Skip to main content
Loading video...

Stroganov Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 22:47

hey everyone today i'm taking a look at stroganoff which is a one to four player euro strategy board game designed by andrea steading and published by game brewer this one takes around 90 minutes to play on average before i get into the video i want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kianda dot co dot uk who are my go-to online retailer here in the uk and if you use my discount code in the show notes you can get five percent off your first order okay so the main board for stroganoff is going to look like this and at first this might look somewhat intimidating but it's not too bad if you break things down so at the top going across here is the scoring track and below that we have the round structure so you're going to be playing four rounds um each represented by a different season and the winter phase is going to be somewhat of a of an admin phase and the play with the most points by the final winter is going to be the winner you've got a market here which you can kind of exchange these different furs and these furs are i suppose one of the main currencies in the game and they range from two all the way up to these big grizzly bears here um with a value eight and the rest of the symbology at the top here is mainly just depicting the different actions and the turn structure of the game so it's just a bit of a memoir uh here we have a a song track which you can climb throughout the game by collecting these loot symbols here and at certain points or if you reach the top of the track you can spend these points in order to claim these bonuses which we'll talk on a bit later and depending on the player card there might be more or fewer of these bonuses available to you um just to

restrict the options you have and i suppose the main part of the board here is this kind of track which is broken down into these five different regions and within these regions you've got these tiles which have been semi-randomly distributed out on the board and with on those tiles you have these furs as well which have been drawn out random from the bag here but they have been placed in order so they always range from lowest to highest and you can see here you can end up acquiring these tiles um and getting the rewards on the bottom but again we'll talk on that shortly and below all these um these modular tiles you have the main parts here on the main kind of um you know sections of this track where you have these cards you have these yurts tiles and you also have these town tiles now these two here are kind of exchangeable throughout the game as they're claimed and refreshed however these town tiles are going to be a permanent fixture each player is also going to have their personal player board which is essentially another track that you're trying to climb throughout the game by trading in these furs and this track is going to offer you end game victory points if you climb all the way to the bottom or depending on how far you climb and it's also going to give you a little checkpoint along the way to get these other bonuses um additional resources include these horses which come in these um individual or i believe these countless three horse tokens and we'll touch what they are on what they do a bit later you're going to have coins and you're also going to have these outpost tokens you're going to start with one available to you but you

are going to have the option to unlock more of them as the game goes on additionally at the start of the game you are going to be distributed one of these objective cards just to give you a starting point on something to work towards okay so let's talk about how the game actually works so the first thing you're going to do on your turn is you're going to move your cossack up to two spaces for free so i could go like this and that wouldn't cost me anything however if i want to travel further which there is a benefit to do so because if you travel furthest at the end of the year you're going to get some free movement on the song track up there but yeah the first thing you're going to do is you're going to move up to two spaces and if you want to move further you can choose to spend your horse tokens so for an additional movement you just have to spend one horse which would mean you can move up to three spaces or you can spend an additional three horses to go to that fourth space or if you spend a massive six horses you can go all the way up to five spaces once you've settled on where you want to move to you're going to have the option to take a basic action and these are the five basic actions you can take you can either take a coin from the supply you can move your cossack one one or two spaces in either directions you can actually end up moving back on yourself and if you choose to do that you can do this one here which is to take four horses from the supply you could do a hunt action which is where you take these furs so the top one is always going to be just a basic action to take that one however if you want to get the ones

access to the furs below it like say i really wanted this bear here for each horse i spend i can actually climb down that track so if i could say you wanted this eight i could spend two horses and get access to this bear now whenever you collect a bear you're also going to move two up on the song track also when you do that hunt action you can actually optionally spend an additional coin and when you do that you can take another fur and the final basic action you can take is to do this one here and when you do this action you're actually going to have to trade in a fur matching this symbol here so at the beginning of the game all these different furs are distributed on the different regions and put in numerical order at least for the basic game but you can optionally change that later but there's always going to be one that's left out and put on this um on this action here and when you trade in that type so ie the uh the foxfair you can take two of these actions so you can get you can either take a a coin you can go two up the song track you can move your cossack even more or you can take three um horses so once you've moved and taken your basic action you have the option to either take another basic action or you can take a main action and the main actions are generally more tied or anchored to the region that your cossack is in or where you've built an outpost because that is actually going to be one of the options you can make is to establish one of these outposts so let's talk about what these um main actions are so the first thing that you can do is you can use the action of the the

town that's you know cemented on that region so this one would be to take one of these special tiles here which will act as additional income when it comes to the winter phase so for each one of these you get an additional horse obviously which is a great currency to have um of course this is just going to give you more horses and you can use the yurt action here which this one in particular lets you take three of those tokens and go up one on the song track however when you take one of these your actions they do actually get discarded from the board so there is a kind of an urgency to get to those if you want to do that or you can take one of these um special tsar cars here and these are going to give you something to aim towards so you can see this one in particular wants you to have four of these level two-thirds um and if you have that and you trade in one of them because you can see it's got that red outline there you are not only gonna get two points but you're also gonna add something to your engine so this one here means that when it comes to the winter phase i can take a fur from the bag and the final main action you can take is to claim one of these actual tiles now when you do that you have to spend two furs matching at the region you're in so this would be two level twos and it's going to be an additional fur of that type for each fur remaining on the main tile so what that means is that if there's still fur here it's going to be much more expensive where is if this has been completely depleted it's only gonna go back to that value two so it's gonna be a lot more affordable if you do it once it's um

being you know ravaged by all the other players now if you do end up buying them you are gonna get the victory conditions at the bottom there so this one's gonna be you know you've got two victory points um take one of these um furs from the marketplace there and take a coin and there's an additional incentive to collect these tiles because you can see here that each of them has a symbol on them um i think representing the different seasons and for each set of three or four you're going to get a an amount of points i think it's three points for a set of three and four points for a set of four unique symbols so once you've moved your cross act you've taken your basic action you've taken your main action and you actually get the option to take another action however this one is going to cost you um it's going to cost you resources either it's going to cost you one of the matching symbols here so it's going to in this example it's gonna cost me another twofer to take another main action or if you want to take a basic action you can just discard any fur at all there's also some auxiliary actions that you can take any time during your turn without limitations um so you can spend five horses to either take a fur from the market or takes them from the bag again drawing two and keeping one of them um you can choose to complete one of your tsar cards here which we touched on already so it's not gonna get spend any time to do that and you've also got these ones here where you can exchange a fur and a um and a horse in order to exchange it for a lower valued fur or you can spend any

two fairs to exchange it from one from the market and once you finish your turn you're going to lie your cossack down just to show that you're finished and it's going to go to the next player who can do the same thing i'm you know moving how far they want taking the basic actions and main actions however in the next round and the person who is furthest along will go first so you are going to play three rounds of that until you get to a winter phase and the winter phase you are going to follow this little sequence here where you're going to take an income of two horses plus an additional horse for each one of these tokens that you've acquired then you're going to activate any winter abilities that you've acquired through these tsar cards here you know to get you additional income such as going up the track or get taking um furs from the bag or market it can be all kind of uh all kind of things um and then the person who travis traveled the furthest along uh the track here is going to get an additional two um movements up the scoring track the second place is going to go up one and then whoever's moved the the furthest is going to get to claim one of these bonus tiles so they are going to um let's say um the yellow player wanted this one here they're going to do spend the three um song points go one two three so that should be on the same spot as the blue player there and take the corresponding award which in this case is going to be five horses and then the blue player is going to do the same where they can spend two song points like so um we'll be back there and take a point and once all that's been

completed you're going to go into a bit of an admin step when you're going to start replenishing things on the board such as replenishing the song tiles ready for the next round um any tiles that have been removed from the game are going to get refilled in by new ones by sliding all the existing ones along and refilling them from this side with the stack here i'm always the one on the end is going to have one of these tiger um tokens um which are actually a wild fab if you don't spend them by the end of the game they're going to be worth two points each so still quite a valuable resource to be had there um additionally any um spaces that have been created by these sar cards or the yurts are going to slide along like so again refilling them from the supply for each gap that is created now halfway through the game uh the b tiles start to come into play which start to ramp up the rewards and benefits that you get from them just to give it a bit of a you know a forward projectory and you're also going to move your cossacks back to the starting spot but keeping them in the order that was um from the previous round and there was one action that i missed from the main actions list there which is to place these outposts on the board and when you do that you are going to have a look at where your cossack is and then you're going to place um one of these x's um on the available slots here and these slots are going to vary depending on the player count just to keep the game feeling tight i'm only going to spend the amount of horses depicted on that empty slot um normally you would go from left to right but again some of these are going to be filled in by um by proxy players and what this means is that later in the

game say i traveled further along the track here when i get to take my main action not only do i have the option to take the main action from where my cossack currently is you can also do it to where you have an outpost so your options are constantly expanding um if you have like a strategy that you want to keep going back to so let's take a look at some of these towns and yurts that are available to the players so we've already talked about this one here but we got this um this trophy symbol here which actually lets you climb down your personal board so this one again when if you have the available fur here um by spending it from your supply you can um do that and slide this down and not only are you going to start unlocking victory points for the endgame scoring but you're also going to get the corresponding bonus such as climbing up the song track taking horses i'm getting to activate a um a town i'm getting victory points and so on and something i should have also mentioned is that at any time you can actually use these coins to exchange a fur to another third um so it kind of turns first wild and for any reason you might want to do that you've got these ones here that let you take furs from the market this one here lets you climb up the soul track and take a new outpost ready to be placed on the board later i'm again taking more income from those tiles there giving you a big boost up the song track and getting you money and so on okay so let's share some thoughts on stroganoff and i have to say i'm out of almost all games in recent memory this might be the most difficult game for me to piece my thoughts together about and that is because there is no kind of

distinctive hook or mechanism that makes stroganoff stand out and i don't mean that negatively at all what i mean by that is that this really is a bunch of smaller systems patched together to make the finished article and as i said i don't mean that negatively but it does mean that the game is quite difficult to almost pitch to other players and to give somebody um or somebody who's not ready before an obvious approach on what to go for i suppose if anything you could say at least aim towards collecting one of the different types of um of tiles here because that's going to give you a healthy amount of points but also maybe try to climb down as far as you can along this track but everything else you almost have to work out as you go and this is definitely one of those games where um things will start to click into place the more you play it now i must admit something that i didn't like about this game is the way that the round structure is broken down i do find it somewhat confusing at least explaining it to other players um the first part yeah perfectly simple move one to two spaces or spend horses to go further perfectly fine the second part you know take the basic action and then those basic actions are one of five actions and one of those five actions you can take another kind of follow action by spending another coin um and one of those five actions is also to take another two actions if you match one of these and however if you don't have that that matching fair you can also spend a coin to make that fair wild to do that in the first place so if that's not confusing already then you go into the main action part and the main action you can actually forsake the main action to take a basic action and then you you can take another

action after that by spending a matching fur of the region you're in to take another main action or you can take another common action by just disposing of any fur so it is actually quite a confusing thing to break down and to explain to somebody where you know for me the best games are once where you know you do this on your turn or you get one of these four options and that's it so i'm not quite convinced that the actual um you know user interface or the way you do actions in this game is the best thing for it now that being said as the game goes on you do actually have some quite cool scope to pull off some pretty big moves um especially as you acquire more and more of these horses to give you flexibility and something i definitely learned is that these horses you know you need to be prepared to spend them they're not as um you know as scarce of a resource as you might think at first you know i was very reluctant to spend them i wanted to hold on to them to the best time where i did quickly learn that you know what if you have them spend them two capsules on it now um but as i said there are some good options here because if you want to travel really far you can by having those horses and you have some good flexibility in changing things from the market um the more and more you put outposts out you can start to line moves up as well and of course if you have money you can start turning things to wild and you can build up a little bit of an engine by acquiring more and more of these cars and it's also quite a cool touch that you don't actually have to spend most of these furs when you do them so just acquiring them is enough because i think it would have been a bit too stalling if you had to spend them each time i really do enjoy this outpost mechanism because again you

are normally restricted to the region that you're in in order to take those main actions but if you have spent that effort to put those outposts down then you are going to be anchored to a certain action and if you are again fully focused on doing something like say i really wanted to climb down on this track here and if i've got my outpost there then i'm always going to have the option to go back there meaning i can venture further start collecting all the first i need to climb further down on my track here and i can tie together and synergise with each other and pretty damn well and also something i didn't mention is that the more outpost you get down on the board the more points you get at the end so another benefit for doing that and it makes the you know the arc of the game feel a bit more alive because you are doing more or having more options as the game goes on there's also a pretty cool thread of tension when it comes to player interaction because you have to be quite careful with the opportunities you leave to other players like for example if somebody completely ravaged a tile and by spending all their actions to take all the furs then it's going to be quite easy for somebody to sweep in after you and only spend those couple of furs in order to claim the tile for themselves which will not only give you these bonuses but again potentially those end game bonuses as well um however you might be willing to spend a bit more because that's the exact tile that you want but it's going to cost you more first because there is still furs remaining on it so again it has that cool push and pull of wanting to deplete them but not deplete them too much so it invites other people to steal them from you um but being prepared to you know know what you're willing to pay for that specific tile and something else i briefly wanted to touch on but not make

