Nations - Boardgame Review - Still Worth It?
Transcript
hello welcome back to the ball games at 4k YouTube channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs unboxings and we generally talk a lot of bollocks about tabletop gaming in general and in this video we're gonna be talking about a civilization building game we're going to be talking about nations and this is a game where you will be gathering resources are enough Isis building buildings trying to build wonders that will give you victory points that will allow you to win the game and in this video we will be giving you a very brief overview of the rules it would be telling you what we do like what we don't like and then we'll come back and what's here whether or not Nations is still worth pain 6 or so years after it was first released so remember if you new here then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment down below give us a thumbs up and we'll see you after this
board games for K so nations to play this game so Nations is a game that spans over three phases you've got the maintenance phase you've got the actions face and then you've got the resolution interface so the maintenance phase is exactly that you're gonna be a bit bored maintenance you're gonna be moving the round marker forward you'll be refreshing some progress cards on the portably taking the bottom two rows out again and then you'll be sliding down all of the progress cards onto the board onto the thing so you'll notice that they will get cheaper as they get older the bottom row will cost you one gold - Gold and then free go so once you've done that depending on how many players play the game you'll get a certain number of resources or a worker so if you've got a plan before / Sprint's this you'll get three of any one resource or you can take a worker from your board and put it in your personal supply so then you will reveal the new event that will be triggered at the end of the round and then you'll refill the architects on the relevant space on the board and that is the - phase done and dusted so then you will move on to the actions face and there's really essentially only free actions that you can take in this game you could deploy a work on to a building or a military space on the building so generally below the military spaces are generally red and then you will increase your books or production so that will allow you to adjust either your military strength or your resource production accordingly you'll notice that the icons for the numbers of guys of a square or circle the square means immediately the circle means that you will get that in the resolution face nice and easy so the next action you can take is you could
buy a progress card this quite simple you look at the cost and then you'll take it and you'll put it on a relevant spice so you've got a spaces for different regions that you can annex you've got spaces for advisors you've got a spaces for buildings if you want to upgrade a building if it's but already print another border just place it your new card on top of it all the workers come off and we'll go back into a personal supply you'll have to pay them to go back onto the card line so the first thing you could do is you can hire an architect and what you'll do is just take an architect from the board and then you'll place it on your one day and you'll see that there is always a cost to deploy in the cart there's always a cost to deploy to work on the cart and then with specific two wonders you'll have to have a certain amount of architects placed on that cart before you can actually complete the wandering get the benefit from the wonder right there's also special actions in the game these vary from civilization civilization car to car you can also under ploy a worker for free at any time too once we've completely actions and everybody's past then you will go on to the resolution face and what you'll do you'll count up all the resources you got you got different substances you got the food you've got books you've got gold you've got all and then you add them all up and then you'll take the relevant stuff there is owed to you so then you adjust the turn order up it depending on who's got the highest military strength if there's a tie then it will go down to the most volatile ice books that so the person's got and then if a wall card was placed in the boat's pocket and you'll resolve the wall card and on the wall card you'll see that there is a threshold that you need to me and anybody below the threshold including the player who played the wall card will suffer the penalty and that's always bad so then you'll resolve the
event and that's exactly what you're gonna do you're gonna look at the event card and you obviously your hat you would have had this round to prepare for that VIN and your resolve in the top bit and the bomb bet you'll ever get benefit or reward or whatever happens on the cardfight and then you will pay a certain amount of food depending on what the famine section of the event cartagia and that's all you got to do it's pay food into the main supply right and then you do a bit of end age scoring so you look at the amount books everyone's got the player with the highest amount books will guess so our points based on how many people panic games so if you're playing a four player game and you've got the most books you'll get three points and then the next person will get to in the next bus get one and then the last person okay so you'll keep doing this until you get to the end of the eighth round when you've gone through the industrial stage of the game and then you'll do a little bit of final score and we're just very very basic and the player with the most victory points will be the winner of Nations and that's basically very very basically you pay nations so what do we like about nations so the first thing that we really like about Nations is the way it condenses the spool in other sort of civilization building games down into a semi manageable Gameboy and we're thinking specifically of Fruity ages this takes these all best Bitzer and chops out all the order fluff and condenses it down into a say maybe a three to four hour game alone oh that's still bloody long going but it's better than the six to eight hours of through the ages if you want to play a full game in air so we really like fact that gives you that
