Tash-Kalar: Arena of Legends - Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and BR I are doing a discussion over Tosh Kar uh Arena of Legends this new uh brand new game that just came out about 11 years ago uh so uh but there's a new right or new printing or none that I know of okay it's just old nope this is just an 11-year-old game uh so four people will see this video um and that's okay um I bet it gets at least a hundred at least in the first year alone in the first year maybe uh maybe at Le if it does then that would be pretty cool um cuz I see no one talking about this game um but it was a game that back whenever I first got into the hobby I remember like seeing and I was like that's not for me like that's not a game that I I would like and you know fast forward 11 years later and still and it's still not a game I like no that's not that's not true um this game is very interesting I think it is certainly a cge production just something about their games you just can just tell that they have a very just a distinct way of making their games with their components with the way they write rules it's just it just screams
CG and consistent yeah I mean even to this day like this came like this game looks like they're games that come out now yeah it's just so bizarre to me uh but that's that's also kind of a cool thing uh at this game's core it is a skirmish game um at least I would call it a skirmish game uh but done in such a very go like you know polyomino puzzle placement piece placement where you are trying to get the most victory points and the two two ways that we've played it is uh that what was it I don't remember what they were called Death Match death match and the high high form the high form yeah um which is standard yeah that's that's the way they they teach you the game um so it's not a matter of I need to kill like you don't have like a leader or anything where that I have to get to and kill or uh anything like that it's tasks like objectives that everyone's going for whoever gets to nine points wins so Brett what did you think of Tosh Kar interesting in the sense that uh not amazing in one wonderful and grabbed me and I've got to play this again a bunch of times mm but certainly not bad at all right um uh again an interesting hybrid of puzzle placement and and and objective solving in cards in your hand
yeah and strategy for doing so and then real frustration at the other person who is trying to achieve completely different things at any given moment and they change every turn uh screwing up your plans yeah exactly just by being like ah you know what I have this one card that I'm not going to get to make for you know for a little bit so I'm just going to place right over there what why would you go there out of all the places why would you go there and I don't know like I'm just I have a cannon that I want to make uh and it's like and that happened so many times where I was like just trying to and I me whenever you're vying for objectives that it's like I have this perfect card that would help me get that but I can't get it out because I can't get rid of your one unit that's like in that spot man is it frustrating so then you have to find bad and I guess that's a good thing about the game is you now have to find alternate ways to get rid of that piece right so that you can then go back to so it's like here's my plan or achieve a different objective so that you draw a different objective card so that you can do something else exactly which you always get to see what the next objective is which is nice because I hate Top decking objective cards where it's like oh lucky me lucky me I win it's like you didn't plan for any of that right um but yeah it's like here's my plan like that's that's plan a to do plan a I need a you know a point B a
point C so to get all to circumnavigate finally get rid of that piece and then I can finally revert back to plan A yeah um in fact the last game we did where I was trying to place out the stupid stupid master of Entry this fat [ __ ] eating like look yeah which is good but he needs hyp specific spots yeah um it is very interesting that this game is like 13 years old yeah cuz it came out in not 13 11 11 years old yeah uh because it came out in 2013 uh anyway you can keep going on on your your thoughts on the game well I mean it's just you know again it's it's an interesting mix between strategizing trying to solve a puzzle trying to get my pieces in this configuration so that I can do this um and then but show limited on each turn right that it's not a slam dunk which of course it wouldn't be any fun if it was just I collab you you collab me exactly um uh so again the Intrigue and frustration of I can't do what I want to do how am I going to do it or what else can I do mhm um um there are definitely some negatives some downsides to that that play into those frustrations yeah um but overall it works MH um it's not amazing but I think it's good um yeah and and and we'll get
to the overall again after we get through some more specifics right so there was a game that came out uh last year called uh it's I don't really like the name but it's called arican Wars okay whatever um it's basically a grid based card game um where your cards basically were static like you played them in a specific spot do its ability and it stayed there unless you had other ways to move it that came out this year or last year in 2023 and I hadn't played this at that time but now I'm starting to see oh that's basically this because you're units are just there like when you're placing units like uh if I place on my turn I do two actions in place there and there MH unless I have a card that lets me move they're staying there right until I destroy them or you can destroy your own if you're just in your way yeah I think one of the games we just played I actively kill like I upgraded one of your units because I could and then I killed him MH um but yeah you can also wipe your own units cuz you're also limited to your own tokens and since it's not area control kind of some places are well not area control yeah you're right you're not necessarily yeah wanting to hold areas yeah so by reducing your presence on the board it's not it's not an
