CloudAge Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hi everyone today i'm going to be looking at cloud age which at the time of this video is the newest design by prolific euro designer alexander fister and arno steinwender the game takes about an hour to an hour and a half to play and accommodates one to four players um i suppose in the essence it's a an engine building game a resource management game with a very small loose deck building element um so i want to make very clear first that obviously alexander fister is known for his huge you know massive euro games with massive amounts of strategies such as you know your maracaibos your mombasas your great western trails this one um isn't quite at that level in terms of its depth and complexity and just rules overhead um however it does have some of the you know the the decent or the really amazing um alexander fister tropes that he's he's known for you know you've got your abstract combat you've got your your player boards where you can build up your engine and upgrade things um you've also got really interesting card play with lots of unique um and interesting powers and you've also got this new thing he's known for which is this uh campaign deck where as you're playing through the game the story is going to change and new elements are added in and taken out new tiles are added onto the board etc so you've got a lot of those things that um that alexander fister is really known for doing well arnold steinwender is a game a designer i know less about you know he's um i think he's
known for making some very light party style games and even children's games so i can't really say about any of his other designs but obviously interesting to see this collaboration of two very different designers so i suppose let's talk about the actual idea of the game so the the idea is that we are in this world of um or this kind of dystopian future where water is an extremely rare resource now um and all the cities have been overtaken by this kind of rogue militia called cloud um i'm not sure how you know how relevant that is but it's interesting to see a game leaning towards that euro side of things with such a different setting i mean normally you know fister games are set in very dry settings and these kind of post-apocalyptic dystopian games are generally more kind of the american style games but so interesting seeing you take um or a new theme or setting with with a game like this so um while i say it's uh the games are lighter than those big strategy games i would say it's still quite a touch heavier than some of this other games such as isle of skye um so it's probably somewhere in that middleweight category um at least in my in my perception i think some people might be arguing it's a bit lighter than that but i i would argue that it's still relatively mid-weight in terms of it that it's um it's waiting so um throughout the game it's going to be it's going to be quite um regimented in terms of how the game plays out you know going from phase to phase to phase but those phases are pretty straightforward so
basically what you're going to do is you're going to be converting energy into water if you if you want to and then you're going to be traveling around this big map made up for these hexes and different towns and cities on them where you're going to be going from town to town fighting all this different militia picking up bonuses as you go and then after that you're going to be kind of going into the city phase where you can upgrade your ship and hire new crew members in the form of cards and basically move on to the next phase so let's talk about how mechanically actually plays so the first off everybody is on this production board where you have the option of converting energy into water the water is one of your main resources in the game which lets you buy new cards which is not only going to give you extra abilities and increase your engine in doing things but those cards are also going to grant you points as well at the end of the game um after that you are going to have a well everybody's going to have a unique hand of cards which are numbered from i believe it's zero up to three or four um and you are going to draw two of those cards um the lower of the two you are going to use to take resources in the form of energy and energy is going to be useful for something i'll explain in a minute and also um or if you don't want to take energy you can take these project cards which are the ones you're going to buy with the water and after that you are going to use the higher card to travel around the board um basically from hex to hex some hexes
take a couple of movement and as you do drive-bys you can pick up bonuses such as um you know additional points or additional metal which is another resource and then you're going to have to stop in another city and those cities have different um different values on them so they might have a combat value of say you know two at the earlier states earlier side of the board and as you travel on and on throughout the game the battles are going to get progressively more difficult to to win i'm going up to about i think seven or eight or even higher than that so yeah the game has this progression where obviously as you're increasing the power of your ship you are going to have to fight stronger bad guys in order to compensate for that um and after you've done that you have you know the battle is um you are comparing your your combat that your ship already has which you start with nothing and then you obviously adding any cards and stuff that's increased your combat skill and but you can also choose to spend um spend energy in order to top deck your um your cards that you start with in order to add that value to your um to your combat value but obviously as you're doing that you're spending more and more energy which is useful for converting into water so you can't just do that willy-nilly and just keep on burning all your energy because it's quite a finite resource and um you know you don't want to be wasting it and obviously if you if you win the fight you're going to get a reward but if you don't win the fight then you're not going to suffer anything so that's what i mean when i say the the combat is very abstracted it's really just uh tried to match a certain number
um and after you've done that you're going to place one of your round marker tokens onto the board showing you can't go back to that city or you can go back you can't go and fight again in that city and um as the game develops you can be dropping more and more of these cubes off which can trigger certain um story elements so um after a certain amount of rounds you're gonna check what the current state of play is in terms of the scenario um after that you are going to go into the city phase and this is where you are going to do one of three things the first of which is buying upgrades um upgrades you're going to be cashing in metal to upgrade your ship basically and your ship it starts with you know all these or it's basically a play board and you've got these jigsaw pieces which kind of state how much you need to spend in order to upgrade something so the three things you can upgrade is um being able to move faster um being able to fight so add some guns onto your um onto your base skill basically and also the ability to spread new growth which is a way of placing tiles um onto the board um to get other points if you don't want to do that you can also just choose to choose to buy cards and those cards are very from very cheap into quite expensive and as i said they all give you different points but they can be things such as you know increasing your combat skill making you move faster giving you points for certain criteria making other cars cheaper to buy so you've got all these different kind of paths you can follow down and
