Skip to main content
Loading video...

Wingspan Asia - Expansion Review - Beyond The Base Game

Transcript 22:13

in bird culture this is considered a dick move turn you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.co.uk Kinder stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on Aldo's over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded bacteria's points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kinder and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so on this beyond the base game review we're taking a look at wingsman Asia which uh yeah you'll be seeing there's something wrong with this picture already firstly that is the base box of wingspan it's not Asia secondly there's a bat on it but it's got wings and they don't have a bird plushie so sue me but the idea with this is that I bought the nesting box which is down there on the floor crumbling the floor as it possibly can and the Asia expansion was included in it so I don't have the actual box but here's a picture on the screen there you go that's what it looks like so I'm just going to go over the content of the game and sort of give my thoughts as to whether this

expansion is worth it if you're a die-hard fan or if you're new to the game and just say how it is now as a bit of background I love wingspan I love wingspan you know Stone Myers made essentially free games that I adore I love viticulture and I love scythe and I love wingspan there's the basically the main three well actually saying that the only three but with this in mind I do love this game it'll hang it was like 11 on my top 100. it was definitely up there it was somewhere in the high tens you know like almost in my top 10 games of all time so I do adore this game okay so naturally I'm excited for more content but I am starting to reach a bit of a limit because we're not short on content here and knowing that there's more continent expansions coming out fills me with a little bit of like hope but also with a sense of dread and it's mostly because of this expansion now you know take that with a pinch of salt in terms of you know what I think of this expansion but know that I'm going to be saying some positive and negatives here but this is for a game that I absolutely adore so does that help my view I don't know we'll see so the main aspect of this is that it's essentially packaged as a one to two player stand-alone expansion for wingspan and I know that doesn't make a huge amount of sense but basically it gives you more birds it gives you more Asia birds and that's pretty much the primary reason that anybody is buying this frankly more birds and yes they're not all sleeved I ran out of sleeves I need to get some more but there's a good quantity of

birds here I mean the idea is that this is meant to be playable on its own without having to buy the base set of wingspan and so they give you plenty enough birds in the box so if you're like me and you just want to get a bunch of new birds for this game mix them up with your previous set and bundle them all together then well you're in luck because there's some really cool ones here the Bram Lane the comet the common Sandpiper at a crested Lark Indian peafowl the white crested laughing thrush well that's supposed to be nice that's a weird version of a kookaburra I don't know a Trumpeter Finch the stalk build Kingfisher the Sri Lanka frog mouth what what kind of bird name is that that's a weird one but these ones have the powers as per the previous expansion so if you've played Europe and Oceano you know that they came with other powers that happened at the end of the round and the end of the game well they're in here as well so you've got the normal when played powers where it's only got white and nothing else but then you've also got the European blue Banner Powers at the end of the round you've got the normal when activated Browns and somewhere in the mix you have the occasional game end yellow one although not many of them in fact when you go through this deck you're gonna find a lot of Browns you're gonna find a decent amount of Blues and you're gonna find about one two maybe three game end Birds yeah there are very few of them in here so that was your favorite part of the Oceana Birds well then you're not going to see a ton of them here but there's a good quantity of birds although part of me is wondering why they didn't just simply they give me a promo pack with all of these in so that for 15 bucks and

let me have it because frankly that's kind of all I want for my wingspan expansion at this point just give me a bag with a bunch of cards in it and say there you go more cards that's all you need to do you patented it and packaged it and slapped it on a plastic lunchbox and now you're selling it you're gonna sell it so the fact that it's playable on its own without needing the components from normal wingspan means that you're getting a lot of content in the box that you don't desperately need unless you're going to use every feature of this expansion you'll end up with two more player colors because of flock mode needing six or seven players but if you already own wingspan then you don't you're not going to bother with you know two sets of colors particularly if like me you've pimped up your copy of wings man and got bird houses and plastic resources well the fact that it gives you more cardboard tokens and more you know cardboard and cardboard cubes you know wooden cubes is not really going to be a selling point for this but the idea is is that one or two people can buy wingspan Asia and still play play the duet version of this game on its own without needing any of the original components which is is quite cool although part of B is sort of thundering why didn't you just simply make a spin-off game called wingspan duet and package it in a tiny box and just Market it as its own thing why did it have to be packaged along with Asia me thinks it's because they didn't think that it would sell well enough if they just bundled a bunch of cards in the box and said Asia well you did that with European so you know we'll get it but the idea with duet mode is it's essentially using this board and if you're wondering oh duet mode I like playing wingspan with two player this

could be really interesting well it's um you might want to temper your expectations a little bit here because in terms of changes between the two player of this and two player wingspan here's all your changes that's pretty much it it's just this essentially with the help of the nesting box I've got here you have a bunch of these basically like teardrop tokens as I want to call them for white and black in your player colors and what you're essentially doing is you're playing a normal game of wingspan and I gotta say the boards that they do put in they've got very nice artwork in them I do really like them but it's all about this like grid here with the different icons on it every time when you set the game up you have to put one of these little tiered tokens on your board and when you play a bird on the space you take the the token that was on that space and pop it on this little grid depending on what type of bird it was you played so which habitat was it well it was in the green habitat okay well it was a greater than 50 centimeter wingspan it had a wheat is its cost it also was in a uh you know wood Nest or whatever so I could put it on any one of these three spaces because that's what the bird had so you put your little token on the space and and whoop There You Go and that's all you need to do for now at the end of the round you have round end game Sorry round end game round end bonus tiles which function in the same way as the stuff in the previous game except in this occasion they're all based on these tokens so you've got you know total on total tokens on the map tokens on the food

spaces uh tokens in one horizontal row they are all keyed to this but other than that they function exactly the same as the end round goals a person who has the most gets the most points Whoever has you know second best gets nothing it's just flat out points or nothing with the two player version and then you carry on as normal and then when you get to the end you look at your biggest contiguous group of tokens and you get a point for each one in that group and that is literally it wow um okay uh bear in mind that this game was packaged in the nesting box which cost over a hundred pound if you were buying it not as a stone buyer champion and I believe the expansion on its own was somewhere in the region of 35 to 40 bucks to buy it it's not a cheap expansion and most of what you're paying for is effectively some extra components that you're not really going to use and this board with a mode that literally could have just been put in as a variant yeah in fact like I said why wasn't this just separately packaged as wingspan duet you could have literally just gone right well here's you know half the number of birds here's the boards some tokens here you go wingspan duet it's its own thing like Splendor duel like seven wonders Jewel but instead it's in an expansion for Asia which is going to contain stuff that people who aren't interested in this are gonna buy because they want all these cards laughs mainly like me because I don't play this game with two players but that being

said it's a nice little twist on the system it's not like this is a bad way to play wingspan it's a fun way to Wings play wingspan but honestly I could take it or leave it I could play it this way or I could just play it the normal way either way I'm happy but I do like and I think more games need to do this they have Quick Start guides in here to help new players get into this so each player can have one of these and so player a and player B they've got red bits in the corner to highlight cards that you should use for your first game I can't pick up these when they're not sleeved but it basically takes you for the first four turns script for script so it says like turn one play the willow tit in your forest and it shows you what happens when you play the willow tit which icon you put on the duet board and then what food it will cost how that works and then it says turn to play it in your Wetland and it goes through four full turns and then turn five and Beyond you just get on with it this is a very good little quick guide I think if you want to help new people get into this or say you're completely new to Wings man somehow you're completely new to wingspan and you've bought Asia to get into it from a two-player perspective these are a very good way to do it so certainly positive things to say on that but yeah this massive thing about it being a standalone for two players I was kind of expecting a bit more than just a variant on the end end around goals some wooden tokens and a board with some icons to cover for you know for a non-fromatic area control thing I mean why are we scoring points for a contiguous group you know why are we

even covering these things in the first place there's no real theme with this I mean not saying that wingspan's most formatted game in history but it's you know this kind of just feels artificial feels very mechanical but it works if you're into playing wingspan 2 player and you want to play it this way you'll enjoy it because frankly it's so similar to the original game that you can't hate one way of playing it and not the other it's just a little twist on the idea and I've seen people enjoy it and did I say I enjoyed using it as well but it just when I consider how much the expansion cost and you know what height there was for this it's like come on uh I was expecting a bit more of a change or something a bit more dramatic I mean even Splendid Jewel has more changes and it's gameplay than this does and that's same sign but now well it's still a decent enough addition to the expansion however oh my words oh boy ranting coming yeah this game also touted another Mode called flock mode flock mode is where you get to play this game with six or seven players did anyone in the name of all that is Holy in bird culture ask for six to seven player wingspan I want to see a poll I want to see documentary evidence that at some point in the feedback for wingspan there was a decent enough of people not just a few a decent enough to cause a publisher to go and make a business decision to do this that they

wanted wingspan with six to seven players I don't even like playing wingspan with five five is right out five player wingspan is too long I'm sit there I'm sat there like waiting ages for someone to get back around to me while other people are taking a turn I've already planned out my next four actions it's just like ah get a move on it tracks the game out like crazy never like wingspan with five I'll play it with four or fine and I love it at three I love it too I'll even play it solo and to be fair you can play this with the solo mode and the solo Autumn though with this is pretty good fun I mean it's pretty pretty much the same cards it's just been tweaked slightly to you know akin to the Asia rules but six to six to say but hey Grace maybe you want six or seven players so how does it actually play oh dear God so dear God almighty um mode is basically why I still can't get over why basically you set up the game in a massive grid like massive system where you have two groups of players so you have two groups one group of three players with all the stuff laid out Trey bird feeder cards you already know how much space that takes up on the table and then you have another group with its own bird feeder tray cards boards the lot so you can already tell that the table Hulk space required for six players is insane now try and squeeze a seventh on the board and you're in for a real treat but essentially what happens is there is a little dial that is I believe it's in the nesting box at the moment but it

will you'll put the six or seven player marker on there and you'll twist it round as you go through and the idea is is that it takes the system from Mystic Veil which I've got down here the Equinox variant and it essentially means that two players can play the game at the same time so well sorry I've taken their turn at the same time so two players will take a turn finish done and once they've both wrapped up dial points to two other players and they take their turn so two people are playing simultaneously so you might think well this kind of speeds the game up brilliantly could I use this in less players not really the game only has these dials for six to seven players so if you want to play this fast with four or five you're out of luck but even then the word fast I think has a new meaning I mean I I will quote you from the book okay so let's find flock mode uh gameplay so here we go flock mode I will find it this is quoted in here just need to find it come on flock mode flock mode flock mode here we go six to say this expansion enables six and seven player games when combined with the base game plan for a flock mode game to last about two hours on your first try longer if there are inexperienced players in your group that's putting in mildly seven did anybody want to play wingspan for Two Plus hours two two and a half no the great thing about wingspan was as it was short it was light fluffy and yet gave you a good amount of tactical choices in a 60 Minute time frame 90 absolute Max and once it gets

past 90 I'm kind of done yeah this is meant to be a shorter game so you've basically made a mode which you know makes the game take out take longer it's like The Ticket to Ride rails and sales uh um Standalone expansion that happened it took a game that was short light and cool and then made it more lucky and twice as long you can tell why that one you know bonds didn't yeah but it's not that you just have the table hog issue or the length issue you also have the fact that the rules are a bit more complicated as well because it's easier when you've got six of you because it's always going to be one from each of the two separate groups how does that work with seven well when you've got seven you've got four in one group and three in another and so the book actually stipulates it that at certain times you're gonna have one person take a turn on their own and at some point you're gonna have two people from the four player group take turns while the other group of three doesn't it's like huh and the amount of times I've had people sort of go wait a bit you know in the same game going okay wait a minute so there's two of us now oh there's meant to be one of us now and you can easily lose track of what's going on it's unreal but that's already weird in itself but then you've also got the fact that when you've got two separate groups of players you have to ask yourself well how does that bird work with that one and how does that bird work with this one and stuff well it's got the rules in here but it's got you know interactions and special circumstances as I said but then it's got rules for how certain cards interact based on it so flock mode powers that

interact with other players you've got you know a decent half a page of rules for circumstantial times for once between turns all players other players another player three very similar types of terminology that are on these cards and there's different rules for the three of them ah you've basically made a mode that is longer more unwieldy and more fiddly and complicated than the original wingspan and everybody's okay with this did I miss something why was this made I don't understand now maybe you want this with six or seven players and maybe flock mode is everything you've ever wanted but seriously I would rather you just got two copies of wingspan and broke up and the two teams are free you know it would probably be a lot more fun in that respect because all you're basically doing is just saying well we've got a group of six or seven of us and now we're just gonna try and find a table that is remotely big enough to house six or seven people on it with wingspan it's not like it it's a small table space I mean most most tables won't hold six to seven player wins man it's insane and you've just made it longer more unwieldy more fiddly more complicated it doesn't need to exist I'd love to hear your comments in the in down below if this is something that you love and you know I'd love to hear your reasons why we can debate this until the I was about to say the cows come home the birds come home I guess but still it's not a mode that I'm ever playing again that's for sure in fact

so in summary this expansion was just a big disappointment for me and I love wingspan 11th favorite game of all time or at least top 15 I can't fully remember this is a game I adore so the fact that I've had negative stuff to say about this expansion is gather speak some volumes here because as much as I could have gone into this thinking it's wingspan related and therefore I love it I Gotta Give it tough love and honestly the only person who I think is going to get any decent value out of this is somebody who really really wants this duet mode or maybe it's two people who have never played wingspan before and want to jump into wingspan at a cheaper price point but you're still paying 30 to 40 bucks for this I mean you could just you know find an extra 10 bucks and buy the normal box of wingspan and then at least you've got the facility to play with three or four players you know not five trust me do not play with five but it just doesn't seem that worth it for the money the value is lost here the flock mode for me is a waste of time and I think for most people there may be be the occasional person out there who wants to play six seven player wingspan but for the life of me I don't know any personally and I'm not even sure most people even have a table big enough to house six or seven player wingspan it is that much of a table hog so that mode just seems like a waste of money in the box that I'm never gonna use so really all I'm after is these and you could have just given this to me in a 15 promo pack bag with less packaging less wasted cardboard and I'd have been totally happy this was all European was and that

was overpriced because it came in a fancy box just give me a bag with cards in it and I'll be happy do that for Africa and Antarctica and South America just more birds a few end and round tiles and a few bonus cards there you go I'm happy that's really all I want from wingspan at this point because it's already got enough content as it is this is just a minor tweak it's a good little minor tweak but it's not enough to justify 40 bucks and the flock mode is just a waste of design space wow that was pretty brutal even by my standards no backseats take it from that what you will I was just looking forward to this and I ended up really disappointed this is a 4 out of 10 for me below average it's saved from being considered bad purely because the duet mode at least works I do like the quick start mode they put in this that is good for new players and these birds are cool but considering the value of this expansion it's just honestly not worth it at full price wait for it to be discounted only buy these cards if you're desperate to add more birds to wingspan if you think you've got enough and it's all in one box and you didn't need the big nesting box example then you've got enough content you don't need these you certainly don't need to spend 40 bucks on them but as I say I'd be interested to know your thoughts so that's it for me I'll see you on the next broken meeple video if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and especially from it open Board Game Geek let's get those thumbs there because to see it appear in hottest reviews would make my day but of course let me know your thoughts down below is six to seven

player mode the the one you've been waiting for are you that that one person that I'll meet for the first time that likes six to seven player wingspan in which case tell me your thoughts tell everybody your thoughts do you love the duet mode is this the preferred way to play two player like let me know your thoughts and opinions on that as well but as I say I love the game just don't like what they've done with this expansion maybe it was better for you but these are just my faults so until next time you can check out more content on the show but mainly check out the nesting box review it is down there on the floor it's huge I can't pick it up with one hand at the moment but I've done a full unboxing and Showcase of what it's like pros and cons Galore so take care and remember as always regardless of how many players you want to play wingspan with it's still only a game regardless of whether my thoughts are positive or negative take care and bye for now we kill them and ate their lives

Progress saved