Skip to main content
Loading video...

Gaudi Review: Swing from the Chandeliers

Transcript 20:13

Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassel.

I'm Wendy Yee.

And I'm Chris Yee.

Today we're taking a look at one of the newest games from Davier Gaudi, um or I don't know how to pronounce his name exactly.

maybe? Because the accent over the the I at the end there.

Yeah, this is from Danny Garcia and it is a game about

You got

You got it, Tom. That's the exact theme.

Well, yeah, okay. So just as a heads up, there's no theme in this game at all. Uh I mean, I guess there's a theme about

I I feel like it utilizes its its setting very well. You know, Gaudi, the Spanish architect and the you know, there's three different types of points you're collecting based off of three foundational principles of his architecture.

Sure. But anyway, no, there's no theme in this game at all. But

There's no story.

that doesn't mean it's a bad game. Who's teaching it? You are? Here we go.

I are. Here's Gaudi set up on the table. This is the central board over here where all of the actions are going to take place around the chandelier. There are these different which are in these different groups over here available to be pulled by actions that allow you to pull tiles of that color or of that shape. There are also cards down here that correspond to the three different types of victory points, the green nature cards, the red Catalonia cards, and the blue religion cards. The goal of the game is at the end of three rounds of play or three loops around the chandelier to have the most combined total victory points. The way that you do this is that you will earn victory points in your color in the three categories corresponding to the cards. So you have the nature symbol over here representing your nature points, the Catalan flag over here which represents the Catalonia points, and then your cross down here which represents your religious victory points. And as as I said, they correspond to these types of cards down here. On your individual player board, and each would have one out. I have only the red player set up here. You are going to be collecting these onto this dual-layer board here though.

The middle area is free-floating. You have room for your cards as you play them out of the different colors. You'll have a hand of cards as you collect them from the board here. It might be a little bit difficult to see, but these are simply card slots with three different cards on display in each color. And then you have your chimney tiles up here at the top that you'll be able to move up as you collect a combination of tiles of these different shapes, unlocking instant abilities or end-game abilities. Now, this is the basic setup side. There is a backside of the board that has a small little difference in bonus actions, and instead of playing with these symmetric puzzle pieces, you'll flip them over and play on the asymmetric side. I am not going to show you how that would slot in because these are puzzle pieces that puzzle piece in under the backside of the player board, which is a weird decision.

Now, let's talk about taking a turn in a Gaudi here. This is a an action rondel, meaning players are going to move as as far as many spaces as they want to on the rondel and then be able to take the actions as shown here by the pencils and the hammers. Now, the thing is that many games like this, if you were to move here, people assume the next player would be white because they're furthest back. That's not the case. In this game, you simply take turns in clockwise order. So red would take a turn and then yellow and then white player then red again, yellow, white, so on and so forth. Now, there is an incentive to jump further along because if when you land at an action space, you are the frontmost player, you get to take advantage of both the pencils and the hammers on that spot. If I as the red player were to jump over here, I have to choose between taking a pencil action or a hammer action. The difference is that the pencil represents taking the action as shown on the wheel right there on that space that many times. So one time here, two times here.

The hammer represents being able to take one of these three options. So a hammer can be used to take the action of the space that it is at just like a pencil or you can move up one of your chimney markers or you can play a card from your hand if you meet the requirements. If you meet the requirements as shown by the shapes here on your player board as a chimney hammer action, you can move this marker up and you gain this immediate bonus. So for example, this one allows you to grab any colored tile of any shape on the board and place it directly into your board and then these all have different upgrades. Some of them have end game effects. Now the other option is to play a card from your hand. You have a limit of four cards in your hand and these cards have requirements. So if you're allowed to play a card, if you play a green card into your display, it must be played into the green column. You will immediately activate every benefit in the green column. So you'll get four nature points plus two more nature points plus be able to draw one of the face up religion cards into your hand.

