Everdell Emerland Review: Diemands, Sappheirs & Emerlands
Transcript
mrk everybody welcome back to the Dice Tower. My name is Zee Garcia.
And I'm Chris Yi.
Today we're going to be taking a look at the latest in the ever expanding line of Everdell games. This is Everdell Emerland, not Emerald, Emerland. Uh and this one has us going to a different corner of the map in Everdell. Uh exploring kind of has a like an Indiana Jones-esque vibe to it where you're going to be going to different locations, collecting resources, spending those resources to deploy cards, also exploring this temple that has you advancing and collecting victory points from that, but generally doing the same things you do in the other Everdell games, playing cards, getting victory points, creating little combinations. I'm going to go ahead and show you what this looks like on the table. I'm not going to go over every little thing cuz there's too many, but give you an idea. And then we'll come on back after that. We'll tell you what we thought of this one.
The game is in many ways similar to other Everdell games, but I'll go ahead and pretend you don't know anything about that and I'll just kind of give you a quick overview. So the game's going to be played over several seasons. At the end of all of those seasons, we're going to figure out who has the most victory points. And you'll be getting victory points from cards you've played in front of you. You'll be getting them from different uh artifacts. You'll be getting them from tokens. Uh you'll be getting them from a few different things. And so there is uh player aid that everybody's going to have in their color and I'll kind of talk you through the things you may do on your turn. You begin with some amount of cards in your hand and in this game every card is double-sided with a basic side and an upgraded side. The basic side has this sort of dark green banner on the bottom that indicates what's on the other side. So that's one way you can tell that you're facing a card correctly. It'll begin like this and the ones in the center here will begin in the same way. And so on my turn I am going to begin the game with two workers, two helpers, as well as one of these Everybody has that. I to the first thing I may do is place a worker.
Placing a worker entails taking one of these fellows, sending them out here to one of these locations they can go to and gaining something from that, collecting some resources. The different types of locations uh have a different background on them and that denotes the kind of thing you can send there, how many you can send there, that sort of thing. So these basic green ones, if there is no worker there from anyone, I can send one of my workers and gain the corresponding goodies. So I can send uh this guy out here and get two of these figs. I can also, if I want to, send him with one of these helpers and double the reward. I would get four figs from that, okay? Uh so let's say I do that, get my two figs, put that in my supply, I am good. The next player would go. If the next player also wants figs, uh this space is occupied, but they could go there with a helper, which now behaves as a sort of liaison, and they would get two figs. Be aware the helper is not doubling their reward, it's just allowing them to go here in this case because it's occupied. Though they could go there, bring along a little helper that they need to bring as a liaison just to allow them to go there, and then bring along another one to double the reward. You're allowed to do that if you want to. Uh and so that's what those spaces behave like. The ones here with the stone background of which this is an overlay for three players specifically by the by the way, but there's some that are preprinted, that means everybody can only go there
once for the entire season, whereas these I could go there again, though I need to bring a liaison just like everybody else, all right? So these you can only go there once. The ones with a dirt background are specifically only for the little guys, just the little helpers, and people could go there, multiple helpers, but one per turn only, one per action only, okay? [snorts] So that's what these are for. And all of these then are going to have different benefits, gaining the different resources you see around the outside, gems, marble, figs. We've got these harps, we've got bamboo, we have leaves. All of these are costs that are going to be funneled into various things, but largely cards that you're going to be building, all right? So those are the the places. If you go to these two right here, you're going to get dice. These are rolled and placed in these spots, and they'll have a, you know, a varying reward, right? So if I go here, for example, with this guy, I could choose to take one marble and maybe one leaf.
Sometimes these will have different rewards like gaining you straight up victory points or gaining you cards, that sort of thing. So there you go. That's what those are there. And that's the first action, place a worker with or without a helper. You can also place a helper that I've already explained in these that have a dirt background. You can play a card on your turn. When you play a card, it can come from your hand or it can come from the plateau, which is the center of the table here. You're going to pay the cost for that. You're going to deploy that card in front of you. You have a limit on the table of 12 cards. You have a hand limit of six. The limit on the table could grow based on something you can do in game. So if I want to put out this fruit market, it specifically says the fruit market has a type of card here. It has a cost of two bamboo, one leaf, and then it's worth a victory point. It is a building.
