Skip to main content
Loading video...

Cavemen: The Quest for Fire Review

Transcript 21:43

welcome to john gets games today i'm going to talk about cavemen the quest for fire this is a light engine building game with a small auction mechanic and a whole bunch of amazing art first i'm going to show you how to play the game then i'm going to jump into my review and i'm going to end my video by giving you guys a poll tell me what game you guys want me to review next alright so how do we play caveman the quest for fire in the beginning of the game each player is going to have a starting village set up identical to this where they have a single cave which can hold four different cave people a tribal leader and a fighter let's take a look at the icons on these guys we've got baron here who has a single arrowhead symbol and abe who has two this means that the collective fighting power of our village here is three at the beginning of the game we also see that baroon has a single light bulb symbol the light bulbs are the icon for technology in this game and this is caveman the quest for fire and in order to you know fulfill this quest for fire to invent fire we are going to need seven nine or ten light bulbs depending on the number of players in the game this is also a pretty good time to note we got a little candle inside of a ceramic light bulb the art in this game is very interesting in that every single card is unique and every single card is a photograph of an actual claymation sculpture so pretty cool anyway we're gonna need quite a few light bulbs in order to win the game the last icon is this little apple here and a two this means at the beginning of the game the foraging value of our village is two all alright so how do turns actually work well we've got this totally cool starting player token here

and it's going to pass to the left person of the prior starting player and that person will begin a bitty ground to see who will be the actual starting player of the round in this case you're bidding teeth in order to become the starting player and you're just going to either pass or keep increasing the bid values until one person remains that person is going to pay teeth to the bank equal to whatever they bid and no one else has to pay any teeth there are two pros and one con to being the starting player unfortunately the con comes first right after we figure out who goes first we are going to feed our villages if you do not have the starting player token it only costs a single food to feed your whole village no matter how many cave people you have however if you are the starting player it's gonna cost one food per cave person when you feed your people in the beginning of the game this is not that big of a deal you have two people versus only spending one but once you start having five six seven eight cave people that's a very big difference so those pros better really make up for it and they oftentimes do so now let's talk about how we take the turns themselves we've got our starting player every single person is going to take a single action except the starting player is going to take one more action once everyone has gone so the starting player takes the first and last action of the round with everyone else going once in between the actions consist of taking cards from this card row except for foraging which i'll cover first foraging is very simple you just look at the apple value of your village and you take that amount of food from the supply and throw them into your stock so that's

simple the rest of them involve taking cards from this card row the first one is we can recruit a fighter we see that lou the fighter here takes two food or one tooth in order to recruit him into our village when we do that we're gonna get two more arrowheads though so that's pretty great the next thing that we could do as an action is we can fight a creature in this case we have a direwolf here in order to fight this direwolf we're going to need an attack power in our village equal to one and when you fight a creature you automatically kill it and it's gonna give you one tooth and two food however you have to draw from the top of the deck of cards in order to see if this direwolf killed anybody as you were killing it so what you do is you draw the top card and then you don't look at anything on the card except those little stones in the bottom left corner we see they're four in this case they range from one to five now we look at our village and we see if any cave people in our village have stone pit values equal to that in this case we're fine a four and we only have a three so we killed the star wolf no problem this card is discarded as well and then we get our one tooth and our two food for killing for killing the direwolf so that's great however if we had drawn this card instead it's got three pips on it and we've got a three pip in our our uh village that's terrible that means that the direwolf would have been able to kill abe now you don't necessarily kill the card that matched the stone value it just means you have to take one person from your village

and kill them and you're not allowed to kill the tribal leader so he that's probably why he's giving you a big thumbs up he can't die all right so the next thing that we can do as an action is we can recruit leah the explorer explorers cost a little bit more resources three food or two teeth and they only give you one arrowhead but they increase your foraging value which you can now imagine is a much safer way to get food because you're not drawing cards off the top of your deck and potentially losing cave people uh and the last thing that the explorers do is they give you this foot symbol see that foot symbol right there you might also notice a foot symbol right here on this hill cave so the great thing about having explorers is that once they are in your village you can for an action find you can explore a cave for free because you have a foot you don't even have to lose the explorer to do that if you did not have lee of the explorer then in order to take this cave it would cost you two teeth the reason you're gonna want more caves is because the starting cave can only hold four different cave people and you're not gonna win with only four you're gonna need more caves to hold more cave people the next guy that we can recruit is fuco the thinker he spends all day long staring at this egg and because of that our village gets two extra light bulbs this gets us closer to inventing fire as well as allowing us to invent various technologies which i'll get to in just a minute the last kind of person we can recruit is an elder this is mo the elder she gives you one thinking power and she gives you one forging power so

