Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Board Games of the Year

Transcript 25:31

it was a good year for board games in fact it's the first time since 2019 where I found enough good games to make a top 10. I played 83 games released in 2022 and these are my top 10 board games of the year if you want to buy any of them there are links below trekking through history is this year's best new Gateway game and such a great introduction that I'm actually angry at the newbies who get this as their first board game back in my day you just get a gray box full of sand and the shopkeeper would punch you in the face and you'd thank him for his service I mean look at this box colors like this just didn't exist 10 years ago it's got an interesting theme you're time traveling through history as an obnoxious time tourist turning up to sculpt with Michelangelo or write a play with William Shakespeare I'd tell him to change it to all the worlds a game and all the men and women merely players makes more sense and it's dead simple every turn you choose a card from the board representing a cool moment in history and add it to your track it's a family-friendly take on the past you can ride with Genghis Khan but you don't get to see him at the coal face you're trying to create the perfect timeline by taking cards in chronological order because you get huge points for a track of 10 or more cards as soon as you travel back in time your track is finished and you have to start again but you also need to take certain cards to collect the resources to complete your

personal itinerary so every card you take is a compromise for one or the other plus witnessing history takes time and each card moves you around the clock this is one of the neat modern touches of the game because you don't take turns in order the next player is the person furthest back on the clock it's a mechanism you might know from Patchwork and it gives you the chance to make clever moves like taking two turns in a row to get the cards you really want it's a little more insular than I'd like it's a personal puzzle but a remarkably satisfying one and it still manages to get you talking by having a theme that everyone can enjoy as you read more about the history on the backs of the cards I would call sea salt and paper a dark horse and the reason I say that is because I don't want to say that a game about the sea has hidden depths on the surface at first glance there's not much going on you draw a card every turn and you're trying to get matching Pairs and collect sets of shells and Penguins to get points but within each simple move is an interesting decision when you take a card you can choose from Two Face up cards or you can take two cards from the top of the deck and pick one everyone loves a mystery box a boat's a boat but a mystery box could be anything it could even be a boat but by taking two the one you don't pick will now be a new exciting option for your opponent with the basic cards if you collect a pair of symbols you can play them to score one

point and you also get to take its action which gets you more cards and that usually means more points each round is a race to seven points but only if that's when you want to get off the ride if you have seven points amongst the cards in your hand and in front of you you can stop the round immediately and take those points or you can carry on to try and get more because whatever you score will add to your total to win the game or you can gamble on a last chance you give the other players one more turn betting that you'll have more points than them and if you're right you score an extra bonus it's the ultimate brag you're not just saying I'm better than you you're saying you can have another turn and you still won't catch me of course if they do then you look really stupid it's such a cool original mechanism you can't see all the cards your opponent is taking so you don't know if you're ahead of them I always love a final reveal in a game and this is even better because it has an epilogue where The Underdogs get one last shot at taking down Goliath luck plays a part but I love that you can react to that if you think you're not going to win around then focus on collecting one color so you get a good color bonus you've lost the battle but you can at least take home some grenades to help you win the war and if another player is dragging around out don't try to catch up just cut the chord as soon as possible so so that big finish isn't quite so big it reminds me of Reina kanitzi's llama in that some people would dismiss it after one play as being

too lucky but if you give it a chance there's treasure to be found just like in the sea fifty percent of board gamers love trick taking card games because they used to play them for hours with their favorite Grandma bathing in familial love well I didn't have any of that so I see trick taking games for what they really are with an objective bitterness that you won't get with other review channels every year 50 new trick taking games are released each advertising a Twist to the format with the confidence of someone writing a recipe for mashed potato because they've added black pepper but occasionally there's a Twist so good that the game reaches the other half of us who didn't play them with our grandma and just had to sit there and listen to her talk about the war the last time that happened was the crew and this year it happened again with cat in the Box the mustard in the mash of cat in the box is that you decide the color of your card when you play it if you want your four to be blue you say it's blue then put a token on the board to show that because like any trick taking game there is only one blue four in the deck no one else can play it later the board makes it really easy to follow because you can see what cards are left you know if someone can beat you by playing a higher card in normal trick taking games you'd have to count cards to know that which I hate because I can never remember anything when my mind's so busy thinking of ways to solve world hunger and be a

