay. So for my that's my first secondary action. My second se secondary action is I'll recruit this blue guy.
That's my turn. Second turn. I want to come down to this spot because now I can place the blue on that. Oh wait. Do I have the Nope. I don't have the square icon with the dot. Okay. I'll spend a gold. All right. So, now that I've done that, that's going to require three two resources. Well, hypothetically, I have potatoes. All right. So, now I have two tasks that I can do. Well, luckily, I'll do the corn to get two corn finally, and then I have three stone to build steps. You know, it that's that's it. That's a lot of the a lot of the game is you you have to manage so many things before you can even get one action done and then it goes to your next turn and you're like all right you kind of rinse and repeat. It's not a long game, but this also has that feeling of one thing about this game I just remembered that I don't really like is there's nothing that keeps the game moving forward because at the end of your turn, there's nothing stopping you from cuz the game ends after three festivals. A festival only happens when the village uh the village is empty of resources or of of people. And to recruit those people, you need a corn or you need a potato
depending on which side of the track you want to recruit. Now, yes, obviously to be able to play the game, you have to have workers that you can spend to go down, but you don't have to recruit them. Nothing is stopping you at the end of your turn from just saying, "No, I don't. I have one worker. I don't really need a second one right now, so I'm not going to recruit." So, you can have a lot of rounds where the game isn't making any progression to end. Now, naturally, the game will end because players will have to recruit or you kind of want to recruit because that'll cause the festival and you get a little bit of points for causing the festival because then in the festival you get a lot of points and you get to you get a lot of resources to set up for the next turn.
So, naturally, it is going to happen. But there are moments where no one is recruiting so that the game just kind of has these periods of stalling and I don't really like that. I like the fact that in every other game there's a round tracker. Oh, hey, you went, I went, then that person went. Okay, cool. Boom. At the end of 10 rounds, we have this big scoring event or whatever it is. Uh, yeah. So, that's just kind of a weird element where yes, the game will naturally end, but there's periods of lulls that I feel like just didn't need to be there. And the game does get shorter. Not only by recruiting does the village get empty, but by conquesting, you just naturally pull one of them out.
So rounds can get faster. Uh or festivals can come quicker, but it if no one's doing that cuz you don't have to conquest, then it just drags a little bit longer. Not that it's a long game, but it is longer than it should be. So overall, I mean, it's going to sound pretty harsh, but I think core game, I think I'm going to give this game a seven. Uh, which is I mean, whenever it was a 10 so many years ago, it's going to drop a decent amount. And to me, seven is, in case you're wondering, like I don't do sevens compared to the US grading school. Seven is not average to me. Five is average. Uh, so I still think this game is good and I would I would have a good time playing it, but I don't think I would be rushing to get this to the table. And with the expansion, I don't think it really moves the needle for me. I think this is an expansion that if I were to have played this all the time, if I didn't have so many games that I am constantly playing or campaign games that I'm known on my channel for doing, uh, then yes, I think this this expansion would be amazing. It's not a bad expansion by any means. I think all three modules are good modules. It's just for me the only one I would really probably throw in consistently is the
temple track and then maybe it'd probably be temple track and the palaces and then the conquesting. Uh so even with the expansion, I mean I'd give the expansion probably a seven as well. So on average both of them together is going to be a seven. And yeah, and that's it. I'm trying to think. I can't think of really anything anything else about about this. So yeah, that's it. That's my thoughts on Toant and Suyu and the Golden Age expansion. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Like, comment, share, and subscribe. And have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.