Skip to main content
Loading video...

Heaven and Ale Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 24:05

hi everyone today i'm going to be talking about heaven and ale which is a two to four player board game designed by michael kiesling and andrea schmidt published by edgar spiel this one takes about 69 to 90 minutes to play and it came out in 2017 so it's a couple years old now michael keisting is a very prolific designer who usually teams up with one of my favorite designers wolfgang kramer but it's interesting to see a game that he's kind of taken ownership of here so the game or the book describes this game about being the head of a monastery where you're striving to provide the people with the heaven's best ale um but to be honest that is about as skin deep as it gets there is no real theme here it's a purely mechanism-driven game very much on the euro side of the spectrum um the setup of the game is going to look like this you've got your individual player board where you have this almost like a field with these different bars in the center or at least areas where you can build build barns later where you've got a sunny side of the board and you've got like a side of the board in shadow and that'll be very relevant as i'll explain later however the main board here which is obviously going to be where all the players going to take their main turns is pretty much like a time track so if you're familiar with this mechanism where you have your player piece and you can travel as far as you want along this track and take the relative action but you can never go back on yourself and then the first player to get back to the center here is going to get to choose one of these spots and potentially get a little bonus such as money or moving your little goods along this track which i'll explain the relevance

of later so a lot with a lot of euro games the idea is that you're trying to get the most victory points however the victory points are a bit different in this game at least how you're going to get them because as you can see on your board here you've got your little brewmaster this is going to be quite a significant piece in the game and you've got these little colored tokens depicting all these different types of resources and the idea is you're trying to get all the resources as far as you can along the track because the the lowest resource you've got on the track at the end of the game is going to get multiplied by the spot of your brewmaster so say the um the lowest spot here or the the the the piece that you've got um the lowest on the track is gonna be on the five marker and your brewmaster is on the six you would end up timesing the five by the three for 15 points and this part here is going to be relevant because that is going to be the conversion rate at the end of the game um depending on the positions of these markers so say one was really far ahead you're going to keep moving them back at a conversion rate of three to one in order to move the furthest one behind um up and that might be a bit obtrusive and harder to explain but it's pretty simple in practice once you get your head around it but let's get on to the actual main mechanism of the game which is as i said this time track here so um naturally you're gonna end up moving your piece to go do a number of uh simple actions such as collecting these um these little tiles here so for example if i went here i could end up taking this blue tile and

what i can do is i can either spend two coins in order to put this or collect it and put it on my shadowy side of the board like so or i can spend double that value for example four coins in in this specific example i put it on the sunny side of the board now the importance of that is that when you come to one of these these um segments with these discs on you're going to get the opportunity to score a certain type of um criteria so um this one here only lets you score this specific um spot on your board like so this one here lets you score your monks which i'll explain in shortly uh this one here lets you choose any kind of resource so see i choose this one and i would put it say because i've got a blue tile here i can put it on the blue and that would mean that all my blue tiles are going to trigger a scoring now this is how important the side of the board where you plant these tiles on is important because if you go on the shadow side of the top of the of the board then you are going to get the amount of coins equal to the number on the tile but if you put it on the sunny side of the board then you are going to gain uh move along the track equal to the amount of um number on the tile so in this example i would move my blue tile my sort of my blue um token two up the track because i've got two points here and that's going to be how relevant the you know the size of the boards are but on top of all that once you've kind of surrounded these these little farm areas here so let's just

show you an example like so once you surround it you are going to have to choose or something's going to trigger straight away where you're going to tally up all the results of what you've just planted so for example 2 4 5 8 9 13 then you're going to look on this little chart here and see which bracket you fall in so here you can see i've i fall on the 12 to 17 bracket you're going to take the relevant tile from the from the pile and you're going to plant it in the middle of the board and that means that not only are you going to choose um in this example two different tiles surrounding this one that are on opposite ends to each other which is kind of signified by this little symbol here and get those scoring criteria again so for example i could get say three coins and two up the yellow track but also i am going to move my brewmaster a certain amount of spots equal to the bracket i'm in so if you're doing a very low kind of tally of tiles you're going to move your brewmaster a lot but you're not going to trigger any scoring and for example here you're going to trigger all your tiles if you go in that 24 plus bracket but you're not going to move your brewmaster along at all and of course that brewmaster is very important for end game scoring additionally you've got these um these monks here now these monks are really powerful items because when you put them on your board by paying the cost depicted on this on the thing

