Arena Roma II Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at arena roma 2 which is a 2009 released board game designed by stefan feld and published by queen games this one takes around 30 minutes to play and is strictly for two players so this is actually a sequel to steppenfeld's first game roma and is actually compatible with that one if you want to mix the two together and unlike um pretty much all of stefan fell games this one is the most confrontational you do have some direct player contact and kind of conflict um and the board is going to look at look like this where you've got this central column here of all these different pit values that lock together in this kind of a modular method you've got a bunch of cards here so at the start of the game each player is going to start with five cards you're gonna keep three of them you're gonna pass two to your opponent um and then you're gonna allocate them to the different spots here but i've added another guard here just so i can see i will show you more of the different cards that are potentially gonna come up in the game and we've got a few more spots here not only the one to six but you've got the um the money spot here you've got the bribe spot here and you've got the draw card spot here each player is going to get given 10 points at the start of the game you're going to get given three dice of your own color you've got a battle dice and of course you have the big deck of cards and the objective of the game is to either force your opponent to lose all of their victory points or to have the most victory points by the time that this common pool runs out so mechanically this game is really simple to play and the first thing you're going to do on your turn is have a look how many empty spots you have on your row of cards here so you can see
that every slot here is full apart from number six therefore i'm going to lose one victory point for each of those slots so in this example i'm going to lose one point and put that back to the common supply now i only have nine points and then as a free action i can play as many cards as i want from my hand and provided i can afford to pay it and the card anatomy is going to look like this where you have a value here which is what it's going to cost to pay you've got the defense value of a card if another player chooses to attack it and of course you have the ability here so all this best of your card this one allows me to attack an opponent's card for the weakest defense value and if several cards qualify i can pick which one to attack um so yeah as a free action i might choose to play that one by spending the money and then allocating it to a free spot or even replacing an existing card and putting the other one into the discard pile but as the as the main focus of the game you're going to roll your three dice and which of course are going to show the different pit values and then you can allocate them as you see fit to the different spots on the board so of course i could put this five here on this um on this five location and take the ability of this card which says remove three victory points from the general supply from the game so if i'm doing particularly well i might want to deplete that pull and try to bring the gate end of the game closer um but if you don't want to use the actual cards you can choose to use these bonus abilities like this one here which is going to let me take the amount of coins equal to the pit value of allocated there so this will give me five coins which of course is going to be used to pay to play new cards or you can also allocate them to this
spot here which is going to show how many cards you're going to draw from the stack and then you're going to always keep one so it doesn't matter what pit value you put there you're just going to have to you're going to draw as many cards but you're only going to keep one regardless of that number and the other spot here is the bride one which works slightly differently um very similar to these other spots but instead of um allocating the dice as you would normally without paying any fee you actually have to pay the amount of money equal to the dice that you are allocating to that spot so this actually cost me five coins in order to use this ability so i'm naturally you want to be putting lower values on this one so it's uh more affordable to play so these cards do lots of different things and there's actually quite a few different paths to victory here so i'll just go through go show you through a few of these cards and then we can take a look at what the different paths of victory are so you can see here the forum card actually requires you to place two dice onto them to use this action and the first one just has to match the number but the second one could be anything but that second dice is going to give you a number of victory points equal to that second dice so if you put like a one and then a six that's going to give you six victory points um which of course is very good uh you've got this one here the speculator which means you can look at your opponent's hand and and take one of those cards so it's got a bit of take that and grabbing those cards from other people's hands that they've collected and this one here lets you um discard the card opposite so again you're trying to deplete cards on other people's sides so that when it comes to the start of their turn they're going to have to forfeit more points because as i said at the start of each chart for every empty space you're going to have to lose a point if it's your turn this
one here means that whenever you take the money action you're going to take an extra two coins so a nice way to keep a nice flow of income coming and there's castro here lets you play the top card from the draw pile onto one of your unoccupied die token spots so if you have an empty spot here then you can choose to just top deck from the um from the stack and fill up one of those gaps to prevent you from leaking those points um you've got the taberna here that says you can gain one victory point from the general supply for each of your face um of each of your opponents face up character cards if you know you're already slipping behind on characters or if your opponent has played a lot of characters then if you have this card then that's a really good way to gain victory points um again we've got another forum there we've got this um some of the take that cards or the more aggressive cards here so this one lets you attack the opposite card um and what you're gonna do when you attack is you're gonna roll this attack die and you're going to try and match or exceed the defense value here and if you do you're going to remove that card but this uh this one here lets you increase that kind of pit value by spending three cysteria which is your money just to increase them it by one for each three that you spend you've got the porters here that you swap one of your face up cards one of the hands one from your from from your hand now the boat here says you can take three victory points from your general supply if you have more face up characters than your opponent so again you can go for a real kind of character driven strategy you can go for a building driven strategy you can try and and make people bleed their money by um you know trying to attack their pieces and remove their cards meaning they're gonna have to keep placing more or keep