inherent negative right um it just leaves two your options but it might expand others yeah which gets back to the puzzle solving aspect mhm of of specific piece plac yes uh cuz the the game does it did have a bunch of expansions and a bunch I mean three that basically came with unique decks but the game starts with two identical decks uh which is fascinating because it's more of like we both have the same options in Our Deck but the availability is going to be different yeah um which is both which I think is a good thing for a game like this because it's like okay I see his placement you learn the game enough to know that's what he's probably building towards it becomes less playthroughs we could start recognizing right you're trying to do this maybe this but probably this way exactly and then it comes down to like okay it's not just me trying to set up for my own stuff it's me trying to prevent you from setting up your your stuff uh which is what probably Experts of this game would just know uh off hand it's like I'm going to play I'm first player I'm going to place here okay you have the cannon the Herold and the time age in your hand how did you know that I placed one unit and it's like H well I just know the game well CU you played all your other cards no no it's like at the beginning of the game yeah yeah your old deck is discarded um but that's also what it comes down to it's like hm okay
I don't remember him ever playing the bomb yeah is that something that he might be wanting to do would that even be beneficial um but it is very fascinating that because you don't have to place adjacent to your own spot MH uh there are going to be times where you just can't make a move like I can't summon anything that's going to be beneficial we ran into that last time we played yeah you can't do something beneficial you can always do something yeah well I meant like yeah like these are the cards in my hand I'm losing by one point if I draw my deck yeah then I will lose so what can I do to stall because I don't want to summon anything especially if I can't use its ability yeah um and it will end the game and you're you know you're losing so it's like okay the points are open exactly there's no surprise end game points yeah there's the objectives I know you can't complete them right now so what can I do to stall out the game to eventually get me to achieve one of these objectives and then end it so those are the aspect of games that I like exactly when you can tell where we're at what needs to be done crap I can't do that so let me figure out something else to do exactly and and for the record yeah these are all positives um from for my end even if it's frustrating where it's like why did you even go there like
because I'm trying to do something different than what you are yeah um but there are still some negatives that uh well there's two that pop into my head right now one I hate those flare cards really yeah I think that they like I I like the idea of having a catch-up mechanism but the fact that some of them are just way better than others yeah is there is some imbalance there for sure is like okay like many many times oh these are uh did I like get some that are like hey you have to have five more upgraded than me uh I get two common units anywhere oh you have to have five more units in general than me I get one common anywhere oh wait but if but then you have one that if I just have four more than you you get an extra action it's like what like because you only get one of these in your hand yeah I again I like the idea because the game could just be very situational that what is in my hand is better for me right now that I could steamroll yeah well and and the fact that we're drawing different cards we're trying to do different things yeah you know either I try to achieve my objective I try to screw up you from what I think is your objective um or I'm just trying to achieve a larger objective which is going to take more turns than I have right now exactly so
it would be very frustrating it's like oh man yeah nope you have four units on the board I have my I ran out of tokens sorry it's like the the flares are I think the game would be worse without them okay um but I also don't like the fact that some are clearly better than others yeah and the fact that you have no choice yeah you get one random draw you can't even draw two and then pick one yeah as a lot of mitigation that goes and to be fair they they do have a way as an as one of your two actions you can discard a card and then like legendaries or flares you can pop to the bottom and draw again so if you have one that does suck then you have a way to get rid of it which is again better than nothing but that's half your turn it is half your turn and again the fact that you even have to do that for some flares is very annoying um yeah they're honestly my biggest negative um and again it's like well it'd be worse without them so I guess I'll deal with it like I didn't think they never swayed the game they actually to be fair they actually kept the game balanced yeah uh if I was cuz you were winning the last game we just played not this Deathmatch one but the one the high form yeah uh I think you you always played flares like I don't think I ever I got one flare in in one of the games um but you were winning I was killing a [ __ ] ton of your units but you were still ahead by one point at that at that
time um and I think if they didn't exist and it's like okay I killed all your units now it's just it's a matter of time before I complete these objectives so let's just call it you know yeah if it came down to that yeah so I guess they are a good thing it's just like man the flare I have [ __ ] sucks and and there's no way I mean there's effectively no way to get rid of it yeah and get something better exactly um that's that's my that's my biggest problem off hand with the whole game is just the limitations of choices yeah I mean I know I've got this hu I know I've got this deck what are they 18 20 cards uh I don't know actually 2 4 68 10 12 14 16 18 okay out of 18 cards I only have three and they're totally random and there's nothing I can do to switch them out right um I'll be a discarding one in drawing again uh yeah the flares but but again that's not quite wasting half of your ability to do anything this time mhm the flares even more limited one at a time no choice um and some of them are clearly more powerful and some of them are more more situational like there there are times I want to get more pieces on the board yeah so if I'm way behind yes I would love to place two mhm all for free and then I get my two actions beond yeah and also to be fair the um the one flare I did get to play all it required me was hey this is not one of my actions I get to place a common unit that common unit allowed me to play like a night which
still let me kill a bunch of units and I still got to summon something else which helped me complete an objective right so a free unit is still really beneficial on this because if you're able to place it somewhere and then one of your actions is now placing to then summon something uh that is super beneficial to you it can happen um but you also have to have you have to be behind yep and sometimes significantly behind yeah so they're not my favorite but I think they are a necessity the other thing you mentioned it comes down to the deck yeah um this is a slight negative for me but again that's the whole Crux of the game honestly um and there's only one aspect of the game that I or the deck that I do find as a negative and I wonder if you agree okay and it's that it it kind of relates to what I mentioned earlier about your units are static where you place them is where they are at so if the placement starts not being helpful uh or beneficial to you like you have something that keeps killed like I'm going to place right here so I can finally Place something oh you just okay you killed that so that's neat so now I can't summon anything I can't move any of my units because the only way to move it is through card effects so that could be very frustrating if I just happen to draw like all my Attack cards and then my
move cards are all at the bottom of the deck yep so that it is what it is and for a game that's supposed to be very I mean imperfect information yeah like very tactical One V one yeah it's like it it feels strategic on a level of like um onama or um aell um but there's way more luck to what you get and what you can do at any given time right for it to be that strategic so it's very strategic but luck is so important exactly that it's not it's not that there's a balance of the two it's that there's a dichotomy mhm yeah I mean and this is my preferred way of random or uh you know randomization in games because I mean one the game would be pretty I mean might as well play chess if you had all your units you know available it's like this is the one I'm doing you know if you had every access to all 18 cards yeah um I would be like that's kind of boring but it would also be kind of dumb if you had no plan and you're like man I don't even I'm just going to start placing and oh oh okay you know if you randomly Drew yeah so yeah even looking at three different cards looking at the board I was still spending you know a couple of minutes on some turns figuring out what I can do mhm or if I can place one piece and then do it yep um or what I can set
up for next turn without you hopefully destroying it yeah exactly and that's kind of what It ultimately comes down to is so having four or five cards would you slow that down even more it really would and like chess yeah ex so slow well exactly unless you're you know Grand Masters they're just two grandm and then they there's like so much controversy around those guys yeah cheaters they're all cheaters it's like and they're juicy listen they're doing yeah so stupid some of them are like hooked on C brain enhancing that uh oh what was it Boy Meets World episode or something where she was like hooked on caffeine pills I think it was no say by the Bell that's it yeah so got a bell yeah that's that's those grand Masters just out there on caffeine pills with the worst addiction imaginable um but I mean that is you do a lot of like forward planning because it does it in which is a good thing with this game it does you no good just to kill units right like me unless you're playing a certain form it's like me like me wiping out you know six of your units yeah that probably prevents you from playing cards but ultimately it's like well I did that but I'm not close didn't help me didn't help me with any of these objectives so when you're looking at the cards in your hand you're like how can I set up for these that is going to then allow me to
play use their abilities to then get an objective worth whatever amount of points one two or three and none of them are Overkill no none of the powers on these are are overblown you know a couple of them are really really powerful but they have inherent limitations like yes yes this will destroy everything in its path that's the weakest piece exactly or This Will Destroy any of the first two pieces yeah and and it's like well I and even like the cannon for example that only kills Commons it's like well you have to place it in such a way that the the cannon piece that's summoning is in position to do that yeah uh and might destroy your own pieces exactly um oh I'm sorry another can on the bomb bomb will kill your actually no the Canon will kill your own pieces as well uh which is a clever way to mtig the really powerful actions right um I mean and I mean there's some that seem like they're inherent like that is actually a really good point is there's not really any card in the in these Decks that I was like that's useless right um there are some that it's like that's useless right now and I really wish I could just set it aside and pick up another one just yeah put it in preserve um but whenever you start adding in like the legendary monsters and stuff then it's like oh the messenger comes in handy where it's like hey he can just now move all the way over there um the chronicler which is
supp to upgrade any any piece it's like oh man I have a common there [ __ ] I really need a heroic piece there oh chronicler boom now he's a heroic got him uh which is very fascinating because there's no like deck construction right it's just here you go here's your red deck and the red and blue decks are identical like I mentioned they they had EXP iions that added uh well there's these two then the base game came with two more that are uh unique and then there was everfrost other weave and nether void that came with their own different decks so it's all strictly a one versus one or a team versus Team game though actually I think there is a there's no way to have like three there is a death match for three or four players oh yeah which I bet you was not really any good I don't know everything I saw in line was saying this besta 2 so I was I was thinking I don't know if you want to have a discussion about the two different modes that we play yeah that was coming up next okay then I'll be patient okay um next up yeah so uh the the other mode the Death Mode which is basically victory points like Now units killing units does matter yeah and it's the primary way of winning the only way well that's not true you can get points for someone playing a flare and you get points for summoning a legendary uh but other than that it's like for every two comment I get a point for every heroic I get a point uh
legendary is two points which but there's very specific ways to kill legendaries the Assassin can do it uh the champion can do it um yeah gun Tower can't I think that's pretty much the only two and another legendary can and another legendary summoning on can can do it uh but other than that like yeah it's like first to 17 points um I didn't really care for it like I thought it was like kind of whatever I got all three legendaries out that was cool yeah um and I didn't get a single one yeah I really think it's just kind of like you're that that that to me get the legendaries to me was much more luck cuz in one of the games I put out one or two but I didn't set it up I just saw the board and I went o Place one there it is right funny enough in the death match I did set it up no um but because you know you can really just run wild with because the death match or in the in the high strung or the high mode the high strung mode High form High form mode you care very much about positioning so you don't just want to summon willy-nilly it's like I need these to be in a specific area so I can fulfill that get three points yeah um and in the death match you don't care
about positioning at all so you're able to summon all your cards all the time I was just like whatever like if the high form mode was really strategic I thought Deathmatch wasn't not certainly not as much yeah but I am going to say that it's going to appeal to a different set of players than us that's true and I'm glad that they included it as an alternate mode of play I think it's worth trying out and and pulling out every once in a while it strikes me as the thinking game version and the drinking game and and the fun yeah the fun version which is let's just kill each other's units yeah it's just a slaughterfest even though it's extremely abstract and but there're still thinking and there's still plotting involved it's just not as strong correct yeah I mean I it wasn't go with the flow like I wasn't just like I'll summon that I'll summon that I'll summon that I still had to plan yeah but it was like okay well I'm just going to not satisfying I I personally didn't think so um and it definitely made moving not as helpful even though funny enough I used my movement better uh so I can get the legendaries out um so yeah I guess cuz I I wouldn't teach someone with Deathmatch though oh no um yeah that's definitely the drunken brawl sort of right hey if you like that let's just wild I'd rather play other
games though if that was the case if I was going to be drinking I wouldn't play Tosh kalar as a drinking game with because it's like the only theme you get is from Reading like the abilities match kind of what the card is yeah but other than that it's just like I'm going to summon this Griffin Rider okay that piece is no longer the Griffin Rider it's now just a common unit now uh that's going to be used so that same piece that I used he's now going to become the Mage so it's very abstract which is meant to be yeah I don't think they were really throwing in a whole bunch of theme to the game right uh what do you think of the legendary cards um hard to get hard hard to use and very powerful when they do yeah but again one time it's not a continuing effect right so I mean again I think well balanced um and and for the for the value they're they're adequately difficult to achieve except when you got like three in a row for some stupid reason [ __ ] planning yeah right yeah it just so happened that all of my heroic people happen to be in the same spot but they yeah they are they are powerful like it'd be it'd be really lame if they were so hard to get and it's just kind of like oh there they they like the FL like the oh yeah like the flare but I mean hard to get in a little bit like the game where I
was behind I was finally able to get like the eldest tree out and it's like oh I'm just going to summon all in this area yeah and it's like oh now I have so many options I think more experienced players would draw their legendaries and probably do their strategy around them probably versus uh we just took them as extra units that if they happen to match try and get him out there uh but I bet you there are ways that people take that eldest tree for example and meticulously try and get their pieces in a spot so it wipes all the units of someone else in those specific spots I'd imagine I imagine this feels like the kind of game that you can really get into it's no longer about the game it's more about who I'm playing against yeah um yeah I mean because the only luck is um the card draws yeah we know exactly what the others abilities are at some point we know what they've done if we're card counting and and keeping track exactly um I and also like because there is no deck construction it's not like I'm ever surprised by what you have in your deck how'd you get another one of those yeah exactly it's like really you have and there's nothing that lets you go through your discard pile no so you can never see that one again cuz these are all one time use yeah so cuz the game ends either at nine points or you deck out
and it's like okay which reminds me of a game called Summoner Wars which is if your deck runs out you're just out of options yeah um some games like one V One games are you lose if you're de Runs Out summon re Wars in this game isn't the case right it's like in fact there will be times where if I'm you know like at seven points and you're at four or you're at five and it's like these are really hard objectives to get I might just start summoning just to draw more cards so I run out so I race the game I clock the game yep uh before I get a chance to get those last two points exactly again a good another layer strategy right so it's I I definitely think that this game holds up mhm uh 11 years later yeah uh and even the negatives that we were talking about we kind of were able to handwave them away yeah for the most part they're not big negatives but they're definitely irritations they're definitely annoyances on on my end um but yeah so on do you have anything else uh do you want to talk about packaging artwork rule book you might want to talk about the rule book it's a cge rule book there you go yeah like lots of examples and sometimes the rules are buried in the examples yeah which is it's just what you are expecting especially obviously this game is 11 years old so you can't really fault them
but like I've played games there plenty of modern games out 11 years ago I feel like um no I actually feel like good rule books are modern thing okay uh okay I mean to be fair like the you can learn the game in fact what they do because there's another game of theirs I just played recently uh Mage Knight does the exact same kind of concept of we're going to give you a watered down first game version here's the first game rule book okay you've done that now here's the rest of the rules um the problem is is yeah it's buried in the tiniest font imaginable and the tiniest printing well we found one very key strategic important rule that was actually in an example explanation not in the actual here are the rules yeah where you would think it would be where it's like hey okay summoning a being let's see can you mirror and Orient your patterns in any way you think you would but let me find out for sure and then it's like nope not in the summoning a being section oh it's in the more example section yeah you get that far I'm not saying the rule book's great I've never really liked cge rules oh yeah um because they they try to be like witty and like fun to read which is a positive but then it's like I just I just want to learn the game I don't want to I don't want to figure out oh is is orash the great is he explaining like this guy this guy
he's supposed to be like some comic relief thing and it's like but is he saying something important yeah it's like can I skip that or is it flavor text um again it's a cge rule book it gets the job done I just I've always had a kind of an issue with them uh and then overall component quality again CG you're going to you're getting somehow they they must make all these in-house cuz how they get the exact same card quality and tokens and all that and the bags are it's just it's weird it's it's weird how they haven't like improved but yeah they're not bad yeah I don't think they're bad components and they're not they're not outstanding they're just solid but they also never go on Kickstarter um so their loss uh yeah right they it makes so much more money uh without actually doing anything they can steal so many people's money uh and then the artwork I like the ones on the legendary cards yeah I think the rest kind of suck I think it's all good uh um um legendary one's definitely more shading more dark so I mean that just appeals to an an emotional state right the rest of them are all more bright and slightly cartoonish kind yeah they're more cartoonish and more like it's like they wanted it to be like old school DND art is that is
the vibe I'm getting off the art but then it's still very cartoony yeah this is cool the this is more like the legendary yeah anyway but again that's all flavor surrounding what is inherently an abstract game exactly so on a scale of 1 to 10 what do you giving Tosh kalaw I'm going to say seven seven that well above average but not outstanding yep that is exactly where I'm at is as a seven as well I think it's a it's definitely a good game um and some flaws yeah so that's our thoughts on Tosh Kar let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you