Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 22:30

thank you hey Gamers this is Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and I'm here with a preview of an upcoming game from Salt and Pepper games called Witchcraft and this game is designed by David Thompson Roger tankersley and Trevor Benjamin and they are the same design Trio that's behind another game that I really enjoyed from the same publisher called resist mechanically I would say this game is sort of a follow-up to resist that builds on it in some ways so if you've already played that game uh then you're this will then a lot of this is going to look familiar but I'm also going to give an overview as if you haven't uh just some disclosures before we get started I do not do paid previews this is a preview that I'm doing because I like doing previews for David Thompson he and I are close personal friends and we are designing a game of our own together and the other reason I always take previews from David to be honest with you is that he and his co-designers hopefully including me in the near future tend to have finished games even before they go out to be crowdfunded so the rules for this game are essentially complete as you can see this is real art this game is fully cooked already and even though there might be some minor changes that take place between now and publication we're not dealing with something where massive development still needs to take place but this is a setup for witchcraft and essentially this is a game in which you are playing a deck of witches who are fighting against actual Supernatural evil that is threatening the town

however you are not necessarily going to be believed by the people of the town that your magic is good while other magic out there is bad and inevitably that means they're going to be witch trials so your goal in this game is to persuade each of these jurors that witchcraft is not so bad after all and that you are a trustworthy and valuable member of the community in order to persuade them you have to bump their persuasion meters up to a degree that is actually not fully specified and we don't actually know because these are their conviction cards and they're face down they're gonna be things that we can do throughout the game to kind of see what's under there but we've got some kind of number to overcome and it can be fairly low or it could be pretty high so the conviction card values range as high as six although the average of two cards is going to be about seven so seven is your working persuasion number but you really don't know you could have somebody who's super tough to persuade or somebody who is totally willing to trust you which is is a bit of a pushover which we like those we like those jurors so in order to please the jurors uh your job is to come over here and complete these missions so these are missions that are decided by the jurors that you draw so as you can see there are symbols in the top right hand corner of each of these cards they're going to match the symbols on the mission cards that form our mission deck for this particular game so you're gonna see different missions depending on what combination of jurors you have they also impact some of the challenge cards so there's a basic of challenge

cards that appear in every game there are also a few extras for each of the jurors that again are marked by their specific symbol and what's going to happen is that we're trying to overcome these Mission values with the number on our witch cards which we're about to look at and we also are going to have to deal with a number of challenge cards that come up for the mission and that are placed on here face down beneath each of these missions so we don't actually know how challenging the challenge cards are going to be and so maybe it's too late but that's just a risk we're gonna have to take at the bottom of each Mission you're also going to find out what happens if you either fail or succeed there are various consequences sometimes even to success and also if you do succeed you're going to find out which of the jurors you're going to be able to persuade so the higher number is going to be the juror with the matching symbol in the top right and the lower number is going to be just any other juror so for example if I want to protect our children at the school then Ichabod who is bookish book book is particularly persuaded by that and if I succeeded this Mission I can bump his persuasion up by two If I complete this Mission but I want to persuade Cornelius or Elizabeth then I'm going to have to only bump them up one for this Mission because the symbols don't match so the way to win the game is to get all these persuasion meters high enough how do you lose well losing is a lot easier than winning that I will tell you you're gonna lose this game if either you fail two missions as in like two missions throughout the whole thing you only have one chance to make a mistake or else it's over and there are two other ways to fail one

is when the total number of villagers on the cards in your lost soul pile is five or greater so this is our villager deck and they're gonna be things in these missions and in these challenge cards that basically kill our villagers and so when that happens you have to flip cards off the top of this deck there are varying value sometimes it's one villager sometimes it's like three villagers but if your villager lost soul total of of cards you've flipped over into your lost souls pile ever hits five then you automatically lose this game the other way to lose is if you're told to gain a curse when your curse file is empty so into this play Deck that we have we're gonna talk with the witches in a moment I have already shuffled three curses there are three more curses in the little curse deck hanging out that I might have to gain at various times so if I have to gain a curse and they're all already in my deck then I lose the game whoops so the odds are very much stacked against you and it's just gonna be something that you have to deal with you know It's just tough being a witch out here So speaking of the witches themselves let's look at their cards basically my thought is I'm going to give you just this overview of the game we're gonna play maybe a sample Mission and call it because I like my previews to be short I don't know about y'all but we have two decks here that contain witches this is our actual active deck and this is a recruit deck of which is that maybe we can get maybe we can't it just kind of depends on what's on these cards I'm also just gonna look at some cards from here I want to talk about what's on them so on each card you have witches so this particular deck is just the recommended starter deck for your first game in a