build an engine that way uh based on the cards you've accumulated throughout the game and the the other option sorry something i should have said as well is that whenever you you take that build action the other place um you sort of the person who chooses it gets to build twice or to upgrade twice and the other players get to do it once so you've got that kind of piggyback um action where you can do something even when other players are doing things or when when they are choosing something to do um the other thing you can do is to collect resources and this is quite a simple but unique concept about how this works so basically you have these three sections um all relating to this um different resource card i think they're called city cards and those city cards show um four different things with the four different resources on one of those resources is going to grant you three of them uh what's got gonna grant you two and two of them are gonna grant you one of those resources and those resources are obviously water they're gonna be uh the metal they're going to be the energy and going to be drawing new cards but you think why don't i just choose the the one that grants me the most of those resources and that's because these cards are in sleeves um obscuring the view of um of the of the artwork on that city because the artwork actually shows um how how much of a certain resource is on that card you're gonna have to kind of um fill in the blanks if you want to put it that way to decide what's going to be the most um you know the most abundant resource there so
that's really quite interesting and you can you know try filling the gaps and hopefully you you pick the one that you really want um additionally some of those cards have additional bonuses on such as having a another upgrade action or being able to grant you the ability to shed a card from your discard pile so you know as i said you start the game with one of those zero cards you can just get rid of that from your deck so you never never have to worry about drawing another zero card so i really do like that and as i said much like the upgrade action when you go there you someone else can go to a spot after you um but just not take the exact same resources so again you're constantly getting resources and trying to weigh up how you're going to going to use them the third one is the third spot is to spread those new growth tiles where you lay these tiles out from where your airship is and um either get points or resources and even covering up spots on the board to stop other people from getting those bonuses by driving past them so that's going to be that's going to basically be the uh the flow of the game you're going to go through those motions again and again and again whenever there's a a point in the game where you're checking the story you're going to be you know reflecting on that but those are the key mechanisms in the game um and as you go on and on and on more elements are thrown in um but i'm not gonna go into any spoilers or go into any story or anything like that just just trying to give it just about how the game plays um the game also offers you these mission cards that you can try and fulfill and that's also another quite
interesting concept because you all these all these mission cards have two sections on them um that wants you to fulfill certain objectives to get points at the end of the game but whenever you take another mission card you're going to have to cover up one of the squares on the existing card so if you have one card you're going to be having two missions if you have two cards you're going to be scoring three missions and four cards you're gonna have to cover up another one so you're only gonna be scoring four missions so you can't really um you know manipu or exploit the uh the mission um way of getting points so i do i do like that it's another just a concept that works well um so yeah that's that's gonna be the flow of the game it's it's pretty simple once you get your head around it um i must i must admit i had a bit of a struggle learning the rules from the rule book and i'm not sure if that's because um i didn't quite know what to expect um but and some of the terminology in the game is quite weird as well um but once you get to playing the game that flows very smoothly and um it's certainly not overwhelming in terms of its rules but it still has that um real weighing up of how you're going to spend your resources because you know you need those the water to do pretty much everything um you want to be constantly increasing your production boards so that when you go up um you get the option to spend in energy to get more water and potentially more points the further you get up the track um but you need the energy to fight um so yeah there's there's lots to um there's lots to think about and um and you know how you're gonna
spend your resources most efficiently is is quite clear thread throughout the game um the the balance of the game is you know it is perfectly fine i mean there's nothing to complain about obviously you're you're constantly drawing cards at your your you know your disposal to to um you know to use and upgrade your ship and maybe some people can get lucky with the colors they're drawing but generally they're all good and you can follow different paths and it's not like they're a real scarce supply to keep drawing cards you know if you you know when you're not taking energy by spending one of those lower cards you can constantly take cards into your hands so um you know you're not so subject to the cards that you're drawing and there's always good options there um at least from my um from my perception of the game so far um mechanically yet it's quite it's quite regimented in how it works but you know breaking them down independently all those sections are very easy to explain um bit by bit so yeah mechanically pretty simple um you know gaining the resources is simply in this concept but it has that new um you know new way of obscuring the perfect information which is interesting but still you know mechanically simple and we know traveling is is very simple um fighting is very simple so you know the all these things thrown together create quite an interesting game but independently all those different aspects are extremely straightforward um time investment you know the game takes i said depending on the play account you
know 60 to 90 minutes i think the box says 60 to 100 minutes um but i think that the turns float by pretty quickly uh you know you can when you're upgrading your ship for example everybody can do it together it doesn't really matter you don't have to wait for other people's turns there's not too much scope for analysis paralysis um and yeah so it's not too much time bugging you know bogging it down and making it drag on it's pretty snappy um replayability is a real strong factor for this one because um not only have you got that um you know the story elements of things where it's constantly throwing new mechanisms in new ways to score points new the actual story itself is is interesting um and i love the way that fista is um you know almost creating this new genre of eurogames where you are compelled to go back to play them at least at least it works on me i mean the fact that it does have that story and a progression throughout and you know adding new tiles to the board adding new cards into the um into the card deck you know more powerful and interesting ones that really appeals to me and it makes me feel like i want to go back and play it again and again and again where sometimes i might not want to and uh well while i you know i love fisters extremely heavy games this one's a light one much easier to get to the table meaning that you are more likely to go and actually complete that story and see what the game has to offer so i really do like that and i think the waiting of the game you know paired with that story out of it works really
well um interaction is not massive i mean obviously you are competing in terms of points but the yeah other than that there's not a tremendous amount of interaction other than you know piggyback on off other people's actions um you know taking you know the resources and stuff like that but yeah i can't really think of of too much interaction in in the game um however you know it it's fine you know you're kind of just focusing on what you're doing and i'm just just you know pedaling along aesthetically i actually do like the way the game looks i mean typically i don't i'm not really that invested in this um you know post-apocalyptic dystopian theme it doesn't really do much for me but the fact that it's not a you know it's not essentially like a a real high conflict game it's not got all the you know the clans warring over each other which you normally find with this kind of genre it's basically just going around finding water and metal and upgrading your ship and things like that so um yeah it works well for me and it's certainly a new asset a new theme to um to dive into and something a bit different from fista and i you know it works for me um aesthetically um the game looks quite nice i mean you got some nice um nice wooden components i love the airships look great the artwork on the cards is decent the player board is is actually really good and functional because i said all the upgrade pieces are puzzle pieces so they sit nicely and if you upgrade and you flip them
over which shows the points you're going to get at the end of the game um and the cards are also color coded so you know when they're going to trigger so yeah really nice i i like the way the game looks it's not overdone but it's not underdone either i think it's just right um and it just works um the setup and tear down time as well is relatively good um you know normally fister games are quite fiddly in how you actually prepare for the game but this one i think you can get to the table a lot quicker than those other ones so no real complaints considering the weight of the game and all the different things going on um the progression throughout the game is is is very good in fact because you are obviously adding more guns to your ship you're constantly throwing new cars down to increase what you can do so by the end of the game you do feel significantly more powerful than at the beginning of the game you know you're flying around the board you're beating more difficult enemies um you know a lot easier than you were you you know you you can really pile up these um cards to uh ramp up the benefits you're guessing and make cards cheaper and um yeah so lots of different strategies and things you can go down and um you know the progression is is really good um scalability as well works well at all the player counts i mean it's even got a solo mode that's extremely simple and stripped back um i think it's more of a kind of a be a score um way of playing but you know if you if you are alone in these there's covert times then it's a nice campaign to go through without having too much housekeeping to do on the um on the solo bots um you're basically just i think the bot
is just getting or giving you a certain benefit each round you go through and so yeah you're not actually competing with anybody you're just trying to be a certain threshold and comparison wise while there's nothing exactly i can think of that matches the feel of the game it does have uh or borrow a lot of the things that fist is used for but uses them in a slightly different way you know you've not you've not got all the um things that fista uses again and again and again but you still i said you still got those clever cards you've got the upgrades and the boards um so yeah you've got a lot of his his things that he's good at but implemented into a slightly lighter game so yeah it's a nice fresh feel to a fisted design we're still being familiar but still treading into new ground so that's really interesting um so yeah overall um this was a real interesting game for me um i'm certainly going to be playing it again and again and trying to you know invest in the story and try and see what else the game offers me but i've really enjoyed it i think it strikes a nice balance of said being accessible but still having the fist of elements i'm still having some euro um greatness good some good resource management some really interesting card play um you know you can go different routes in terms of you know really increasing your production and getting points that way um yeah you can really focus on getting loads of cards down you can focus on getting all the upgrades um you know fighting in loads of cities all the harder cities to get points that way
so yeah loads and loads of things you can try while still being pretty um digestible and i would certainly recommend it giving a try you know don't be put off by the fact that it's being um you know everyone's communicating that this game is oh it's so light it's it's not what you want from a fister game it does have a lot of those vista elements that people love so give this one a try for yourself um i personally really enjoyed it and i said i'm going to be playing it again and again so yeah it's it's not as light as people are saying it is but of course it's not the you know the big magnus open fister strategy fests but still it's it's a nice balance between the two it's not it's not dumb just going through the motions and you know having the game play it for you it's yeah i'm really interested by it i'm always still interested to see what fista brings out you know everything he does at least intrigues me and while i wasn't quite sure what to expect with this one i was pleasantly surprised so yeah this one gets my seal of quality um more good fista um games another game here that's that's really good from him uh if you have enjoyed this review please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too and you can also support me by following me on instagram and backing me on patreon if you'd be so kind to do so i'll leave the links below for those for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye