Skip to main content
Loading video...

San Fransisco - Reiner Knizia's twist to tile draft - A Board Game Review

Transcript 15:45

foreign city building San Francisco I love San Francisco by the way how many times have I say sentences go 14. so this game is by Rebel Studios the fox who brought out Meadows and this place two to four place and as usual we're gonna do overview before we share our thoughts yes so this is a game by Ryan indeed very important it has the it has the simplistic that a lot of his games do you've got two options on your turn uh the first is simply to draw a card from the deck and put it in one of these three columns um that's all it is you just put draw a card put it in a column you can choose to put in a column where there's already a card or you can create your own column if you get one of these cards it's the foundation for a skyscraper and that's one of the potential endgame triggers is counting those down this is set up for four player games by the way okay yep the other thing you can do on your turn is take all the cards from one of the columns and then build any or all of them into your city you have to build each color from left to right like so so I wouldn't be able to put

this out over here you've got to go from left to right the black ones can go in any color and then you're really trying to build up a network that scores points so what are the ways of scoring points um one of the major ones is having a majority of worker icons in each of the five columns so these little worker icons these are the ones that you'll build up and at the end of the game these Columns of points here will score for whoever's got the most second most and least in a given row so two points one point negative one points you can try to completely fill up a row and when you completely fill up a row if you're the first to do so you get the hexagon point for that row you can build up your cable car Network so many of these cards will have these Cable Car icons on them and as long as they connect back to the depot or a different Depot that you put on the board then you get to put this token on it and whoever has the most of these tokens second most and fewest will get these points here and you can build skyscrapers so when you get one of these foundations down your aim is to have seven workers orthogonally adjacent to that card and that's actually relatively difficult to do um these cards may have sort of one or two or three on them there are some of these cards that will have four if you

can get a cable car adjacent to it so if I wanted to score this I would need to make a whole Cable Car Network that came up here or maybe find a Depot card to put it out there um I'll need it I'll need a Depot to make that work but yeah there's a difference so if I did this this would automatically get one this would get one so now I've got four there and there are also these ones here that reduce your skyscraper requirement from seven to six so if I've got all of this out here now I've got what I need I can build my skyscraper it's very cute three-dimensional I know and they're each worth one point and there's also the master builder token whoever builds the first one gets it and then if you've got sort of Catan longest road style whoever then has the most from that point forward will get well it's not to connect yet it's just the most yep okay the other thing you've got going on is these bonus icons so if you get two bonus icons in the same row then you get the bonus from the right hand side of that like green one and that can be helpful cards it can be just one and a half points um yeah that's that's really the game the smart thing is the stock so the stock is the really special one that stops you from

you keep getting towels or just it's just like another level of strategy yes so these these ones here the contracts um the contracts here that's contracts yep so as I mentioned at the start your options are to put a card out or to take a column and you're sitting at home going but if the first player always puts the card out then I'll just always take it and it's completely broken and that's where these contracts come into play it's actually not all that intuitive but it manages the draft I think it's not intuitive because of something new but it's it's there to it's really really there for a really good reason yeah it takes a little bit of time to get your head around but basically if I take a card or if I take a column I get a contract um from that point forward I'm not allowed to take a column that has fewer cards in it than I have contracts so if we're playing two players and it's like this you've got free reign to take this card after putting it up I can't take it that one as well yep I'm not allowed to take unless I unless I create a column of 2 and you leave it there for me to take and even if I did take these um and put them in like so then I would get another contract and now I've got to wait until there's three cards there to take it it's harder and harder for you to take it gives you much more free Reign Over the next card you take and then once you get a

contract essentially once everyone has at least one contract everyone discards a contract and that way the number of contracts stays low when it manages that draft so it takes a little bit to get your head around but it's necessary and it actually makes the draft work relatively well it kind of gives you a push push your luck element where if you see something you want the risk of taking it is the opponent getting a whole lot more choice you don't know what that choice is going to be correct because like a push your like drafting yep the game will end either when all of these tiles have been placed on cards or when someone has completely filled their grid and the points are essentially just these big red numbers um Plus what's on your skyscrapers so it's a very low points game you're going to win with like 10 points it's not a big Point salad like a lot of the games on the market is scrabbling for every little point and there we have it that's the game yes what do you think Karen I I do like the points of difference I I'm always instinctively drawn into games where you don't have that big point seller where all the points are hard to get and so this was interesting from that standpoint I like the challenge of having to you're trying to build up a and we spoke about this in um in our review for

