Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 18:21

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the series discussion for vagrant song this is technically our second discussion uh for it i believe we did one uh a while back uh we are how many did we do as you can see since we're doing a second discussion uh without finishing it you can probably imagine how this is going to go yeah like other other series that i've done um we played quite a few i feel like yeah enough to fight though we fought the played man twice and yeah and otherwise all the bosses have been different yeah we got one like one two three four five six seven eight probably like ten damn ten total feels like a lot it definitely they all start to kind of blur together especially when you play them as a as a campaign um where i just i i i can't i i can't do dice anymore yeah and there's just so much that hinges on how these scenarios this one was very painful yeah i mean just the the fact that you have to do the random chance of doing the search action to find the nail one specific item one specific item and then you have to roll and succeed on the action and it's just to search one place

it's it's too random yeah and the fact that it's a timer there's no strategy right it's like i hope i get lucky this run yeah yeah no that is exactly exactly correct and that's what a majority of these started boiling down to so let's let's talk about the the reason why we're done with with the series as a campaign um i mean overall this game came kind of came out of nowhere we heard about a gen con and i i love this art style this betty boop i don't know what era that was i was gonna say 20s i always feel 20s the 20s cartoon um and so the theming is really cool and at its core as a boss battler it was like i was i was really excited because i liked that concept but as we were talking about it there's never really a sense of progression as characters and maybe that's just something we've put on the game to try and get something out of it uh but ultimately every single time we finish a scenario it was kind of like oh what different skill do we want it didn't feel like anything was like escalated yeah like i don't know like like say you're protecting your town or whatever and you feel like okay the stakes are getting raised but no it's like okay we're going down a train we keep fighting dead people what is the overarching story here can i get just licks of it as i go right like little hints i mean i get we get these little events and we see stuff and we make a

decision yeah and then it's completely random and then one's gonna [ __ ] you one benefits you yeah one's kind of whatever that one's kind of neutral yeah yeah yeah so yeah so it's like i would this theme sounds like it could be really cool in a fleshed out story but you have to kind of and it's not even really that you're piecing it together to figure out the overarching it's really just kind of like ah here's a little event and i don't know like i i couldn't get into the theme like i never felt like we were saving people it was like yeah we're beating the [ __ ] out of them how is that helping like you're a good person and so i never viewed it as that as us redeeming them or sending them to heaven or whatever the [ __ ] we were doing it was just like okay well this is just a different boss like every scenario felt like what's the flavor of the month this time and after doing about 10 total scenarios it was like these kind of feel the same i wasn't like s it started losing its luster it was never like oh who's the new boss this time it's like yeah yeah and i never really felt there wasn't at least in like ktm for example like there's a give and take like how you're trying to strategize and move around the board and and use events to or use items to try and predict what the enemy's gonna do and you hit them and then they have this reaction i always love that system about kdm um and this doesn't have that it's just kind of like oh that okay you're a

bullet sponge okay i'm going to hit you for whatever for if i can [ __ ] hate you uh and then randomly draw from this tiny ass [ __ ] mouse's scrotum of a bag and then just see what he does yeah like it's and i know i [ __ ] on like madara like for its dice but this one has enough little niggles to just kind of add up yeah just it's random in the items you get it's random on what the enemy does it's random on what you get to do um it's random on the events it's random it's just it's it's random and in a game where you're trying to straight and be a boss battler that would be like if you went to play monster hunter and you just had no control over anything like oh hopefully i can hit with my weapon like uh the one we did earlier like right out the gate just oh well look it's so yeah that'd be amazing two sixes and it's like but they like it's almost like it's designed to use like they really want you to do like one action a whole bunch and not to spread out your actions so much right um because they just made it so difficult to get certain roles i mean a lot of them are 50 rolls yeah um but yeah anything that's like a five plus it's like okay you better put at least two there and then you have to get lucky yep and and the only way to mitigate your dice is through um [ __ ] specific items or skills yeah that's it i forgot there was

