Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ark Nova Revisited - Friendly Ties Podcast

Transcript 49:42

hello everyone and welcome to Friendly ties we today are doing something that we have not quite done before which is to go and do something that we have already done which is to talk about Arc Nova so a little bit of a trick here because actually I want to start off by kicking it over to Anastasia to talk about Golden geek surprise it's a trap well thank you Nick so I have a little bit of a favor to ask everyone that is listening to this right now so when we started this podcast almost two years ago guys yeah yeah 18 months yeah at least this was Arc Nova was our third episode and that was 18 months ago so it is it has been a it's been a little bit of time I had an aspiration that I wanted to get friendly ties uh nominated for a golden geek award I do not have any illusions of grandeur here I do not expect to win the golden geek award all right I just want to get nominated that's all I want I want to win I just want to get nominated so as it turns out you can help us do that it's true it's amazing it's amazing so for four low payments of zero dollars and zero zero cents you could click a link you can click the

link and you can do that um it it is slightly easier if you're already a member of board game geek but if you can you can you can also do that there's a link in the description if you click on that link you can it will take you right to the nomination page in which you can nominate as many podcasts as you want all the podcasts you want if if I was one of them it's not as many as you want but but several um if we were one of them I I wouldn't complain you can also nominate a number of other games uh for Golden geek award I believe there's a number of other golden Geeks yeah there's a ton of different categories it's a pretty neat thing just the community can can uh can weigh in in some ways and uh and they have a podcast category so yeah it'd be it'd be neat if we showed up there but I'm not going to be too no pressure yeah I'm I'm gonna be devastated but it's gonna be fine from from purely a game theory perspective shouldn't we tell folks to just vote for us and no other podcasts because it will like up our relatives to come in with the dominant strategy of this I would like trying to be nice but yeah okay so let me take that back don't vote for anyone else just vote for us all those other podcasts I love you and when you get nominated I'll tell everyone to vote for you because I don't want to win I just want to get nominated so just nominate friendly ties we're going geek award all right I think I've said enough on that um shall we get back to the episode we do yeah

so yeah we when we first started friendly ties like Anna said just said it was one of our first episodes um arcanova was just coming out like Essence Spiel had happened like two weeks before we released our episode so people in Europe some people in Europe had copies no one outside of Europe essentially did and the game was just starting to get a little bit of hype and we did this whole episode in fact it's interesting we recorded an episode then played it more and then did an addendum to that episode and here we are like the third time doing an addendum to the addendum but like a lot has changed um in that amount of time and our opinions have maybe modified also this game is number four on the all-time list on Board Game Geek right now it's skyrocketed it's been incredibly popular way more so than I think anyone of us could have uh imagined and um it recently went up on board game arena uh in Alpha and the three of us have played uh it there you two far more than me I'm like you know what we just have so much more to say so um I have played it 18 times now because it starts with some numbers some raw numbers last time we recorded this I think I'd played it three times and and I I ended that podcast saying I hope to play this one more I had no clue that I would play it 18 times that is a lot for me I just looked it up um this is the 20th most played board game I've ever done um like in the 13 years I've been

logging my board games so that's really impressive especially considering how long the game takes to play we joke sometimes I play a game three times and then I don't come back to it and I've played this one 18 times and it's a far different story for you two wait does do you log board games and card games separately no the fact that you've played like teacher 100 million times is like teach you one of the top 20 on there yeah teachers number one crocodile's number two okay yeah so that's actually even more impressive yeah yeah that is impressive yeah for sure especially given the length I mean yeah I mean I remember finishing that podcast and being like you know doing that thing that I do where I'm like oh this is like kind of addictive and I want to kind of like figure this game out and I'm gonna keep playing it but like I don't know how much more I'm gonna keep playing it like there'll probably be some sort of upper limit and honestly one of the biggest reasons that I have wanted to do this episode is because not just because of it coming into Alpha mpga and how many times I played it in the last couple of weeks but how many times I played it in the last 18 months I mean like I think at this point I don't log my plays but I played it 15 times on BGA so but before that I know I played at least two dozen times so I'm I'm somewhere around 40 plays probably of this game over the last 18 months you know and for me that is a lot of games like I oh you know I play more games now than I ever did before thanks to the internet but still that particularly for a fairly new