I am going to when I deploy it because of this card type, I am going to immediately get one fig. Now later in the game, I might be able to upgrade this card. When I upgrade it, I'm going to flip it over to the other side. And on the other side, I will immediately get two figs again because of the card type, and it is worth more victory points as well, okay? There's several different card types. I'm not going to go over them all, but they will would behave differently based on the card type it is. And so if I want to play this, obviously I would have had to buy now collect a couple of bamboo and a leaf, but if I did have those things, I would put them back and I would deploy this card in front of me and I would immediately get my fig there. So, that's one thing you can do is play a card. You can use an artisan card. An artisan card is a type of card that you can tuck other cards under. Like this card right here has uh something it would give me if I spend from my hand a card, tuck it under there, trigger this ability. It has a number and an arrow that lets me know how many times I may tuck and gain the reward. In this case, two times I may do this in the game. So, that's uh the uh artisan cards. I could excavate with my archaeologist. For that, we would look up here and you are going to I'll go ahead and grab this actually and kind of kind of bring it in here.
Uh this one, if you uh want to excavate, you are going to spend in this case to go from this step to this step. You spend any one resource and you have to discard any number of cards, but at least one. You would take your figure, you would go to this area right here. If you're the first one there, you're going to get some victory points and then based on the number of cards you discarded, you're going to draw artifacts from a bag and keep one, throwing the rest back in. So, if you discard four cards, you get to look at four and keep the one you like best. Uh these are also tied to the seasons, so you cannot go ahead of what season you are currently in. Uh but if you get to places earlier, you're going to get more victory points than if you go later. You might not get any at all.
And so that's the way this works and they have increasing uh discard requirements for you to move ahead. There's also this at the very end of the game. If you make it into one of these areas, you're going to get some victory points simply by going in and taking the highest victory points available uh or leftover at the end of the game. So, that's the way this is going to work out and that's something you can do on your turn as long as you don't go like said ahead of the season, you are currently in. Uh so at the beginning of the game, you can just go to that first spot. And so that's excavating with an archaeologist. And then the last thing you can do is simply prepare for the next season. If you do that, you are going to reclaim all of your workers back into your supply. We are going to look at the bottom of the board here. And if you're going into from summer into uh uh fall, or I guess from yeah, you're going into this first season here, you're going to get a little helper.
You get another one of these. You are going to If you're the first person to do it, you're going to reroll these four dice and place them back anywhere. It doesn't really matter. And then you are going to retrigger all the cards of that type. In my case, if I had that card I showed you earlier, well, I get another fig uh as listed there. And then everybody else goes. Just because I went into this season does not mean I'm done playing. I can just immediately basically I'm in the next season. And it does not mean I have to wait for everybody else to catch up to me. Uh I can just My next turn will be simply putting out a worker again or deploying a card or whatever. Eventually the other players will get there as well. Uh each of the seasons is going to have a few things that trigger. In this season here in winter, you are going to um you're going to get a new worker and you're going to get a gem. And the first player to do this is going to reroll the dice again, but also clear the uh the middle here and replenish it.
And then lastly for the final season here, spring, you are going to get two more workers, another helper rerolling things, retriggering these green cards. All right? So that is basically what's going on. There's a few other things I have not talked about, leveling cards up and the way you do that, playing cards for free by using these harps and deploying them onto some cards to let you play a critter from your hand for free. The two types of cards being buildings and critters, and they have a symbol right here to assist you with that. Uh so you can use these to let you play some things freely only a few times in the game. And then also these cards right here are going to denote some end game scoring. You might be getting these and getting some victory points at the end of the game based on things you have, things you've acquired, what have you. So there you go. As you can tell, a lot of moving parts, a lot of things going on, but that should be enough to give you an idea. Let's go ahead and go back up top.
So one uh thing we're going to be bringing that's different uh between the two of us to the table here is is sort of familiarity with Everdell games, right Chris? So you've played Everdell, the original.
Played the original
And you play like Everdell, My Little Everdell, whatever they call that one now.
I think they rebrand Welcome to, very confusing.
yeah. Um
Those are the only two that I've played actually.
Yeah, and I've played I think all of them and the expansions, which I have not
some of the expansions, not every expansion.
Yeah, yeah. So so I played a lot of Everdell stuff, okay? And I'll just go ahead and say that I like this one all right, but it is certainly not my favorite. In fact, of all of the main Everdell games I don't know how else to call that. Like I think Everdell Duo is great. Actually it's one of my favorite Everdells. And the Kids one is okay. Of the big ones I think this is my least favorite. That's not to say I don't like it, but I think it's my least favorite. And the reason for that is because I find this one in many aspects overwrought. It feels like it is a game that was developed, designed and developed by the designers in a bubble. In a setting in which the only game that exists is Everdell.
And they have continued to iterate on just Everdell. There doesn't feel like there's a lot of influences in here from other games and nothing's been dropped. There's nothing from Everdell that they've kind of gone, you know, we've done it six or five or six times now. Maybe we can remove that aspect of Everdell and explore new things, new ideas. The new explorations are there, but nothing's gone away.
I and I see several side steps. So rather than uh a specific building saying, well, you can recruit now this character, this one specific character for free,
Yeah.
you know, I see like, oh, okay, any building can recruit any character for free by using this new harp mechanism.
Yes.
And it's kind of this side step, but also yes, it does kind of feel like more. It feels like a little extra on there. Every every card is double-sided. Every card can upgrade. I think that's really neat.
Yes.
But that's on top of uh and also in conjunction with this building has to be upgraded in order to place harp to recruit any character for free.
Yeah.
And that character comes out upgraded.
Well, I think some of the clunkiest stuff in the original Everdell was a building can have you deploy a specific character that lives in that building. Thematically beautiful, mechanically kind of a pain. But they did away with that immediately. Like almost the very first game that came out after Everdell did away with that and they had a very similar idea where you can spend a thing to to put a character out for free from any building. Um so they've done that. Now new, brand new, brand new things in here are the two the double-sided cards thing. They haven't done any of that before.
Mhm.
But it comes with a lot of rules overhead because every card type that was in Everdell and the spin-offs is still in here plus one new card type which you can tuck cards under to trigger. That's brand new.
Yeah, the kind of wingspanny feeling one, right?
right. But then also you have so you have to know how they all work. This card triggers when you play it on the table once and then never again. This one triggers when you play it, but then also when you change seasons. This one's just end game scoring. This one's a modifier to other actions. Great. Also, you need to explain to me how they all trigger when they're upgraded. Oh, the green cards, they'll trigger again when you upgrade them. It's like so they all
The red ones which are worker placement spots trigger for anyone who is on there when it's upgraded, but it doesn't uh it doesn't activate when it's upgraded for the owner until someone places a worker there.
Yes.
Yeah, there's there's like a new layer of rules kind of you know slathered right on top of Everdell's not a light game, but it is delightfully approachable.
Right, I agree. It's a game that goes hand in hand with this look, you know, this amazing look. And now this one, Everland, I feel finally pushes it cuz they've been toying with that feeling of man, there's a lot going on. I think Everland is the first one that finally goes pushes this game onto the kind of heavy game playing field. There's a lot of moving parts in this game now.
There are there are a lot including the new construct in this one being that like adventure, that spelunking kind of track.
Yeah.
You move forward, but it has restrictions based on season, how far you can explore down the thing. And so it's visually represented, I think, very odd. Like I both
about the 3D thing?
Yeah, the 3D structure.
which I did not show the 3D thing because I can't really show that from a top-down camera, but there's a cardboard contraption in this like in the other ones and it's yeah, it's a mess. It's an absolute mess to put together. And putting it back in the box, by the way, there's an page of instructions as to how you lay the cardboard pieces out. It's a puzzle.
It is almost indecipherable. The the like I was like, oh good, there's a packing up guide. And I was doing it, following it along, and I got to one of the layers of and I was like, well, I think I think it'll all function more or less at this point, you know. Uh but the the construct is not just like the tree where you can say I don't want to build the thing and and you just have a flat market. It's mechanically very relevant in this version.
is. They do include a flat cardboard thing which you saw, but it takes a big hit graphically. It's like really it looks ugly and doesn't give you any idea that these people are going into a temple. It loses that completely.
It And so it's weird, right? Because you either
have that, and it's good, it's more functional, or you have the 3D construct, which is harder to view from
anywhere.