there weren't even there is no mitigation in this game so far short of that drink and the poison we found but at the cost of humanity right just health yep at the cost of humanity and also it's like okay and if you want to heal yourself well you have to spend actions to rummage and you're rummaging in this bag and you're like well i hope i can get something and i didn't yeah so a lot of it is you're you're putting in a lot of effort for uh dissatisfaction and the fact that it's like okay you if for my turn i have to now survive two monster turns you know before i get to go again sorry wherever i'm stuck i'm taking that much more damage whatever the random nonsense he's doing right and like in the case of this game okay there was four damage in our collective health pool yeah um so so it's almost like they and that's the thing is like we never felt like it's like when does this end like after 10 games like what i was excited for was i would have been perfectly happy with you pick a door and you go through that door and then that's the end it takes you to a different ending so that adds replayability so it's like if we pick the snow door we went through six pivot or six scenarios of a snow themed kind of thing and then it's just like at the end of that it's like oh you know here's a unique ending and then you play it again you're like well we went through the snow door last time let's do the bone orchard yeah nope it wasn't that it was oh okay you did the snow stuff pick another door and i was like that's kind of where i was really checked out because i was like

i'm another door yeah you fight do you you fight every boss and then if that's the case then you're just like well no replayability because i fought them all and it's not like they have levels so yeah there's no level progression in this game nope it's all just one i mean yeah it's very easy to balance and you keep everything the same level that that is fair the i mean the only thing that is kind of a different leveling system are the items like the junk oh gosh there's different tiers oh okay yeah um and is that it that's the only thing that has tears yeah yeah the skills are just kind of whatever um hell even the in-between stuff isn't truly random you go in sequential order um so we were on the 10th one that's actually how you know how many games you've played so if you're supposed to be going through all of these this is like kind of i feel like this is where you're supposed to have the story there's 20 games damn yeah yeah uh because like i said these are in sequential order so we were gearing up to do number ten so we played we played ten games total yeah and it's just like it gets stale yeah because it's especially this one this one was a bad one yeah and that's kind of as i just was i didn't care i was like okay all right let's see if we can find nails yeah no i felt like we're going through the motions in this one yep and i don't know because i wanted to like this game

but when you have no real overarching narrative uh and you just get little snippets of stuff from each scenario it's like i almost wish that this wasn't you know you know what this game would be how this game would be better if it wasn't a campaign yeah if you just picked out of 20 different bosses you just picked like you know like i said time for townsville tussle did it really well the nice four episode like okay this is gonna be my run yeah and go through that there's still maybe some story stuff i'm like they didn't put enough story to make it as long as they made this game right right or they didn't give you enough meat in between you know like there's no i know we always reference katie and with the campaign games because the one with the few that we finished um that's true but uh at least there you know you have the resources you have the gear building you have the progressing your settlement all that in between and this is just fight and to fight and to fight you you can buy get some very samey skills yeah if you complete the rituals i mean there's no power ups there's no core stats that are upgrading it's just the same over and over right and you made a good point last time on the rituals how it's like that's supposed to be kind of more of your theme within each individual scenario but you're like we basically get more beat up trying to complete those so the extra coins or [ __ ] we get we end up using to heal us for doing that it's really these are just the quicker way of beating the haint so it's like oh we did this boom seven humanity oh man that's that's a half itself i mean it took me three turns to

do that and i could have been hitting him for possibly three to four five damage each time right right but i don't know i i can see this game being good for a lot of people who aren't playing it all the time or yeah maybe we hit it kind of hard i mean i don't know i just i don't know i think it's like it it almost feels like it wants to have its cake and either too it wants to be a campaign game but it doesn't give the meat of it doesn't give enough yeah it needs more it needs a story or it needs more options to do during the game right and if it wants to be kind of a boss battler where you just kind of pick a boss to fight and just see how well you do well then townsfolk tussle does that or like yeah make their campaign and make it like a themed around beast these kind of dead people or like what's the story of these dead why what happened to them rather than just a whole [ __ ] variety of dead yeah this would have been yeah that's a good point this would have been really cool had it been kind of centered around that yeah getting real rich and tight and in writing because this is a really cool theme that could warrant and like you know they could have done that in a way where you still ah i mean fight them um but if there was like actually different terrain and it wasn't just some row of stuff and then yeah you got to really get into these characters and then at the end you find out that you've actually been you know helping them move on from their