When you play a red card into your Catalan column here, you do not activate it right away. You will usually be able to activate the red column at most once per turn, no matter how many cards you play into it by taking this action, this symbol shown right here on that central chandelier tile, you then get to fire off everything in this column including grabbing tiles and earning Catalan points whereas the religion cards will only score at the end of the game. So these are going to give you the religion points so you won't earn as many of those throughout but you will get a good amount of them at the end. And so you'll continue to collect tiles of these colors from anywhere on the board regions and you can take them from different regions even to place them into your into your tile area immediately. You can draw cards. There are three cards on display of each color at the start of the game. So when the red player came here and they chose a red card to take, let's say they took this one into their hand.

Uh these don't refill and the tiles do not refill. If a player were to ever take the last tile from a space or the last card from a space on their turn, they'll activate the associated bonus. So in this case, this region awards three Catalan points. This area allows you to grab any tile of any color is what this symbol means. At the end of a turn in which a bonus is activated, you'll refill back up to the designated number of tiles or to the designated number of cards. The other actions here allow you to take any wild action that you want. Uh and then lastly, players are going to continue taking turns until one player jumps all the way to the end of the track, not this last action space, but the actual inside of the chandelier itself.

The first player to jump here is going to be allowed to do both parts of what is shown on this central tile space. Every other player then is going to continue taking actions until either they take an action in this red area here and then at the end of that turn, they will remove their marker to show that they are done or they can jump all the way over here to the chandelier as well, but they'll only get to take one of the two options. At the end of the game, you're first going to score up all of the cards in your religion column, the blue column here. You're going to score based on combinations of different types of cards you've collected, different shapes that you have on your board, or different objectives like how many times you've moved up one of the chimney markers in a specific color, for example. So scoring these up, I would get 15 religion points. At this point, players are going to sum up the value of their lower two victory point thresholds. So you see that's why white is at 37, summing up these two, ignoring their nature points. Yellow is at 44 by summing up these two, ignoring their Catalan points. And for me, before I do this, I do get to activate this ability here because I unlocked this. It said I can lose three points of one category in order to gain three points in category.

So now, my sum total will be the 35 Catalon points plus the 18 religion points. So I'll be at 53. Then players will go to their Tanaka these tiles here on the board, and they're going to score one point for every tile in their second largest contiguous group of colors and their third largest contiguous group. So you ignore the first largest, and so in this case, I would score 10 more points. And then other players would add points to their total value as well based on their tile scoring. Then whoever has the most combined points at this phase is the winner of God.

Um component wise for the game, uh there's a couple things I want to mention here. One, I think the rule book could have been slightly better laid out. It's just it's it's This game is has some funky rules to it. Like a very small example is if you move farther than everybody else, you get to use both things, right?

Mhm.

Player one, does that mean them too? Cuz there actually is no one else on the board.

Right, you have to kind of assume they are the single player

I went online and looked it up, and yes, that is the way it is. But I would have been very clear on that in the rule book.

I suppose. I actually To To make a small counterpoint, I think this is one of the best Devir rule books I've read in a while, actually.

I didn't read the rule book. Chris taught me, so I am out of this argument.

the most damning with faint praise sort of thing. I mean Uh okay. Other The other thing is and a lot of people have complained about this online, and because I saw the complaints, it wasn't as big of an issue for me. But people complain that the small little triangle pieces fall to the bottom of the bag and therefore don't get pulled as much.

I could see that.

And And I mean this is not a few. This is a decent amount of people complaining. I'm mindful of that, so I'm like shuffling around grabbing things.

pull from the bottom. Make sure you only have four of the five that you pull out depending on the side of the board, yeah.

I I Again, I didn't notice that, but I know people mention it. My bigger complaint is just such a minor one is I could never figure out how to put that one pentagonal shape on the board.

Oh my God.

I like keep spinning it, flipping it. Like, what on earth?

have just been a regular like even pentagon.

It's the quad tiles for me. The four-sided ones are like, okay, put the little end on this side. No. Flip it, rotate it.

See, I think the four's close enough that I I'm okay if it's messed up. But the yeah, the five-sided ones I'm like, now.

The tiles are a nice homage to the style of mosaic that Gaudi was known for.

this is a highly thematic game.

I totally get what they're going for. But yes, manipulating those pieces is sometimes a bit of like a It'll fit on there. Give me a second. Take your turn. Don't look at me.

But I also really enjoy the way that the pieces are tied in. Like, I love that little board that you've got in front of you, trying to get clumps of the same color, trying to figure out like, oh, I want the same color, but I can only take the same shape. Like, I think that makes really interesting choices as you're going through and picking all the same color or all the same shape or whatever. And then I also love when those pieces come off the board and you get that little bonus if you're the last one to take a piece. I think that's super cool.

Yes-ish. And I really like that too, but I've paled on that a bit because I think I don't love in games the whole chicken aspect that this game has.

Oh, yeah.

Like, I don't want to take the second last piece because I'm setting up for a bonus. And those bonuses aren't inconsequential. They're pretty good.

Mhm.

I think this is one of the reasons why I might prefer the simplified side of the board over the advanced side. The simplified's what we showed in the overview, uh, I believe. And in the advanced side, you can trigger bigger scorings. And I feel like that that is a more significant bonus to get. I think with the front side of the board where you can just get like three points of either thing or draw a card, it's important, but it's not so important that you won't take the second to last tile if it really fits in with your mosaic display because is to let you qualify for different things and advance up those chimney tracks and increase your third largest area so you get more points in end game scoring. I I think it compensates for that. On the advanced side it is a little bit I don't want I really don't want you to get that bonus.

But then it's really worth it if I'm like, okay, I'm taking the second last piece, how much do I want that piece? I really want that piece. Someone else is going to get that bonus.

I agree, but I still don't love that. I like, oh man, I'm setting you up to get those bonuses, especially the card bonuses.

the cards as well.

I take the card and get that card bonus. Now the game kind of lives and dies on two things. One is that

The rondel movement, yeah.

is kind of a weird a weird movement thing. It's it's different than most games because you want to jump to the front to get the extra actions. So usually people will because there's no benefit much at all to dragging behind, but at the same time sometimes you want to because of the action.

You have to really drag behind in order to draw out a lot of extra turns when other people finish. And I think that that's so fascinating. The whole like half of the rondel, half that chandelier is red. If someone jumps to the end, you only get one red action or jump to the end yourself and then you're done. But I have seen it where someone really just kind of like slow rolls in that yellow area for a while, gets like three or four extra actions. Yeah, they're weaker, but they get to draw cards, they get to play cards, they get extra tiles, and then they'll jump right to the end and do the chandelier thing.

Well, it's interesting because are they that much weaker? I mean, I guess they're that whole one less hammer or whatever,

Yeah, exactly.

if you're getting three or four more actions, that's significant.

I agree. It it it's kind of a tricky thing. I I do want to quick aside, I think they do a very good job with the two player variant on this or the because you have a third piece that just keeps moving.

And you don't have any other piece.

in front. Yep.

And that's and it makes the game so much easier but keeps it moving. So they did a good job on that. The other thing is the scoring. You know, take a page from Reiner Knizia's age old, your two lowest things are your score, but But three very different ways of scoring, right? One of them you don't even see till the end of the game, which makes me I never know who's going to win this game.

to balance.

I have no idea. Like, oh, you're all those points, but do you? Do you? You might get zero at the end. I don't know. I mean, for one of your scoring tokens.

Right. You shouldn't. But it is it is possible, and I do like that because it obscures things a little bit, but not completely. You look at someone who has four of those religion cards, you're like, well,

You're doing well for yourself.

Ex- exactly.

Yeah.

The game has a kind of a weird It It's over pretty quickly, actually, I think. It It It doesn't take particularly long. It feels like a deeper game. And I don't know that that's a bad thing. Uh my my first play through this I really was vis- enamored with it, and less so on on subsequent plays. And I think some kind of a mix on this one. Like I think I'm at a 6.5, which is really close. There's a lot that I like in the game. I like the the the different kinds of scoring. I like the combos that you can make. I like the rondel, even though I'm not a fan of the symbology on it. Drives me nuts. Like take the hammer or the what's the other symbol?

The pencils.

The pencils. And what does that mean? Well, that means the action that's right there. So

The written action.

