Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 23:00

thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games on lockdown Brian and I are doing a discussion for beer and bread uh one of the newest games by Capstone games and designer Scott alms um I knew nothing about this game at all uh didn't even know it was a two-player game didn't know anything uh because I was like beer and bread that sounds [ __ ] lame I gave it I saw it when it came out at like Miniature Market didn't I looked at the cover didn't really think about it a whole lot you know it's kind of like that and my wife actually it's like oh that looks good and you're like so then I clicked on it to look at it a little bit closer I was like Scott alms it's like oh Capstone I was like yeah so Capstone is what sold it okay for me because I was like okay I've been on a Capstone games kick the last four years so because they put out they just put something like it was cheap you know it was only like 25 bucks yeah or something for all the I mean when you get wood you know and everything it's really cheap to get it Head to Head yeah if I had known it was a two-player game with Capstone I might have looked at it because they did Watergate uh and Watergate is a phenomenal head-to-head game uh but then I would have saw the designer and have been like oh never mind uh because Scott alms is mainly a Miss of a designer for me personally he has some that I'm like oh this is good uh but for the most part I mean I think he's the one behind all the tiny epic he is and then he also did

uh warp sedge warps Edge which was good he did the dragons Road games which are good didn't he do no and he did hear his Lander and see I'm thinking of the other another big game that he didn't think that he wouldn't put that yeah but he did the heroes of Lander and see the big one so but uh anyway this game is great this is very very smart uh of a design like um lately my tastes have been I've been I've been more wanting to just focus on games that I play you know so whenever I play new games that are coming in it's like ah this is good Not Gonna Keep it I don't know in this game this is yours but this is one I'm like well I'm gonna get a copy uh you did tell me you finally got what they're like we need to keep a tally this is like the second game you showed me and I'm like oh uh I have one minor gripe which we talked about whenever it happened in the game we just played and it's not that big of a deal it's just a weird design decision in my head uh but I can still kind of justify it uh but overall like I I don't really have any issues with this game I think the flow of it is really well done it's a different style of head-to-head of resource management the abilities you get are really cool and it's not long like that's the thing it's like sure I guess the abilities

aren't like superb you're not getting game busting uh upgrades but you still get upgrades that are cool and unique in the length of the game and it's a nice head to head like you're not being vicious like you have to share extra Resources with the person and they get a choice you know so it's like yeah it's got to flooding with [ __ ] and be like okay thanks I was getting gather resources but I guess I can send a bunch of insects over here foreign

is there's two phases there's the the yeah I was gonna say fruitful and Bounty so I'm frown tea uh yeah the fruitful phase and then the dry phase and in the fruitful phase you're passing cards so you're doing kind of like a draft uh not quite akin to Seven Wonders you're not building a hand the other one seven wonders you pick one plate one no you build your hand do you I don't think you might pick one player one oh yeah because you always found one picked it played it and passed it you just you'd always get oh no you are right yeah so it's pretty much it goes strong I played something wonderful uh yeah okay so then Seven Wonders where yeah you pick one and then play one but then you pass it so when you're using your cards to get resources um if you're trying to get resources for a card that is in your hand you're hoping it comes back to you but that's when your opponent can be like oh I see that's what you're trying to get so I'm just gonna use that for either its ability or for its resources and even then that doesn't bother me it doesn't bother me like it does in seven wonders because a lot a lot of it is it doesn't really feel hateful because for the most part your opponent is gonna want resources or the upgrades right and also the ability the ways to build these they're they're not drastically different a lot