death yeah but it isn't that and after 10 games i was like i just can't do it i can't i can't sit down just to hope how well we do is deterministic based off dice and how well you can draw from a bag and i mean ultimately that's kind of that's really it like i just i just can't do it anymore if i'm gonna have any type of dice i mean i already [ __ ] about that whenever we're doing madara it's just like this scenario is hard because we're rolling bad and they're rolling good uh dice are just very frustrating for me because it's like there's literally nothing i can do like it's just okay and then other times we steamroll [ __ ] oh man look at my dump and you know my triple sixes and then just boom boom boom and then i wiped up we wiped the floor with them um yeah i can't remember what we gave this the first time we we played it i don't know i think that was about two words oh he gave it a pretty decent probably i think this one's definitely soured for me too yeah yeah i because i'm i'm cool it's not even really that i'm like stretching to like come up with something like positive um i just think in the time we did the first discussion it we hadn't played multiple games so it was like three games and we're like oh this is fresh this is new um

yeah your turns are relatively simple so it's not a sprawl it's not a deep kind of system people like dice chucking like so i can see it being extremely positive but as we played seven more games and saw seven different bosses which i will commend them for it was they're all unique i like their design in terms of like the art and but it was like oh seven more of wait so i'm still the runaway like i i still have these same skills yeah uh and i still have like i still have 10 health i still have like you're you're skill it'd be cool if like you actually had a character that you can change your movement you can change your investigation it's like oh i want to be i'm the runaway i want to try and hold a [ __ ] ton of these they're over here a [ __ ] ton of those tokens um like nope to be to do that you have to be the um where is he the songsmith and the wayfarer can hold three songsmith songsmith can hold three rummage he can't move that much but he has 10 health i don't know i never really cared about the skills that were coming in either especially because they were all relatively just yeah they're pretty whatever different variants on different things there's a bunch of them and they are all different so um like and then there's some that are very

specific to you as as a character uh which i don't know if i ever got like my own like oh yeah i did who's a good boy yeah that's actually all i kept that was the only time you ever got to feel unique is whenever you got skills that were specific to you but then if you ever go wayward and you lose that then it's gone yeah it's just yeah it is what it is it's kind of sour just kind of bland sammy yep i mean playable game but probably sold fiverr yeah probably um yeah because i don't think i'll keep it yeah like yeah this is one i'm too super thrilled about i'm like i'd seen her play one of my other campaign games honestly now i've had this much experience with it just didn't have enough yeah so you're thinking a five out of ten i'm vibing five it's very playable maybe give a little more i put some work into it but it's just it's like we yeah we like you said we have we played ten games and got if if i'm feeling pretty gray you know i was just kind of like you know a lot yeah just kind of glossy eyes yeah like okay that's what we're doing all right oh yeah for the record um yes uh at 14 uh we would have picked the last door okay so we have to do all three doors do the whole game yep yep so we got about halfway

halfway through and uh hard pass i'm gonna i'm gonna stick with the five five yep um i mean that's that's average that's uh happen oh uh yeah yeah for wanting to be a whole gaming you can't just this isn't like a bike game that doesn't really option it's strictly a campaign yeah no if it was just if there's like a randomizer or something that you just pick a boss and whatever and you just fight them yeah it'd be higher but the fact i mean i guess theoretically you can do that you can just go let's do this one but at the same time you really can't because uh you would have to have skills right and stuff so no you would have to yeah it finally feels good all right well that's our thoughts on vagrant song again uh yeah we'll we'll call the series there um let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved