On Mars Review - By Board Of It
Transcript
hello i'm tally this is farrell and we are border bit and today we're going to review on mars which is an absolute beast of a game for one to four players games by this designer italia are actually heavily debated some see them as overly complex and the amount of time it takes to learn them isn't worth the fun to be had however others see them as colorful and bright and that they're perfectly designed bringing together many complex systems into a wondrous sandbox of possibilities you will take the role of a corporation and your main goal besides getting the most victory points is to contribute the most to the colonisation of mars you'll send your mars rover and robots across the planet to discover locations and build your colony then you'll develop technologies and hire scientists to build bigger and better colonies hopefully becoming self-sufficient with no help needed from off planet you'll get one main action on your turn and then one secondary action you'll trigger the end of the game with a combination of building a thriving colony or completing these mission cards and the mission cards are just generally taking a specific action a number of
times between all the players
one small step for doggos one giant leap for doggo kind on mars came to our attention because it's already in the top 100 games on board dengue despite only coming out within the last year so we wanted to see what all the hype was about and having now played it we can totally see why it's in the top 100 and we wouldn't be surprised to see it climb even higher up the rankings it's actually a hard game to fit into a category and this is because there's a lot going on it's very complex but there's definitely some resource management it's definitely a strategy game and in fact in a lot of ways it's like terraforming mars in that you're going to be filling up this board here with little hexes that represent colonization but at its core it's just a work placement game with a twist you have an area on your playing hat called the living quarters where your colonists live and next to that you have another area called the working area almost every action you can do on the board will be circled in red or in teal and sometimes both will be circled such as over here red actions are pretty similar to classic work placement where you'll have to put a worker next to the action you want to take teal actions do not cost a worker but for every worker you send from your living area to your working area you get to repeat that action you can only use workers from your living quarters for actions workers in your working area are considered spent workers
this is actually a pretty interesting twist on classic work placement and we like it but it's also necessary for this game because of the fact that you only get one main action per turn and on top of that you can only take the actions in the section of the board where your astronaut is by being allowed to boost actions with your workers you're actually being asked to find a balance between getting as much as you can out of the single action and the cost of workers and resources versus spreading your workers out across several actions thereby having more variety to your strategy but getting less benefits from each action the game board is split into two sections one is in orbit and the other is the colony on mars and in each section you have different actions available to you in orbit has more preparatory actions such as collecting resources improving your technology or researching new actions the colony is really the meat of the game because as time goes on you'll become self-sufficient and may not even bother going back to orbit here is where you colonize mars and most of the actions are focused around building or using the technologies you gain from orbit to get back and forth you'll be taking the shuttle which moves between the two sections of the board at the end of each round the bigger colony you build the longer it will take for the shuttle to move back and forth players will decide if they want to change sections when the shuttle moves by moving their player token and then
picking a spot they want to go in and potentially gaining a reward players will also at this point gain back workers from the location they are traveling to and they will gain all of their meeples back from their working area into their living quarters whilst at its core the shuttle is a good system and it's thematic it can also be a bit of a hassle earlier on in the game you're going to have to deal with moving it every turn each player has to decide whether they even want to move and if they do they have to move their astronaut decide what place they're going claim their reward sometimes the reward will trigger the objective markers take their workers off the board and it can become even longer than your main turn and it kind of longs the game out i think the reason why we find it a little bit annoying is because in a game that's already so complex the shuttle is essentially forcing you to take an action just to get to the other actions that you want to do on one hand it's a nice system as it prevents the game having to be broken up into rounds just so players can retrieve their workers and it creates a nice flow and a game where the theme is intrinsically linked with the mechanisms on the other hand it's just a bit finicky and creates unnecessary work for all of the players following on from this we now describe the actions that you can take this lets you move your mars rover and robots the robot allows you to build tiles in
its immediate vicinity whereas the rover will move about the board and hoover up goodies this leads nicely into the building action which allows you to put down one of the six building tiles shown here building will also allow you to gain resources of the tile you're building here you can see that we've built them apart from each other if you want to build a complex which is multiples of one type of building connected to each other you need to take the tactile action over here most of these will allow you to build the complex as just mentioned but a few of the others will allow you to increase the people you get when you take this action move your rotor further or upgrade multiple buildings in one action you'll want to gain these tactiles because they'll be worth victory points at the end of the game and also because the more different complexes you've built the more victory points you're eligible for next you can use this action here to upgrade your textiles to upgrade tiles you move them along this track which will net you rewards increase the vp value of the set tile and also free up space to gain more tiles most importantly they will increase the effect of each tile so the space where they are plus three here will let you build bigger complexes another thing you can do in orbit is to gain blueprints blueprint cards are shown here and these allow you to upgrade your hexes that you build on the colony by putting one of these little buildings
on top blueprints allow you to unlock special actions as your secondary action during your turn such as this one allowing you to gain two crystals or this one allowing you to build a green house tile once you have a blueprint card you can do the upgrade action to remove the building from the card and put it on a hex of the matching type then you're now allowed to do this action this leads us nicely to the scientists you can do a gain scientist action which after paying the costs shown here you can take one of these scientists and the matching card usually you would have to pay two crystals to use one of your blueprint actions but if you have a scientist with a matching icon such this grass guy here the action is then free to gain new workers you can do a welcomer ship action and then you'll move one of your ships into here also unlocking another secondary action but then you pick between gaining two workers or a worker and a pot now the lss is quite an important part of the game this is just a tracker for how many of each hex there are in your colony on mars so say if we build a greenhouse we move this up we score the points shown under we score the points under the condition shown here and then also if we built a complex then we put one of our cubes here and
this section here depending how many cubes you have for how many complexes you've built different kinds is scored multiple times throughout the game when all of these match the space shuttle marker then you move this up and then things about the game will change so this for example tells you to score the progress cubes area and this now means that the shuttle is gonna take longer between moving from orbit and to the colony the further you go up and become even more self-sufficient you'll actually get closer to the end of the game by this point you're probably feeling pretty overwhelmed there's no getting around it that is how you're going to feel the first couple times you play i don't think the rule book ever left my hand the first time we played except look at the reference rule book this is by far the heaviest game we've played and even multiple games in it's still really hard to keep track of every system the actions you do aren't particularly difficult to understand but how they link in with each other is and combining that with having to move from one side of the board to the other will make your head spin one of the most difficult things about the game is that these relatively simple actions often have almost silly levels of cascading effects when you take them and it's really hard to keep up with every minute step of what you should be doing and just for example if i move into space and i pick the textile then i gain a tactile and then i put it
on my player board but then i pick which reward i want so then i get a reward by the way getting the tech tile is one of the missions so now i move this mission cube down but then i get rewards from that and then i go to put those in my player board and all of that that wasn't that wasn't a turn that was just moving to where i want to be to do a turn one of the harder things to keep track of is the mission cards and i think the problem with them is that rather like in most games they're used as a way to score victory points in this game they're used as a timer to count down the end of the game and in the game that's already so complex why would you spend brain power trying to remember something that doesn't benefit your final score and in practice what often happens is that someone will realize several rounds later oh that objective cube should have been moved about four times by now and you can also end the game by having thriving colony and increasing the level of the lss and i actually think i might prefer it if this was the only way you could end the game because first of all it would be a lot simpler and easier and second of all i find with the combination of the two if some of the games come in a little bit short a lot of our two player games are only kind of under 90 minutes and in a game this big it just doesn't feel like it should be that quick what we like about on mars is that the game tries to help you do whatever it is you need to do by providing multiple routes to the same action or resource so you rarely feel completely restricted and this system allows the gameplay to
flow for example oh you need a water but you don't have one you can use a mineral instead you need to take a red action but your other workers spend a crystal instead of a worker so your options are never limited like in other games summed up this game is a time investment if you buy this game you're going to have to commit to getting it on the table multiple times ideally within the first week the complex systems and design choices mean that the game will only pay off after you invest time in it which obviously means this game won't be for everyone once you put the time in this becomes a masterfully designed game it's a sandbox game in the way of scythe letting you travel whichever route to victory you desire in one game i might focus on the blueprints and building the advanced buildings and collecting scientists that match those whilst i might build sprawling complexes and collect contracts and score major points from them it's exceptional the way that each part of this game connects and interlocks together to create something impressively balanced there's a lot of replayability here with each game being wildly different in the way that it unfolds it's an interesting puzzle to try and figure out how to make your colony the best the pleasure of this game comes from watching you call me grow as you simultaneously unlock further actions this script allows you to be self-sufficient and do any action you desire which then allows you to attack the problem as you see best furthermore the game never
permanently locks you out of what you want to do somebody take the greenhouse tactile you can still use it the owner just gets a small reward or if you have a scientist but your opponent has the matching blueprint you can still use it it becomes a system of no player left behind where players can do what it is they want and what makes them happy this means that no player ever has to just spend their time counteracting what another player has done or racing towards something that then another player gets just before they do and then they have to be annoyed about it this is an expensive game no way getting around that but i don't we would actually argue it's worth it the components are incredibly well done and maybe the best we've seen the player tokens are wooden and customized and the cardboard tokens are sturdy and durable and the art design and the board are just a pleasure to look at in terms of the gameplay as well you could argue that the design that's gone into it and the complexity are also worth the price tag we're going to do our quickfire review comments this game is beautifully designed in every aspect from art to components to gameplay it will be difficult to learn and it will require you to put the time in however games are surprisingly short once you've got scripts with it there is high replayability due to the sandbox nature of on mars also it doesn't really change at different play accounts you get the same simon from three or four player games as you do have two players it's fun to explore mars with your robots and make the best colonies they really
nail the theme they make some questionable design choices with a lot of things adding to the complexity without being worth the hassle there's almost too much to keep track of with insane domino effects occurring from simple actions the choice to end the game with mission cars i find a bit arbitrary and unthematic if the point is to build a thriving call me i don't see how having a few extra robots signifies that mars is complete feel like we've spent a lot of time discussing the complexity but the end of the day it can be learned and it is a fun game it's a great play how you want to play game and you get a real sense of progression from watching your economy develop and grow whilst it's not for everyone we do really recommend it bye-bye you