of them so like you can even if that one card goes yeah chances are there's something you'll be able to build yeah well actually there was a perfect example in the game we just played where I had a bunch of rye um and I think a one water and one something else and I was building for a particular card but then the cards you handed me I had resources for them as well I'm like oh okay well never mind I don't I don't need to wait uh but that would be the only thing I can see of someone being like I'm just gonna but at least it's like I'm getting a bunch of resources versus I'm just getting one coin don't want you to have this one coin really one coin just to make sure I don't get a card um what do you think I like it yeah yeah yeah I really enjoy it um the multi-use cards having three things you can do with each card um be able to use as an upgrade produce it or gain the resources yeah I also like the way you can stack how the resources stack yeah it kind of makes you think because when you put down you get everything above it too so it kind of you could really flood your your storage really quick yeah if you do that but which in turn makes you have to share with your your neighbor your neighbor so it's so interesting yeah it's it's pretty neat and then be able to trade the cards you know in that in the dry phase since you're not passing that kind of is a weird way of passing because if you trade then oh I might like the one you put up there you know it's there's a lot

of little elegant things to this that makes it just awesome you know like um you know and we'll probably talk about that what I figure what you're going to talk about hearing a little bit about the um cleanup and stuff but but uh you know you you get those uh you get those out of there to make room for new stuff when you play an upgrade so you kind of have to take that into account and yeah well because there was one time the reason at the very end when I grabbed the sweet it was to do a it was because one of my cards was a bread card that required weed and I'm like oh I only have a room for one bread and I already had one there and I'm like ah I didn't need that wheat after all right so then I try the course correct uh because the scoring in this game is your lowest score out of two um uh between two cities does that between your two cities whichever has the lowest scores the one is your final score uh so the way that you manage that is also pretty interesting like I had more bread uh than I did water but my water one had a nine in it so I was trying to like compensate for that and I'm also interested in it's like hmm how much of my scoring came into effect from there because you gave me way more resources than I gave you it's like did that take I'm sure that probably did come into effect I'm sure it'd be nice to be like to calculate and be like which how many of my cards did I score

based off the resources you gave me probably two of them I think yeah because I remember you gave me a water and I'm like oh I don't have to use this card to get a water anymore thanks a lot that you made it an upgrade yeah I chose to make it an upgrade instead yeah uh but yeah so let's go over my and it's it's such a we it is a negative when I think I have a way to justify it I also do too um because I said it's not that big of a deal but I wouldn't call it a nitpick I actually do find it because in the game you pay resources to store cards in your Brew in your Brewery or your bread now you produce them you produce them yeah the way I was thematically putting it was they were in order being made so it's like this is the bread order this is the beer order uh and then they sit there so and each of them can only hold one ignoring any upgrades that you might have so then one of your actions so the card is going to be used for resources for the orders or for an upgrade uh if you do an upgrade that's how they come off into your scoring phase Elysium other where it's like okay now I'm it's not quite like Elysium because you don't get anything for them but it's like hey now they're in my scoring pile and you do that the entire game except at the very end anything that's produced freely comes off and my only justification is because of the nature of it being a friendly game well that's why they're not trying to

punish anyone I think it's a Viewpoint because I think how it needs to be looked at is as soon as you produce it they're scored if you've got those points right there you just had in order to get more points you have to make a move to get I mean I think that's the way they're going with it because I think I think once you produce them those points are yours if they if they if you left them there they whole game six points that's just sitting there you're just not producing anything else I guess you know I just I just think it's weird that it's like the entire game you have to actively use a card one of your precious five actions to pull them off to start producing more um that it's like if someone because of the entire time for the final fall phase I I was like meticulously planning the five cards I had to be able to build the beer that I wanted and then pull them both off and it's like oh no you can just do that you can just put them all there and the end of the game just make them and put them there and it's like well I kind of feel like there should be some punishment if you mismanage your car count maybe they were trying to do away with any Randomness because the beer and bread cards are shuffled together yeah maybe they were trying to yeah you do kind of punish yourself if you just leave it there though and don't pull it off because you're not school you do points you know I mean you have to kind of pull them off too yeah but there are upgrades that like your Brewery and stuff pulled more so you theoretically could get those and then just like have three and three in each and then just be like I don't know how