rainforest which is another game which has a similar sort of thing going you're trying to make like networks of cable cars and trying to get things adjacent to each other but you're forced to build each of these from left to right and it forces you to plan ahead and think through what you're doing there there's still a major problem you can still throw out the cart so if you are it's very important if you take this one you don't have to take all of them you can just throw out this one for example and then skip this one yep sorry continue so I like that it is for all of what's out here it is a deceptively simple game um but not a very intuitive game it definitely takes a game to get through it if there's one complaint that I I know what you're going to say I think the biggest complaint that I had was the first the game ends based on essentially these Foundation cards coming out of the deck the first time we played it was over in like a third of the deck we barely we had barely achieved anything this this type of cards so when this tile runs out so every time this card is out you put one without the game ends immediately yeah so it can end very abruptly and very quickly um which again is a point of difference I guess I'm so used to uh end game deal yeah I'm so used to end

game conditions being very optimized or being very optimized isn't the word being um fairly predictable predictable and narrow and this is this can be complete flu that it can end very early when no one's got more than a couple of and in their case you're not going to build any skyscrapers in that time so you know that is that is a downside but yeah I like overall I like um what makes this stand out is a bit different totally I also enjoy it but then yeah that that first game it was like what it's over and then it was like um it's out in um it's just the luck of the track draw of the deck as well I mean we thought then should we second down house rule it so we just you know put it in the last whatever cards but then I don't know if that still works because you might still need that and certainly when the game is going to end so you're trying to you know go for your goal for the every single turn for your the longest cable card or yeah trying to make this skyscraper objective that sort of thing yeah at the same time with a four player game it'll be a bit more predictable because you know all 10 of the cards are in here you'll get through most of the deck and if you get through half of the deck at two places you're kind of having the same amount of those indeed and it is um it is here so the first time I was

like oh Brandon it's yeah of course I'm gonna give it a go and it's just takes a little bit off what's yours you take it about the the contract so what you take it but then when the opponents are about to take it you lose one so that's less intuitive but it's definitely something different when I say less intuitive because maybe it hasn't been done before maybe we're not used to it but it's definitely necessary to be in the game I think that's a smart way of trying to stop the opponent of getting away with getting the cards like you say like okay I'll open it and the other person takes it that's that will stop it and then it's like oh I want to keep taking it but then oh I have to wait a little bit more until I actually can take the pal yeah I mean there were times when I had had did I ever have three contracts I probably think it was a title I made up to three contracts and it was basically I knew I had to sit and wait and but you've still got some interesting little decisions of drawing these cards and putting them where it like entices the opponent to to take it and bring you back into the game so yeah it was interesting yeah do you like it yeah overall I like it see except that for that fluke that you could essentially get when the game ends abruptly immediately the biggest the biggest thing to remember when playing it is that a lot of the points come just from the the

boring majorities so to speak just having the most workers in each row because it's it's fun to like try to make your skyscrapers and get sevens in the right places and make Cable Car networks and all of that stuff but there's a really big chunk of the points that just come from most workers most workers and you've got to remember that yep simple enough games simple enough to teach uh simple enough to get into the table except you know just putting the stuff there but you know it's not that much it has some difficult decisions and card management interesting card management and card drafting that is slightly different it's a bit of a Twist there uh I know this game is might not be for everyone it might be that not intuitiveness I think it's pretty Niche overall yeah yeah I think so I don't think it'll end up being a classic um but I think it'll have a it'll have an audience yeah so that's what we think um if you if you think that is something that you like you don't mind about the the stock sorry the conflict part of it then give it a go it's you might find it refreshing interesting maybe it's something that you either like or not like I don't know if there's any other games quite like it let us know in the comments anything else down no that is San Francisco one thing that I have to mention is that this this beautiful like it's not really is not really that colorful but it is

that type of artwork and I do like oh Painted Ladies I've been to San Francisco I stopped over there on my way to Gen Con and on my way back I love the city I don't like the hilly bits because and then the going down a bit I saw Lombard in here somewhere as well oh really so they do have a few it's got painted lights Painted Ladies so it's a like some San Francisco Maxis is the what they call it Central Park or something um Central Park New York there's one oh is that look like sorry yes yeah there you go so that's really amazing and that that's that bit is really nice the the park I actually um hired a bicycle and then just goes around the park it's still beautiful so yeah the artwork and the and then that's the maybe Fisherman's beer which is very touristy but it's fun it's not bad ones Maybe I'm showing one of these maybe this one all the landmark all the landmarks welcome to Maple University's travel hour thank you that's it okay I'll stop now yeah let us know in the comments what you think of this game I personally think I know this is like completely different game Meadows from their previous rebel games treble game Studio are probably like this one a little bit better than Meadows um I I think you would say the same thing I would say that I was not uh I was not terribly glowing on Meadows not a game for me all right that's fair

enough so let us know what you think and if you think somehow this video has been useful you want us to do more of these please hit the like button it will be really felt really helpful subscribe to us and hit the bell and uh that will give you a notification when we have new videos we do reviews like this how to play my shot and Suite and lifeblade cruise on the weekend I'm also on Instagram find me there as well and hopefully we'll see you next time thanks for watching bye

Progress saved