bleeding points um which is what cars like this bestiary does and you've even got ones here like this aqueduct um which is really cool because actually lets you remove ones from the pool here which i mentioned earlier where you know if you are winning on victory points but you know your opponent still has got too many to rely on them running out then you can actually try and get rid of them from the pool in the first place and eliminate them from the game to try and draw the end of the game closer and you've got ones like this which is going to just mess up your opponent and where it says um in the next if i can focus there in the next turn your opponent has one less die to roll so you're gonna mess with these players with the other players that way as well and there are a bunch of other cards here all kind of doing roughly the same thing um so this one here just lets you pay attentio to just destroy a card this one here lets you roll the battle die and you get half rounded up of the victory points um of that of that pit value um you get ares here that lets you um the opposite building card is placed on the discard pile um you've got the the um predator here that lets you place up one of your face up building cards on the discard pile and you gain the equivalence of the defense value of the victory point so if you've got a really strong building that you don't need anymore you can maybe use this card and change that building into victory points you've got this one here that lets you re-roll all the dies that you that you roll in the first place at the start of the round so gives you more flexibility and mitigation and again you've got these extremely aggressive cards here like this elephant that lets you just automatically destroy a card opposite of the value four or less so that's pretty much what the game
consists of you're just going to keep taking turns in order to use your dice play cards try and deplete your opponent's points or to try and have the most points when that pool runs out and then of course the winner is going to be determined um so let's talk about how i feel about arena roma 2. so if you are kind of a regular consumer of my content you're probably aware that i'm a huge stefan phelp fan and this one did feel like a bit of a disconnect because it is so confrontational and so in your face compared to all those other games and no other time do you kind of have a role to resolve and try and um you know try and smash your opponent's cards in order to make them lose points but um this one does actually work quite well and considering you know it is more of a drooling style game and it does have that kind of steppenfeld vibe and using the dice in clever ways uh i do like the way that the actual um the actual fallout of those battles isn't so in your face in terms of you know rolling a dice and you maybe lose that many points it's simply try to roll the dice eliminate the card and then if you can't replenish the card you're going to lose that point so it is kind of eurofied in the way that the combat works which i haven't seen before and it is kind of a matter of trying to plug those holes as quickly as you can in order to keep up you know to stop you from believing those points um whenever it comes to your turn which is you know a nice little twist on this kind of game i also do really like the different paths of victory that you can take i said you can really focus on just doing that and making your opponent lose all their accounts you can focus on building buildings and then getting points like synodized with that and getting you know for every building you have get a victory point you can focus on just the
pure points gaining ones where you're just rolling dice and then getting that many victory points there are certain cards that let you kind of manipulate the board and you know if you if you have a card on one that you really want to use but then you roll a four the four card might say i'll pick a card of your choice and so there are different ways to kind of point to cards that you want and you can build a tiny little engine and try to cater things to your taste and try to or try to cater it to your strategy and your you know a path to victory so i do like that i like the ways that you can you focus on bleeding the points out here that's quite cool but i suppose that's one of the double-edged swords about this game is yes there are different ways to victory um but some of them can feel a bit grindy and can take a bit long in order to be resolved so for example here i played i played a few games at this one some of them were over in 10-15 minutes and then some of them took over half an hour to play which did start to feel like it was a bit long and started to feel a bit more of a kind of a war of attrition rather than a kind of quick dueling game which you probably want this to be so i do think this one does have potential to outstay its welcome particularly if you're not drawing those more punchy cards so yeah that is something to bear in mind with this one is that it is a very light game yes there is some clever kind of interaction between the cards but it does have potential to take longer than you'd probably want it to because ultimately you are mainly reacting to what dice you've rolled so you know there is quite a lot of luck in this game yes you can kind of mitigate that like sometimes by getting the right colors out and you know spending the um spending your higher values in order to