many there are because I saw this one's as a beer one but I don't know how many there was a bread one for sure yeah but I don't think there's like enough to make it like where it's like funny these three cards funny enough or you may hold one additional bread card in your bakery I mean maybe that's a different strategy yeah you just actually get those upgrades to hold them up and at the very end of the game you just pull it's just that's a lot of resources though I mean you can only hold that's like your whole game it's like literally just trying to stand back most of these bigger ones are six seven resources and you can only hold I mean I know there's extra ways but you only have nine yeah spots to start off the game so it's like there's ways they'll get around there there's six rounds five five actions each so 30. you get 30 actions I'm not saying again it's it's just weird of of kind of uh the entire game you don't get anything for free well I guess you get resources you don't get that Action for free until the very end where it's like here you go it's not that big of a deal it is just something that I was like oh oh okay because I mean it didn't matter uh in terms of scoring but it's like oh hey cool I can just build this and my only thing is they didn't want it to be that kind of like you know [ __ ] you at the very end sorry you got screwed over by only ever getting beer cards uh which I thought that was also going to be a problem when you Shuffle the beer and bread I'm like oh someone's just gonna get handed all beer cards but because you're passing yeah it all mixes

up it does I never once felt like no we both were like where's the wheat yeah I finally got them like I don't even need it I just like putting it yeah that is the interesting part is when you are passing resources you get to choose what you're handing over and because I was what what was a big thing and whether it still wouldn't have made a difference it would have made it closer was because this is the one I needed the week for um because this is the only this is the only bread card I had in my hand gotcha see so like if I needed that's because everything else was beer and that wasn't gonna help my score because I knew that all I had was these breads so I had 10 points no matter what yeah yeah so it's like I was wanting that but then there was no wheat so I just like it's done yeah I guess there's not there's not a lot of ways if you're not getting any cards that give you a particular resource that can happen there are abilities and stuff that do kind of help mitigate that but there you can get locked in a way where it's like I can't I can't get this resource at the end of the day it's a 30 to 45 minute game yeah I mean especially when you know how to play it you could probably whip this out in no time yeah you know and and stuff so yeah because I mean it's really fast if you had gotten that one it would have been 22 to 70.

yeah I would have made it more right I just couldn't I could never get the wheat to do that and then I had a handful of beer this was all the beer I had in my hands so much yeah it was just like so it has end game scoring like that was what I was planning on uh was banking on mitigating because you had way more orders done I only had five uh you had what seven yes it's seven complete so you had two more orders than I did but then I got like extra points to help spread the love where it's like oh okay if my bread is higher uh then I can put some dump some more points into my beer to make it to kind of close and close that Gap I always love that mechanism of the lower of your two scores because then you have to kind of try and balance uh which balanced as all things should be damn it uh but yeah this one it's just it's just it's Unique I can't think of any game that plays like this and I had to head Style that isn't like some grandiose Resource Management game uh small footprint with extremely clean play style and if you have any questions on the abilities yeah it has all everything and yeah all the ability upgrades are listed out in the back with examples and I mean the turn the whole phases of the game is Just simple yeah simple to learn uh but still

deep in in strategy where you don't feel like you're going through the motions it doesn't I mean I wouldn't consider this a filler game because it's like 45 minutes but some people might like like 30 minutes might be their gap of or their ceiling of filler but I'm like this is like in the same like Realm as like games like Calico and stuff like that where you're thinking the entire time but you're not overthinking right you know like I don't I don't know I like who will I want to do like because you had a massive resource engine I just went all in on end game so there's a lot of different strategies so maybe there could be a little bit of AP for for people that are prone to that with this because you have to look at those handed cards each time to decide yeah there's three choices per card and then five cards to start with I mean yeah you know but and then the cards they use as resources are the ones you pull back uh in the next phase and then you just get kind of some new cards yeah so it's like hmm But I mean you could theoretically play some cards as resources but then plan for the next episode that's what I was trying to do but I couldn't I wasn't getting there right yeah but yeah I was trying to do resources and I was looking at the I wasn't doing that at all like I was using them as resources for what I was using in that round and then I was hoping yeah resources I had I'd be able to you know get cards and be like oh hey but then the trading element is so nice too I think I traded for resources once

