Skip to main content
Loading video...

Coming Of Age Board Game Review

Transcript 11:22

Hello. Welcome back to the channel, and this is a channel where we give you reviews, don't do unboxings, don't do play-throughs, but we generally like to talk a lot of bollocks about tabletop gaming in general. In this video, we're going to be talking about a Euro style game by Danny Garcia. We're going to be talking about Coming of Age. And in this game, you'll be taking on the role of a kid. You'll allegedly be progressing through your childhood, gaining memories, going to different places of interest, and gaining enough victory points that will hopefully allow you to win the game. So, in this video, we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules. We'll tell you what we do like, what we don't like. Then we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not Coming of Age is better than coming in your pants. So, remember, if you are new here, consider subscribing to this channel, hit the like button, and all that YouTube [ __ ] We'll see you after this.

Bollocks. So, Coming of Age is a Euro style game for one to four players. You'll place the main board at the center of the table. You set the bus token to one side. You'll put some memories in the starting spaces, and you'll block off all of the other memory spaces, right? There's some bus stop tiles you've got to chuck in. Every player is going to start with a D4. You'll have a pool of other dice for subsequent rounds. You'll have a player board, and you'll populate the first two tracks with a little marker that you can move to the left and the right. You'll also have a personal fulfillment counter that you can move down and get bonuses. And yeah, there's some other bits of setup, but who gives a [ __ ] really, cuz there's not really that much to do. So, the first thing everyone's going to do is they're going to roll their dice. Like we've said, you're going to start with a D4, but in round two, you have two D6, then you'll have a D8, then some D10s, yeah? What you'll do, you'll put these on the locations matching the number of the dice. So, if you rolled a four, you put it on the four spot. And you can gain frustration tokens and stick them on the right side of your tracks to move your dice one space to an adjacent space. You can do this multiple times. You can gain two frustration tokens if you want to to move it two spaces, yeah? Frustration tokens will cover up the passive bonus that you get if you move your token on that track all the way to the right, yeah? So, they're a real pain in the [ __ ] ass. They're not called frustration for nothing, mate. So, that you might have to potentially advance your fulfillment counter. This is the

track on the far right. You'll move it down one and you'll get bonus, yeah? You'll notice as well that there is an intimacy icon. If you look at the left side of your player board, there is a friendship track. You'll be gaining friends and moving them down the track and you can only get really, really intimate with them if you pass the intimacy icon on the personal fulfillment track, right? So, next thing you're going to do is you're going to experience the location. You'll gain the bonus from the experience space. This generally mean that you can move a trait to the left or the right. Muggle will power tokens, you'll be trading these into take the memory bonuses. We'll talk about that in a bit. And you can optionally use a memory token, which is one of those little cassettes, to move a trait to left, to the right, or I don't know what the purple one does, but do something else, yeah? So, next thing you're going to do is you're going to be able to gain the location benefits.

You'll take the bus token and you'll move it along the road and when it stops at a location where somebody is or has a presence, you'll do these two steps, right? If you've got a dial presence there, you will get the bus stop bonus. This will more often than not mean you're going to gain a friend because you picked up some random munta at bus stop while you do. And you'll stick the corresponding token in your friend slot. As time goes by, you'll move this down and get extra bonuses for having mates, yeah? And if another player was present there, you'll be able to be mates with them even though you hate their guts because they brought [ __ ] garlic bread to [ __ ] game night, didn't they? And if you have a die in that location, you can claim the memory card bonuses. If you've moved your token to the far right of the trade track, you will get what's called a motivation token. You can trade these in to take the memory bonuses, or you can just trade them for willpower to take the bonus here. You will look at the memory card and you'll get all the [ __ ] that's on the card, right? If you don't want to do that, you can place a presence token on the location. Remember, if you've got presence here, you can become mates with other players here, or you can play a parent card from your hand. Because if you've got [ __ ] all else to do, you can always ask your parents for a bunch of [ __ ] money, you leeching [ __ ] So, once you've done all that, it is the end of the year. In the second round, you will roll two dice, and then three dice, and so on and so forth. You'll only use one die per round, and you'll take back the other dice. If you've still got dice in your hand, you'll roll them and do all that [ __ ] that I just spoke about again. Otherwise, you do a bit of clean up, you move the bus tiles to the right, and all that sort of stuff, and you will unlock two extra locations that will

give you extra memories and all that stuff. So, you keep doing this for, I think it's like nine rounds or something, and then the player with the most points at the end of the game will be the winner of Coming of Age, right? So, what do we like about Coming of Age? So, the first thing that we really like about it is, well, there's not really that much that we like about this game. Let's get that [ __ ] out of the way, yeah? But, I suppose you could say that it looks quite nice, yeah? The artwork's really nice. It's done in a sort of a high-contrast art style, yeah? And the components are nice. The player boards, whilst being slightly abstract and a little bit messy, yeah? Reminds me of opening up the original Campaign for the first time and almost having a [ __ ] mini stroke, yeah? But, I suppose if there's nothing else you can take from this game, then I suppose you could say it was aesthetically pleasing. But, the second thing that we kind of like about it is that one of the mechanics, the interest mechanic, is kind of interested, yeah? When you put your dice out onto the board, not in the first round, but in the the other rounds, you're going to have to take one back here, because you can only activate one die at a time. but you will be able to place an interest cube in that location.

Means they're going to be an extra bonus for you there. So, even though you have got the random nature of the die rolls, and sometimes you don't want to gain a frustration to move the dice to a more lucrative spot, you do get to put an interest token out there, so you don't feel like you have had your right testicle cut off in front of your wife. But, the final thing that we quite like, took me quite a while to sort of think about stuff I do actually like about this game. But, one of the things that just came to me in, I suppose you could call it an epiphany, right? Was the fact that you get bonuses for [ __ ] everything in this game. You move your token to the right or left, you're going to get a bonus. You can move your token down the personal fulfillment track, you're going to get a bonus. You get bonuses for having friends. You even get bonuses for pushing tokens to the left, yeah? And you can even turn frustration into all points if you play your cards right, yeah? So, this game tries really, really hard to prevent you from feeling like dog [ __ ] by giving you bonuses for literally everything you do. So, don't we like that coming of age?

So, the first thing that we don't like about this game is, at the end of the day, it's a [ __ ] abstract euro, yeah? And that is unforgivable for a game that promises a theme of progression through your youth. We've yet to find a Sims-style board game that gives you a rich thematic experience. You think back to The Pursuit of Happiness, that was a [ __ ] bean-counting exercise that didn't feel like you were living a second life, do you know what I mean? I mean, what the [ __ ] the bus all about, yeah? You've got a school bus that goes along a road. School bus is going to pick you up from the [ __ ] arcade and the pizza [ __ ] parlor, is it? The memories are really weird. It doesn't make sense. They're already there before you've even made them, yeah? And some of them, I didn't even know what the [ __ ] they were. Some kid sitting in a [ __ ] swing looking like they're about to cut their wrists. There's no sense of progression. It didn't feel like you were 7 years old or however old you meant to start the game at, and then you're moving through your youth into adolescence. The memories are just dumped there. It didn't feel like there was scope in the game to make you feel like you're getting older. Yeah, you just reveal some extra locations. I mean, what's the [ __ ] difference between going to the pizza parlor or the [ __ ] basketball court between 7 and 9 years old. It made absolutely no sense to me, and it's just [ __ ] an abstract token pusher. The second thing that we don't like about this, and let's elaborate slightly on the previous point, is that there's no real human element in this game, yeah? Okay,

there's like some tiny little friend tokens that you can pick up when you're waiting at the [ __ ] bus stop. I mean, that's another thing. Why are you friends with these people? There's no story, there's no narrative, there's no real reason why you are friends with these people aside from the fact that they got on the same bus as you. What was I talking about? Yeah, there's no human element. Even the player boards are sort of like an abstract head, and I didn't get the impression that I was existing in a living, breathing world, which is what this game really should have done. It reminds us of a game called Dinosaur Island, if you played that many years ago, where you open up a theme park about dinosaurs, and you're trying to get people in, but there's no [ __ ] people in the park, yeah? This felt empty, felt like you were walking around Nuketown in a Call of Duty: Black Ops 7. And I could only pray that somebody pushes the button and blows this the [ __ ] up. Thirdly, the final thing, I mean, I could go on and on and on, but I'm [ __ ] bored out of my brains talking about this piece of [ __ ] is that the dice are way too hard to mitigate, yeah? Frustration is so costly that every time I've played this, nobody wants to absorb that much frustration to get the more lucrative points, yeah?

It's going to block your way of getting the memories. You are not going to be able to make any [ __ ] memories if you take the frustration tokens that are going to move that track up. So, it's completely illogical. You're going to have to take frustration to go to a different location that's going to allow you to move a token up that you've just put a frustration token over. That's [ __ ] mental. Why the [ __ ] would you do that? And in my experience, nobody ever does. [ __ ] batshit. So, to summarize, is Coming of Age better than [ __ ] in your pants? So, we are going to say no. I'd rather [ __ ] myself than play this piece of [ __ ] [ __ ] ever again. It's far too abstract for a game that promises a rich thematic experience. And the lack of a human presence in a game about human development is beyond problematic. It does look really nice, yeah. I did have a nice time absorbing the aesthetic features of this game. And there are some novel mechanisms that reveal themselves to be mildly interesting.

However, the costly mitigation of the dice rolls, coupled with the inane tug-of-war centric counterpoint, means that Coming of Age is the biggest pile of donkey [ __ ] that we have played this year. So, there you go. That is Coming of Age. Remember, if you know it, consider subscribing to the channel and the like button and all that YouTube [ __ ] See you next Tuesday.

Progress saved