Up or Down - First Play Review
Transcript
Hey there, I'm Jonathan with Getting Games and this is my first play review for Up or Down. Now, what you're going to see here is a segment that was originally sent out to the Patreon supporters as an exclusive perk, but now it's made its way to the main channel as well. In this video, I'll be talking about not only how the game plays, but also my thoughts about the game as it was going on. Now, if you have thoughts about this game, maybe you've played it as well, then please leave a comment about those things down below. Also, if you enjoy this video, then please click the like and subscribe buttons down there as well. Okay, let's talk about the game. All right, let's talk about Up or Down. This is a small box game. It's just cards. Uh, designed by Kramer and Keysling. And I've heard a lot of good things about it, like just buzz kind of happening from my overall friends group. And last week, my friend Anastasia came over and she taught this one to Jessica and myself. And we had a really lovely time playing this one at three players.
So, let's talk a bit about how it plays. It's a very um straightforward game mechanically. Uh, as you can see out here, we have a deck of cards with numbers on them. In a three-player game, at least I think the short game in Anastasia said, you have numbers from 1 to 60, but you could play with like 1 to 75 for a longer game if you want. And you're going to shuffle the cards up, put two decks out in the middle, one face up, one face down, and then six cards face up in a circle around those. Now, you're going to get a hand of cards. I think you always have three cards in your hand. And on your turn, you're going to take one of your cards and you're going to place it out into the middle between the two cards uh relative to the value. You have these cards in the middle in order. So, for example, I have this 20 in my hand. I would have to put it here between the 11 and the 23 because that's where a 20 would land. After putting the card here, I then have to take the 23 or the 11, you know, one of them on either side, and I score that card. I put it into a tableau in front of me. And this is where the up or down thing happens because you can have at most three of these scoring columns. And they can either ascend or descend. And in the art, it's elevators. Like you're going up, going down, that kind of a thing.
Uh, in this game, I think I was going down and then up twice. Yeah, I actually stacked up with my down, which confused some people around the table, but it made sense for me. We were playing on a really small table. So, you're going to put these down in order. And if you can't, like if you have a card that does not fit on any of these um going up or down, then you have to burn a pile. Essentially, choose a pile, flip all the cards face down, they'll be worth one point each, and then you've opened up a slot to start a new one of these columns. And I did that once, just burning a single card to make that happen. And that's pretty much the game. And the why of this is because multipliers, there's uh I think six different colors of cards in the game. And at the end of the game, you're going to score each one of your columns, and you're going to take the number of cards in that column, and you're going to multiply that by the largest number of the same color in that column. So, for example, this column right here in the middle. Right now, it's two cards, and they're both red. Red is the largest color, so that means I'm scoring two for the color and two for the cards, so that's four points. If I added, you know, four more cards to this and one of those is red, then it would be six * three, which means I'm getting 18 points. So, you're trying to grab the cards of specific colors to have as many as you can in these columns while also trying to maximize the number of cards in each one of these scoring columns because the numbers in this play anyway went from 1 to 60. And if you have too many big gaps, then you're not going to be able to fit things in. And in a really bad situation, if you fill it up too much, you might have yourself not able to place a card down and have to burn something to actually make room. At the end of your turn, you draw a new card either face down or face up. And that's the game. uh you play every
single card from your hand. So you keep going until all of the draw decks are gone, both of them, and then you keep playing until you've played every card in your hand. So at the end of the game, there are six face up cards. So in the three-player game that we played, we essentially played through collectively 54 of the cards. Uh so we had a lot of cards in front of us, 54 obviously divided by three because you take a card every single turn. And when we added everything up, it was not particularly close. Anastasia kind of blew this one out, but that doesn't really matter. I mean, I like to win, but it was a really fun experience while also being frustrating. Um, the frustration never veered into like bad feels territory. It felt like tension, I guess, for the most part. But I I felt like like I kept drawing random because I didn't like the card that was out here. And my cards kept being super close, like 20, 23, 25 or, you know, that sort of a thing, which meant like all my cards had to go into the same slot. And I really wanted that card over there. So that I'd score a card and then I'd, you know, try to draw random and it's like, oh no, it's all the same again. while I watch my opponents like taking all the perfect spots, but then later on I watch them in the same boat that I am. Like it just there's an eb and flow of how much agency you have essentially. Um, also there's luck. You're drawing a lot of cards face down. Also, you know, the person right before you might take the face up card and reveal the perfect card for you. These all these things can certainly happen, but there's a lot to think about here as well. I don't want to overstate just how deep this game is, but there's still things to think about.
For example, trying to plan for the future. You can look to the cards that you have and a card in your hand and you can't put these cards directly in front of you. It feels like you should, but no, these cards in your hand go out onto the table and then you score the cards from the table. So that means if you really want this 20, for example, you could put it down and then hope that neither of your opponents takes it so that on your next turn you could score that 20. But of course, you would need to have a card that could make scoring that 20 happen. In this instance, for example, if I put the 20 down and then drew this 18, odds are very good if the 20 is still out there that I could put the 18 next to it, there's only, you know, one number in between and then I could score that 20. But of course, I have to float this card around the table before it comes back to me. And I don't know what's in my opponent's hands. So, obviously, they might be able to take it, they might not. I could glance at their piles to see if they want to, but that's beyond I think the scope of what I would put into this game. We weren't quite going there. We more just hoped.
put this down like and then it comes back to you're like yes you didn't take that card or more often you put a card down and somebody takes it and it's like gosh dang it. So the game itself took probably about 40 minutes or so. We were not playing particularly fast or slow. I we were just having a a lovely time chatting while we were playing this one and I'm impressed with it. Jessica really liked it. She loves sorting style games and ascending and descending. It kind of reminded me of Keltus, which is a game that Jessica and I played a lot u back when we first got together. Actually, that was uh something we spent a lot of time doing, playing the iPad version of that game. And I like Keltus, which has some boardplay elements, but it also is all about scoring ascending or descending columns of cards. Uh we don't actually have Keeltus anymore, and part of me regrets getting rid of that one. I probably shouldn't have done that, but you know, there's other games that are riffing on that as well, like Up or Down, and it's a much smaller box. I don't own this one, but Jessica really liked it. So, I think that's definitely going to up the chances that I find a copy to play this one. Uh, it's probably cheap. I haven't even looked into it, but enough people are talking about it that it it seems like it probably has relatively good distribution. So, yeah, I will very likely have a chance to play this one in the future. Yeah, I'm looking forward to it.