Yes, yeah. If you're if you're like soling it front on, you're like good.
Yes.
But it also has restrictions based on what season you're in,
Mhm.
where how far you can go, and sometimes it's printed on a flat part on the top. Sometimes it's printed on the side. It's bizarre. It is thematic. It is cool. And I And I see that it's going to sing for the people who are like, oh, yes, like spelunking going down into this ancient temple.
Yeah.
It's It is a nice driver for you to want to push into future seasons earlier,
Right, right.
if not a little bit inelegant of a way to encourage that.
Yeah. Yeah. No, I agree with that. Um to me, this game kind of feels like the Everdell for Everdell, not just lovers, but like Everdell collectors almost.
People who want Yeah, just a a bigger, heavier Everdell. Now, that is my Like I said, I haven't played any of the little steps in between. This was a pretty big leap forward. This feels I would agree with you in kind of in that heavy game space.
So what did you like? Tell me some of the things you enjoyed in this one coming from, like you said, just the original to suddenly boom Everland.
I really do like all the new card Like the the ways to use cards. If you want to explore on the track, you have to discard cards, and you can discard multiple to kind of get more control of your luck as you dig through tiles in this bag.
Yes.
Uh I think that it it This is very much like a multi-use
The cards have a multi-use feel, yeah.
Yeah, because you can tuck them for those bonus actions. You can uh discard them to go exploring into the castle. Every one of castle The The temple. Every one of them is double-sided. I really love the card play in this one, which the card play is one of the strong points of Everdell to begin with. And so this is that almost times three, it feels like.
Yeah.
That's probably my favorite addition and my favorite difference in this.
Yeah,
there's a lot of card play for sure. Um and and card variety, interesting ideas within the cards, yes, for sure. I like the idea that um you have a board limit, you have a very small hand limit now of six cards, which is very tiny.
Yeah.
But you also have a board limit of 12 cards. Unfortunately, that that brings along more rules because now that size can grow based on something you've gathered. I forget why, but like
The the realms end of game scoring cards give you another slot.
they let you have more than 12. You'll hit you'll quickly hit 12 too, so you definitely want to go into that. Um yeah, it's it's tricky, it's thinky. It doesn't feel as sort of restrictive as the last one. I think it was called Silver Frost.
Mhm.
It was a where things would snow over and you you were kind of clawing your way through feeling like you couldn't get enough. Like the resources were limited. It was hard to it was hard to make progress. And a lot of people didn't like that feeling. I liked it all right. I I thought it was an interesting spin on like it simulated this world very well. My issue with this one one of one of my kind of concerns is the it's the opposite. It's almost too much of an abundance.
What do you
of of resources. There's an abundance of workers, two worker types they can go together or separately. That means different things. It means different things if you're there first or later. Um abundance I think is a good word and I don't mind the idea of abundance, but it also it it goes too far, I find.
I was going to say I do really enjoy the two different classes of workers, your main worker and your helpers,
Yeah.
but it is about it it makes the simple action of place a worker in a spot about three more times complicated, more complex because certain spots have restrictions, certain of the spots they use they can help or they the little ones can go on their own. Do you do you enjoy that part? And then as a separate question, do you feel like it's worth the rules overhead?
I like the feeling of
a guy out with his little helper. It's a cute theme also, but the idea of going somewhere and I'm like, "Oh, I get four figs for going there." That feels like, yeah, look at me. I'm going to be able to do all the things. I also like the idea if you don't get blocked out of a place, I can still go there. And if you went already, I'm like, well, I can spend this little guy and go there and do the thing. I'm just not sure if I like the idea of the helpers have their own worker placement spots that they just go to by themselves. And I'm not sure it was necessary to have a whole second worker placement type, you know? Could this not have been achieved by saying if a worker is somewhere and you still want to go there, you have to discard a card to go there or something? Something that already exists within the structure of Everdell. You know what I mean?
Yeah. Yeah, and that's the and I agree. This kind of circles back to earlier point. It feels like Everdell with nice new additions. Good, you want that from a new version, but without really removing anything to compensate for adding more stuff to it.
