Skip to main content
Loading video...

Lancaster & Expansions Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 22:16

hey everybody today i'm talking about lancaster which is a 2011 release board game um by queen games and designed by uh matthias kramer who's quite a prolific euro game designer made games such as glenn moore obviously glenn moore 2. and rococo so he's one of the designers that i kind of hold in quite high esteem and a game designer that i trust to be honest um anything he brings out always kind of turns my head and gets my attention this one is a two to five player game takes about an hour and a half to play maybe a bit more if you add in some of the expansions um and it's kind of on that medium weight level so not overly complex but it does have quite a bit going on again especially if you add in the extra kind of expansion modules the main mechanisms are worker placement area control and you've also got a bit of sat collection in there as well and the idea of the game is that we have this kind of fleet of knights and you're using those nights as your workers to deploy on different kind of counties around england um and when you go to these counties you can do a lot of different things such as upgrade your knights power you can you know get a new knight into your kind of um into your team you can get no rules which these these notebooks kind of sit on your um in your big kind of dinner table and they give you not any set collection bonuses or points at the end of the game but they also give you voting power in one of the future rounds which is quite important

additionally you can just get points or you can upgrade your own castle which kind of has a little bit of an engine building style feel to it and on top of that you can also choose to kind of commit your knights to different battle battles with france which almost has this kind of area control style mechanism um and whoever kind of contributes to most of the fights gets more points than anybody else so um yeah there's quite a bit going on um and the the flow of the game is pretty simple um uh but something i do kind of hike on about quite a lot is with worker placement games um is that i like to there to be something um a bit extra a bit um you know an extra layer to them to kind of differentiate themselves from all the standard you know mediocre worker placement games out there because worker placement is an extremely popular um mechanism and obviously with popularity becomes a lot of kind of mediocrity as people kind of just put stuff out there um but this one is different because when you are deploying your knights to these different spots um obviously these nights have different strengths um you haven't secured that spot because once you deploy someone it's going to go on to the next player and if they if they want to they can actually choose to kind of overpower you on that spot and kick you off it so say i deployed a level one knight to there and then my opponent deployed a level two knight he would kick me off that spot and return my knight to me um and then obviously if it comes back around to me i can choose to deploy a level three knight and so on so there is this kind of jockeying position on the um positions that you want which i really like and it makes um a good amount of conflict in the game

without being too punishing because you you as i said you get your knights back so you can always redeploy them or outbid your opponent going forward now on top of that you've also got this other resource um in terms of squires and these squires are basically um a kind of a consumable resource where you are well when you use them you can use them to kind of bolster the strength of your knights to um kick someone else off but then if you're if your kind of position with the squires is also replaced then all those squares are going to go back into the kind of um you know the common pool you're not going to get them back so they are expendable um when when you kind of deploy these things on the spot you've got to weigh up whether you want the um whether you want the nobles which is quite important as i said for scoring and and other reasons or you want the other bonus and that kind of option of choosing one or the other is quite important because the nobles are very scarce um say for example in a three-player game there's only two nobles from each in each of the counties so not everybody's going to have access to all of the nobles which again adds a bit more tension and player interaction into the game but you can also always pay three money in order to um get both of the bonuses so money is another very tight and extremely useful resource in the game on top of all those things going on on the board you have um you have your own player board which is a castle and you can also deploy your knights to those um to spots on your castle board which is safe you know you can't be kicked off your own castle board um but they can give you things such as giving you more money giving you um

you know more squires um you know and stuff like that so there is there is kind of a way to get more income and additionally um when you go to certain spots on the board you can add new kind of tiles to your own castle which means that kind of at the end of each phase or at the end of each round of the game you get income based on where you've upgraded so you don't actually have to deploy workers there so you know if you have that castle upgrade that gives you money each turn um then you are going to automatically generate that money each round which is a nice kind of progression in the game and um a way to kind of mitigate expending your workers to do kind of mundane or kind of things that you you need every round um so after you've kind of deployed all your workers um the the kind of the the phases are quite interesting because uh you don't actually the way the game plays is you don't actually get all the rewards instantly as i said obviously you have to um you know make sure your knights are settled in there and not getting kicked out by other players um but once they're all in there you go into kind of a voting phase which is a really cool a very unique mechanism and to be honest what i haven't really seen in anything else and this is where your nobles or how many nobles you have is very important because for each noble you have you're going to get a voting cube and at the start of the game you're also going to be given like a a thumbs up token and a thumbs down token and um basically at the start of the game there's going to be three laws on the on on the separate player board and those laws are going to kind of give you rewards or you know punishments based on certain criteria on the board so one