here so again four to go on the shadowy side of the board but double that to go on the sunny side of the board but when you put them down and you end up maybe going to one of these scoring spots where you can choose any scoring criteria then you can put them on a selected monk so for example this mug here because that's the one that matches this symbol then it's going to trigger everything that monk touches so you know as you can probably imagine when the board builds up you've got tiles everywhere that can be quite a lot of things being triggered at once and additionally if your monks are next to each other like this they will trigger other monks which will move your brewmaster further along the track that's going to be pretty much the base of the game and there's also going to be these barrel spots here which are pretty much a race for public objectives because as you can see on the main board you've got all these different barrels with all different criteria on them and these are going to be quite a quite a powerful way of getting victory points for example you know if you're all the first player to get um all your 15 tiles on the sunny side of the board to get six number five tiles to get three of the barns of the same um are the same value to get four of different values to get six number one tiles and so on so you've got all these different things you can do but when you go to that spot you can take all the tiles that you make that you meet the criteria for so you know i could end up taking you know these ones and these ones for example which will get me eight points at the end of the game but there will still be opportunities for other players to get those

but at a lot smaller victory cost also when you end up scoring two of these adjacent um criteria so in this example these two monks you're going to have the option to play one of these cards here to give you a bit of a boost so for example you can get a bit of a cash injection to get 12 coins you can get make your barrels worth an extra point each at the end of the game you can move your brewmaster five along the spot um you can choose one of your resources um and get or move your marker the furthest behind the number of spots equal to the number of tiles you have um or you can move your furthest behind desk a number of spots equal to the number of discs that you've played and when you do that you're going to end up putting them in these spots here like so to show that you've cashed them in but additionally if you don't think you're ever going to get to achieve one of these things or you don't do it you need them you can get rid of them for a quick three coins in order to just keep you going in terms of cash flow and that's going to be how the game's going to play out until you play a number of designated rounds equal to or depending on the player count so i think in a three-player game you play four rounds in a two-player game you play three rounds and i think in a four-play game you play all six rounds and then obviously at the end of the round everything's going to be replenished meaning that potentially that there are going to be doubles or even triples on the um on the resource tiles where you can choose to buy you know one or more tiles from then on so it's not like the board gets wiped

it just keeps on getting replenished and potentially building up resources to give you more options so that's going to be how the game's going to play so let's talk about my thoughts about heaven and ale so let's start off by talking about the main mechanisms in the game so first off as i mentioned at the beginning of the video i really love a time track or kind of a rondelle where you can move as far as you want but not being able to move back on yourself but in order to be good or at least for me you need to have that real incentive to want to you know weigh up that decision of how far you want to go you know do you want to slowly trickle along and grab all the drags that other people don't want to do or do you want to jump really far ahead to get something you specifically want to ensure that nobody else can get there before you do and i think the layout of this board does a fantastic job of that of just dangling that carrot in front of you and making you want to jump ahead out of the anxiety that someone's going to get there before you you know for example you know if you really do need to score your monks this turn then you're going to have to jump here and trigger those monks because there's only one opportunity to do so um at least for every round apart from the final one so i i really do like that the same applies to the barrels you know are you fulfilling loads of criteria of the barrels and can get loads of points but you know that somebody else has a lot of those criteria fulfilled as well so you do need to get there before they do meaning that you're going to sacrifice a hell of a lot on the way in order to do that so that that decision space of what you need to sacrifice in order to do what you really need to do and prioritizing things really does shine through just because

the layout of this board and how everything is weighted in terms of what you need so i think that's fantastically executed um additionally as well like when you get right back to the beginning here um you can pick which position you're in so you know do you want to move on your tokens too too long um do you want to get the extra cash or do you want to go in first position you know all these little decisions are very important but on top of all that this is the actual playables themselves are something that i haven't seen before and i really do like the way this works do you want to play the basic um you know the basic cost of things and put them on the shaded side of the board which is basically going to be your income how you're going to invest in yourself and keep your cash flow coming along and also naturally this is contributing to these um these little barns which can give you extra scoring opportunities and again keep the cash coming but that is all fine and danny and it's going to be your infrastructure to keep you playing and keep you in the game but ultimately you're going to need to keep planting on the sunny side of the board because if you don't then you're not going to get any victory points at the end of the game so i really do like that decision and that that weighing up on how much you need to invest in yourself or and knowing when to kind of stop doing this and start focusing on points or just keeping or spinning the plates between the two is a real strong decision throughout and on top of that you only get to score all these different um all these different criteria once in the game you know you can only

score each monk once you can only score each type of tile once um or at least and this one here can let you choose a certain um number of tar wants so you know you've got to be aware that you can't do everything and you need to um choose when you're going to score these things and bearing in mind that you're only going to get a few big reaps of rewards um towards the end of the game by the time you've already spent a lot of your scoring criteria so it really has an interesting pacing and i i would say that every decision in this game is really relevant and you can't just wing it and um just hopefully hope that it works out because i said cash is extremely tight um you know choosing these scoring criteria to at least pair up so you can play one of these cards is important as well because these are all really powerful and you you're going to want to use them but again you can't just do that because you need to be doing these in pairs so there's lots of well very smooth mechanically great decisions throughout and everything is really relevant the balance of the game as well is extremely interesting because it's not a game where you can choose to completely jump all in on one type of resource you're gonna have to spin a lot of plates to keep all of your pieces here moving along this track because as i said when it comes to scoring you're going to be using this conversion rate depending on where your um where your little brewmaster is here so say it ended up here on that three to one ratio

and what that means is that you're going to be moving this back three spaces for every one that your one furthest behind moves up so you because of that you want to keep making sure that everything is at least keeping up with one another while keeping your brewmaster ticking along while making sure you have money coming in while making sure that you're triggering scoring to move your things along anyway and at the same time trying to get the barrels and things so the balance and the different approaches you can take in the game are all really interesting and as i said it's one of those games where you do have to spin a lot of plates and you can't just get two tunnel visions because i don't think that's going to work out if you do that also in terms of the time investment i would say this doesn't outstate it's welcome whatsoever particularly you know in a you said in a two or three player game you're only playing three or four rounds and that naturally means that you know you're gonna be jumping ahead quite a lot over time which means you might it might mean you only stopped four times per round and but at the same time you could stop loads of times per round but only get the things that are falling behind that people have left behind that is so yeah i think the game ticks along really nicely you want to be getting your towels down to surround these things but at the same time you want to be getting the the nice juicy one so that when you trigger the scoring you're going to get lots of rewards so yeah i do like the time investment it does feel um engaging it doesn't outstay it's welcome it ticks along nicely turns are fast and basically when it's other players turns as well you are invested in where they want to go so the

uptime and time investment do work really well and there isn't really much scope to lose interest you're always thinking about where you're going to plan where you're going to go next you know if somebody snatches your place what your backup plan is etcetera so no complaints whatsoever in that regard a replayability as well um things will change up simply because of the layout of the tiles on the board um also you know the the balanced approach that you need to take here as well um and tailoring your game as you go along in order to get these barrels um fulfilled um so yeah it's a game where you are reacting to what other players do but you can't go in with a certain game plan um so i think the replayability is decent because you're always reacting to what other people are doing that pretty much leads into the player interaction there is a real scarcity of the certain tiles as you go along and of course the the fight for the barrels in the first place is important so i think the game does a good job of creating some incentives you know that you need to bear in mind what other people are doing you know the the monks that you might need don't come up um too too regularly so you might need to jump really far ahead to get them to stop other people doing it etc um and of course you know you get a very limited chance to score things anyway so you know again jumping ahead to make sure that you're scoring things before your opponents do is equally as important so i love the passive player interaction here there's no in your face smashing each other's things and you can't really affect each other too much other other

than jumping ahead to get the resources that you want but that for me just is a sweet spot of player interaction um aesthetically i think the game looks wonderful i love this um almost throwback um you know almost like you know church-like which fits obviously the theme um artwork but at the same time it's still bright and vibrant and i think it strikes a great balance of feeling classic but still feeling fresh um i love that you know the characters look really cool and quirky the tiles are nice and clearly um you know numbered and assembled nice and bright and um you know you clearly see what all the boards looks like and what it does the track's all nice and clear so yeah i like the artwork there's nothing completely fancy or elegant about it but it just works for me um and in terms of the components um they're i'm really impressed by the production value of this of this game um yeah you've got some natural or some basic euro components such as the wooden pieces etc but all the tiles are a really good quality the cards themselves are ridiculously good quality they're they're so thick um it's almost um you know a treat really all the money yeah you got some card money here but again it's super thick um the coins are fine all the tiles are fine i mean all the wooden pieces are good so yeah it's a an affordable game and i think the production value um exceeds itself really i'm really happy with it the setup and teardown time is um is fine as well

