Guild of Merchant Explorers Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hi everyone today i'm taking a look at the guild of merchant explorers which is a one to four player board game designed by matthew dunstan and brett j gilberts this one takes around 45 minutes to play on average before i get into the review i want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kianda dot co dot uk who are my go-to online retailer in the uk where you can pick up games such as this one and if you use my discount code in the show notes you can get five percent off your first order okay so the game is going to look like this when it's set up where each player is going to have the identical same player board and there are four of these to choose from so you've got a bit of variation there and you're also going to have this communal board here that looks like this which is going to show the cards that have been and have yet to be flipped because this game plays very much like a flip and write style game however you are not writing you are simply placing these exploration cubes so that's going to be showing what you have or what you haven't explored um on the map there's also going to be some of these public objective cards that come out depending on the map you're playing on so you can see here with with this avenia map we've got these three objectives here where the first of which is to place two trading posts on cities value three or greater you've got discover five villages or you've got explore three ruined spaces along the border of the map and if you are the first player to achieve that goal you're going to get the 10 points but if you do it later on you're still going to get compensated by getting five points and there are two decks of cards here these are the special cards that you're going to unlock as the game goes on which are really powerful and we'll touch on that a bit later and you've also got these um
these treasure cards which again you can discover as you explore your map and there are additional resources as well um such as these trading post tokens which again will be placed on your board should you um tie these trading posts together you've got these treasure chests here which shows i've already explored chests or ruined spaces you've got all your points tokens and you also have these wooden tower pieces as well if you manage to explore these towers okay so the flow of the game couldn't be more simple waste all you're going to do on your turn you're going to reveal the next card from this stack here and you're going to place it on the main board here this is going to show what all players are going to explore this round so you can see here i've revealed this um grassland here so therefore i can explore two grassland hexes and you're always going to start at least at the beginning of the game from this main space here and i might want to say um well i can only explore grassland so i say go here and here like so now if i ever cover up one of these coins then i'm going to get one of those coins which is essentially going to be a point at the end of the game and then it's going to continue to all plays have done that and then you're going to go to the next card and reveal it like so so this is going to be the sandland and then you're going to place two sideland tokens but now you've placed some cubes on the board not only can you explore from your main city or the starting point you can also span off from where you've already explored so maybe i want to start venturing down here and spreading further and further so you can see here all the different cars that come out you've got one a one
mountain exploration hex you've got the two we've already explored you've got a two wild one and so when you reveal that you can actually choose which ones to explore so it gives you a bit more flexibility there so let's just say i wanted to go here and then maybe i wanted to go here as well and we'll touch on why i might want to do that a bit later um and you've also got this one here where you've got the three um water spaces but in a straight line so that lets you cross the ocean to again start venturing onto these new um islands now you can also see on the main board here you've got these other spaces for a one two three and a one two or three card now basically each round there is going to be one of these cards um added to the deck so the first round you've only got the one in the deck and when you reveal that card you are actually going to draft or pick two of these cards from the top of the deck and then select one of them to add to your player board so let's just say i revealed these two and these cards are absolutely fantastic they're much more powerful than the basic ones you get here and that you explore a lot faster further and quicker so um you can see here this investigate card says it lets me explore a continuous path of five desert and or c spaces or this one here says i can explore up to one c and four desert spaces in any order so again that lets you cover a lot more ground than the basic ones and when you selected the one that you want so let's just say i wanted to click select this one you're going to add it to the side of your board here like so because later in the game when it gets to the second third and fourth round essentially um
when you draw that card again you're going to get to use this ability again so you can use this more than once to get maximum dividends from it so let's talk about what we're actually trying to achieve here so the first way you can get points is to simply land on the coins which i mentioned already and the second of which is to establish new villages now when you do that you are going to have a look whenever you complete a full section of terrain so you say here i've got all these three um sand terrain types complete i'm going to take one of my little village tokens and place it on one of those empty spots like so so i could replace a cube with the house like this now this is important because not only does it get you victory points depending on the round you're in in era one you're gonna get one victory point for that and here are four you're gonna get four victory points for that but also what's important is the actual establishment of this village because when it comes to the end of the round after all of these cards have been depleted every one of these exploration cubes is going to get wiped off the board however these um these villages are going to remain on the board and going to act as new spawning points in the future round so it lets you kind of reach further and further and cover more ground without having to start back from bare bones so let's take a look at some of the other features here so you can see you've got these um these trade houses here now whenever you tie these together so let's just say i managed to have a continuous group of cubes i'm connecting these two trade houses together you are actually going to multiply them with each other so it'll be four times three
for 12 points um and you'd also cover them up with one of these tokens so you can actually choose which one to do but it does mean that you'll not be able to score that particularly that particular trade house again so you know you cannot keep exploiting it again and again um additionally if you choose to um explore these ruins by placing a cube on it you're gonna get to draw a card from this ruin deck here which can give you a bunch of different things such as these um these jars which let you score points based on a sliding scale depending on how many of those you've collected or some of them might give you a kind of endgame victory points as well based on other things if i can find one here like this for example for each tower i explore i'm gonna get a coin at the end of the game and that ties into these towers which are usually on the kind of right on the board or the map in the hard-to-reach places so whenever you expert an exploration coin there a cube there obviously i would have had to connect it um you are going to get a number of points based on this here so the first one you explore you're going to get six points the second one's gonna be eight then ten and then fourteen but achieving all of them is very difficult because they are all really spread out and that is essentially the way the game plays and how you get points of course at the end of the round you're going to reshuffle all these cards in together and add the next rounds card meaning that when that one's drawn you're going to add a new special card to your deck meaning that you can start again really ramping up your ability to spread across the map and at the end of the game after these four rounds are complete bearing in mind that the last one at the last round you're gonna have this kind of wild card where you can choose which
special ability to activate you go after all those four hours completed you're gonna add up all your points and the person with the most victory points is going to be the winner okay so let's share some thoughts on the guild of merchant explorers and i suppose the first thing i want to touch on is the buffet of options on how you can get points i think this is a really good touch because everything seems inviting you know i want this big cluster of coins here just sat there ready for the taking and you know if i set up a trade house i can maybe exploit that again and again and again because my my um exploration cubes are going to come off the map meaning again i can keep taking those points and i want to reach these far points on the map because these towers are worth a big chunk of change here and can really put you in a good position to win the game and we want to connect the cities together so you can get these big multipliers i'm getting the bigger cities connected to the other bigger cities is more difficult and it's going to require a longer trade route however that might be worth it as well maybe you want to explore all the ruins and start maybe going for this um this kind of set collection method as well so again tons of different ways you can get points there and additionally there's even those public objectives so you've got that tension there to try and be the first to achieve that however i do like the way that that is almost like a conflicting mechanism because you are so drawn into getting all these points um you also need to bear in mind that at the end of the round you will be resetting your player board meaning it's ultra important for you to establish these new um these new villages and because early in the game they're not worth many points at all but it is going to be vitally important
otherwise you're going to start from scratch and not really venture too much further whereas if i'm starting from here it's not going to take much effort at all for me to start reaching these really far reaches on you know on the map to start you getting those really juicy um hexes and really kind of ramping up your point scoring so it kind of reminds me of something like um blue lagoon or something like um takao for example where creating new spawn points is really important but it might kind of act as a short time sacrifice for long-term gain but despite all that cool stuff going on the coolest thing about this game by far are these special cards these are absolutely fantastic and adds so much life into the game and make your turns feel so much more satisfying than the basic um cars that come up let's just take a look at some of the other ones here that we haven't had a look at like for example you've got these ones here that lets you explore three mountain spaces which is normally a difficult thing to explore because the basic card only lets you explore one but it also lets you double the value of coins you have um or you earn from those spaces you got this one here that lets you explore a mountain but also explore all the hexes around that mountain or this one here that says explore up to four c spaces then explore any number of cities adjacent to those sea spaces so it lets you really explore these um trade posts on the um kind of on the coastline and these are all different strategies you can go for even these wild ones well there's even ones that let you kind of go as far as you want in a straight line so there's a bunch of different things you can do here and