might say if you have all your level two nights deployed you can get a bonus or um you know the person with the most um you know knights committed to battles is gonna get a bonus and every every round you're gonna have three new laws that come up ready for voting and you're gonna kind of resolve each one each time being being voted on and you are going to either bid you know yes you approve that law or no you don't approve that law and you can also commit a number of these voting cubes to that vote as well and obviously depending on the board states some players are going to really want those laws to go through because it's going to benefit them and some players are going to not want them to go through either because they're going to hinder them or it's going to help another player quite a bit so there's this really cool um idea where you you almost the game rules change as the game goes along and based on what the other players want to do and based on kind of about voting prowess and so on so i really like that kind of dynamic board state where you know you you're catering your gameplay to the current laws but again you can bring new laws in to um you know to be a bit more malleable to suit your needs and i really do like that it's very cool um the there's a battle as i said the there's another kind of um conflict area of the game as well which is based on these area controls um where you know you're deploying your knights to these different spots um based on these cards um which represent battles with france and these cards have different strengths some might be as low as um i think even two or three and some might be as high as a 10 i believe um and the the idea is that you are trying to um not only by yourself but with the other players fight off the french by

um you know matching the power level of that card with your combined knight strength and um whoever's dedicated the most is going to get the kind of the higher um nominate or um number of points the next person is going to get the second highest and so on um but additionally if you if you fail that battle then you are going to basically those cards are going to slide down and your knights committed to these fights are going to remain committed which means that for the future round you are not going to get those notes back um however you are given some incentives um because when you do send a knight to battle you get an instant bonus and those bonuses can be very useful such as taking any noble from the board which is particularly powerful you can get an upgrade a night upgrade you can get quite a bit of money you can get squires and so on so there is that incentive to go to those spots um you know so that you are not just sending them there just to be committed or stuck somewhere for the rest of the game or for a few rounds at least um additionally with the um with one of the expansions which i highly recommend adding the expansion i mean for this particular review i'm talking about the big box version which comes with all the expansions and i think it's called the king's resentment where if you don't commit um a one of your knights to a losing battle then you actually take a resentment token and they give you negative points at the end of the game and whoever has the most kind of resentment tokens at the end of the game gets another huge punishment and based on a loss of points it's a bit like the corruption in lords of water deep and works a bit like that um so yeah there's another real incentive to get involved in those fights

and that's going to be basically how the game plays out um if you want to add further expansion to the game there is stuff based on a um kind of like a clergy board i forget the actual proper um terminology for the game um where you have a priest token and that priest kind of lets you take certain other powers throughout the game so it's bolstering your fighting prowess or giving you an extra kind of two night strength to add to something else so you can really bolster up your forces and even um kind of protecting you from certain spots on the board so say you wanted a particular worker placement spot in in england then you can put a token on it saying that you can't be kicked off that spot which again can be very powerful and particularly if you want a particular noble so yeah they're all very useful again all very lucrative and you really want those spots um in addition to that when you do send one of your priests to those spots you have to almost pay a bit of a tribute um it could be either a voting cube a bit of money or a squire and it goes into this big pool of kind of gained resources and then you know as opposed to going to one of those other spots to get those bonuses you can go to a separate spot which lets you take all the rewards that have been contributed to that to that particular spot on the board which is really cool so the incentive does build up as the game goes on um so yeah once you've resolved all those things you know it's gonna be quite formulaic about how you get your awards so you're gonna basically um get all the bonuses you've dedicated to england you're gonna resolve the you know the the religious board you're going to resolve all the conflicts and so on so