better friend once you've seen your hand you bet on how many tricks you think you can win I love this mechanism because winning or losing one trick is nothing it's one point I don't care but trying to pull off a perfect round by winning exactly three tricks makes you care about every trick do you push to win them early and once you have them it's just as hard trying to lose tricks and when every player around the table has conflicting bets your epic Victory is someone else's heartbreak it's funny but on yourself it's like making a New Year's resolution to eat healthier and then hearing your own voice order a burger afterwards feeling like it was achievable but only if you'd been someone else entirely if you win your bet your prize depends on what's happening on the board because you score for your largest group of tokens so the whole game you're being tempted into playing bad cards just so you can grow a jackpot that you're unlikely to win because you're playing bad cards you're so busy weaving the basket You're Gonna Keep your eggs in that you forget to feed your chickens to make your back come true the gang gives you plenty of rope to trip yourself out with if you don't want to follow suit you can say I don't have any more greens but later if the only space left is green and you said you didn't have any you've created a paradox because you can't play a card it ends the round and you get minus points for every trick you want it's such a great punishment because you spend the game terrified of having enough room left for your cards or

hoping someone else causes a paradox before you do I find most trick taking games to be too subtle so I love the way that cat in the Box hits you over their head just like old grandma did in horse racing games it's hard to give players a feeling of control over what is in real life of passive experience but too much control and you lose the suspense and excitement that you get from not knowing what's gonna happen long shot the dice game gives you the twists of a horse race by having you roll the dice every turn one of them says which horse moves forward the other by how many spaces you can't predict what will be rolled it's pure luck but that doesn't make sense either because in horse racing some of the horses are faster than others the favorites with better odds should have an advantage and they do when a horse moves it pulls other horses with them shown on their card and the favorites get pulled more often luck can still Grant the underdog a surprise Victory but it's more likely that the favorites will finish first just like in real life if you bet on a long shot you'll get way more money if they win so you have to decide between playing it safe on a favorite or betting on an upset the player who ends up with the most money wins the game every turn you you take an action related to the horse that just moved so you could place a bet on it buy it to get its special ability or cross off its number on your concession stand and this is a little bingo card that you're trying to fill up to get special powers and these are the big moves of the game such as taking

more money for betting on horses with or you can influence the race Itself by moving horses forward or even backward there's a lot more thought in this game than you'd expect but it still captures the essence of gambling every role you're begging the gods to shine on your horse for light family fun I'd still opt for Camelot but for something more involved with less luck and more strategy I'll be keeping long shot I do have one complaint which is there are way too many ways to pull the horses back which makes the race feel like it's never going to end and it's worse the more players you play with you can alleviate it by Crossing out one of those bonuses before you play but I'm baffled how it made it through play testing as it is and don't be fooled by the one to eight player listing this is a three to six six player game but that's more than enough for me Carcassonne is one of the original pillars of modern board games in which you build a map of medieval France and compete to control cities and farms and now after 22 years they've made a Cooperative version of it in Mists over carcasson your favorite French town is overcome by fog which is the amount of Jeopardy we can handle right now we're not going to stop wanting to play this game because of an unprecedented Global fog the fog brings with it ghosts and if the town becomes so overrun with ghosts that you run out of them you lose the game meanwhile to win the game you've got to collaboratively build a great town and score loads of points for it before the ghosts get you it's the classic Cooperative game dilemma short-term firefighting to stop yourself

from dying versus the long-term need to get your coursework done because what's the point in even being alive if you don't finish your degree in media studies and that conflict is person in every tile you take do you add it to your perfect City to score you the most points or do you use it to trample the threat if you ignore either one for too long you'll lose the game the fog works like its own type of region and if you're able to close it off like finishing a city you can get rid of all the ghosts but it's really hard to do another way to get rid of them is when you score a road or a city instead of taking the points you'd get you can remove three ghosts but that goes against everything us Gamers stand for it's like asking a kid if they want another Christmas present or to sponsor a donkey instead I want my points carcass on it still feels like Carcassonne deciding where to place your tile is still a challenge but now you get to share it and help each other spot good openings and because the threat of the fog is built into the tiles you're placing there's no admin to slow you down between turns like most other co-op games it's great and it makes me feel stupid for thing thinking it wouldn't be it's like they've put a hat on Beyonce and the Hat's nice but it wasn't ever gonna look bad was it is the best two-player game of the year it's hard to look at this board made in Microsoft PowerPoint 98 with a CD-ROM of clipart and imagine it's one of the best

games of the year but I'm asking you to try you play as Caesar and Pompey carving up ancient Rome by sending your Legions to occupy regions for political reasons it starts as a polite Buffet of Europe I'll have a bit of Sicily they'll have a bit of Sardinia I'll have some Crete they'll have some more Sardinia and then you freak out that you're not going to get any Sardinia you want to focus on the places you're trying to win but if you don't fight back you're letting them get theirs for no effort like winning an auction for one pound because no one else is bidding and yet by retaliating you're escalating the problem with another whack to the pinata so it explodes quicker because once the border is filled up the player with the most strength wins the region each token is double-sided and you place them on the borders between two regions so every decision is two-handed by going hard in one you have to phone it in next door it's a neat example of how you can't be everything everywhere all at once which may or may not be the message of a film I haven't watched you both have equal claim to the board the same bag of tokens what separates the winner from the loser is their approach and how you use these bonus tokens which can increase your hand size giving you more options for attack or kill an opponent's token helping you to win an important region you get them by finishing a region so you're not just keeping an eye on attack and defense but grabbing the right bonuses because taking at the right time they can win you the game I

also really like Blitzkrieg which came from the same designer a few years ago they both managed to do so much with so little Blitzkrieg is more Cutthroat you can bomb your opponent out of the game whereas Caesar is classier quicker and a bit smarter the game that is not the guy couldn't even spot a knife coming how do I talk about foundations of Rome it is really inconvenient for someone who is vocal about not buying expensive overproduced Kickstarter games to find himself enjoying an expensive overproduced Kickstarter game it's like when one of those obnoxious I have a great marriage type guys turns out to be cheating on his wife here's my I'm not actually a bad guy justification video in foundations of Rome you are building the city of Rome on a shared board and that in itself is a breath of fresh air every city building game of recent memory quadropolis my city Tiny Town Santa Monica Acropolis involve building your own City in your own personal area which is fine but that's not how cities work I want people to get in my way it's about connection that human touch that you get from shoulder barging a Taurus to the ground for walking too slowly the other huge surprise of this game is how streamlined it is never has a box this big contained a game so svelt the product is a parody of modern board

games with extravagant Miniatures plastic trays and metal coins but somehow the gameplay harks back to the early 2000s to Carcassonne and Ticket to Ride in its interactivity its punchiness and its Purity every turn you have three options you can buy new plots of land from the market you can build on plots you already own and you can collect income so you've got more money to spend simple options but it's always a tough decision if a plot next to one you already own is for sale you want to buy it so you can build a bigger better building but how badly do you need it because when cards appear in the market they cost 10 coins whereas if you wait for other cards to sell the price will come down it's a nail-biting dilemma no one wants to pay full price but the fear of someone else buying it is huge the worst feeling is when a card comes up that you really need and you can't afford to buy it so you have to get income first and hope it will be there on your next turn but why are you taking income when you haven't put any commercial buildings down yet to increase your income so really you should put a building down then take income then buy the plot you want if you're being efficient the best time to do everything is last turn you feel behind at all times that's what building a city on a shared board does to you you're desperate to grab land before those other bastards can get their hands on it it's not just about taking big areas it's about profiting from other people's buildings these Civic buildings score points based on what they're

adjacent to for example this one will score points from any residential buildings next to it so much of the game is watching how the city evolves and spotting opportunities you're the devious kid at school befriending the study group that will get you the best grades it's the perfect level of interaction for a game you care about what everyone else is doing that every turn is interesting but you can't destroy their hard work as a design it's one of the most refreshing games I've played in years it's in the same caliber as Ticket to Ride so it's heartbreaking that they've made it this exclusive product that's four times the size of Ticket to Ride and four times the price again this good should be played by everyone and what's more frustrating is this game could be made from nothing but cardboard and still be great and if you buy it you're encouraging this business model so more Publishers will do it I'm encouraging it by giving this game oxygen on the channel I don't know what the answer is I just want to highlight the best games of the year and this is one of them I've never owned a racing game that's not strictly true I've owned many racing games up until the point that I played them and realized I didn't want to own them anymore they're either so random and lucky that I didn't feel like I had any agency or they're so complicated and slow that it felt like racing snails so heat pedal to the metal is not only the first racing game I've ever recommended on this channel it's the only racing game I would even play