sort of same sort of taste in half the time even though that might be a little bit too long anyway so the next thing that we really like about Nations is the good range of car tops there are so you've got the regions that you can take over yet the ones that you can annex and you've got the military personnel that gradually get better throughout the game and you've got a building's you've got the wonderful wonderful wonders that you can build that give you these game-breaking special beliefs and also you've got those advisors that could give you all that advice and obviously there's only one spot for a lot of these cars so you could put you've only got one spot vide advisor and you've only got two colony spots if you want to swap out more powerful ones as they come you've got dump the one you've already got there's so many different abilities so many different options with the cards it is a truly wonderful thing so the next thing that we like about nations is the way that this game spans a vast number of epochs and this abyss is it's the same sort of thing with through the ages but this does it better in a sense because where it's a short game you're not waiting forever for the more powerful cars to come out in the Industrial Age you know that when you start the game in the antiquity era that you know that there's gonna be some excellent more powerful cards coming and it's just a matter of what biding your time waiting for them to come out the way that this game spans a huge amount of time in history but condenses it down in real time to a color of hours is wonderful so what don't we like about nations so the first thing that we don't like about Nations is it seems to be a lot of the time that you're wading through war and thus seen if you concentrate on one
thing you're not gonna be doing a lot else with all the other things so say if you concentrate on military that it's gonna nuclear in other areas if you're concentrating on getting books then your military isn't gonna be very strong or you're not gonna be able to afford to buy any cards or you're not going to be out of feature dudes it need famine so it does seem to me that you're always fighting too much perhaps against different factors in the game and that can be very frustrating so the second thing that we don't like about our nation's it's the way that as you're progressing through all these different ages you've got different things from different nations cropping up on your board so let's say your father's like the Egyptians for instance on my type like sons ooh or I might have Marie Curie in my civilization and like barbecue is nothing to dish with Egypt's is it so it does seem a bit weird you can hire the advice of people that have no connection or correlation to the civilization that you are taking and that's a little bit weird innit so the next finger that we don't like about Nations is that wars seem to be a little bit unbalanced and they can be devastating so if you're one of these PI's it focuses on military words on military military leads you could buy a war card slap it down and boom everybody is stuffed because it's very very difficult to catch up whereas if you if you like we said earlier what are the things we don't like about it it's the your pawn in all your effort to get resources or for the cards that you have you've taken from the progress cards and someone starts down a walk code and you
haven't gotten a military I know because you've been doing something else your stuff so it does seem to me that military is probably one of the most important things but then there you won't be able to do nothing else so it does skew the game towards military maybe that little bit too much and that's again very frustrating so the final thing that we don't like about nations is the end game scoring does seem like a bit of a wet fart yeah because you sort of already know there's one game before you even get here you know and the the scoring isn't isn't like Carcassonne with you sort of sitting there going oh my farmers gonna deliver the goods from here naked pull that order stops I'm not gonna win this you'll sit sitting there thinking don't think so I mean there might be a chance I'm gonna win it by Fink like you know my mom's gonna win it like she did the other day so the end game scoring can seem a little bit flat a little bit of a loss the word non-event you know so just be aware of that when you play Nations so to summarize these nations were playing today and in the future and we're gonna say the depends what sort gain you want if you look in for a civilization building game then it depends whether you don't want a really complex long game or a game that sits in the middle or a game that is very very quick so the options that you've got you've obviously got fruity ages or new fruity ages or whatever you've got this and then maybe you've got Peloponnese right so they're the games that you should consider depending on what you want so if you want this big sort of all-day affair don't fall flower disavows fruity ages if you just want a sort of an evening where you're gonna be just progressing
nicely food game license is the one and if you just want a quick simple hour of Civ building then Peloponnese is the one that you want to do and it's a good game don't get me wrong it's a good game but it's very limited is frustrating in the sense that you never really feel that you'll progress in as fast as you need to and it's almost as if the the game itself as it moves through the ages you can't keep up with with time and moving so you doesn't feel like you're progressing and maybe that's that's how civilizations were built in the first place that they've moved solely through time but when you play a game you want it to be more fun than that you know and it does tend to get burnt out in age four in the Industrial Age because by that time you're weary your brain start a fry and maybe is that sort of that one ERA too long so it's a good rival to freely ages but the only way I think we can give this 3/5 we enjoy the game but it's not one that we pull out on a regular basis so there you go that's nations so remember if you are there then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment down below and if you made it this far give us a thumbs up and we'll see you next time