more advanced game of Witchcraft you're going to want to draft where you just draw two witch cards and you pick one but these are going to tell you basically everything you need to know so these witches are interesting because you have these dual sided cards so you have a hidden side and a more powerful revealed side but there are consequences for revealing yourself and you're also going to have a family name so one thing that's kind of interesting about this game is that a lot of the witch cards are connected because they're from the same family and they're going to get mutually reinforcing abilities if they're in your hands together because they're in the same family so part of your drafting might be oh I want a bunch of witches from the Kent family or oh I want a bunch of witches from the Miller family and you know you might deliberately go for those combos that you have some good Synergy in your deck the other thing that is immediately noticeable about these cards again is their dual sidedness so when you play a witch card you have to choose which side you're going to play it for so you have a hidden side which is less powerful but might have an ability that you really want and then you have a revealed side which is more powerful typically and might have a more powerful ability however if you reveal one of your witches They're Gonna Leave Your Hand they get revealed as a witch and they go to jail and so part of the issue with playing the revealed side even though even though it's the most powerful is that it's going to thin your deck out anybody that gets put in the Hidden Side goes back into your deck eventually they go in your discard pile and you'll shuffle them up when it's time and so hidden powers are less potent but they are also safer because it keeps these witches in your deck you want to

make sure you're playing your revealed Powers at times when you really really need to in order to keep from thinning your deck too much too soon one thing that's also interesting is these families have different kinds of powers that influence different things so uh Catherine Kent here does things that have to do with the curse pile whereas there are other witches that are going to do things like let you look at conviction cards or let you remove challenge cards or peek at or manipulate them in some way and so you're also going to be drafting for the different skills that are going to let you get where you need to go in the game so let's just go ahead and play One mission and then we'll call it and basically we're gonna draw a hand of five cards one one two oh that's a curse three four oh no another curse five so basically What's Happening Here is I'm already kind of in trouble because these two curses are unplayable they serve to clog up your hand which is why you don't want a bunch of curses from the curse pile to make it into your hand so we're just going to set these down for now and then I have these witches so if I play them strictly for their Hidden Side I can only generate four power which is enough to overcome some of these missions like four four three however it's not going to be that easy because you can see these challenge cards down here ready to get in my way and make things hard sometimes you can't even beat a mission if there's a challenge card that's guarding it and I just don't know what's under here so I'm gonna have some kind of weird issues trying to make it through this first hand so the first thing I'm allowed to do is play witches so I don't actually have to choose my mission yet I have the option

to play some of these witches for their powers first so let's see if they have any powers they're gonna help me so we've got Gwen Hayes on her Hidden Side it says choose a mission for each Haze including Gwen and play discard a face up challenge and replace it with the top card of the challenge deck so this will let me get rid of some challenges that were face up if I hadn't me that were for the revealed side it says move one or two face up challenges from One mission to another mission with fewer than eight challenges so challenges can really pile up as you might have noticed this game's a bit of a table hug but this again will let you manipulate those challenges if they're face up which none of them currently are although I will get to choose a mission and then maybe play this after the mission is chosen we've got Catherine Kent who we just saw uh for her for each kins including Catherine and play you can discard one curse from your hand to the coven discard pile and then draw a card from the coven deck to replace it that sounds like a great idea because I'm feeling super low right now on good wishes to play and then if she's revealed it's plus one power for each curse in the curse pile so right now if I play her on her revealed side then she is worth one two three 456 power which is nothing to sniff at so I can either try to get a better witch card and win that way or I can reveal her and get her kind of at max power before some of these curses start making it back into my deck and then we've also got Mercy Lily so on hidden she's two she doesn't do anything uh on revealed for each Lily including Mercy in play I can draw one card from the recruit deck choose one it's a place in

your hand and Shuffle the others back into the recruit deck so basically I can replace her with another witch by revealing her but it also makes her power go down a little bit all right so now I have to decide what to do I have two different play witches phases so I think what I might do is I could go ahead and play Catherine and discard one of these curses and try to get somebody else out of the deck but actually I think I'm just gonna go For Broke and play her for her revealed side just to demo how that works so I'm not gonna play any of my witches in this first phase I'm just putting these to the side now I'm going to choose my mission and so that means that I am going to I have to pick a mission do my best and like look at the challenge situation I end up with so now it's a question of which Mission will I choose I can try to protect our children at the school which I personally feel attached to as a mission and if I succeed I can discard One Challenge from another mission which is pretty cool I can choose to investigate strange noises at the mayor's house uh that will let me draw a conviction card and add it face down to Elizabeth if I fail oh God yeah we don't oh we don't need to fail this Mission that's that's bad it's the easiest one to beat except that we don't know what's in here and then over here if we fail investigate strange lights at the church then I have to search the villagers deck for the zero card and remove it from the game and then Shuffle the deck so there is one villager card that's a zero and like that's good you want that so this makes it riskier to lose villagers if I fail at the same time it's got fewer

challenge cards so maybe it's a little easier to beat I don't know I think I'm just gonna go over protect our children at the school because everybody wants to protect children at the school right this is my natural inclination I can't help myself all right so here's what I'm gonna do I've chosen this Mission For Better or For Worse I could fail it this could be really bad uh we're gonna flip these over great oh so Charming so many nice little possessed enemies oh God plague rats and duendes so this is really bad actually um because I got some really nasty challenge cards in here oh Lord all right so here's the thing the challenge cards are basically here to make it harder for me to defeat the mission but I have to defeat the mission because if I fail two of them uh then I'm gonna lose the game so for me what this is really about is how many of these things can I defeat while also taking the mission down and there are consequences to everything that I do so for example if I failed this one I will decrease the persuasion of all jurors by one but it's got a four value which is as much as the mission playgrounds if I fail it I lose a villagers card so that's rough and both of these possessed are related to different jurors so for success I get to uncover one of Elizabeth's conviction cards which would be cool but if I fail I have to decrease her persuasion by one and this one does the same thing but for Cornelius and they have these pretty

pricey values up in the top left corner so what am I going to do all right well I've already decided I'm going to play Catherine on her revealed side uh she's gonna go to jail for this but it's worth it you know because she's gonna be worth six it's plus one power for each curse in the curse pile and there are three of them there right now so that means that she is worth six so I at least have four and then maybe some more spillover and let's see I'm gonna play mercy Lily on the Hidden Side for two which puts me at a total of eight and then I've got Gwen Hayes what I want to do with Gwen Hayes I think I'm gonna go ahead and play her on her Hidden Side and I think what I'm gonna do is so I'm gonna play around her Hidden Side for one value and then I'm gonna take her hidden action so it says choose a mission for each Haze and play there's only one I can discard a face up challenge and replace it with the top card of the challenge deck so maybe I want to try to get rid of this one because I think it's particularly nasty so we'll get rid of this one oh great lost soldiers even better so if I fail this one I lose a random hidden witch and I have to place the Lost soldiers back on top of the challenge deck oh man well then that was Charming uh okay so now I have to figure out who I'm actually gonna be so I have six seven eight nine power we're certainly going to get rid of the um protect our children at the school we

just are then I have to decide which of these I want to beat so I definitely want to I have five to spend so I could do something like one of the possessed and one of these more expensive cards which I think is what I'm gonna do we're just gonna accept that Cornelius is gonna be mad at us that could be a huge mistake but you know it is what it is so we're gonna defeat the mission and then we're gonna use our remaining five to take out the possessed and the lost soldiers here so these will get killed and these will remain so now I'm going to resolve my challenges one at a time and we're just gonna get through them and then we're gonna do kind of mission cleanup so this first possessed I have managed to kill it with two for a success I can uncover one of Elizabeth's conviction cards which I will a four oh God okay well now I know we gotta gotta work on Elizabeth over here not as cool as the Elizabeth who's me um so this goes into discard and then we've also got lost soldiers uh we didn't fail them and that was the main thing but we are going to fail these two so in the case of a failure I had to decrease cornelius's persuasion by one so he's dumped to zero this dude don't like me much uh oh and then for plague rats I have to lose a villagers card so that's two villagers out of the five that I can lose in the lost souls pile yikes so these have been resolved