you each have a car and you're driving it around a track trying to cross the finish line first it's a race I don't know why you're making me explain this to you you know what a race is the way you move is by playing cards and you can play as many cards as the gear you're in if you're in first gear you're moving slowly you can only play one card if you're in fourth you'll go much faster which you don't want when you're going round corners otherwise you'll take heat is the core of this game it's the heart that those other Tin Man racing games were missing whenever you do something Reckless you add heat to your deck so if you change gears too fast you take heat if you drive through a corner too fast you take heat you're pushing your engine to its limits and it will come back to haunt you because when they turn up in your hand they clog it up with useless cards so you could be on the home straight and not have enough good cards to make the most of it when the race starts you feel in control because your deck is Trusty and predictable but the more you push it the more it will let you down it's like well it's like a car isn't that cute when the feel of a game is best described by its own analogy that's when you know it's good that sounded like a joke I'm being serious take me seriously I have gray hair but taking heat like a hangover in your 20s is not so punishing that you don't want to keep doing it you need to take it to win the game it's all about how much and when and riding that balance is so much fun looking at each tequila shot and

deciding if it's worth the long-term repercussions to get a little little boost right now and you'll take it because of peer pressure you don't want to ever get left behind from the pack because then you won't be able to slip stream if you end up behind another car you can move two spaces for free so you're constantly trying to weasel into position to piggyback by predicting where the drivers in front of you will end up you all start the game with the same deck of cards so you need those tiny advantages like slip streaming to win you will stay neck and neck the whole race but it's the player who conserves the right cards who only takes heat when it's worth it that will pull ahead in the final lap speaking of taking heat when it's not worth it I no longer think that June Imperium is overrated okay just leave me alone for me the best board games are the ones that make you feel like you're in their world and they don't do that through intricate Miniatures or artwork and certainly not through flavor text those things can sign you to the sidelines the feeling has to come from the gameplay from the pressures that you face and the decisions that you make as the protagonist of your story hidden movement games are brilliant at that because you run around a map trying to out think the people hunting you always feeling moments away from being caught it's kiss Chase for those of us who had to retire due to an exclusivity deal but nothing takes you out of a feeling quite

like having to check the rulebook to answer another question Sniper Elite manages to place you in its World make you feel like you're a sniper stalking an army base with a lean rule set which is why it's my new favorite hidden movement game as the sniper you must decide what approach to take if you run at speed then you'll make noise alerting nearby enemies but if you're too slow and stealthy you might not reach your objective in time and lose you can shoot enemies to get them out of your way but you have to weigh up whether it's worth it because you'll be giving the other team Clues on where you are all things that you'd have to consider if you were in that situation yourself of course I would have died getting caught up in my parachute way before this bit and it's no less authentic for the hunters albeit a completely different experience they feel in the dark for much of the game trying to systematically sweep the map and use scraps of information to catch the sniper it's a less iconic role you're the henchman in a James Bond film sent to soak up some bullets but in this film the bad guys can win I love discussing theories with my teammates about where the sniper is it's a mixture of Hard Evidence and trying to get in their head would they really try to creep right through us and risk getting caught or did they take the long way round and like any good film it doesn't outstay its welcome like most other hidden movement games to learn more about what makes it special watch my full review link below

it's rare to find a good game these days that is cut throat and vicious it's not something that gets designed anymore which is why my favorite game was designed in 2012 and resurrected in 2022. in libertalia Winds of galecrest you play as pirates fighting over Loot and trying to win the most gold every day the pirate Fleet divides up their Bounty so you send a crew member from your ship to make your claim you all pick a character at the same time then reveal and they're placed in order of rank the highest will get first dibs taking a chest that's worth five gold the lowest ranked character could be left with a cursed Relic that will lose the money but first your characters take actions such as the brute that will kill the highest ranked character before they can even take their loot which is great when that's not you eat the rich I say until I'm the one that's rich and then I say oh the nurse is a greedy aren't they it might seem mean and chaotic and it is but it's not without warning you see every every player has an identical hand of character cards you know the other players all have a brute that could kill you and that fact is into your decision every time you pick a card you can also see what loot is available and you know where you are on the tiebreaker track all that's left is to guess what your friends will do but if I could do that I would have picked friends who like playing board games and not going to work every day in true pirate fashion there are cutlasses

flying everywhere and the challenge is in dancing through the brawl unscathed picking a few Pockets along the way you will feel the pointy end of a saber occasionally that's the life you signed up for and when death is expected getting beat into a bloody pulp feels like a victory part of the magic of libertalia is that I miss that chaos you can still carve out a strategy there's a real joy to be had from planning when to play your characters so they complement each other when you build an engine that gets you three gold at every turn it feels like a remarkable achievement like you've just set up a successful business during the blitz I've got way more to say about this brilliant game but rather than repeat myself please go and watch my full review of it from last year it linked below those are my top 10 board games of 2022 to find out my next 10 favorites of last year become a patron of the channel on patreon to get my newsletter and to see more videos like this please subscribe I'm John Perkins thanks for watching

Progress saved