it's quite formulaic and the phases are quite distinct about how things are resolved and then you'll go on to the next phase and so on and there's also an additional spot as well where you can put your workers on to get rid of these um corruption tiles or these um you know these shame tiles when you don't contribute to the fights which can be quite lucrative particularly at the end of the game because you want to shed all those negative tiles and not only to not to suffer the negative points but also not to be the person with the most of them because again that can hit you very very hard so yeah there's a lot going on in this one and you've got to stretch your workers quite far because you want to do so many things at once and you can't do it all really um so meaningful decision-wise there is a lot a lot there because as i said you you know if you're contributing fights or or people to the battles then you can get a bonus but if you do that you're not kind of adding your workers to the um to the main board which can affect your kind of uh you know the laws that you voted on and so on um you want to get involved in the in the clergy board because again you want those bonuses and additionally you can get these seals which gives you a huge amount of points at the end of the game if you collect more bishop tokens um so yeah i know there's a lot going on here but um this is with everything into the game so i only really played this game with all the expansions involved because that's the kind of way i like to play games however if you want to strip back to just the kind of the conflicts and the england board with the with the um obviously the law stuff still involved then you can without the

whole corruption thing without the whole um you know bishops and priests side of the game so that really is an additional tack on thing if you want to really ramp up the complexity um so yeah mechanically and it's very very cool i mean in terms of the jockeying position but decision-wise as well there is a lot a lot to factor in and every decision is very important because there is so much um push and pull and kind of uh you know a loss and gain variance to be weighed up at all times time investment wise i mean the game takes about probably about an hour and a half to two hours if you are including everything into the game um if it's just the base game alone i'm sure you can get this down to about an hour um but i really do feel like all that other additional stuff is is almost a necessity particularly if you want to keep going back to the game um so i do like that um uptime is a bit of a strange one because the actual main focus or the main kind of play phase of the game flows by very quickly and because you are just smashing your workers down you're knocking each other off and so on so it's very kind of um you know very very involved very engaging during what the actual play phase but once you've done that part of the game the whole scoring system and the whole um housekeeping and stuff like that going as a very formulaic phases in order to resolve things um that does slow the game down quite a bit um to a bit of a halt um and it almost feels a little bit dated in terms of that side of the game because i think a lot of these games now or not

more modern games bear in mind this game is nine years old at this point um tend to have a bit more of a free-flowing feel to it rather than a kind of play-play play a load of housekeeping play play play a load of housekeeping so this one does kind of feel a little bit dated and i'm being i'm being very nitpicky in terms of that um so the resolvement or the resolving of all the kind of action or the placements is is a bit jarring um and obviously that that applies to the kind of uptime feel of the game replayability wise um is again i've played i've had this game in my collection for quite a few years now and i've played it i think five times at this point um and i think i'm just about at that point where i've i'm done with the game and to be honest i don't i don't often play games as often or even up to five times i mean a lot of the times i just play them a couple of times um because i don't really see much reason to go back to them because i feel like i've explored everything so five playing this game five times is is right for me i mean it's a pretty good standard of of kind of replayability however i i don't think i could get to that kind of 10 15 and play mark um but a part of that is my kind of own taste because i like to keep playing new things um however i think if you are one a player who really loves do coming back and backing back to a game this one is okay i mean there is a lot of different strategies you can go down and focus on you know do you really want to focus on conflicts do you really want to focus on the you know religion board do you want to

focus on getting a whole really strong force of knights um but there isn't like a whole wide variety of kind of different engines you can build or different things you can try um and you know you're going to be basically seeing the same thing gaming and game out um interaction wise is excellent in this game i really love the um i said the almost area control base with the worker placement you know that really jockeying position for the for the sports you really want that is super cool and also the lore part of the game is awesome a great kind of tension trying to get the laws you want in trying to kick the laws you don't want out i absolutely love that so yeah player introduction wise is fantastic for a euro game ascetically as well i think the game looks okay i mean it's not an ugly looking game it almost has like kind of stuff a euro feel to it and which does turn some players off but i i happen to quite like it the the graphic design is a bit um it's a bit primitive um in terms of the cleanliness of it it almost feels a bit almost like pixelated like it's it's not crisp and clean and bright um however component-wise are really cool i mean that you have very chunky wooden pieces and something that was particularly cool about the game is that the almost the strength of each knight is based on how big it is so uh the strength one night is particularly quite a thin bit of a wood the strength strength two knight is double the size of that the strength four night is double the size of that so you could physically see the strength of each knight being deployed which is a really cool thing a very

tangible way of um and a physical way of showing the strength of each piece so i do love that side of the game and it's really well done to be honest um theme wise as well i actually do really like the way the theme is used in this game the idea of collecting all these these um laws getting them into your kind of circle of influence onto your huge banquet table using their influence to push laws through that suit your needs is very cool and of something quite unique um to games or eurogames um and i haven't really seen it done this well before um additionally you know if you don't contribute to battles you're so you're giving or you're receiving resentment from the king you know because you're not contributing to the kind of military aspect of things i really do like that and i think the the use of theme is very well done um setup and teardown time is a little bit of a pain um not overly um but because you have to um you know circle the different nobles and they're all unique and you have to put them all the different spots um giving each pair their workforce to play them on the board setting up all the lore tiles and stuff so there is a bit more set up and housekeeping than your average game i'd say um but it's not a short game and i think it's just about proportionate it's a slight obstacle in getting it to the table but nothing too bad um progression of the game is fantastic i really do like the way that you start with a very small force of knights you know i think it's just a level one and a level two night and as the game goes on you're getting not only you upgrading them you're bringing new knights in

and you're getting rewarded by points at the end of the game by um having the biggest night force of knights additionally as the game goes on you're upgrading your castle which again gets your engine building to get you more and more income each turn um and and so on so there really is a great sense of progression in the game and you know by the by the fifth round of the game you're doing a hell of a lot more than you are in the first round of the game and i i i think that's really well done um scalability wise as well i mean this game has a horrible two-player version of the game and i'd never even consider playing a two-player it really is um a three four or five player game and to be honest i think five players might be a bit slow um i really i really think the sweet spot of this game is three or four players um and if that's your kind of game size or group size then um this is going to suit you um and comparison wise i mean obviously there's a lot of worker placement games out there but this one is different enough to be distinct to those other games and stand out i think slightly uh head and shoulders above a lot of the generic style games because of the aspect that you can push people off this spot because of that lore board um and so on you know it's really is a great mesh of mechanisms without being too um too much of a learning curve because they're all pretty simple in their own right but they come together very nicely but yeah overall um this is a super game it is very well put together um you know cream kramer is a great designer um i said my only slight problem with the game is that the the you know the main kind of

play phase and the housekeeping are quite separate and quite distinct and you know do offer a bit of scope to lose interest or to lose your engagement when you are just going through the motions of collecting risks or collecting your upgrades collecting all your different rewards you've used during the actual play phase um but in addition to that you know i've had this game in my collection for quite a long time now and i've always completely you know shout from the rooftops about how good it is and you know and it really is a fantastic game um but i am at a point now where i don't feel like i need to play it again um and you know if you'd asked me um you know before i played it my mother most recent time i would have said this game is a an absolute must-have and um you know euro game or gamers collections because it is so different at the player interaction is great and so on um but i think there does come a you know a point where that you know the camel's back is broken where you want to um where you're ready to move on from it because i think you can explore everything the game has to offer in as i said in that kind of bracket of five to ten plays um and it won't really go much beyond that but you know if if if you don't really play games much beyond that anyway this is certainly one to check out it is much better than most and worker placement games i definitely put it in my top you know four or five workout placement games of all time because i really do think it's that good um just super well put together a great production really fun um and you know just just just really clever to be

honest and that is my kind of thoughts on lancaster if you love your worker placement it's great because there is so much going on you can tell you the tailor the play to your kind of complexity or complex needs because the the additional modules do add a lot to the game and um can kind of differentiate your strategy as compared to just playing the core game alone but yeah that's that's lancaster i highly recommend giving it a go um it gets a similar quality for me and again if you asked me a year ago it would have got a seal of um my you know my elite seal um but again ready to let this one go because i've had my um i've had my worth out of it and i've really enjoyed every single play for it i think if i played it again i would just be kind of tainting that experience because i've again i've experienced what it has to give so i hope you've enjoyed this review if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved