Skip to main content
Loading video...

Whitehall Mystery | Board Game Masterpieces

Transcript 22:17

hello i'm adam from no rolls bard and welcome to another episode of board game masterpieces now fair warning for anyone who doesn't like loud noises uh feel free to skip to this time code because i want to talk about tension prolonged mental and physical strain expectation of something bad stretching that expectation out never sure of when the explosion will come as it stretches thinner and thinner until the moment where it bursts and startles both you and me some not all but some humans crave tension the compulsion of fear

the adrenal spike when you survive if you survive horror movies thrillers that hurt extreme sports humans enjoy flirting with the worst case scenario the gap between success and failure life and death getting away with murder or getting caught scare the [ __ ] out of me board games are often presented to the mainstream as a light social experience either the traditional shot of the family gathered around a monopoly board and faking smiles or people laughing up kidneys are cards against humanity but actually board games are really really good at creating tension social deduction games like werewolf or blood on the clock tower shreds your nerves as your lies start to unravel co-ops like pandemic give you itchy skin as you flip over a card praying that it's not an epidemic and then there's this this little thing one of the globally understood symbols of board gaming rolling a die creating an isolated moment between success and failure but i want to talk to you about possibly the best type of board game for creating tension one of my favorite types of board games in fact hidden movement games not just that my favorite hidden movement game which is whitehall mystery

that bloody hell this was the wrong costume to establish heading into summer hidden movement games can simply be described as games where you have to catch someone that you cannot see on the board with that character's movement being recorded in a secret fashion the genre first rose to prominence with scotland yard released in 1983 which saw mr x travel secretly around the streets of london by bus taxi or tubers detectives tried to catch up with him it's not the most oversubscribed style of board game but there have been other notable ones escape the aliens from outer space rules we covered the jaws video in a recent list fury of dracula's really popular and then there's letters from white chapel released in 2011 it's a game designed by gabrielle mari and john lucas santo pietro which saw a bunch of bobbies team up to try and catch jack the ripper now lettuce from white chapel was good i owned it for a long time i liked playing it but it was lumpy it had some issues it was about half an hour longer than it should have been so six years later in 2017 the same designers released a kind of sequel kind of unofficial reboot of the game trimmed down in both gameplay rules and box size they released whitehall mystery and whitehall mystery is one of my favorite games ever made this this is whitehall mystery and it's a relatively modest production small-ish bored compared to some not that many bits but trust me don't turn your back

on this little killer whitehall mystery and letters from whitechapel are linked in some sort of from hell cinematic universe and while on the surface they look pretty identical no no no whitehall mystery kills whitechapel stone dead murders it leaves it with its guts over its shoulder in an alleyway and speaking of horrible imagery sorry about that here's a bit of history whitehall mystery is named after a famous unsolved london murder where different body parts of a dismembered corpse were found scattered in different places around the whitehall area in 1888 an arm in pimlico a torso and whitehall a leg several streets away it's part of a series of four murders actually from 1887 to 1889 collectively known as the thames torso murders all linked by different body parts of victims being separately discovered scattered around parts of london along the river thames all four murders are unsolved and in all four murders several body parts were discovered but never ahead just as some ripperologists linked the much more well-known jack the ripper murders to these cases because they happened at roughly the same time so have the designers linked whitehall mystery with letters from whitechapel smaller not quite as well known but if anything more devious more wicked so how do you play it well the rules are fairly simple one player plays as jack jack's a prick jack has a sack full of body parts and he's making a tour of whitehall dropping a body part on a

white circle in each of the four corners of the map in whichever order they decide like some sort of morbid postman or a tooth fairy who's really misinterpreted their brief everyone else will be playing a triage of primary colored popo's pursuing you persistently who i've nicknamed yellow hello red zul this then and bruce willis so the game's divided into three rounds before the game jack looks at the map and chooses four of these circles and secretly writes them down at the top of their sheet now they have to be white circles and each one has to be in a different quarter of the map once they're locked in jack announces that they are at one of them hey i'm at 32 come get me before they then move to an adjacent circle and try to get to one of the three other quarters of the map and that circle they've written down within 15 turns if they get to one of them they announce again i'm here now come get me and then the next round immediately begins the jack marker moves all the way back to zero so they have another 15 spaces to try and get to another one of the now two remaining circles that they chose right at the beginning if they hit all four circles and complete their grim circuit of london town jack instantly wins however if jack is arrested

by the cops or 15 turns go by without jack making it to one of these circles the police also instantly win bloody hell ugh stop sweating bastard so far so good it's a story of cops and robbers a love story as old as the red slick cobbles but this isn't a dice chucking race game this is so so so so so much better than that this is a hidden movement game the cops their figures stay on the board jack's figure does not instead being used to mark the number of spaces jack has moved that round otherwise he's invisible see jack is moving on this map the rules stay every turn jack has to move and short of using one of his few special powers we'll get to that in a sec jack is going to move from one of these circles to an adjacent circle anything connected by a single unbroken dotted line so this circle is adjacent to that one or that one or even this one so jack's moving whistling a happy tune sacks swinging lumpily on his back hey jack why is your bag so lumpy don't ask questions you don't want the answer to he says oh jack what are you like but instead of this movement being visually marked by a token's procession on the map jack writes down each new circle they visit on their pad of paper hidden away behind this screen with its own version of the map printed

on the back so jack's moving invisibly around the map circle by circle and here you cry that's not fair well yes murder isn't fair and every day is a school day but how do the police bring jack to justice slowly but surely see once jack's moved then the policemen also move each one in fact and unlike jack who moves from circle to circle the policeman moved from black square to black square on their go each copper can move either one black square two black squares or not move at all when each cop is finished moving they can look for clues or they can make an arrest when a policeman looks for clues they are checking each of the circles adjacent to them sort of peering at the street slabs looking for splatters of blood and the cracked stone or dung encrusted footprints in the gutter or someone with a bag full of body bits you know though like that's also that's a clue as well so bruce willis is here announces he's checking for clues at 72 jack then checks their pad and says have i been to 72 at any point in this round jack hasn't so he says no the policeman throws their hat to the ground and stamps on it for good measure if they're unlucky with the first one they can check another circle that's next to them as long as it's adjacent if there's nothing there they can check all adjacent circles until they find something if they don't find anything and they run out of circles their go is over but and this is a queen

victoria sized butt if jack had been to 72 at some point this round then they simply pop a piss colored disc over 72 congratulations officer you found a clue a footprint perhaps a trace of the ripper now blue had found a clue they can't then check another circle that turn their turns over now but maybe reds nearby hasn't had their movement takes it and decides to check 73 and oh maybe jack's been to 73 and then suddenly there's a trail they've got your scent and maybe if they count the number of spaces that they know that you've moved this turn maybe they notice hey jack's only moved five spaces this round and 72 could be three spaces away from where they started which means 73 which we know jack's also been to could be the fourth space because it's right next to it which means that if jack's on their fifth space right now then jack is either here here here here or here right now and jeff's going because after a cop has moved instead of searching for clues they can instead pick one just one circle next to them and make an arrest and if jack's there game over see at the beginning of round one jack has three possible directions to go the cops

are gonna have to desperately spread out to try and cover every direction and got no idea where jack is where jack's going the jack player moves with such ease the malicious swagger of someone who knows something that you don't know but as the game ticks on as we get into round three and jack has checked off all but one drop zone then the cops are gonna know for certain for certain the jack is moving somewhere in this last remaining quarter of the map the haystack that jack's been hiding in has suddenly shrunk to a fistful of straw with a big bloody needle in it and as jack makes the desperate dash for the last drop zone the cops are going to move in and they move faster than jack oh one more thing jack can't move through policemen because you know jack's walking down the street with a human puzzle in a bag jack has to move every single turn but if the cops surround jack to the point where jack cannot move then that is also game over yeah big pillock jack starts so strong with so much freedom on the board but like most serial killers they get cocky they leave too many clues until they're left with fewer and fewer options and that map becomes a prison the police they start off clueless but slowly build their case up and up charting routes on the map until they know exactly where you've gone

and exactly where you're going this is the magnificent story arc that makes whitehall mystery such a satisfying play experience in one basically unbroken sequence of events jack starts overpowered the police start underpowered and the game goes like this and then through that tiny gap pours adrenaline so let's say jack's here 97 they have to get to this space here in 62 and they've got five moves to do it that seems easy but red is perched right here and now jack has to decide where they're gonna move are they gonna move to 46 which is right next to red but they think well red hasn't moved yet red's probably gonna go here so i'm not gonna go to 64.

pro probably what if you move right next to where red is right next to that policeman and they decide maybe i won't move this go and i'll just check for clues and you see blue also moving in at your side and oh god yellow has stood exactly where you need to get to do you retreat do you double back round to go the long way route but you don't have enough spaces of movement for that what are you gonna do what are you gonna do you big murdering bastard but all is not lost for jackson they start the game with six of these tiles now spending one of these tiles allows them to perform a special power on their turn there's three special powers two uses of each to help them escape a tricky spot or bluff the police they've gone a certain way you've got the carriage token this lets jack move two spaces in one turn this is also the only way that jack can move through a policeman because they're hidden inside the cab i guess makes sense what's that lumpy bag attached to the carriage's roof don't think about that there's the alleyway token which lets jack move through a building now all these brown things on the map represent buildings and jack can use the alleyway token to move from one circle that's connected to a building to any other circle connected to the same building for example moving here to here in a single turn finally the boat action which lets jack move from any blue water circle to any other blue water circle that's part of the same bit of river

and that's it and you may be thinking bloody hell now jack's got superpowers that makes him overpowered again right well maybe but also the police have their own one-off movement powers they can use and one of them's a dog which is delightful and second and this is crucial jack's got six to last the entire game not six each round six total spend them and they're gone and you also have to announce that you've used one every single time that you do so do you blow one early to get a head start on the coppers or do you desperately try and save them all for one final sprint and it's such a brilliant end game there's no points to tally up no awkward minutes spent over a calculator and end game bonuses to work out who's won in the end jack either shout i've done it as they move to that final space or the police heart in their mouths make an arrest and jack says you got me boom get to prison yeah yeah wang get it get to get get to get to prison get to prison my whole mystery moves from low stakes to high stress to endgame in such a short amount of time as well this map looks big with all its numbers trust me it is so small and there are so many times that jack's footsteps will be missed by a single space so many times that jack will brush past a copper making their nightly rounds effectively they're holed up in an

alleyway back to the shadows as policemen rush past you missing you by inches both sides painfully aware that just one just one lucky clue has the effect of suddenly grabbing jack by the tie and ramming the knot up to their throats hell if jack plays well and the game goes down to the third round you're still looking at under an hour of actual game time that's so lean such a tight design there is not an ounce of fat on this corpse hashtag hot corp summer no i don't like that the game differs from letters of white chapel which is sort of the same general premise mechanics hidden movement looking for clues but that game requires you to reset the game in between every round there are like four or five rounds you gather the pieces every time you mix them up you start fresh it drags the game out to just beyond its welcome whereas this jack gets to the next drop zone boop round resets to zero off you go again immediately it's so much more thematic because it never slows down and ever interrupts the root deduction process it never lets the players relax from that thrill of the chase and that is why this game is a masterpiece and you should absolutely buy it above any other hidden role game because this game provides the fewest mechanical barriers between you and the story that you're building together on these streets between you and the

momentum that you're gathering slow but steady until you're roaring along like a freight train between you and your own body chemistry from start to end it's one single chase one unbroken string of tension are you looking for a board game that feels like a movie slowly unfurling around you are you looking for a board game you can feel in your chest are you looking for a board game where a single turn can lead people to unironically shout this changes everything well there you go drop 30 notes on whitehall mystery you really won't regret it if you don't like tension or the theme is understandably a little too grim for you then i mean why why are you still watching why are you still watching are you cooking you're cooking aren't you turn me off are your hands full and you can't click to another video do you suddenly feel self-conscious and want me to stop directly addressing you no stop it wash your hands get up and change the video stop watching it's a superb game and it's also really variable in how it plays depending on a few things obviously jack and the cops play incredibly differently and as soon as you've been one you'll want to start a new game and switch sides but it also scales really interestingly from a psychological perspective he said pretentiously you can play it as a heads up one versus one two player game that's super intense cops making eye contact with jack over their screen it's murder chess played in horrible silence broken only by increasingly aggressive demands for

clues it becomes a game about getting in one person's head bluffing them counter bluffing them fainting going one way but actually going the other it's about observance of habits private deductions secret schemes and racked nerves however playing with three or four players that type of tension changes because more than one person playing the cops suddenly they have to discuss with each other where they think jack's gone and jack is just sitting there and listening to them jack becomes a spy within their own game hidden in the shadows as the cops plan their next moves in a two-player game you are trying to mentally suss out where the police might go you're guessing but in a three to four player game they're telling you and sure as jack you might be able to switch up your plans last minute but you might also have just moved and have the horrible agony of listening to them talk at length about where they plan to go deciding your fate guessing where you might be right now and you know they're right it's not a game for everyone some people play board games to relax cowards and not everyone wants to roleplay as one of history's most grotesque killers get that but by now you'll probably know which camp you live in all i'll say to finish the video is this everyone that i've introduced this game to and played with them has either hated it or bought it

make of that what you will and that is our board game masterpieces video about whitehall mystery have you ever played it or letters from whitechapel or indeed any hidden movement games let us know in the comments don't forget to like and share this video around if you enjoyed it and subscribe to no rolls bard for more silly board game content get on board get old get old food

Progress saved