draw the particular card you want out and to allocate them but you are still you know fighting through that deck and trying to get the card you want and of course if you do get a particularly strong card out your opponent is probably going to come for it and try to eliminate it from the play anyway so yeah it does have a maybe much more of a luck factor than your average fold would have the actual mechanisms themselves of the game are rather simple he said you're just rolling your your three dice here and you can spend them as you wish um you know are you going to use them for money are you going to use them for cards are you going to use your bribe card or of course are you going to use the ones you've allocated to these certain spots um and of course managing your hand is important as well because you know you won't be getting the right cards in there and you've got no limit in your hand and i do really like the fact that you have no limitations on how many cards you're going to play each round it doesn't take on your action dies it doesn't take an action at all so you are free to just replenish what you can and no it's not that hard in order to get money in the first place so i quite like the fact that even though you do lose cards quite frequently it doesn't feel like too much of a grind in order to replenish those cards and to i've said to plug those gaps in because the cars aren't overly expensive you know the most expensive ones are i think like nine or uh maybe ten coins um but most of them are rather cheap so you can actually get them played quite quickly and get them on the table without any limitations so i do like that but at the same time you do have to actually spend an action to get more cards into your hand in the first place so it is about how you're going to use them you do have some relatively interesting choices here but you are somewhat tunnel visioned because again you are limited to those
dice and there isn't much mitigation apart from the odd card that will let you reroll things or point you in different directions the replayability of arena aroma 2 is okay yes they have made an effort to um you know to do i said give you all those different paths of victory and there is quite a big deck of cards here and you know there are duplicates here but most of them are kind of unique there's not there's not a tremendous amount of the same cards in the deck so you have all these different paths of victory you can take to give you different things to try and but ultimately it does feel like the same kind of game every time you play you're gonna see the same cards come up um so i do think the kind of replayability is limited um however there are some different things here that do have kind of um you know peaks and valleys sometimes you'll find yourself just absolutely annihilating your opponent so and sometimes you'll have that really long drawn out battle where you know you just have a few points left you just need to hang in there to make sure that you're not going to run out and you can start to slowly fight back but i will say that once you are kind of in that negative and starting to feel like you're being beaten um it is hard to get out of that pit and sometimes it is really hard to make a comeback so it's not very swingy which again is either a good thing or a bad thing depending on how you look at these kind of games but yeah i think i think there is a ceiling for this one and it isn't going to stand up like is more traditional euros the components in the game are all really good i mean the cards themselves are really nicely illustrated i believe it might even be michael menzel artwork so as you'd expect the cars do look pretty great all the um well the text is very clear to
understand the iconography is good and simple and the boards here that this strip of um pip values do string together nicely and feel good quality as you'd probably expect with queen games i'm generally happy with their production and despite this one being an older game it certainly does hold up to that quality you know the money is is decent the points are decent so um a nice small little box game that holds a holds a good standard of its own production so to wrap up my thoughts on arena aroma 2 i would say that this game does what it does pretty well however what it does isn't really for me i suppose um in terms of these head-to-head dueling style games i normally do steer away from them um but you know with this one with the actual kind of spin of the steppenfeld magic on it it does certainly um take it up to a more game that's more suitable for my film for my tastes i do like the different paths to victory i like the um i like the way the dice are used i actually don't mind the fact that you can't mitigate it as much as i'd probably normally like because it is what it is is a light simple game i like the way you gain the money i like the kind of bribing mechanism it all works fine but ultimately it is a very luck dependent game and there isn't really the kind of magic there for me to keep me coming back to this one i've enjoyed my time with it and i think probably the biggest thing that puts me off it is that potential for it to take longer than it should do and i suppose when i get a game like this to the table and one of the biggest factors for me would be to you know how quick is it going to play is it going to serve a purpose to fill up you know 15 minutes of time while we're waiting for someone else to turn up to game tonight and uh this one just gonna has that
potential to go off the rails and take too long it's not always going to be the case and it probably is going to be the rarer exception where that will happen but that nagging tension the back of my head thinking you know what am i going to get into here are the cards going to come out that are going to just make the game drag and drag and drag so yeah unfortunately and this one is probably my least favorite fell game i've ever played but i'm still not saying it's bad i think it does what it does well in terms of you know putting a new spin or a euro spin on a dueling game i still rate it about you know a six out of ten again i like the variety i like the efforts to be made for the different strategies i like the different paths you could take i actually really like the um factor that you actually believe points when you um when you don't have these gaps filled it's a real unique mechanism that i haven't seen before and but yeah ultimately i think there's better two player games out there even faster two-player games out there that do more with what they have so yeah it's not going to be a big recommendation for me but if you do like your dueling games with the euro spin then give this one a look because it is again it's a decent game it does what it does well but ultimately it's not the kind of game that's going to um that's going to keep me coming back for more thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because i am a woman operation i don't get any support from publishers then please consider backing on patreon at patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much i'll see you next time