Yes, right. Um and it's still at its core Everdell, which I like Everdell. It's fascinating card play. It looks gorgeous. The resources in this one, this is the deluxe, like the collector's edition, so I don't know what they look like you know otherwise. They're fantastic resources. Every single one of them is a banger. Marble looks amazing. The leaf, they nailed that one with the rubbery feel. The figs, everything is like just tactile and from a tactile point of view is is spectacular. The look is lovely, you know? It's very captivating, lush. The whole thing looks great. It's just really I don't want to say slog. That might be a little too strong, but it it approaches that feeling of just everything is everything. There's so much to parse. There's so many bits and pieces and moving parts. Um I barely even showed or I I don't think I even showed, reaching into the bag and pulling out tokens and then you get to keep one and throw them back.
The abundance here is wild.
There's a lot and and there's no individual part I dislike. I think that the
The sum of the parts is kind of what is too much, right? Yeah.
Yeah. In in a way that I still really enjoy. Like I have tremendous amounts of fun with this, but I also know it's at its core Everdell. And that's not a bad thing. It's fine to have a more beefed up version of a game. But it's funny that there are so many decisions that make this feel like more game, like a heavier game. And then there's little things that feel disconnected to that like, reaching into the bag and pulling out artifacts.
The luck of that, yeah.
The luck of that that can be worth one point and a bonus up to seven points.
Yeah.
I'm sorry. I don't Like those bonuses can be important because they can help you then play a character and you know, get the little resources bump you need.
Yeah.
But I want seven points
Right. Right.
every time over, you know, two points in a in a fig.
This Everdell, maybe in a bubble I'd give it a higher score, but I can't imagine reaching for this one when I have several of the other options available to me that are beautiful as well, have captivating card play as well. Um, and are easy to get to the table. That's the thing. You know, they're just going to be easier to get to the table. They're going to be easier to teach, certainly to play, to engage with. Um, I'm going to come down I'm going to come down at a six on this one. Um, I like it. I would play it. It's just I'm never going to reach for this Everdell over the other ones. The other ones are just better games, I think. Um, even the first one and I think the first one by now has a lot of flaws that have been fixed, you know. Um, especially without expansions. There's a lot of things in there that just feel clunky now. But even that one, I think I would still reach for that one before I reach for this one. So, six for me.
That's not a damnation, but it is certainly it suffers the comparison.
And I think I have less to compare it to. So, I come at this and just kind of like, ooh, I have Everdell and then I have heavy Everdell. It's kind of how I look at this. And and I like I still enjoy all of this. I look at the sum of its parts and I think there's a bit much going on. That mechanism feels a little swingy, but you know, does it affect the score a ton at the end? Well, well, there's lots of ways to get points.
Yeah.
I I enjoy everything that it's doing. And so lest it sound like we complained the whole time, uh I I do think that the core loop of this game is solid. So, I'm still giving this a 7.5.
Yeah.
I I can recommend it, especially if you are someone who says, uh you know, Everdell is maybe a scooch simple for you and you wish there's a little more game to you know, to it. There is.
Yeah, for sure. I think you'll like it. Yeah.
Yeah, absolutely. Managing the two different types of workers is a really fun puzzle. Managing the exploration, the timing, should I move to the next season or should I eke out everything I can now, you know, before kind of advancing forward? That's good. You know, I don't like
up cards just feels great. Being like, boom. You know what I mean?
Absolutely. Yeah, yeah. And the fact that there are ways to get cards out on the advanced side immediately, it's a bit tricky to do it, but you can. And so, is that worth it? I like those I like analyzing those decisions. I think it's a solid solid game. I think it's a good addition of a game that I'm already familiar with, but yeah, it's it's still a bit clunky and it feels a little bit much for for what's in there.
All right. Well, there you go, folks. That is Everdell Everland. Thank you for tuning in and checking this one out with us everybody. Uh my name is Z Garcia.
And I'm Chris Yi.
Enjoy traveling into the temple.
Hey, uh thanks for watching another video here on The Dice Tower. Uh we really appreciate you stopping by and checking our things out. Thanks so much for joining us today. And hey, if you really like what we're doing here at the Dice Tower, then there are different ways to support the Dice Tower. One of those ways is through Patreon. We have links in the description to this video. And we have links to lots of other things we do down there, so definitely check it out. But either way, we're glad you watched us. Tell your friends about the Dice Tower. Until next time though, I'm Tom Vassos and I hope you enjoyed this video.