a big issue of is that it does often feel like at least to me personally that you are jumping through quite a few hoops um in order to get little almost payoff for doing so because this is generally a low scoring game you're getting two points here or there and maybe a few more if you claim one of these tiles but again you're not getting those big bursts of points which i tend to generally enjoy more now again i know this is probably more psychological than anything but it does feel like you are doing a lot of work to get little um in return the game does take around 90 minutes to play which i feel is perfectly fine for the game not for a second did i feel this game outstanding it's welcome and i was engaged from start to finish i think you know for the first maybe half of your first game um you are just kind of trying to figure things out try to understand how you can get the most from the systems here the replayability for strobe and off is also fairly decent because the tiles are going to come out in different orders each time and sometimes you're not even going to see all the tiles um you've got a bunch of the different cards there you've got a bunch of the tiles and the song tiles and something i didn't mention is that not only do you have the matching play balls where everyone can play from the same board each player also has the option to play with a variable side which means you have your own little strengths and weaknesses okay so let's talk about the production for stroganoff now i do have the deluxe version here and i have not seen the standard retail version so i can't compare the two um but i think the main difference between them is that the deluxe version comes with these rather nice and um well cut little horse meeples these are very nice to play with

um and i like them a lot so yeah that's nice that you can have these and it's a shame that the retail version doesn't come with them because i think playing with you know standard tokens um isn't nearly as nice let's talk about the artwork so i think the artwork in this game is fantastic very atmospheric has this like hyper realistic look to it look at the water here i mean the actual artwork in this game is stunning really nice to look at when it's on the table and i think it's top notch and even the even actual um you know the character artwork looks fantastic as well definitely my style of art now something that the game brewer have received a lot of criticism for is the physical production of the game and i might even have to say that that is being blown a little bit out of proportion here well yes i can completely accept that maybe people were expecting a more lavish luxury deluxe um product here and this certainly is not that um but it is more than adequate you know the couple stock is you know fine at best but it does still feel relatively strong it's not going to wear out on you or anything like that and i'm not sure if a big part of that is the way that these cards um the tokens about are cut they do hold together quite well and i do feel somewhat robust okay so let's share some final thoughts on stroking off which i have to say i am pleasantly surprised by because there is some good decisions to be had here some cool combos some big moves you can pull off and i'm even a small degree of energy building when it comes to acquiring these cars and you do have to think ahead and plan and be quite savvy if you want to do well at this game which is all stuff i love and saying i'm pleasantly surprised with this game is probably a bit of a disservice to

a great designer like andrea sterling because he has made some of the best games ever to exist however however this one does feel definitely apart from those other games because it is undoubtedly more disjointed um it's definitely a mishmash of mechanisms and it doesn't have that harmonious hook or something to really grab your attention to you know get define the game for me so most of the time now if i want to get a you know a 90 to 120 minute game to the table i'm probably going to want to play something for a reason you know i want to play this game because of this mechanism um with stroganov i do kind of struggle to find its identity um you know do i want to get this game to the table because of because of what you know because i want to trade first for other pers and it's not even like the time track system is that strong it's all just again small parts to make an overall product that is actually pretty good and it works well so i think if you are willing to put that extra effort in and deal with something that isn't as refined or as sophisticated as some of those other designs there is still enjoyment to be had here but for me personally am i going to request to play um stroke it off and get it back to the table often absolutely not it's just not going to be the case because while there's nothing wrong with the game and i did enjoy my time with it there's also nothing terribly special about it either so yeah for that reason it's just not going to um you know stand out amongst the pack and demand 90 minutes of my time unfortunately you know game time is limited and this is just like another one of those games where it's another solid euro but in a sea of

great ones

Progress saved