Skip to main content
Loading video...

Insider Secrets of Board Game Design: Tips from a Published Designer

Transcript 7:01

hi I'm Evan Porter this is my board gaming vlog and today its third video in three days so I've already talked about prototypes and I've talked about protecting your ideas in my previous two videos but the I wanted to just answer the the smaller questions that fan Rick one of my viewers asked recently so one question was about does a prototype need to be in English or could it be in another language and the second question was about whether you should whether it's it's sensible to work on one large game or whether you could you'd be better off working on smaller games and building up as a new designer so let's start with that second question first I think the answer is very much it's better to work on smaller stuff and build up a lot of new designers when they come to our play test group I run a play test group with my colleague Rob Fisher and we meet weekly and we have done for several years now and frequently when new designers turn up they turn up with these massive epic games with so many components and so much often they've spent a lot of money on it a lot of money on the components a lot of money on the art and they've really not tested the game beyond they're very close circle of friends they may have played a handful of times and you know a heart always sinks because we know we're gonna have to have that conversation with them where you say look you've kind of wasted your

money because all of this stuff is going to change if a publisher takes this they're going to change all of the Arts you know all that time you spent on the art and the components and actually you're not even sure if the game works if it even functions if it's fun and then they try and explain the game and it's so long and convoluted and difficult and there's so much you have to pick apart and it would be so time-consuming to change it it's really disappointing and difficult so a really good piece of advice there is if you do have a massive massive game then I think it's always useful to put our game to one side and it doesn't go anywhere you've still got it but start thinking about what would a junior if that game be what would the kids version of that game be you know like you've got monopoly you've got junior monopoly you've got Cluedo junior Cluedo on my shelves I've got a gray color I've got a gray color family edition okay there's concept concept kids you've got SCI and then my little side okay so what would your board game be if it was my little version of your board game what would it be if it was made for children and what you find out by doing that is what's important in your game and what are the barriers to entry to your game what are the things that are making it complicated what really matters in your game and actually the games are far more complex your game is probably ten times more complex than you think it is because in your head you've got everything worked out and it seems simple it very rarely seems that simple

to somebody else the key to game design is often stripping it everything out and getting it to really what's what's the the core important stuff that's in there and that's usually something that's relatively small and it'll still you know what your junior version may well end up being medium heavyweight in terms of its actual complexity even if it doesn't feel that way to you so yeah I would say work on smaller stuff and then build up to that sort of magnum opus although that said I am a designer of fairly light games you know the games I have behind me here which I've published all of my published games have been really quite like they're games that take 10 20 30 minutes to play easy to pick up the rules you know that that is kind of the area that I particularly enjoy playing and I enjoy designing although in my previous video to this where I was talking about Pro slaps I did show you a much larger more euro style game that takes an hour or two to play that I've been designing for the last couple of years and and I hope eventually we'll find a publisher for so I'm not completely averse to that but I do think you learn a lot by focusing on those small games that rely on one or two mechanisms rather than throwing everything in at once and making numerous mistakes along the way which are very hard to fix when everything so into woven so that hopefully that answers the first question the second question about language I've only ever designed in

English I only speak English but I do try in as much as possible I try to make my games language independent now sometimes that doesn't work sometimes I have to have text in the games and and and that limits you it does it limits your the publishers there are publishers that only want to do language independent games and as soon as you show them a game with text in it they're going to be turned off from it it is helpful to have it in English because I mean I've dealt with publishers from all over the world I mean so many countries and I've never found one yet that doesn't speak English and isn't able to play the game in English but if you're presenting it in a different language to English then I think you're gonna limit the number of publishers that can play it I actually think a really good design challenge is to take an existing game a game that you really like but one that relies on a lot of text and then think to yourself well what would this be like if it had no text how could what would this game be if all of that text was replaced with images and you may find that you've actually designed a totally different game by going through that exercise I like exercises like that where you take an existing game that you love and then you completely turn it on its head and you see what you come up with so for example I like trick-taking games so my game pick Koko came out of thinking

about what would happen if I had a trick-taking game but you can't see your own cards and you end up creating something unlike any other trick-taking game I did the similar thing with my game thrown what would happen if you take a trick-taking game but instead of cards you use dice and you end up with something totally different but language independence is one way of doing that looking at what would happen if my game was entirely based on pictures and images rather than words and you may find that you create something that you can show to any publisher and is very different to what you were originally in you know planning and it may be something that's a bit simpler too so anyway I hope that's useful and if you enjoyed it please watch some of my other videos on YouTube I'm Adams boardgame Wales on Twitter I'm at board game Wales and on BoardGameGeek I'm Adam 78 thank you very much for watching all the best

Progress saved