the only thing that's a little bit fiddly um but you only have to do it once is setting up the barrels because obviously you have to lay one on top of the other like so but i'm nitpicking it's no big issue at all um setting up isn't too bad because you only have two different types of of these monks so you know they're easy to separate at the beginning of the game you have two different types of um tiles you know numbered one and two at the back to kind of dictate the pacing of the game it's it's real no it's really no issue at all as i said you can do the housekeeping between each round very quickly and the initial setup as well is no issue at all um of course as the game goes on you're going to be building your board so the kind of tear down time is going to be longer than the setup time um and progression is really good i mean i love the way that you're constantly building your um your own little farm here i suppose or your land um constantly trying to weigh up what you're going to be surrounding these things with um because you know you do want to bear in mind that you when you do these things you're going to be getting the bonuses surrounding them but also you want to be moving your brewmaster up but also at the same time you want to be trying to go for these goals as well and i would say that most of these goals are going to be fulfilled towards the later end of the game you know for example you know do you want to get three of these barns the same value you only get four of different values are you going to try and tailor to a strategy to get these kind of six independent one tiles and etc so there is um there is a good sense of progression of working towards something

and building your own little um plant or little farm thing where you're trying to take ownership of it so i do like that and it does feel like a bit of a puzzle on top of it which is very satisfying scalability because the player interaction is um you know it is limited to the rondelle thing here in the time track um i think it scales absolutely fine i would say the sweet spot is probably three players and four players again would be absolutely fine i think that i'd probably prefer them over two players simply because i think at two you would probably tick along a bit slower and pick up more than you um more than you would at the higher play accounts because i think you know when you're waiting two or three times before you take a go again then you're gonna be more incentivized to jump further along the track and for me that's where these type of games really shine so i would say that three or four player sport is um is going to be right at least at least for me personally and comparison wise there are so many of these time track games you know you've got your um you know you glenn moore's you've got your um francis drake's there there are a lot of these type of games you know igesia but i'd say that heaven and ale does a really good job of um of this time track probably better than 90 of these um these time track style games simply because you are so incentivized to move ahead and um and i really do like that you're not going to do terribly well if you just sit back and just lap out all the other things and just getting things that people don't want you do have to you know

just sometimes just bear in mind that you do have to sacrifice a lot to do what you really want to do and i love that so yeah overall um i don't know if you can tell i really am impressed by heaven and ale um i don't think i mentioned at the beginning of the game michael keisling is a designer i i really love but generally i like him a lot more when he teams up with wolfgang kramer now this one is hands down my favorite um michael keystone game that he's done without kramer now i wasn't a big fan of azul for example and this has really lit a fire for me to try some of those other games that he's done on his own or at least with somebody else other than cranium because i think this is so well implemented yes kramer of sorry kiesling is um is he's a genius he's one of these um you know mount rushmore designers who's been around forever he makes elegant gains ones with tight rules interesting mechanisms easy to digest but will still extremely meaningful and um agonizing decisions and for me heaven and eye just does it's just a great example of that i i absolutely adore this game i think it's fantastic and i think it's has a real kind of timeless feel to it and i don't think it's going to wear off its luster anytime soon because it is so clean but still so interesting i love that economic cash flow system where you're going to you know choose to invest in one or the other i think that's really compelling it's a really hard thing to wrap your head

around to do well at this game and um i'm looking forward to trying to um be better at it and keep my cash going while still trying to um you know keep my keep my points going as well i think the scoring system is going to be a bit harder to explain to most players considering that the game itself is pretty light i suppose at least in its um rules overhead um but once you've done it once it makes sense and i suppose if you just say to somebody the strategy is to keep all your things moving as far as you can then they're gonna be okay but yeah this one is um really good i'm really happy with it um i think it probably goes a bit under the radar now not many people talk about heaven and ale and i think they should because it is a really solid design um one with for one i can't really pick much fault with at all um because it is just uh another example by a great designer who really knows what he's doing so uh this one gets my shield of quality now already missed out on my elite shield um but who knows with more plays and um down the years this one could creep up into that next bracket so um i hope you've enjoyed this review if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too you can also support me by backing me on patreon and i'll link the uh i'll leave the link below for that one for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved