Inside Art Society Deluxe Edition - Exclusive News and Interview with Designer Mitch Wallace
Transcript
Hello and welcome to Untap, the Patreon exclusive video podcast series uh which we're doing a little preview for on our main channel. So lucky viewers of boys she chief they can get to see a little bit of this and the reason that is is because a very very special one uh before we introduce our guest for this particular video of course and quickly introduce my co-host the Italian stallion the Caesar of board games Mr. Matteo Genevi.
Hello. Hello guys. Yeah, we got a really good one today. We're very excited about it and uh
absolutely
he might pick something at my behind my shoulders that maybe it's going to give you a little hint. But yeah, Wayne, if you want to be
That's a very wellplaced game there, Matt. I like it. Uh, so yeah, welcome along. Uh, Mr. Mitch Wallace, uh, if you want to give us a quick pitch, tell us who you are and let the people in who haven't figured it out, uh, what you've designed.
Sure. Uh, I'm Mitch Wallace and I'm the designer of Art Society. Um, it is a spatial puzzle uh art auction game and it came out in 2023 and it's currently having a uh deluxe Kickstarter right now. So, uh, in in art society, all the players take on roles of art, I guess, afficionados. They care about art, but you know, they they care also about being the trendiest. So, they're uh collecting art, getting out on on the the gallery wall in their house in their in their drawing room, and they're kind of chasing trends. They want to have the most uh prestigiously invogue collection by the end of the game.
Love it, love it, love it. It's me and Matt's favorite game, I think, pretty much from 2023. We absolutely adore the game. It's
Yeah, we consumed the game. So, we can't wait for the deluxe edition to come out just because I need new pieces because we use it so much.
Yeah. And uh yeah, we're going to we're actually going to have our faces on one of the boxes, isn't it? Way
I think so. Yeah.
It's the weirdest things ever, but I love it so much.
Yeah. If you're a follower of our Instagram, you'll see. And I'll actually put a link below in the description. uh the Mighty Boards team put us on a little uh some artwork which is amazing.
This is how much we love the game and how much Yeah, it's a fantastic game. Was the one of the 2020 best game and uh Kiss being played a lot in uh in our houses. So,
it certainly does. Um, so Mitch, I'd like to start really by asking about how that collaboration with Mighty Boards came about because as far as I understand it, this is your first published game. Um, so how did you get in touch with Mighty Boards? What did that process look like? How did they get interested in it?
Sure. Um, I think the simplest way to or I think it's a pretty simple story. um they went to there's a there's a convention in uh the United States called PAX Unplugged and uh PAX is a series of conventions all across definitely the country. I think they at one point were in Australia and they're mostly video games, but they have one every year um that's dedicated to uh board games and I've been going to that since 2021. And then in 2022, that was Mighty Board's first year there. And um in the I guess that part's not important, but basically the last day I um I was running around trying to talk to publishers and they were on my list because I like the um uh the production value and the art value that they had made for their games and uh an art game needs good art. So, I was only I was talking to um a few people or pursuing a few few publishers that I knew consistently did good art and they were on the list and so I I was I was talking to them at the uh at the very last day of the convention and um swung by and um talked to David and showed him what I had and he was he was pretty interested and we just kind of kept talking from there.
That's great. And yeah, we spoke to David about you as well a few some episode ago. for the people you can go and watch that episode as well cuz he's a really nice guy. We really like u what the attic that mighty boards got behind their games and how they treat the the people working that is uh is fantastic. So that's u mesh made in heaven I I would say for you Mitch. Um but um my question for you is so our society has been such well received by the by the general public. Um, what do you think that resonate the most from the with the players in the game? What what do you think how that magic happened? What do you think? What's you you might have an idea about it? Do you think it's the the fact that the art is so beautiful and the mechanics is so good or what what do you think that brought a lot of people to buy the game?
Because they Mighty Balls we can say they sold a lot otherwise there would have not have been a deluxe version probably. Oh yeah, yeah, yeah. It's it's it's it's done pretty well. Um I would say and okay, it's difficult to pinpoint one thing because I think what it actually does is it does a lot of different things. And so what it does well is it brings in uh different types of people to play the game. um it does have have a lot of um uh really good art and the people there's it was kind of like designed to be a cozy game and so for the players that want that cozy game experience where I'm happy to collect art put it on my wall and and play with that kind of spatial puzzle um and and deal with the shapes and like a lot of people when they get done they feel they're boarded they feel really good it like that's part that was that was like baked into it. And I know so many people that play it just for for that experience. And before the game came out, um you know, at PAX, there were two really great uh play tests that I had.
And one person said, "When this game comes out, if it comes out, I want the art to be so good that I don't care if it's the right piece for me to win the game. I just want it because it's awesome." And when the game came out, I've heard that that's happened so many times that people are happy to collect the art because they just want that piece on the on their wall. And so it does it does that really well. Um because it just you can just kind of be immersive in that space. And then the other side of it is I think that for those players that want to be strategic, that want to be uh aggressive with their gameplay and win, it also suits those players very well. um uh as an as an anecdote the the other test so in the um at pack there's there's these uh parts of different parts of the the convention and one of them is uh an unpub room where uh designers bring their unpublished games to get tested and so that's kind of one of the things I'm that I'm referencing and so I had two really good tests one people just excited to do that spatial puzzle and then another one that it was kind of like oh this is this is the I think quintessential ial like dichotomy of the game. Uh there was four four players and there was this one woman just making the most nice and neat orderly um you know
like refined board and then across the table from her was this guy that was making like a Swiss cheese board. Like there were holes everywhere and everyone and the other people are like what are you doing? you're gonna have problems and he's like, "No, I just need to make sure that they don't touch." And then and his eye was 100% on the market
and and I was like, "Okay, we we have two different player types going on at the moment." And it was so great. And then the uh the woman that was being so orderly, she actually lost by two points and she made a faux paw just to complete her wall. So she got the final she she completed her wall, got the final like five points and then the other person won and then her feedback was that the completing her wall should be worth three points more because she wanted to win by and I was like uh maybe you shouldn't have gotten the faux paw like internally right like are you better player don't do the faux paw like the one
like puzzle avoidance kind of rule in the game and the other first it was oh it was it was really interesting to see that kind of dichotomy and then I've seen and heard so many different um other player types that have been attracted to the game and how different people play it. So I'd go with that.
Yeah, that's that sounds great. Yeah, cuz when you well when me and Wayne plays with our partners, it's very much a cutthroat game. It's literally like it's it's gets very competitive. But then when we play with other people, it goes way more relaxed and it's more like we played with people that never played board games, for example, and they pick it up immediately. And it's the the auction side is fun. Building your things is fun. Sometimes you don't need to look too much at the market. When me and Wayne play gets a little bit more rowdy, I would say it's like,
yeah, it's great. Yeah, I think you're right. It does. It appeals to both sides of the of the hobby sphere. If you want to be chill, you can be chill. if you want to be a little bit more uh aggro, you can do that and you know really cutthroat bid outbid people which is great. Uh I think it's a fabulous thing. Um and h yeah it's definitely resonated with us as well. I like that you said Mitch like some people just play it because they like the art and they want to do that and some people just I want to pick all of the animals that I see and they put all the animals in my art and I think that's fantastic.
So let's talk about that mechanical design. We've mentioned it a few things there about the bidding mechanisms, about the tile placement, about, you know, the patterning, that sort of thing. Um, are there any games that inspired the mechanical design of Art Society? And was the theme the driver of the mechanisms? Did you have art first or did the mechanisms of tail light tower laying and bidding come first and then you put the theme on top of it? What was the main driver?
Sure. Um, I could answer the question directly, but I also don't feel like it's it's one to one. So, the game came um out of another prototype I was working on that was like visually or mentally complicated. People said this is like too much. Someone said it was like 3D Sudukco and they're like simplify it. So, I made it like 2D Sudukco. And then then um players were like, "There's too much information on the cards for what this game is." And I thought, "Oh, that's that's almost so poignant." Because there was some other comments, but that was like the root of it. And uh so I thought well what's a setting or you there's a little brainstorm session and then there was and then if kind of like what's a setting that would match what we were doing in the game like what was important for the the components and a salon wall came up in the brainstorm and that was um it it just really resonated as far as the uh the me mechanisms, but then also at the same time um I mean I have a I have a background in uh graphic design, art direction and advertising. So I went to school for um that and uh so did my wife. And so we're kind of in that like art perspective of of things and um so
that was that was like the pinpoint. Oh, this this is what this game could be. And then I didn't work on it for two years after I made those notes. And I went to go design other types of games. And uh I learned, you know, uh and I picked up other different like uh gaming styles from trick taking and and auction games and dice games and rolling rights and all those sorts of other lessons that you get from those. And then when I came back, I didn't like any of my notes. Like I could follow my notes one to one. I was like, I could do that. But looking at what a salon wall is because the other game was made about of entirely squares and then the and I was like I could do that. That just doesn't feel right towards the subject matter because salon walls are full of all these different rectangles. I was like well we got to get that in there right and that and using that as a jumping off point. The other thing had like a rondelle or a pick and pass sort of thing. So I was like well let's throw that out and then what what makes sense with art? I was like, "Well, an auction." And that was very uh resonant from some of like the trick-taking aspects I was uh working on and pulling from and um uh yeah. So, so a little bit of it was so it's like there was mechanical then setting then how to make the setting work with the mechanical. It was like back and forth.
It was a bit of back and forth between the two things. Sorry.
Yeah. Yeah. Um, and then and then as far as the I I guess influences, you know, I've played a variety of spatial games, but probably a lot of like Polyomino games early, not early, um, but Uve Rosenberg um, games, Cottage Garden, Summer Meadow, stuff like that. And then, um, uh, there's a lot of spatial games that are about adjacencies, and those are great, but I was wanting to explore a different way of scoring. And also because it's art, like why why does it matter if a portrait is next to a landscape or anything like that? I think per subject matter, it didn't make sense to copy any of those types of mechanisms. Um, and I came across games like uh Hats and Bites and Harvest Dice and they had this really interesting multiplier system and that was a place to to go from
and then just kind of general uh auction games and and other things of that nature.
Yeah.
Amazing. I like there was kind of cyclical both feeding each other. That's fascinating. Genuinely,
yeah, it's like an iterative process, I'd say. But yeah, I think some sometimes I just I' I've made things where like this is what it is and or like this this is the subject matter. How do I make this subject matter work? And that's that's all it is. But sometimes, you know, actually now I think about it, I think a good number of them it is it is a painting back and forth. Um, sometimes it's mechanical within the setting and then it's kind of like re-evaluating does the do these mechanics make sense with the setting.
That's fantastic. And uh, staying on the feedbacks and play testing and all that stuff. Now, I want to know a little bit more about the future because u, yes, there is an art society deluxe version with everything is deluxified. It looks amazing. It's live now on Kickstarter. has already been founded and but it's uh it's rolling and rolling because it looks absolutely beautiful but there is an expansion as well and I remember when we met a spiel um last year that is the first things that we asked you are we getting an expansion where's the expansion
it's just I want more arts I want more tiles I want give me more
so can you tell us what is the expansion about and or is he adding new mechanics? I know it's for sure he's adding more arts, but what else is uh is in that box?
Uh yeah, the expansion that uh we're going with first is one that's going to be really deepening the gameplay. Um from some of the feedback that we heard from reviewers and and other people, it was um players wanted goals. they wanted more to think about from the upfront and also a way to make things more competitive. So, um, this expansion has, uh, two or three different characters in the game and they're all going to add something different for players to be thinking about and for that's also going to change the reward system in the game. And so such as the socialite will have um these different spatial puzzles.
Typically spatial puzzles, sometimes it's what you collect, but spatial puzzles about how you arrange your art because that's what's that's what's in vogue and that's how the you know the art society cares about what you have. And um when you and those are all going to be races. the first person to complete that thing, whatever that is. Maybe it's the first person to collect uh a size three decor, then you get the rewards are at that at that card. And the rewards could be straight points. They could uh allow you to gain the ability to swap with a mu museum kind of with without impunity and and um and just less restrictions. It also allows you to get decor and then there's some other things um allow you to adjust the prestige of the market and also
uh then there's like one or two tokens in there that can you can avoid a faux paw if you you've collected it. And that's um that's really interesting because it's you're going to collect that either because you've already made a faux paw to get yourself out of it or you want one and you're going to that's going to allow you to not be penalized for it. But it's it's kind of risky. It's kind of risky, you know. Um, every every time people have since I've introduced it in the expansion, people have often not collected it because they because they're like, I wasn't I didn't necessarily uh think I would need to make one. And then when the one person that has collected, they're like, I've just so habitually avoided it that I didn't think about to do it aggressively or on on purpose. Um, and so those are kind of like token rewards that you're going to get that kind of going to help you throughout the game. And then, um, and then there's the, uh, the curator, and these are all characters that are kind of in the fiction of the world. Like these are people that that have given you the hookup because you're doing something that's kind of impressing them. They're like, "Hey, because you've done that, let me help you out with this." And so, um, in that in this scenario with the curator, uh, you do some sort of spatial puzzle and then you're going to get an ongoing ability.
Most of them, like one or two of them are, uh, instant instant abilities, but, uh, most of them are ongoing abilities that are going to kind of, uh, break the game in a way as far as how things are manipulated, how you collect decor, and um, some other things. So, uh, there's and and yeah. So, so there's that.
It sounds like a lot of me.
I am. I am.
I can't wait. Thrilled. Thrilled.