I know. So then why not just I it just not it

It's not intuitive, right?

like this game is not an intuitive game. I think this is a game that's a that is a a little bit It's going to be a teach. I'm going to be like, all right, here we go. This is Let's start backwards. Your two lowest scores, these won't You won't score at all during the game. Take cards. There's a lot of different things to it, but once you played it, it smooths out. It's It's It's I think it has a steep learn, and then it's pretty easy to play. I'm all over the place with this one. There's a lot I like about it, but I'm not sold that I'm going to play it much more, and I think some of it is that the theme isn't there to carry me through, and so the mechanisms are starker. But I don't dislike it. I'm in the middle.

Okay.

Okay.

Yep. I I certainly like this one more. I appreciate that. It does what you said. It is kind of this mid-weight game, one that you can play easily in an hour, I think, in the evening, uh especially at the lower player counts, but it has a lot of the depth that Danny Garcia as a designer is known for in much bigger games. So I'm giving this one an eight. I really enjoy this. I like seeing the little homage to the you say it's themeless. I really disagree. I mean, it is a Eurogame through and through. It's mechanisms first, but all those mechanisms fit into this little homage to Gaudi and his architecture.

mean the tiles? But if you take the

The tiles, the cards.

doesn't. The cards.

Yeah, the cards that have these three different scoring categories that really uh every single piece of art By the way, phenomenal art, I think, from Edu Valls.

do really like the art.

No, no, no. I think it looks good. I'm not going to argue that.

Yeah. Is it a thematic game? Absolutely not, but it's not devoid of theme. It Every part of it I feel makes sense.

theme helps the game. I don't think the theme helps me learn the mechanisms.

I think it's I think it's stuff that's more Yeah, after you learn it, you can sit there and appreciate the different things that it represents.

That I I I I agree on that.

Yeah. And so I I I do Overall, I like the presentation of this. It drives me nuts that you have to put puzzle pieces at the top of your board and then somehow flip it over.

to mention that. That's one of the worst things in this game. And I And you can't glue them in.

No, cuz they're double-sided.

Ah, it's so annoying. Everyone I play this with is like Oh, man.

Yeah, it should have been from the top down. Yeah.

But yeah, so a few production like question marks, but I really like the core loop of the gameplay. I find it very fun. I enjoy building it up. And like I said, and getting done with that whole experience in 60 minutes, and it still feels unique and different.

I think unique and different is a big part of this for me. Um so I'm going to give this one an 8.5. I absolutely thoroughly enjoyed it. Um and I love that that rondel has a different feel. It's not just another rondel like we always see rondels, right? I really appreciate that. Um I appreciate the way that I don't remember what those little tokens are that you're moving up on the the puzzle piece things.

The chimney tiles.

But the advanced side of those chimney tiles are very cool. They add so much asymmetry to each player.

I do like those a lot.

I mean [clears throat] having opportunities to have specific end game scoring on those tiles, but you have to unlock them, that's amazing. Or to be able to have ongoing powers. Like they add so much unique and interestingness to the game and that's something that you really can chase. Um I also love the engine building of the cards and it um I love that they all work differently. And so you have that the one that's like immediate, immediate, immediate. I know what I'm getting, I know what I'm doing, I can easily track those points. And you have the middle one that's like I can kind of track these points, but they come in big chunks at a time. And then finally that end game one. Like I think that's very cool to try to balance out those things. I just had a blast with this. Really enjoyed Gaudí.

All righty. Well there you go. Gaudí. Go check it out from Devir right now. I'm Tom.

I'm Wendy.

I am Chris.

See you next time. Hey everybody, thanks for watching another video from The Dice Tower. Hey you want to learn more about us, communicate with us. We have a Facebook group, we have a Discord channel. Lots of different ways to get involved with The Dice Tower. You can find that in our Linktree link below. So just click that and it will take you and you can communicate with us on Facebook, join our Facebook groups. There's lots of cool things that you can find and become part of The Dice Tower. Thanks so much for watching. I'm Tom Vasel.

Drinking at a party or a get together then they like that your seventh cup like remember where your cup is. Stop stop getting a new cup every time.

Yes.

When I was a missionary

you should always be.

There's these two guys in in one of the apartments and they had a total of three cups and two bowls. And they're like it keeps us honest.

No, that's true.

Progress saved