and here I am with some success on protect our children at the school so I did succeed in this Mission I get to discard One Challenge from another mission so let's just take this one it was some skeletons I mean I can't overcome a mission while it has any skeletons so yeah that could be have been that could have been unpleasant let's go ahead and discard that goodbye I'm Happy YouTube got rid of that one for a future mission and then I also get to do some persuasion so this one is linked with Ichabod so we're going to bring his persuasion up by two two just this three because the book matches his book I can push him up by two and then this mission is complete and we're drawn to the mission so now I've got a new one that I could choose destroy the skeletons in the cemetery we're gonna set it up for more

and I also have to resolve what's up with my witches so Catherine Kent revealed herself she's gonna go to jail over here she's in my revealed pile These Fine ladies are going to go into discard with the curses then I would draw up to five as you can see there's another lovely curse in here but I would basically start this process again so I will be able to use a new hand to choose and confront a new mission so you'll notice that I skipped one step that's on as player Aid if you were being very observant so we're gonna talk about it now and that is go to trial so we're not going to go to trial trial is a choice that you make unless there are no more missions left in which case you have to go to trial so basically if you keep taking on missions you just go ahead and recover you do all of your cleanup and all that kind of stuff if you do go to trial basically that's going to involve uncovering all of these conviction cards and seeing if we've managed to persuade the jurors if we witches are not so bad after all and so you're going to have to do well on these missions in order to push those Persuasions up and it is not easy to do not even remotely easy so that's just a very basic overview of Witchcraft um I really like this game but that's not really a surprise I tend to like David Thompson's design Style and I think that he and Trevor Benjamin and Roger tankersley are a really good team I've enjoyed their work together in the past tremendously so it's no surprise that I like this game

but truly I I do think it's good I'm biased but I think it's good for those of you who have played resist you're going to notice this is basically the same game as resist except it's got a different theme and we have this entire jury persuasion trial thing going on and then the fun links between which family members and so there are mechanisms added onto this that kind of build on what resist was doing and are maybe able to make things a bit more exciting and so the real question for people who've already bought resist is do I need this game too that's a hard call to make because if you already just like resist and just resistant itself is enough for you maybe you don't want the extra bells and whistles or maybe you prefer the resist theme I personally if I only had to get and keep one would actually prefer to have witchcraft I prefer a historical theme when I can get one but I think this is a really fun theming it's a really nice implementation of Witchcraft and witch trials and what's more important really is that I think that of Witchcraft and resist witchcraft is the better game I think it took an already really wonderful base that was resist and added things onto it that I personally believe make the game better make it more enticing give it some higher stakes and just kind of enrich something that was already good and I personally am a huge fan of things that started out good and the designers make them better and I do believe that that is what has happened here and I also say that

because there are a few things that didn't show up in this preview that are also added to the game one of them is familiars so you can actually get little familiars to help your witches out and they show up in the challenge cards it's so cool who doesn't want a pet owl um and then additionally there's also a Tails mode that I'm not showing off in this preview just keep it short but I think is really good so far and so if you haven't picked up resist and this one's the one that's calling to you I actually think this is a better game if you already have resist and you're wondering if this was worth getting that's a personal decision I do think this is the better game so if you want to try them both and choose to trade one I could see you doing that if you want to wait until somebody has a copy of Witchcraft and then compare it with resist I think that would be understandable as well they are similar enough that you can like feel their genetic commonalities it's just that I think that witchcraft Builds on a Model that was already good that is witchcraft that is my preview hopefully this is helpful for you as you make decisions about whether this is a game of interest for you and as usual I appreciate you dropping by to watch a video on this channel so thank you so much please like subscribe comment ask questions support me on patreon if you're feeling generous and most of all happy gaming

Progress saved