QE: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games and Life. Today we are doing a discussion over QE and I don't have the box for it anymore. It's expansion commodities. Um, this was a game that was described to me. And it was well, as it was described it sounds so bizarre. Yeah. Like it's a it's an auction game, a true auction game unlike Skyrise. Um, but I where you actually have to take into consideration what people could bid, try and bluff them, outbid them. Um, but you can use literally any number you want. Yeah. Yeah. And that sounds inherently like it would be broken.
Yeah. And it was if you play it that way, which we did the first time because we misunderstood. All bidding was secret. So no one had a clue what a what a basis number was. Oh, got you. Okay. you can So So one person said five and one person said 15,000. Right. The way you can do is you can break one person and make them never recoverable. Yes. So the first honestly the first bid pretty much will probably dictate at least like 80% of the rest of the bids. Yeah, like you're you like your first bid is 10K and then it's like, "Okay, we're going to be pretty much like 10K more than that." Yes, that's like that's the wiggle room. The 80% wiggle room is somewhere between 20 and 5K at that point.
Um, and I'm going to be I find this game so fascinating. I suck ass at it. I'm so bad. I have not I have yet to win. Um, but I think last time we played together it it's like it's always one bid. Yeah. That is kind of it cuz if I didn't bid that much cuz I was at the race it was the it was EU which is what I wanted. It was four points and it was also manufacturing which is what I wanted. And you controlled the opening bid which means your bid wasn't secret. Well, exactly. So it it like fell in my lap and to guarantee that I get it I over paid but it's like in this game is a lot of Well, they I guess they they don't know I need manufacturing but they know I need EU and four points and we're sitting I mean I think 30K was the highest we did this game but it's like how much are they willing to bid to make sure I don't get it. Um, and that's reading it and it's well, I I really want it. Yeah, I think you guys did like 500 bucks and 200. I'm like, okay.
Yeah, so I did I think I don't remember that one I did 5,000 cuz I wanted the commodity cuz I thought 35 is going to be too high and I know when it's so high off the mark Brett answers $428. So I almost went 500 but the idea is like, well, it's it's it's going to give instead of a 20 or 4,500 credit I'll probably get it still with 500 and basically save myself X amount. Yeah, exactly. And that man, there is nothing more gut punching than like putting in a bid and seeing everyone else's be so significantly lower. Which is hilarious because I did one for 10,000. I got it but Brett did for $999. 99 I was like, so I got three points for a buck.
Yeah, and I mean cuz there's like so much that weirdly taken into consideration in this very very simple game because you want you want the points of the of the tile. You want your own country and you also want the monopolization and diversification. So you're pretty much getting points almost the yeah, from everywhere but you're not getting a lot of points. Yeah. And And to be fair, while we're talking about high spend, it's because in this game, whoever spent the most is just instantly eliminated. There is no That's always me. Yeah. So, and that's actually where I kind of like it cuz otherwise, because it's being game with no limit, you can go as high as you like. You will probably suffer because of it. Exactly. And I mean, I do I do like that because it it allows for people to be riskier and also try to read the players a lot more. Um but at the same time, it can be kind of like I mean cuz it's always been so drastically different. Like I've always had way more spending than you guys. So, I'm like, well, I didn't even have a chance.
Right. Uh but I mean, it would be so shitty if it was like five bucks off. Right. And you And you lose cuz of that. Where it's like, well, I had five more spending than you, but I have zero chance of winning even though my points are more. Right. That's kind of shitty. Um And it's never happened. And then in a game where you can literally bid whatever, I doubt that would happen. But I can see that not sitting too well. On the other hand, I doubt that anyone would ever bid the same number. Well, at least Well, they did because I mean, they do have it in the rules. So, it was thought through. I think it's because we we keep it at round numbers. Like unless we're being weird. And it's like I'm like, oh, that's three points. 3333. Well, there's also only three of us. So, there's only a chance that two people could tie in any round. Exactly. Um And it just happened to happen this Right.
Right. But I think it like yeah, if you're if you're playing this game almost in like a weird like party setting with max players, you're going to have yeah, all over the place of just actual like, oh, this is going to be $31,892.45. It's like Yeah. Yep. That's the bid. Right. Uh And depending on who you play with, like again, we're all fairly technical. So, it's just going to favor that. Whereas if you play with people who are artistic, then you're probably going to get the weird It's $1,292. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Why? And honestly, I should know cuz Brett got lowest spending, right? Yeah. That's how That's how it is in real life. I'm the most. So, I don't know like it's like you and I are total odds here. I'm just like, "I really want that. All the money."
I'm like, "Hmm." And I lost. But the thing is you have to spend money because you're going to get stuff for spending money, which is going to give you points. Right. Now, the reverse is with the expansion they added is the second highest bid is going to get something. They're going to spend that money, but the person who did the auction now gets a credit. Yeah. Which means there's a lot of more Like again, if you do a high number, but let's say Brett's Let's say the 35. I really wanted that to keep it from you, so I did 40,000. Mhm. Well, either you get something for 35, which you're going to get basically because you're opening bid, or Brett went just under me, you get that much back basically to bid for something else in the future. Yeah, the commodities expansion, I think I would always have in every game.
Yeah. Like it's it's so simple to add into the game and adds in such a very unique layer of strategy Yeah. um when you're auctioning. I don't know about either of you, but I definitely used it cuz I got some big numbers on my credit. And I was like, "Well, hell, I can go a little bit bigger now and I want that." No, no. Yeah. I mean, that's that's exactly right because which in a game like this where it's like you're punished for spending a lot of money at times, well, with the commodities, you're kind It kind of counteracts it. It does. And it makes it harder for people like myself if you didn't bid the highest to get the commodity. Yes. Right. But but I'll say also like get but you gain the commodities are worth more points than any of the other tiles. And they're hidden points.
Yeah. I can look at your sayings like, "Okay, I can quickly guestimate how many points you have based on the tiles kept. Your commodities, I have no idea. I don't know when I take the um crypto, did Seth get the 10-pointer or did he get one of the other ones? Yeah, did I get the zero? Right. Um okay, gold, a lot of people were taking gold. I'm not, but there's only two left or there's one left. I'm going to take that just to crash it. Right. Cuz I wasn't going to get any points anyway, at least I'll get three or four. Right. And at least shrinking your point values for everybody else, yeah. Exactly. So, and then oil it's like, "Okay, I want to try and fight for the most." Because one, they're uh six to They're decent point values. They're um four to four to five points, but you can get an additional five if you have the most. Right. Um Oh, I thought it was just most.
That's why I never took any. Sorry. I didn't realize they had face value themselves. Oh, yeah, no, yeah. They're four to five. Gold is six to seven. And crypto just has the wildest range from zero to 10. Yeah, zero to five eight eight 10. Right. Uh but yeah, that that extra layer of thinking like, "Okay, well, I don't really want that tile that's being auctioned. It doesn't It does me no good." Yeah. But I want to But I don't want to just tank and be like, "Here's a one." Because I want the commodity. So, you're you're invested in every single auction where the base game you're not. But I also don't want to do the commodity too high because that's giving you the credit. Right. Just want high enough that I win it, the commodity, Mhm. but giving you the least amount of credit possible. Exactly. So, it becomes a really interesting finesse Yeah.
that this game, every time I try to explain it to someone, sounds the most boring game ever. But it's like when you're playing it, it like is immediately like, "Oh, here's the tile. Here's my opening bid." And then everyone's like, "Hm." And you add the commodities where it's like these are all, like you said, worth the most worth more points than everything you can acquire. Right. Um so how much are you actually willing to invest while also keeping in consideration not overpaying cuz then the person who pays the most loses. Which about a third of the way in the game through I was like, "I'm just going to commodities." I mean I ended up with four companies total and I was like, "Yeah, this isn't worth it. I'm just going to go commodities and try to win through commodities." Yeah, and I was wondering if that was going to hurt you because you didn't sell as much.
Um so it really didn't. Yep. Um now granted if I didn't put drop 30k, I would have at least spent actually, but here we are losing as the EU, so that feels about right. So yeah, I mean if you're hearing this game and it's like, "Oh, it's an auction game where you bid whatever." And you're like, "Well, that just sounds like it's not going to work." It really does. It does work. Yeah. Now, I think this game would do way better with more people. Um I don't think it's horrible at three. No, it definitely plays better at four. I played four and five and I probably like it best at four. At four, yeah, okay. I was I was thinking that five would be best, like max player counts. Um and I wonder if that's the case if you have the expansion.
Yeah. people who are jockeying for the gold and the oil and all that. Um so you're going to have more numbers where it's not going to be the same two people like, "Oh, you get the you get the tile and you get the commodity." It's like, "Oh, now it's you get the like it just it's more people that can spread around." So Right. Which is why I like it at three because because it's more strategic. Because every round two are going to win something. Yeah, I will say with And and so it's it's not it's it's if if I want a commodity, I just got to get between that number and whatever I think you're going to do. Yeah. And that then and that's what I really enjoyed about it. And the more players there are, the more the harder that's going to be to Yeah, I can see that. accomplish it becomes more. And you have like my thing where I'm I have a counting system for it. With more players it just becomes more difficult to count more peoples with two others.
It wasn't terrible. Yep. I knew I was on the high end for spend, but I was pretty sure I was still lower than you. But I didn't fully like I thought I'm higher than you. I didn't think I was going to make it. Which is what it turned out to be. Yeah. Um no, I definitely see where Brett's coming from. I think that you you get different radically different games from different player counts. Yeah. Which is great. Cuz for you Exactly. So cuz for me with higher player counts it's you're going to have probably a an a more I guess even spread Yeah. of of total spend. Cuz whenever is if someone like makes a really bad uh bidding decision like put 30K thinking everyone else does it. At least like I just have to compete against you guys to think if that's worth it. If there's two other people then one I have better odds that someone might pay for that.
Right. Or if they don't, I still spent the most. Well, there's four other people who can also equally make a bad decision. Versus like in a lower player count one bad bid pretty much knocks you out of it. Right. So that's kind of where I'm coming from from base game, but I I think you do get to have a more strategic game with less people. Yeah. Um I mean, but other than that, yeah, it's it's a I mean, it's low maintenance game. Like you could actually easily play this out in public. Yeah. Um with taking up basically no table space. Right. Uh Cuz realistically you don't even need any of these until the end of the game. So you really just need this board and this board with the expansion. And this goes at the end of the game for scoring purposes only.
And if it hasn't been, it could be easily converted to an app game. I agree. it on your phone. Yeah. At least like for scoring, like kind of like the I think the whole game could be played on an app. It could. Yeah. sets a number, the other two see it, they punch in their bids. Yeah. Yeah, you could even do that, yeah, wirelessly. Everyone puts in like they the the game code and then it just kind of pops up, oh hey, I'm the auctioneer. Sorry, company designing an app. Go work with them. With board game tables. What is QE? Quantitative easing. Is that That's not Oh, is that really what what this is? Okay. And the only reason I know that is because I've heard the term thrown around a little bit because I I used to work at a Federal Reserve Bank.
Okay. And so that was what they did when they started buying up a whole bunch of bonds at the beginning of the pandemic to try to ease out inflation and the Gotcha. Gotcha. And now they're going through the opposite, quantitative What is it? Deasing. T It starts with a T. Now I can't remember what they call it, but it just came up the other day is they're going to start Nope, we're going to go back to the way it was and you're going to deal with this. Slowly and carefully. That is fascinating. I was like, here's Brett again just saying something stupid. Quantitative easing. That's what? Quantitative tightening. Okay. Is what they're about to start. Fascinating. Kind of. I mean, it's not as I'm more fascinated that you do the answer more than what the actual answer was. Pure macroeconomics.
Um do you guys have any negatives with the game? Dry erase. I think there's something about it's I have It's not It's not a negative, but it's something I wish the expansion did and said. I Because it's a full auction game and the auctioneer has um like they they put they set the bid price for the the tile, the whatever they're called. Um It's It is weird that second bid gets their pick of the commodity. Yeah. It's a I feel like the auctioneer should try to entice them and also set the bid for a commodity because then that would allow for the the auctioneer to also try and maybe nudge the price a little bit on the commodity. Like, "Oh, I really Oh, yes, see you were going for oil." Right. And then try and sell that to counteract, you know, the negative for the credit.
Or random draw. Or random draw. Either good. Just a combination. But maybe they were just going for simplicity. Yeah. On that for a small cuz it's very small. it more strategic, too. With the randomization? Or with the with the being able to pick? have it, you choose um the credit that you know how much more flexibility you have in the future. Yeah. Um maybe that's what they were going for is make it a little bit more strategic without complicating it. Yeah. Yeah. I don't know. It is a tiny a tiny uh box expansion. Mhm. So I I guess maybe they just wanted to keep the flow going instead of have one person bid you know set the bid for the thing and then also have to meticulously think about how to sell the commodity. Exactly. Uh cuz I would I almost feel like that would be a different game on its own. It might just be easier to just be like, "Oh, let them pick." And They might play tested it and it just didn't work as well as they thought.
Yeah. Yeah. And again, maybe the expansion kind of does that with more people. Yeah. So, um on a scale of 1 to 10, what are you guys giving QE? Solid seven for me. Seven? Yeah. Even with the expansion? Still a seven? Yeah. Okay. Yeah. Okay. Uh I'd like to play it a few more times, but right now I'm sitting at a nine. Nine? Nice. Yeah. Uh that's with the expansion as well. Would you always play with the expansion, too? I could go either way. Um but what it would be is kind of like Kingdomino and Queendomino for me. Got you. I'm going to I'm going to teach you the base game. Mhm. And after we play that a few times, then we're getting into the real one. Yeah. Okay, now we're actually going to put them in. It is a really good expansion without really adding much. It's a good expansion. Um yeah. Oh, one complaint.
Oh, go for it. Just thought of it. I don't like the fact that the person who spent the most is just completely eliminated. Okay. I would like to see a a significant penalty, and like maybe 15 or 20 points. I Big enough that you really want to avoid it, but not that you're totally out. Yeah, I I actually agree. There are a few games that do that. You know, you know, so-and-so and you're completely I like uh Gugaon does that. There There's a track you have to get up to, and if you don't, you can't win at all. Granted, there's a lot of I mean, there's a lot of ways to do like In those games, you have to really grind your way to not complete that goal. Here, there's there's kind of not a whole lot you can do if if it's like oh, you overbid, like we know exactly what you paid for. I paid 30k. We're just never going to ever spend more than that, so we know for a fact you're out.
Yeah, I think cuz I remember this coming in conversation. The problem is especially for base game, and I think that I the commodities might have changed that aspect a little bit, but let's say you remove the commodities because with base game, that's where that rule exists from. I would never lose cuz I would just outbid everyone. I'll do 10 billion, 100 billion, and I'll just start putting extra zeros into the point where you can give me a 15-point penalty, I still only have all the tiles. Right. And that's why that's why it stopped was You can take all the tiles. Like so, I could crush this game if we took out the expansion because there's no way to get points. I could just take every single one, and you guys would never score a tile. I'd be eliminated, but you technically would have tied.
Yeah. No, yeah, that's right. Cuz if you With the commodities, you're getting other points, and so that's where to me the it's now benefiting. So, again, like I went with just the commodities, honestly, just going second, being the second highest, is kind of the better option. It's going to bring the whole total down for base side of it. The commodities expansion should tighten everyone in for that very reason because they are so good with no downside. Gold's the only one that has a downside. Um really. Cuz even if you're like if you're the only one getting the crypto, who cares if you got the zero? You still got eight 10. Because the zero can't like the zero plus the 10 is two fives. So it's two five pointers right there. And then if you could get another eight, that's still the best tile in the game at that point.
No, exactly. So I mean I do agree. I think um yeah, cuz I think that it it is pretty bitter to be like, well, I spent the most um so I can't win. Uh but I don't see a way like normally I would be like, oh yeah, 20 point difference. But yeah, if you're always overbidding just because you there's no limit like you just do some gargantuan amount and it's like, well, I get still have all the points. So I have 50,000 or 50,000. I have 50 points. Subtract 20 from that, that's 30. To your guys's zero. Right. So I still win. a sliding scale, but Yeah. Now we're now we're complicating things. Yeah, but I think with the expansion it it it forces everyone to actually not overpay and take into consideration trying to be second.
Right. Um but again, I think that in lower player counts, the outright losing by spending the most is is worse because it's like, well, I'm not competing against two other people. Whereas if there's five and I spent the most, then well, Right. Yeah, there was five people. Yeah. Uh but yeah. No, I I do agree. It's not I mean it's it's never fun, but there are other games that have that. Yeah. Uh granted, this one's just a little bit more loose and liquid that you have less control. Yeah. Like I have no way to ever dictate what you guys bid. So. Yeah, but I think again, the way around that is you chose to put it at 35,000. If you had chosen to put it 30, let's not make my loss any more embarrassing.
30,000. I did, yes. But you were hoping to be outbid. Not necessarily outbid, but at least have you guys But bid more. 20, you probably might have still won it. And it would have been 10,000 less. Right, but it's like to in my head it was like 20K was a little bit cuz we'd been we were sitting around that. So it's like And that's the risk I took. I I was like we were sitting at max of 20. They know I could really use this. If they do outbid me, then great. If they don't, but they you guys were at least close, then at least my my kind of negates it. So it's like I only spent 8K. But you see, that's where I think like because it was so much more than most of the rest of the bids. Yeah. Then it was like I don't I'm not going to compete to try because honestly at that point I was like I don't want to give you any credit because it's so high. If it'd been 20, and I at that point was really going for the commodities, then I was like, "Okay, 20, Brett might actually bid something for this."
I guess I'm also curious as to how like if some if someone does the opening bid at whatever, 10K. Yeah. What's stopping everyone else from never exceeding that? From seeing someone who like, "Oh, you won that at 10K." And then everyone could just be like, "We are never going above 10 bucks." So that basically singles you out that you are guaranteed to lose. Um but if you're always the lowest bidder, then you're not going to be getting any points. Yeah. Because you're not going to be getting any. well, in a three-player game, like I mean, it'd have to be a weird mutual agreement, but if it was like, "Oh, he spent 10K." Or he opened up the bid at 10K, and you and I just weirdly never go above 100 bucks the entire game for any bid, that would not add up to 10k. So that opening Yeah, I know. But that opening bid would immediately cause someone to to lose.
Right? Yeah. Yeah. I think in a super weird scenario But yeah, so I mean you Yeah, you could That would be like really hard hate like almost hate drafting where Cuz not only let's say you randomize who started first, right? So it has to hit the person you're targeting. And the rest of the table has to agree on this. Not necessarily agree, but yeah, I guess they would if they to agree that they're going to go at such a low value that they're never recovering from the opening. Right. Right. But we had such I mean we have crazy ones where we have bids of $48 for the starting. Like that was the opening bid to 30,000. Right. Like those were the ranges of our opening bids. It's like Cuz I was looking at some of the tiles where like one one for 200 bucks.
Yeah. And like and then there's ones that are for 18,000. Yeah. It's like well, okay, 200 bucks was nothing. Like that just didn't matter. Yeah, it was basically a non-bid. And actually, I guess what also um in a higher player count, you're rewarded for not bidding. Yeah, for zero bids. Uh for zero bids. So that's certain number of zero bids. Yeah, uh three. Yeah. Yeah, you get six points for for not bidding anything. Um But yeah, so I mean there are those scenarios that can happen in a game that basically doesn't have any rules or limitations on on the numbers. And the answer to that is to stop playing with those people. Yeah, that would be super shitty where it's like okay, we're just going to make sure he loses so we all can play. It's like okay.
goal is just to make sure someone loses, then those aren't probably the people you should play a game with. Yeah. Yeah. No, um I can't remember if I gave my score. level. That's true. Yeah, it's really just weirdly targeting. Um I don't know if I gave my score. I'm in between you guys, I'm going to give this an eight. Uh With the commodity expansion, I think I'd put it to a seven with base game, but I I think the commodity expansion does give it a bump up. Yeah, this is such a weird game, but it's also weirdly kind of party-esque. Yeah. Like It's light. Yeah. Um it works better with larger groups. Mhm. Yeah. But it's not party in the fun theme. It's just party in the No, but the scale Yeah, it it's it scales well and it's light. Um but yeah, it's not in the hahaha like joking or drinking kind of kind of game.
Could be. It could. It could be, yeah. And Oh, yeah. Uh and those and those numbers would be weird. It's like, okay, well, you just bid it that's a shape. So Winner has to take one shot, loser has to take two shots. No, cuz I lose. Um all right. Well, that's our thoughts on Qwixx, everyone. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.