It's It's great. It's just like it gets you more cutthroaty. I love it. I guess I guess there is a bit for everyone cuz it all the stuff that you you mentioned sounds like it's going to be um more for the gamers to make the game more
even more like u deep and competitive but at the same times it's going to be for the coy people that just want more art I guess at the same time because this going to be filled with more new art and all the um in the in the art society style that we really Yeah, I think it's I I am thrilled to bits because I think that was one of the things that I said I wanted as I wanted but I I wanted uh like objectives and stuff and that's exactly what you've you well not yeah pretty much what you've made. I'm thrilled. I can't wait to play it. I am dying to get my hands on it. I've got to wait a little while but I'm very excited. Um but obviously the design of something like that Mitch must have come with some challenges. Uh so you've designing an expansion for a game. Uh what are the things what are the challenges that you may have encountered when trying to trying to make this expansion?
It's a great question. Um I'm I'm not sure what the challenges are actually uh because it's just like it's it's going through the process. Um, I created a variety of proposed expansions
and Mighty Board selected this one as the one they want to um be be pursuing. And then from there it was a matter of um kind of honing in and that's just kind of a part of the process. I could say that's the challenge, but that's just a part of the process of um I mean there's two ways to create you and one is you have a lot of ideas and you edit which is what I prefer uh to do or the other one is you have a base idea and and then you need to say no we need more we need more we need more and that can take you know then it's just like constantly adding and adding and adding and so um this process was um coming up with the abilities and then figure out what abilities make sense. What are abilities that people want to do in the game? We've I've we've created some that uh I think recently kind of fell off the chopping block. either people didn't um like never pick them and they was just like it's fine just I'd rather because there's always an option in in art society of what you're going to be selecting and so um it's like that that one's fine but I'd rather do all you know any of these other four over that one and so it's kind of been the process of trying to curate the the right list of abilities and the right list uh uh set of rewards for what the uh socialites are is doing on each card to
make sure that the reward matches with the the difficulty or um or or is enticing us enough to do something first over something second, anything like that. Um so I guess maybe the balancing I guess. Um but there's been a lot of tests. I've done more tests for the expansion than the base game, which is kind of silly, but it's been um but it's been a fun process of just like really um getting to know the game so well,
but you don't want to break the game. So, you want the expansion to be balanced and uh and enjoyable because we saw in the past the games made some some of the expansion just like this is another this is a different game now or uh it's just like oh this break the the the core game. So, I think there is the the challenge there. So,
yeah, that's a really great thing to bring up because there was definitely um some discussions about either what's the right first expansion and also who is this expansion for and who and and what's the audience? And so we don't want to like alienate original not original players but the the the fan base of the of the first um game so much however we define who they are because yeah it should it should augment and enhance the first game and and not or the base game and not uh you know be something entirely different. And I think I also probably proposed one or two that might feel like an entirely different game but you you can play them that way which is fine. We'll see if they ever come out.
Yeah, that's fascinating that there's been more play testing for the expansion than the base game. But as you said, it kind of makes sense. You've already got an existing successful product that is well liked and has been wellreceived and the last thing you want to do is is break it, right? It makes sense to some extent that you want to spend more time on that expansion and make sure they're al they enhance and elevate the experience.
Um.
Yeah.
Yeah. And also Sorry.
No, go ahead.
I was just going to say that some of the cards we want to make sure that they're possible because they're all objective based. We need to make sure like test the difficulty of them. Are they too easy? Which is or are they too difficult? Like I just kicked out someone made a suggestion of like, oh, it'd be cool if you could do this. And for a while I was like, I'm not sure I want to try it. And then I tried it. I was like, oh, that is that took me half the game to do. And I was focused on it from the beginning. that takes way too long and you have to set it up um kind of a very particular way. And so a lot of the cards that I were in the game I want that like if you mess it up you can pivot and try again. And that card was if you mess up oh you probably didn't get it at all.
Yeah. Okay. So yeah it makes sense. You you don't want stuff that is going to basically tank your game if you get it wrong.
Yeah. Yeah. It was that was that was that was was a weird test and because we were all going for it and then as soon as we did it, we're like,
"All right, that's done. Let's let's play the game we normally play it or focus on other aspects of the game." But that one's that one's not in there. Don't worry about it. And but it's find the right balance of things that are going to give you enough um direction and incentive um and creative play. That's that's also something I'm really big on. So,
yeah.
Fantastic.
So, you mentioned a few times there, Mitch, and it's it's it's like tickling the back of my brain that you've done like a bunch of different expansion ideas, and I'm like, "Oh, wow. That sounds cool. I'm wondering what what might be next."
So, I've got to ask the question then, like, is the plan for you or is the ideal scenario from you that there will be more expansions, more variants? Uh, I assume you're not done with Art Society after this new version. Or maybe you are.
Click subscribe. It's a vibe for all game for you and me. Here's what you should play and see.