as you can see she's kind of a hybrid card the last kind of action that we can take is we can invent a technology all the technologies have a little circle symbol at the top in order to invent a technology we have to have light bulbs equal to the value in the top right corner you don't have to spend the light bulbs you just have to prove you have them and then the technology goes into your village and in this case uh stargazing just gives you one extra technology so that's pretty darn good uh at this point we uh everyone takes their single action except the starting player who takes two and then we will probably have less cards in the row more cards will get drawn from the stack and then we'll pass this and we will keep going at some point this fire card is going to come out of this stack of cards here at that point if uh if no one is able to invent it in that at that time it's gonna immediately get shuffled back into this deck here and when it shows up a second time it's gonna stay out for the rest of the game one thing i didn't mention in order to invent fire you have to be the starting player see that little conch there so that adds a lot of uh a lot of reasons to get more teeth because in a very at a very crucial moment when you have enough technology you're gonna have to be able to have the highest bid to win the starting player token in order to actually invent fire uh at this point uh we just keep going until someone wins and i'm gonna show you some examples of the creatures that we can kill and i'm gonna show you some examples of the technology and then i'm gonna give you my review here we can see some examples of the creatures that you can kill in this game obviously we've got um some funny stuff

going on we got like a bird a parrot thing over here and tyrannosaurus rex we've got a woolly mammoth and a saber-toothed tiger smilodon over here so and obviously i don't think ichthyosauruses and cave people lived at the same time but that doesn't really matter because it's just kind of awesome being able to fight all these different creatures in the game and they just they look really cool all right now i'm going to show you some of the technology and here we have every technology that's in the game i kind of sorted them in order from the cheapest to obviously the most expensive being discovering fire uh one thing i didn't really talk about the rules is that this is where a bunch of engine building can really come into play you can have technologies feed off of other technologies uh several of the technologies feed off of different types of people in your tribe for instance shamanism over here you get one light bulb per uh little hand up thing per elder in your tribe and so you can you can make all these things kind of go together there are other technologies like this one over here which also works well with elders so that might give you once you play the game a couple times you might start to get elders knowing that there are technologies that work really well for them so these kind of add up and this is a big way that you actually create enough technology to invent fire is by getting prior technologies all right on that note i'm going to jump over and get into my review i've owned caveman quest for fire for a couple years now i bought it pretty much as soon as it became available mostly on the back of the really cool uh art that i was seeing pop up on board

game geek for it i also saw the mechanics that it was a light engine building game with some uh action selection and so i bought it and over the last couple years i've played it six times which is a little bit low of a number considering the amount of time that i've had the game but i'll jump into the reasons for that in just a little bit as normal for my reviews i'm going to start off with the things i really like about the game then i'm going to cover some neutral potential issues for the game and lastly i'm going to go over some negatives so let's begin with the stuff i really like uh at the top is the bidding auction for the starting player token i don't like auction games that's just that's just a mechanic that i don't enjoy in fact i usually if someone says hey let's play this auction game i will say let's play something else so it's not something that i would have expected to love so much about this game but that little that tiny little aspect to this game of auctioning these teeth to see who's gonna be the starting player has so many interesting mechanical tendrils that that really make it a satisfying decision in fact it's almost the most important decision you're gonna make in the game in a turn is how much are you going to bid teeth-wise to be the starting player and the reason for that mostly is that you you know there are good cards that are going to come out and they're going this could be good technology that's going to come out there's going to be that great creature that you could potentially kill that you want first dibs at and being the starting player having enough teeth to get to that is

very is a very big deal also denying other people from getting that one technology like say the technology comes out that um that i can acquire and that someone else can acquire you want to jump in and get there first so you're constantly looking at how many teeth everyone else has and what everyone else might be doing looking at the card row it's a very interesting decision to make uh i really like it i guess also because it's a low value auction you know two teeth is common to have if you have five teeth then you're rich you know so it's you know do i go from two teeth to three teeth is a very interesting decision it's not like games where you're like oh do i bid 53 or 55 so i really like the auction in this game i also enjoy the light engine building that goes along with all these different technologies in the game you know they're all different some of them they're not all simple like some of them introduce new actions that you could do you know oh the one card lets you sacrifice cave people and another one gives you bonuses every time people die so those combo really well together and some of them are simple like the stargazing i showed in the the rules you know just get a technology but they they range all over the port some of them seem really overpowered you know there's one where you don't even have to draw for uh casualties when you fight monsters so that's very expensive technology you're probably going to get it late game shortly before the game is actually over i i enjoy the way these things interact with each other they're the funnest part of the game as far as the card being revealed it's like what technology is going to come out this term

so i like that and and i just love the art in this game it's just almost enchanting for me to think when i'm looking at these cards that an artist sculpted this you know they assembled together in a figurine this big and then someone took a photo of it and there's a unique one for every single card in the game that's a humongous labor of love i just if you haven't gone there yet i would definitely recommend going to the board game geek site for this game they have a bunch of behind the scenes photos for how they took all these images it's really really interesting and i think it just adds a lot of the fun and intrigue to the game uh shifting into neutral aspects to the game and actually kind of going along with that last thing i said you have all this unique art and then you have all these characters who are identical you know every explorer has the same statistics they have different models and they're all looking off into the horizon you know some other males some are female this guy's got a goatee that's cool but they all cost three food and two teeth they'll give you one arrowhead one forage and a foot and you know i understand that it's a light game it's almost a filler game not quite so they don't want to start inducing too much in the way of uh potential imbalances but i don't know it'd been really nice to have maybe two different types of explorers two different types of elders so you could say oh that's the really good foraging albert oh that's the really good science elder and it just adds some diversity you know you get all these cool pretty pictures but sometimes you really feel like you don't actually have that many different decisions to make because so many of these cards you know get

three fighters out they're all the same card uh many of the uh the monsters also the monsters creatures and sympathy tigers and stuff the numbers actually many of them are identical and so that's like oh you know do i kill this one or that one thematically because i'm going after the saber-tooth tiger but mechanically it's there's really no difference between so many of the uh the different things you can fight the other neutral issue i have with this game is that it could definitely develop a runaway leader syndrome uh having a runaway leader in the game that's gonna last like 60 45 60 minutes is not the end of the world but since this is very you know you don't you never punch any of your neighbors in the face i mean i guess the bidding is the closest you can get to really screwing with someone else's plans and that is not going to hurt the engine they've already built it's just going to potentially stall out the engine that they are building so if somebody gets to the point where they have this great engine you know they're making lots of teeth they might be making the most teeth well you're not going to be able to beat them in the bidding to get the start player token to get that really amazing technology that came out or that last thinker that's gonna put them up to eight light bulbs so they can win the game you know it it's hard to put a wrench in the spokes of somebody who just has their engine whirring and that's a bit of a bummer that there was not there's no way like for people to collectively gang up on somebody else it's it's very one-on-one on one but ultimately it doesn't it doesn't kill the game it just it's a bit of a bummer now i want to talk about negatives uh for this game and

there are two big ones i want to talk about the first one is that fighting these monsters i keep saying monsters fighting these creatures these animals these reptiles it's too random for me i don't i don't like revealing the top card from the deck and seeing if you took a casualty or not it it just sucks the fun out of a moment i i found you know many games where you roll dice or push your luck or your drawing cards on top of the deck and yeah you got it or boo ah crap i shouldn't have gotten so hard this game does not have that in it this game you draw it over and you lose a cave person it's like ah it was a 20 draw crack you know i spent turns getting the food together the teeth together i sacrificed bidding order to keep those teeth to get that guy so they could ah why didn't i fight that smile a dime and you know that's that's not fun that person isn't having fun in that moment and that one person not having fun in that moment i don't know the way my play group plays the way i play i am not having fun when i see somebody else not having fun it doesn't feel like a pushy like game so this kind of puts you like kind of thing in here almost feels jarring you know it's whoa what oh crap i have to lose and then you know it seems like you can get a run of bad luck for you know next turn you're like okay well it's not gonna happen again and you try again and it does and you're like you know we're half an hour into this game and i've got 3k back down to three cavemen

and you know so-and-so over there has six i'm not gonna win and that is not great you know i just don't like knowing that you're not gonna win first of all and feeling like you're not going to win because dumb luck you know that 20 draw or something like that you know because you can draft your cave people in such a way to try and keep them all having the same little values on the bottom so that you have a less likelihood of taking casualties but 20 is 20 and that's the minimum that can happen to actually kill your people and yeah it's just really not fun and so what that means for me is that i stopped fighting animals many games ago you know like the third game i just stopped and pretty much every game i play now i forage i just build a forage engine because foraging you don't draw for casualties you just constantly work on this engine that you're building and this leads into the second negative i have for this game and that is replayability you would think in a game where a quarter of the deck is technologies that are all different that there would be just replayability out the wazoo but functionally the way it feels is first of all it feels like there are half the amount of technologies that there are because the way a the discarding mechanic works we have you know you've got these cards out in the card row and you've got a technology over here and the turn's over and somebody is going to discard these cards down until they're only three left and then we will add more in and if that person doesn't have enough science to research the technology that's out there you know they're gonna discard that

research card and take it away from the tableau because they don't want somebody else to have the ability to get it before they will so it feels like if a technology comes out in a turn it's probably only going to be there for one turn before somebody discards it because they don't want other people to have the ability to get to it and then it goes into that discard pile and you know you reshuffle the discard pile when you go through the whole deck but it's you know half an hour into the game at least before you reshuffle that deck also many of these are quite expensive and you know if a six value one comes out in the first turn at some point it's probably going to get discarded for various reasons and then you know that that card is effectively out of the game for this whole game because it might not ever even show up again uh let alone the whole revealing mechanic where you reveal for casualties when you fight monsters well that revealed card goes away if that revealed card is a technology then it's also not going to come out and you might say well that's cool that will add replayability because that means some cards aren't going to show up in a game but it just it just ultimately it feels like you have to get lucky and be able to buy the card as it comes out so the decision structure for actually purchasing technologies is rarely there usually it's can i buy that technology okay i will i hope that the next technology that i'm allowed to buy will sync up and make a little engine it's rare that you're like oh which one of these two or three technologies am i going to buy this turn so that's that's definitely unfortunate and and the replayability you know it also goes into that thing i mentioned earlier

where so many of these cards are very similar and if you have the technologies which are the interesting part keep getting discarded and all these other cards which are all so similar to each other fill up this row you're gonna have many turns where there are no technologies or a technology that no one can afford and it's like okay i forage you fight a smilodon oh crap you killed one of your cave people you forage you forage okay i'm gonna forage all right let's discard some carbs and do it again so i ultimately that definitely is a negative for the game i'm gonna keep this game i i still enjoy it i i even though i said replayability is a big negative and i think it is it's easy to teach i enjoy playing it with new people uh i have a hard time playing this with people who played it with me two or three times but when new people come into the group i'll sit down i'll teach this to them and they will usually have fun unless they try to try to kill too many creatures and then i've seen that kind of kill a whole game before so that's definitely unfortunate anyway i i recommend playing this game at some point if you can find it for cheap i would definitely acquire it i'm going to keep it it's really cool on my shelf i love the art uh ultimately it's just it's a neat addition to a board gaming collection but mechanically i would not say it's the it's not the greatest uh all right so now i want to i want to try something new that i've never done before if you look in the description down below this video i have a link to a really quick poll that you can do it should take you like 10 seconds and in this poll it just asks you which game do you want me to review next i've

got three options on there i've got uh crocodile i have two different coconut boards it's one of the most played games in my collection uh the second game is uh concordia which i've played many times it's a medium weight really interesting euro game and the third option is suburbia and i also have the suburbia inc expansion so uh just take 10 seconds out of your day jump down there give me a vote i'm really curious to see which one of those you guys are most interested in having me review next and until that time have a great time gaming

Progress saved