but I was like oh that's a perfect end game a scoring ability that I could use yeah I'm I'm very very pleased with this one I like it a lot um do you have any negatives any issue I honestly don't I mean and you know go really quick I had a thought on the AP part of it the deck's not very big either so so once you've played it enough times and you know the cards I mean it's not like yeah there's seven there's there's seven cards left in the deck uh by the time you're done uh but then just the sheer amount of Randomness that you're getting each each and like the thing about it is like yeah we were we were both wanting wheat uh but we're really only wanting them because I we weren't really using wheat for anything like a lot of mine this is the only car that I have that uses wheat yeah it's my my bread card at the end is the one I was needing yeah needing it the most but but you can build upgrades based off of hey I'm just gonna always generate any type of resource when you brew beer or break bread you may spend two weeks as either a hop or a rye like I had I had a bunch of ways to get rye and that's where a lot of my scoring came from was from generating Rye it's Scott you you've got you got a solid one here would I like to see an expansion just because I like upgrades and more variety

sure I think I think this could probably be like a like a small mini backup or just for more cards yeah just a little bit more cards yeah it doesn't need like another whole thing but I mean actually the games I've played of Scots lately have been have been good I stay away from Tiny epic I don't like any of them um but his his uh galaxies is the only one I like uh his Dragons Were Almanac his Almanac games are really good so I enjoyed both of those and then and then this one so yeah if you like head to head if you like Watergate and you like that I mean they don't play anything close to each other but if you like that head-to-head kind of like I wouldn't really say this is getting to the head of your opponent Watergate is kind of like that but if you're into that back and forth uh kind of style then I would highly recommend this I think the name is dumb it makes sense it makes sense but this is not people aren't running to the show to look at beer and bread like I do like the cover the cover is like it's nice this is nice this is a nice peaceful game the the board is nice the the feeling you get when playing this it's not like oh I'm gonna [ __ ] you over I'm taking all the Hops they could have done like what uh what's that what was that one damn game that uh the fair uh the park remember the one that we didn't like the not fun fair but it was

unfair I'm like unfair where you go and screw over yeah you just shot down Europe like that could be an expansion remove all the resources steal the resources kill his cattle what cow tipping yeah yeah they could have done that but no just the the the the rule of I'm getting resources I can't hold it here you go yeah is nice and you can be like ah no thanks or you can do what you did and you're like oh you're all full over there well they're all going away because the one rule is I can't choose to get rid of this stuff if you're passing it over which again thematically is kind of weird because well if you're giving it to me it's like you know I don't really need all that wheat over there yeah I'll take what you got but mechanically I see why uh otherwise it wouldn't really be a head-to-head game to be like yeah let's just all let's make orders together yeah it's like why don't we just it's Cooperative so they I think he struck a pretty good balance here I think so um all right on scale one to ten what are you giving no beer and bread oh gosh um because I like seven wonders so much I know this is gonna get played a bunch uh because Amy hasn't played this yet um I would say I ate five eight point eight eight point five yeah I'm a little bit higher I'm actually giving this a nine I I really like it and again because my

taste of games has slightly changed in that I don't want to crunch over games like I got rid of all my vital games which obviously nothing close to this but it's like I still want to strategically think but it's like well I don't really want to play A Garfield game head to head oh but this one still gives me that same itch and I can play other games after afterwards so yeah and it's just yeah you could see he took ideas from other stuff the between two cities of lowest score the drafting from Seven Wonders the resource management nothing here is like unique but it's all twisted in a different way that makes it feel different so I would agree yeah uh well that's our thoughts on beer and bread let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe never wonderful with every time I play this for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved