Barcelona Board Game Review: it’s all about the points!
Transcript
Barcelona is a city-building euro game where you will earn a ton of points welcome to brains on games I'm Dr Brian McDonald in this episode we're going to talk about Barcelona a brand new game from the folks over at board and dice which is all about building a brand new modern neighborhood in Barcelona in the mid 19th century this is a game with a rule book that has a whole pile of historical facts in it and Barcelona is a game where you're going to earn tons of points here is here's the box for Barcelona Barcelona is a game for between one and four players there are Solo rules in the Box it's a game that plays with kids age 14 and up should be able to figure this out the rules are fairly straightforward though so younger kids who are familiar with strategy games may be able to figure this one out too games play in an hour to an hour and a half but I would say with three or more players you're going to be looking at two to two and a half hours let's take a deeper look at Barcelona by Boards and dice Barcelona is a game that's that's medium in terms of its complexity and it's a game where you are trying to earn the most points and there are a million ways to earn large amounts of points in this game well maybe I'm exaggerating by saying a million but you are going to earn a lot of points I think on our first game we all earned
over 200 or pretty close to 200 points even when we were still learning how to play Barcelona is a game that's going to be played on three boards your main board is this great big one here you're not going to be able to see the whole thing I'm sure on the camera but I'll have some pictures for you the main board is where you're going to be placing citizens and building buildings and keeping track of your victory points the player boards each player is going to have a board like this one where they keep track of all their tokens and upgrades and and buildings that they've built all of their counters are going to start here at the beginning of the game with the exception of a couple of Point trackers that go on the main board and you've got a board where you're going to keep your modernism tokens which we'll talk about and a really a bonus grid here where you're placing cobblestones for your cobblestone streets and sidewalks and each time you place one you're going to get some bonuses too there are a lot of parts here to this game there's a lot going on but the rules are straightforward and the way you play is straightforward as well you've got this cloth bag each player at the start of their turn is going to have a couple of citizens that are drawn from the bag there are three different colors they're representing the upper and middle and lower class citizens who are going to be moving into this new neighborhood in Barcelona the colors are going to allow you to build buildings of different levels but really what you're doing on your turn is you're deciding what order you want to Stack these citizens in and you're placing them somewhere on the board at an
intersection then you look at the this grid sort of like a a multiplication table you're going to look at the action that's on on the column that you're in and the row that you're in and you can take those two actions if you happen to place your citizens on a diagonal you get the two actions from the row and the column and then you also get the action that's on the diagonal now there are specific actions that are printed out on the board but there are tiles that cover these up so you can randomize things and that can sometimes make the game a little more challenging or difficult but it does add to the replayability so you might be earning some resources you might be opening up some public sector buildings like a hospital you might be taking cobblestones off your player board and I'll show you what the player board looks like once we've talked a little bit more about this big board you might be placing cobblestones on that bonus board you might be taking roads off your player board and placing them here on the grid and each thing that you do is going to earn you some resources or some points every single turn every single action that you take does feel consequential and in a way maybe that I know I've seen some of the other reviews online about this game and in a way I think some some reviewers feel that that kind of dilutes the value of those points but it is a lot of fun to earn you know piles of points and to be able to take some cascading actions as you're placing these these characters on the board now the citizens will start to fill things up and and we did like in
the three player game your options started to become Limited once you start to build buildings you're taking some of them off the board but this space is going to be occupied now for two turns because there's two citizens for at least two turns because there are two citizens on there once you've taken your actions well at the end of the turn you then have to build if you can so the way that you build you you need to have a couple of citizens that are next to the same space on your board so in this case it can be citizens of any color but if I'm building a two-story building I need one citizen that's pink if I want to build a third story on top of one of those I I need a blue Citizen and two others so three citizens for those tall tall buildings but they also earn you seven victory points when you build them so if you can you must place a building on the board and when you do that you place it on that space that's adjacent to your two stacks of citizens you're going to be pulling from I could have placed a corner building here as well have these little tiny Corners that you can add just along the diagonals on the map but in this case I placed a larger building that's going to move me up on this scoring track here on the side of the board and then once I've taken my citizens off I can flip that over and now you've got a Park area and a building that covers two sides of the street the citizens get added to the citizens track at the bottom of the
board and you're probably not going to be able to see this with my little camera up here but you're going to place the green one and they're going to start to cover up spaces and as they cover more and more spaces they're going to be covering these these spaces that have numbers on them and you earn a number of victory points for placing those citizens on there equal to the lowest number that that's visible on the board so as these things fill up you might be earning seven points or 11 points for placing a building somewhere on the grid then you've got these building tokens that are going to go on to the a building that you've built just to show that you are the one who built that sometimes there are bonuses if you build buildings in a particular row sometimes you might earn some points bonuses if you're building Corner buildings along the way and instead of the the big square ones so there are various ways that you're going to earn points and and as those citizens tracks fill up at three points in the game you have a chance to earn a ton of points based on these goals that are also placed randomly on the board once you get to the end of each citizen row you may be able to see from from the pictures that I've taken of the board there are three different spaces that are going to have these tiles on them and once you fill up one of those spaces with uh citizens in any row so it could be just the greens make it all the way to the end of a row then you're going to score these tokens now in this case you're going to score two victory points for each of these
modern spaces that you've upgraded on your player board and as I said I'll show you what the player board looks like now what starts to escalate those those points that you're earning is that you're not just earning two points for each of those you've also got this Sarita track on the side and Sarah is the architect who designed this grid and he wanted to have these wide streets and places where people could meet in places where you could set up shops and pedestrian areas so this is the person who who kind of wanted to to build a modern Barcelona and if you're kind of building things in a way that Sarah would have liked you're going to move a counter higher and higher on the certa tracker and there are multiples here so you might be scoring two points for each of those upgrades but then you're going to multiply that amount by two or by three or by four so all of a sudden you're earning 16 points those bonus tiles are placed at the start of the game so everyone knows what they're going to be shooting to towards as you get closer and closer to the end of the citizen track so you can plan ahead a little bit and say to yourself well I want to be high up on the track by the time I get to the end of that second scoring space and then I'm going to have all of my roads on the board all my wide roads and that's going to earn me two points per wide road that I've got here on on the city grid the game is going to end once one of the the final citizens rows are filled up and then you count up
all of all of your points for that final scoring bonus that's in that last grid and then you score the victory points that are on your player board now you do have a lot of stuff to set up here on the player board there's a bag for each player and I've divided things up so that each player has everything that they need at the start of the game but then you have to place everything on this board so that you know what's what and you're going to take things off as you take those actions in the game and this is how you set up everything that's in that bag so at the start of the game your player board is going to look like this and you can take actions that allow you to place tiles on here that are going to be scoring tiles those modernism tiles I mean there's all kinds of things that you're going to be adding and taking away from that board you've got your narrow and wide roads you've got intersections that you can place you've got your tram here that's going to go onto the board potentially and then you can drop off passengers and that allows you to take some extra actions your cobblestones are going to be placed and you'll earn victory points in addition to the bonuses that you get for placing the cobblestones on that Cobblestone board you earn points for placing roads you're going to earn bonuses when you place those those intersections there's everything in this game is giving you something so there are choices and they're usually to us it was always interesting what is it that you're going to do and how do you maximize your points and work towards earning the the most victory points at each of those scoring parents of the game but you're always getting something so
it was never like oh this term is terrible for me I'm not getting anything that I want there's always something that's coming your way there's always some bonuses and then you do get those big points As you move further and further along in the game well at the same time your options are kind of narrowing as the city builds up and there's not as many spaces for you to work with that is a really quick brief overview without explaining all the specific actions and things that you can take in this game and all the ways that you can get points and bonuses there's so many ways that you can get points and bonuses and resources in this game but what skills are you working on when you play a game like Barcelona well it's it's very clearly and maybe this jumped out at you as I'm explaining how those citizens are placed this is very much a spatial reasoning game it is you know you're talking about real estate in the neighborhood in Barcelona and Real Estate is all about location location location and the location where you place your citizens is super important in this game you're not only getting the two actions or potentially three actions or maybe even a bonus action depending on what's happening on on your boards but you're also placing them in a way that might allow you to build a building or prevent another player from building the building or forcing a player to build a building that they don't want so that it's at the end of the turn and their their bonus multiplier is going to go down when they wanted it to be at four maybe it's going to be at three or two um so it is a game where you're thinking about the placing these workers placing
these citizens uh not just for the actions but then also for what happens at the end of the round and because you always need two or three stacks of these citizens you're interacting with the placement that the other players have made on previous turns there is a lot of planning in Barcelona you're thinking ahead to those three scoring routes where you're potentially going to get a ton of points you're thinking about where you're going to place your roads or is it more valuable to place intersections that are going to give you different kinds of bonuses maybe you're thinking about the victory points that you can earn from the modernism tiles that you put it up at the top of your player board so you're budgeting carefully your actions and your planning ahead there are always choices to be made here and you know you always get something from those choices but but if you want to be efficient you have to be organized and you have to plan and think a little bit now it's very easy in a three-player game for the other players to kind of mess with your plans maybe they're going to take the tile that you wanted for your player board or put their citizens on the space that you wanted that's going to block the the action that you want it to use but you do need to plan ahead in this game and if you're planning ahead if you're budgeting if you're trying to be efficient if you're juggling lots of kinds of information based on the different actions that you can take and the bonuses that each one will provide those are all examples of executive functioning skills the skills and
behaviors that you need to work towards a goal and this game exercises those skills in Spades I would say just because of the number of things that you you could potentially be juggling as you play through it's not a math game but there are math calculations here because the points are big and because you're doing multiplication each of these I don't know if you were able to see it before when I was showing the player board but each of those modernism spaces here at the top has an opportunity for you to upgrade and then you're going to multiply whatever bonus you're getting by three or by four or by or by two depending on how things have been upgraded on the board so those are multiple pulse you've got this certa track on the side where you might be multiplying some bonus by three and you're already counting up well okay I got two points for every wide road that I've placed so I've placed four wide rows and they're two points each so that's eight now I have to multiply that by three and that's how many points I'm going to get so you you are the points are exploding you are really multiplying those points so there's a bit of practice in math and in the games that I played the younger people that I I was playing with they were motivated to make that calculation they wanted to see those big numbers that were going to come up uh one once they did the math you're also potentially maybe developing some knowledge or maybe sparking some interest in Modern urban planning maybe or urban
planning in the 1800s because there are lots of little historical tidbits in the game there's one that stood out to me me and now I know lots of people are just going to skip over that part of the rule book but I do always I mean it's brains on games right I do always want to think of what's what what are you learning from playing and this game does actually have some interesting factual information there's little designers notes saying well the game works this way because historically this was what was what was going on and the one that still stands out to me was that here was this architect who who was planning things out with with pretty wide even the narrow roads were wider than the roads in Old Barcelona where everything was pretty crowded together but he wanted things to be spaced out for there to be more light places for people to walk and places for trams and carriages to go through and so and he was really criticized for that at the time according to the information here in the rule book he was criticized that even the narrow roads were too wide and other Architects said oh it's going to be so windy on those roads you're not even going to be able to live on them well I mean of course once cars came along it was really valuable to have those that wider space and so I guess he his his foresight may be paid off despite the detractors so you've got spatial problem solving you've got executive functioning and planning you've got some multiplication and some math that you're going to be doing you're learning a little bit about Barcelona and and historically about Barcelona in the 19th century final
thoughts though about Barcelona well this was a game that initially was a bit intimidating with all of the bits and pieces and bags and bags and bags full of stuff that had to be laid out the setup especially the first time took quite a long time but the rules are elegant enough that it's straightforward once you start playing the game once you played it a couple of times you're going to know the drill you'll know what all the symbols mean uh and it's it's going to go quite a bit faster I think uh it might look intimidating but honestly the the way that the actions work and are chosen uh is straightforward enough that even kind of novice Euro game players can quickly I think get the hang of this game it is a point solid at its core I think there's the worker placement mechanisms are really your action selection and worker placement and you're blocking off spaces for other work where other workers can't go now um and you're you're balancing choosing the actions versus the the location where you might want to build so there the choices are still interesting so it's straightforward it's but it's still strategic it's it's complicated in the choices that you're making but the rules are simple there weren't exceptions that we had to really worry about we didn't have to go back constantly to the rule book some some of the symbols at first honestly we did have to to figure out well what does
that bonus mean what does this uh picture mean of a disk with a chain on either side um but once we got the hang of those icons uh it worked out very well we did like that you know you can see what you're getting from building a building and then you flip it over and it starts to look like Barcelona it looks like a city and you've got parks and as the board fills up it does you know it's it's a pretty busy board but it looks there's a lot of table presence here to me the the straightforwardness and the point solid kind of nature of the game makes this a real I think a great gateway to the city building kinds of Euros that have been around for a long time I think praga capu regni was the last one that I played and that's a beautiful wonderful game but it's much more complicated than this one is the action selection is very interesting but it is much more complicated and potentially more intimidating than Barcelona so I I think that you know players that are less familiar with with Euro strategy games uh you could bring them into the fold a little bit this one would work better honestly this one would work better with my family and with my gaming group than praga and that's because it is so straightforward and there are so many points and it keeps the the actions and the bonuses keep you involved in in
grossed in what's happening in the game now if there are downsides well like I said I know some people have said that the the point solid nature of the game really dilutes the meaning of the points we loved earning those points however this is a table hog you need a lot of space I mean you can see that there's each player is going to have one of these boards you need space at the top for the buildings that you're going to slot in here you've got that bonus board with the cobblestones on it and then you've got the Great Big Grid where you're going to be laying out the city so it is uh kind of a table hog in that way I think three players is the ideal play count for Barcelona it does play well at two I haven't played the solo game I'm not so much of a solo gamer especially a game like this where the sun won't talk about the setup but especially a game like this where the setup is a little complicated and putting everything away requires you to be pretty organized uh so we haven't played the solo game but I've played it at two I played it at three uh I think four would take a while by the time it gets back around to your turn you're gonna be like well now all the spaces are taken and all the things I wanted to do are blocked and there's just too many citizens going to be on the board but three is great the the the city grid is the perfect size I think for a three player game and that works really well for me and my two kids um there's a lot of setup there's a lot of overhead in terms of the setup and
tear down of this game now it came with a lot of baggies and baggies that had silica gel in it um I you know I've gone to the dollar store and gotten a whole bunch of little Ziploc baggies for my games and we did use some of those just to make life easier for setup and tear down so we've got separate little bags for each of the different levels of buildings uh in the game and and that does I mean it takes longer when you're tearing it down but it does make it easier to set things up when you're ready to start playing the game um so you have to be organized in the way that you put it away they did give lots of baggies but I don't think there were enough I did throw some extra silica gel packs in the individual baggies and and just loose in in the game because I I do worry about those player boards warping and then things not fitting uh or sitting flat even even now this is a brand new a brand new game and I've got the gel packs in there and it's lifted a little tiny bit uh on the corner so nothing serious but I want to make sure that it doesn't get worse than that uh so yeah you've got to be motivated to play this one and and give it a bit of extra time for setup and tear down but we had a lot of fun playing this game and and like I said if I can get my kids and my game group used to these kinds of games well then when I do pull out praga maybe there's going to be more buy-in for a game like that but yeah we had a lot of
fun with this medium level uh like super high point numbers uh in in Barcelona and building the city of Barcelona and thinking about traveling to Barcelona are all things that kind of went along with their playthrough of this game so uh board and dice have created something that we really enjoyed uh and there's lots of replayability here because of the way that the the uh you can replace the action tiles and change the order of them there are going to be different modernism tiles that come up in the game and you're not going to get through them all the points bonuses are going to change what you're working towards in every single game so there's lots of things that you can alter and shift around so that it becomes a slightly different game each time so we had a lot of fun with this one and I'm looking forward to pulling it out again if you have any questions because I know I explained this thing pretty quickly and glossed over all of the details but if you have any questions about Barcelona or suggestions or or anything else you want to chat about in terms of the channel you can leave comments in the comment section below or questions in the comment section below you can also email me at Brian brainsongames.ca brainsongames.ca is the website that's where future episodes will go and the previous ones are up there already brains on games is the Twitter handle and the Facebook page and the Instagram feed so we're all over the place and if you enjoyed this video and you want to be notified of future once you can head on over to YouTube and click that subscribe button thanks for joining me and hopefully I'll
see you next time