they all feel great and when they come up you're like yes this is what i really needed and this is really going to kick start my turn there's also a decent degree of planning and strategy in this game because you need to leave yourself with contingencies and options and that's really cool because this is like very easy to look at a glance to see what has come out and what has yet to come out you know with a lot of rolling rights or flipping right style games um they they usually make an effort to say how many cars of this hyper in the deck but it requires too much effort and too much work to really work that out and try to plan things accordingly well this one there's only like one of each type of card so you can see like i've got the two wild cards yet to come out i need to leave this option ready for me for when it does come out and it also means that in the kind of future rounds when things are wiped off you need to leave yourself with options because say you know that the the sand card has yet to come out however you've not left yourself any options for you to explore onto sand then you're gonna pretty much waste your turn so again that is something you need to think about to make sure you're not wasting anything because again a smallest mistake can end up costing you because there are so many different ways you can get points but kind of in contrast to that as well it does feel like sometimes it can work against you in terms of just the luck of the cards coming out because especially when it relates to these special cards like for example say i had a card that lets me explore as many sand areas as i wanted to but i'm not next to any sand areas by the time that card is drawn that means i've pretty much wasted my special cards i'm not going to get anything for it whereas my
opponents are going to absolutely smash a bunch of hexes and i'm going to instantly fall behind and that ground is difficult to make back up but yeah there is something you can do about it all there's often a way around that but it can still feel frustrating if you are wasting turns now despite the good decisions to be had here i do feel like the game goes on a little bit too long you know you are looking at around 45 minutes to play this and i feel like if i'm to break it down into round structure that is one round too long i'm generally satisfied by the end of the third round and i feel like the the fourth round is just a little bit too much for me and i kind of ready for it to end by then but that being said the majority of the gameplay is simultaneous so you're not waiting for other players to take their turn you can really get your head down and you're bored and not worrying about what other people are doing or waiting for them to take their turn so that is definitely a nice touch i do feel there's a decent degree of replayability here because it's one of those games where you can't achieve everything per game and there's always more for you to explore and you do end up making mistakes and i think a big part of this game or the lure to come back to this game is to try and kind of fix those mistakes and improve on your previous score because inevitably you are not going to be as efficient as you want to be but on top of that you do actually get four maps with the game yes they all do generally work in the same way like this one here is just some kind of a more spread out island bit more difficult to spread around and travel or traverse the sea um you've got the volcano one here where you have these kind of dead spaces which you can't travel through i'm just gonna make things a little bit more difficult for you and you've also got this one here with these jagged rocks
which actually adds a new scoring mechanism in where if you visit these crystals um they can start kind of compounding on each other and give you more and more score the more of them you visit however if you visit them again you will not get that payout so it's nice that they do have a different degree of maps to this um and it does certainly does feel like you could add more maps to it and quite easily start injecting new mechanisms and things because the you know the core experience is so simple just adding a tweak here or there isn't really going to change the fundamental experience this is essentially a multiplayer solitaire game there's very little interaction the only kind of degree of interaction here are these public objective cards which i do think is a definite welcome touch here there's added tension of being the first to achieve these objectives and even the way that these objectives synergize with each other is cool as well because some of them might actually tie in with the other one and that's cool you know if you want to get the leg up on your opponent and you know create a bit of a distance between you then you know you can potentially get a ten point or even a five point swing if you are the first to achieve that and there are also a um i think there's like five or six different cards per map meaning that each time you play a map you might have a different array of objectives out there so let's talk about the production for this game i'm starting with the visuals i think the actual artwork of the maps looks fantastic it has this kind of old-school cartography style look to it and it really works for me the simple graphic design works as well just the simple hexes um not too busy you can see a glass where all the different cards are um even all the exploration of the
cards is well worded so the little room for confusion there and you can even just look at the illustrations and kind of understand what everything does so visually no no problems or no issues whatsoever however when it comes to the physical components um i do have some issues with it particularly because the board does become very busy as the game goes on uh these cubes are you know they're they're just standard euro size cubes but because the map itself is quite small it does become quite cluttered and quite fiddly and just quite busy on the way the board looks you know sometimes if you start establishing these villages you have to start digging in and moving things around and sliding villages in there you can start knocking cubes all over the place um particularly as the game goes on you're gonna start place placing these um little trade houses down you're gonna start putting the towers down um and more importantly you're gonna start putting these little treasure chests down and it all just becomes a bit much especially if you have um large hands or large fingers like like i do and it does become a bit of an issue so it just becomes a bit too convoluted on the board and especially at the end of the round as well when you have to start removing all the cubes you have to start sliding them all out of the place and stuff again you're knocking things over and it's just a bit too much for me to the point where it is a distraction and also the feel of the game doesn't feel right for the production because this is essentially a you know it's a flip and right game it could have been done at least i see no reason why it couldn't have been a a
dry erase board just put dots on the different spots take them off as you go and maybe if you've got a permanent spot removed you just fill it in you know in solid black so i can't see why it wasn't a flip and right game you could have half to the production costs um because this isn't a cheap game considering the style the game it is you know you're looking at most rolling rights being you know 10 to 20 pounds this one you're looking at 35 to 40 pounds so it just feels like a bit of a missed opportunity there maybe they were going for a bigger experience here or making it feel bigger than that it is but i think it's misproduced not badly produced just they just didn't quite get the recipe right okay so let's get into some final thoughts for the guild of merchant explorers and i have to say this game is a lot of fun everything you're doing here feels fun it feels satisfying it feels inviting and i think a big part of that is due to the pacing of the game you know you start off not being able to do much at all maybe just getting a point here or there and establishing a village but the next time you get to start spawning a bit further along and reaching further and further getting getting closer and closer to these real juicy parts um of the map and i also think it's a great touch that earlier in the game establishing the villagers isn't going to get you many points um however it's going to be important because it's going to be a new spawning point for you and but later in the game even though you might have a big network already established it's still worth establishing those villages because you still get a big chunk of points for doing so so not only is that great but the way that ties in with this special
card system i think it's a winning winning formula because these feel fantastic when you get to use them it feels really fun when you get to draw two and choose the one you want because they're both fantastic you know which one is going to be benefiting you now which one is going to benefit you long term because you might get to use it again and again and depending on how early that card comes out and yeah so that's a real strong point of the game definitely i think the the thing that most people are going to take away from this now that being said this game is essentially a flip and write style game however in a different format and i'm not quite sure if all this extra components all this fittiness is going to be worth the experience that the game offers now i don't want that to sound like it's detracting from the gameplay because the gameplay is is fantastic in fact it's very strong um but the main kind of lure and the attraction for me to play these flip and write style games is that they are so convenient you just need a a a bit of paper and maybe a deck of cards and you're good to go you're talking 30 seconds set up this one there's just a bit too much going on it's a bit too busy and it does actively um detract me or deter me from getting this one back to the table which is frustrating because i do enjoy the gameplay that this one offers but if that doesn't bother you then um then hey go for it you're not going to have too much of an issue with it and there is fun to be had here it's got a good solo mode as well if that's your style of thing i didn't really touch on that but you can probably imagine how that plays um but i think myself i'm probably going to lean towards the more convenient rolling right off flip and write style games i'm
talking games such as get on board or even like the trails of toucan which has a very similar thing going on but again it's just a pen and a bit of paper so that much more convenient and easy to get back to the table and also the fact that it does come in a full-size box um it might sound silly um but it you know shelf space is a premium for me i do not feel this game warrants a full-size box so all those little things i just knocked it down you know a point or so and it's going to stop this one staying around my collection but i want to reiterate the gameplay itself is solid and i definitely think there's a market for it um i just loved it if it was in a smaller more kind of streamlined and simpler package rather than throwing all the bells and whistles into the game when it didn't really need to be there