Skip to main content
Loading video...

Terraforming Mars: Ares Expedition Review - It's Time To Skip Past Mars

Transcript 16:07

hey folks welcome to another broken meatball blitz review remember if you like what you see or you want to talk about the game in more detail please remember to leave a thumbs up and a comment in the video because i'd like to engage with you on a more personal level and don't forget that if you want to help the channel in any way then the patreon campaign is always running so we're looking at terraforming mars aries expedition i'm a little late to this party but i didn't get it on kickstarter or anything because i wasn't exactly uh gunning for anything terraforming mars related because i don't exactly have a great relationship with the parent game but when i was at essen i was able to grab a kickstarter version of this so i've got the improved components and such and i figured couldn't hurt for me to do a blitz review for this one just to see if this one improved on the terraforming mars formula for me and well let's just say it doesn't really need to improve much but even so that's just my own personal opinion terraforming mars is not one of my favorite games but this is essentially the same sort of thing condensed down you're still doing the same stick of all right we got to get the oxygen level out the temperature level up flip the ocean tiles and terraform mars so that is all the same and you still have a ton of these cards and i gotta admit i do like the fact you do get a ton of these cards but you still basically playing these cards down raise your production levels of money and plants and heat and minerals and whatever the stars of titanium i think it was and various other bits and bobs and so you know you're still trying to do all that you've still got your cubes of multiple types to track everything on your board and you're playing these

cards trying to create combos and basically you know terraform mars better than your opponents can where the difference is though is you don't draft cards in this game you just draw them straight off the deck but the way the turn sequence works is you have five phase cards that you play development production action construction and research and the idea is that you choose one of these in secret and you can't pick two at the same you can't pick the same one twice in a row and you go you know what today i wanna produce and i put that face down the opponent also does this and this is up to four players i believe yes up to four and they decide they want to research okay they go research you all flip they're the phases that you do this round and you do them in order from one to five if you duplicate then oh well sucks to you but if you're the one who played the card you get the bonus on the bottom as well so this might sound familiar oh yeah it does it's essentially race for the galaxy race for the galaxy had the same thing you had a bunch of phase cards like explore and build and settle or whatever it was and you played it face down and you were trying to kind of get in your opponent's head and guess who what phase are you to play this round i reckon you're going to produce in which case i don't need to reduce i'll instead play development and do this while you don't have the money to do it it's it's it was a really cool system and race for the galaxy and it does work well here i like that you know it's probably my favorite aspect of race race is one of those games where i don't own it i would probably never want to

teach it because of the iconography learning curve is insane but i would play it at a max of two players because i think when you have too many players in race for the galaxy you might as well just you know just assume that most of the phases are going to get played in a round not to mention the game goes on crazy long and that was a slight worry i had going into this because i thought hmm okay terraforming mars the parent game way too long way too much randomness in some of the card drafting you get takes like two to three hours which is way too long for any drafting game and some of the cards were just dead draws basically so was i going to get the same stuff in here and was i going to get the flaws of race for the galaxy in this as well well let's talk about some positives first component quality if you get the kickstarter version a lot better the tiles are decent you've got a decent border you've still got these cubes which to be fair are better cut than the previous ones but still you've got these cubes everywhere but the main thing is that the card quality is a lot better the artwork is 100 times better on these things i mean man the artwork on these cards sucked in terraforming mars well actually what art work most of it was screen caps but best of all recess board i don't know if you get these in the retail one i don't think you do but just having a recess board so that you can put a cube on it and not have it fall off everywhere same for the ones where you track production you know you basically just slide the cube through this kind of zigzaggy production line these are a must-have i'm so glad

they're in this game it makes life a lot better and these badly needed to be in the base set of terraforming mars not as an addition or a pinback grade but there are some superfluous components in here for plenty i mean victory point tile tokens for the forest seems a little bit redundant really these five uh tracker car tiles that you use in order to track the phases completely redundant because frankly you can see the cards that are on the table so if you can't remember which phases are happening then you probably shouldn't be playing this game it's not difficult to track what phases are in operation particularly if someone get duplicated so the idea of having to constantly go right hand on this round we're doing this this and this and then this round i'm doing that like that and then this this this this that just takes time it's so fiddly and annoying and i don't use them so screw those they're rubbish but everything else here is pretty decent actually i mean the rule book is clearer to understand and where's the rule book i think i've pumped it somewhere oh there it is yeah rule book decent size linen finish very easy to read very easy to understand one or two rules that are slightly hidden in there but for the most part very easy to pick up you can also play this in the two player co-op mode or solo rules although well i'll get onto the solo in a bit first of all let's talk about the multiplayer multiplayer for this unfortunately falls for one big issue and unfortunately it's the same thing that race for the galaxy had i don't want to play race for the galaxy with a ball and two i don't want to play this with more than two the firstly the whole

idea of choosing the phases is so much better when there's only two of you because you really have to think what your opponent is doing when you have four of you doing it you most of the phases get played it's very random it's just i don't know it doesn't seem quite as tactical in a four-player game but the main reason i don't like this with more than two is because the one thing i was hoping that this would fix over terraforming mars which was to make the game a lot shorter is completely thrown out the window when you have three or four players yes it's shorter than terraforming mars but then walking from land's end to john o'groats in scotland is shorter than terraforming mars it's like ridiculous for what it is this is still too long for what it is though i mean every round is fairly quick in terms of the round but ap players can really slow this game down if they're thinking about what cards to play or what phase to do and you've got the fiddly stuff we've like alright i've played this card so let me just adjust my track here and flip this phase token here but the rounds are so endless and it's rinse repeat throughout you are constantly playing round after round after a round i've lost count of how many rounds the typical game has and like an hour and a half later with three or four players and you might not even be even more than halfway up these tracks it's just too long you know it's like getting it's not like terraforming mars parent game length but it's still way too long for me to enjoy this game because once i'm done right okay i've done development

phase i'll do development here we go right my turn is literally done there you go there's my turn why it seems to take everybody else about 100 years to do their turn is beyond me but that my turn is done within about five seconds the rounds don't last five seconds so there's a long time when you're sort of sitting there going right i've done my card no all right i'll draw two for the research well that one's rubbish and that one right done are you still waiting for you don't even choose your cards come on come on come on and i just end up like just wanting to get on with it it's like get on with it let's get on to the next phase so you know for this sort of game which is simpler than terraforming mars i want this to take no more than an hour tops like completely no more than an hour and it says 60 minutes on the box and that is an outright lie unless you are playing this with two players or solo solo you can get this done pretty quick 30 45 minutes two player can be 60 minutes that's fine three and four player though longer way longer particularly with four some people have even been on bgg saying would they ever be a fifth player i cannot imagine how crazy you have to be or high on mushrooms or something in order to want this to be a five player game that's just ridiculous because here's the other problem this game's mostly multiplayer solitaire yeah other than the choose choosing of the phases there's no reason for your opponents to be on the table because there's next to nothing in fact i'm not even aware of there's any cards in here that influence opponents if there are there's very few

of them way less than in the parent game so me doing my tableau down here has no effect on everybody else you might be raising the temperature in that big whoop you could substitute that with any form of ai mechanic so i'm doing all these things here yes i want to know what phase you're playing but that's literally your only purpose for being in the game and i can get the main enjoyment of choosing the phases with two players third and fourth makes no difference four player honestly this game is a waste of space with four players i can think of a million games i'd rather play with four players than this one so you've already got you know i mean even the parent game had more interaction than this one does and terraforming mars doesn't have a massive amount of player interaction oh you beat me to my score tart what do you do and there's a couple of cards that might you know dick over other opponents but even then i feel like i'm just doing my own game in that one but here cool blimey it's even more multiplayer solitaire so okay two player max what about the solo mode though oh yo solo mode um it's fine i might get some enjoyment out of it because i can play the turns nice and quick so at least i can get the fun aspect of this game done the problem is is that the difficulty level is complete lottery luck fest you basically have to terraform mars by the time 25 rounds are up okay and you have the phases and then dummy face deck is there and you basically choose a phase and then a random one comes off the top getting all that terraformed in 25 rounds is insanely hard three quarters of this

deck is dead draws because most of the cards in there are about building an infrastructure and having a bit of fun with the cards and that none of those cards are useful in a game when you're trying to speed run through the free terraform things you have to basically play the game the same way every time i need a bucket load of plant and heat production or i need a crap ton of mc production so that when i do the standard projects i can basically churn a bunch of those out but ideally you want all three whatever about titanium whatever about the mineral one whatever about card production knows at the end of the day if i'm not flipping over ocean tiles or getting enough heat and pan production you will not physically be able to terraform on mars so you better hope you draw the right cards the problem is you don't draft in this game so you're just drawing off a deck randomly so i play research and go right i'm gonna do research draw an additional like let's let's draw five cards and keep two all right hope i got something good cos 40 can't play it uh when you play a science tag draw a card what you do um oh there's heat production fine uh let's see requires that temperature or higher can't play it all right uh i can't play it that's not useful for me remember two titanium again doesn't matter you know there's so many cards in this deck that are just useless to you in solo mode so you could basically choose a corp and draw completely bad and you have no chance of winning it's not necessarily punishing but it just feels frustrating where you feel like oh i didn't quite get there and it was nothing really to do with your tactical choices you just didn't draw the cards i mean you can say

oh i'm an expert at terraforming mars and there's expedition but if you draw rubbish cards you will not win the solo mode full stop doesn't matter how good you claim to be so even the solo mode just feels like a bit of a letdown i get the fun mechanics done but then you lose the fun aspect of the phase selection because i'm basically luck predicting what a dummy deck will do so really solo mode loses the fun from a two-player game but then makes me play the game quicker but then also gives me the luck fest of the solo dummy player and trying to do these three objectives whereas at least with the two player i'm at least gunning against an opponent and i get to play some more interesting cards so there's not a lot this game's really offering me would i play this over terraforming mars yes but that's like saying hmm luke you didn't like this jar of pickles with licorice in it would you like just the licorice by itself yeah both taste horrible i don't care either way you know so yes i'm definitely not going to play the big terraforming mars ever again cause it's way way too long but then i'm only gonna play this with two player and maybe occasionally solo if i feel like it and i'm never gonna play this two player often i've got other games i want to play two player so this game really just has no purpose being on my game shelf so yeah this was a bit of a letdown i mean i wasn't exactly putting too much hope into it like oh you know this will be the best thing sliced bread but i kind of hope this would be a decent improvement over terrifying mars and instead it's just a

bit of an improvement over terraforming mars so not a bad game you know not a bad game i know i consider terraforming mars to be a bad game on my scales but this one is still i don't know i don't even know if i could call this average i honestly just don't see a purpose i won't play this at three or four players so there's half the player counts gone solo is a complete lottery so i won't really care too much about that so that leaves two player and as a two player game i think this is pretty solid but that's not enough for me the components are decent yeah but there's no real major theme either the longevity there's quite a lot of decent mac cards which is fairly good uh the duration is still alone but it is easy to play so i gotta give it some props in those departments as much as i think the gameplay is at so i was gonna give it a four i'm gonna give you a bit of a generous and give it a five average average game for me decent enough if i play a two player but otherwise i'm not that fast but i do have to give props that the component quality is a lot better although bearing in mind this is five out of ten for the kickstarter version if you've got the retail version that cheap one where you don't get recessed boards and the cards aren't a great quality i'd probably stick this down to a four out of ten because if you lose some of that aspect then what else am i left with so yeah bit of a disappointment for me maybe this is your thing there's people out there who love the original and there's people out there who love this one so you know pick your poison really but i personally prefer this one but basically if it's got terraforming mars on the cover it's just not a game for me

it seems oh well oh well there's other games out there so that's it for me on this video if you like what you see or if you just want to talk more about the game then please leave a like and comment on the video and on the product itself it means a lot to me to know that you appreciate the content but also i'd like to hear your thoughts on this do you prefer this do you prefer the daddy or do you agree with the thoughts like i say let me know i want to talk with you guys so i'll see you on the next broken people video and if you want to check out more content on this channel you can check out the blitz review i did for june house secrets from portal games or you can check out the remainder of my top 100 which is going swimmingly with my 20 to 11 or maybe if you're lucky i'll have my 10 through 1 by this point we'll see anyway take care and remember as always level hate terror for me mars it's only a game bye for now

Progress saved