release that like didn't really come out in the height of the pandemic I mean we can go back and say holler towel and 1800 and other games that we played a ton you know during lockdown but this this game this game has gotten a lot of play time for me serious staying power and I've probably played I don't know 50 or 60 times maybe he's like a decent guest yeah just an incredible amount especially considering it so all three of us listen to our our podcast episode over the last few days to get ourselves psyched up and ready for this and the my feeling listening to us in that last episode was we had fun we were looking forward to playing it more but we were all tempered in our opinions of it um to various degrees which is again why I think I'd be surprised if I could go back in time and and tap all the three of us on the shoulder and tell us how much we'd actually played the next year and a half it's just crazy because you know it's not a short game I mean we it's shorter now than it used to be but it's still not a short game we actually just played a game the three of us we stopped like 20 minutes ago um three-player game on board game arena and it took about two hours and 20 minutes um that's I think partly because I am a slow player Nick is twice as fast as I am according to the statistics on PGA but um you know we talked about the game potentially being shorter and it definitely has gotten shorter but also I've played a lot of two-hour two-player games where we're just kind of like leaning into it you know letting the crunch happen that's part of the fun well you know twice as fast as twice as many games so that's true Nick with the numbers yeah

um no but I think I think you're absolutely right I mean the fact that I can play this game now two player in 90 minutes nine you know 90 minutes 100 minutes easily and I remember it is actually funny listening to the podcast because John I think you even uh referenced the designer say well once you know the game you know people can play it at 90 minutes and I remember thinking in my head like I need to complete that out um and you know but that's because I mean anyone who's heard that part because you go back and listen to it our first play of this game took we now we were filming it but it took like five hours it was so long so arduous yeah we wouldn't even post it that was back when we were posting playthroughs we didn't post it we were miserable like it was one of our worst gaming experiences as a trio ever like I didn't even we didn't even say that like but it really was yeah it was not a great play and yet we all were so intrigued by it that we did then play it again and I think it took us four hours I mean again filming but it it still felt like man this is gonna be a long game I I I said things like this is just AP inducing but once you know the game it gets faster it gets easier it sinks in it flows and I I that is a big factor of this game it just took a little time but it it's one of the few games that has actually for me

it's the easiest game that I played in a long time to reload I am surprised at how quickly I remember so much of the game given how many little intricacies there are and how many things there are to remember I think that's a really good point so I've got a different thing that I'll get into in a minute that ties in really heavily with that I think that there's a lot of the systems in Arc Nova as we said in our original episode they pull from a lot of different things so if you're a gamer it's a really good chance that it's pretty easy to kind of like pluck this from there that from there and you're like oh it all puts together but the other thing is that it's actually pretty intuitive what you're gonna do yeah like it's the the pieces that you do every kind of card that you have or put into play like yeah there's a lot of like special cards or special rules but for the most part it's like place down a thing where an animal can live and then pay some money and now the animal is there and lives there and you're like great awesome that's really cool and then oh this special card is a geologist and he likes rocks so I go to the Rock places you know like there's a lot of stuff that I think is intuitive that makes it easy for for people to like you said reload but also to uh pick up I taught this game to my dad who's a heavy gamer and my stepmom was not a heavy gamer she'll play games with us but I thought it was going to be a really big struggle and she like glommed onto it I mean I was really really impressed at how quickly you know she picked it up and then we played this game that I had

a lot of experience with my dad ended up winning the game and then the two of them played by themselves separately from me and then she ends up beating him so there's something that's like very accessible about this game that is I like to me on the surface Just Dance and and I was wrong I mean I think if there was one thing we were all totally wrong about it is that it it is how accessible I think this game is how how easy it's much easier than I thought to teach it's much easier than I thought to grasp I honestly don't know what was wrong with us like I like I don't know if it like hadn't come out long enough I mean we literally have a a board game rules expert teaching it to us and and yet I like I don't know like I don't know if it was the TTS there was something about the game that that just the beginning I think probably from a lack of overall familiarity with the shape of the game I think in every game I played since and even games I've taught I think if people have either come into the game with a with a general understanding of kind of what it's going to be and then with a few pointers from myself or others it's been so easy for them to pick it up it's just I I was honestly so surprised that I had made such a big deal about this concept of

how hard it would be for new players and yeah I don't think it is I think I was wrong I think I think it really there's a wide variety of of people out there who going to intersect with this game and over the last year and a half I have heard a refrain over and over again from a good number of people when I bring up Arc Nova I'm like oh yeah I love Arc Nova I played it so many times I keep hearing oh I played it once it took four or five hours I don't think I'm ever gonna play that game again I have heard that over and over again uh from people who are highly experienced board gamers and I usually say well was it a four player game yes it was a four player game and I think that's because it's a Euro game people are used to euros and I think it's just very easy to be like most Euros are best with four players let's get four people around the table and I think you absolutely do not want to learn this game at four uh for just about everyone because of the time uh needed especially if all four people are new um uh even three people new is is slightly better but we're not alone in having that really rough first play and it breaks my heart a little bit because I do love this game like it I gave it the number two slot when I did a top 10 list uh for this year I put Scout in the top spot and um and I was wrong guys like do you have regrets yes okay I super dude I played the game like seven times at that point now I played 18 times I and I played Scout like twice since then and I played it like 10 times more and Scouts this tiny little card

game but what I'm trying to say is this game is so lovely and I I enjoy playing it with people I play with so much it's my wife's one of her favorite games ever um she was in love with it the first time I taught it to her so she was a little bit not one of those people who bounced off but again I was already experienced with the game so when I taught it um I could do better at it but if four people nobody knows it just plunged into that really long thing excruciating game and again that you are in charge of when the game ends we talked about that quite a bit in the first episode yeah and if you don't know what you're doing the game could feel like it could last forever and ah man I really wish there was a really short beginner mode that really came with the game I really do like Play This Way first um but you know we already talked about the last time I just want to say you're not crazy and we're not crazy yeah the thing that I wanted to say earlier is kind of like my my I feel like we're in a lot of ways my biggest kind of takeaway from this experience is that arcanova has blown my expectations of what folks are willing to tolerate in a board game and the time thing is very real I still think this game is too damn long and I play a lot of it like and I'm and I feel a little psychotic at some points where I'm like ah this game's so long it has like these problems in the strategy side it can you can have really frustrating experiences and it's it's it is bad to me it is bad design to have a game that you can have a miserable frustrating experience in your first few rounds and then you know you're gonna

lose the game and it's gonna take three or four hours to do that and I yet I keep coming back to it other people keep coming back to it like yeah it can't stop you just can't stop it like ends up being strangely addictive even though it has these things that I think are like these like huge flaws so there's something there that is just like I is is hitting my brain and I'm like oh okay like I people are willing to kind of look past some of these uglier Parts because of the things that they really like about this game and I kind of want to explore what that is yeah you know I there's a one of my best friends from college her and her boyfriend are very big Gamers but her boyfriend even more so than her right and and particularly in Euro games and she tolerates them I think is it like [ __ ] called the like all the games I played once like all the dusty Brown boxes you know like that's how she views uh my taste and yet you know when she was like Arc Nova she was like I got to build a zoo full of monkeys and like she's not like okay she's a great gamer but like you know and it's funny because people keep comparing this game to Earth and Earth is a lighter faster version and her boyfriend was pitching Earth to her and she was like do I get to build a zoo of monkeys and then I played Earth the other night and I immediately texted her and I was like Earth is not Arc no you're gonna hate her like Earth is everything that you hate about you're okay and Arc Nova is it has that right

like it it there's something I don't want to get away from your point Nick about the addictive quality because that was one of the things I was gonna say but there's also just there's something really engaging about the thing that you are building right like whether it is your zoo of monkeys or that for that game of birds that I had in that that game that we uh recorded the playthrough of or whatever I should say lack of birds but whatever it is about your zoo whether it's the map you're playing I mean one of the things we touched on at the end of that episode was this concept of like these the all these different asymmetric Maps well is it turns out the asymmetric maps are awesome they're amazing they're they make for completely different experiences every time you can't get enough of them that alone is super interesting the zoo that I'm playing the animals that I'm playing the way my action cards played out the hand that I drew the hand that I drew later in the game like there's just there's something so satisfying about what you're building like it almost reminds me of like a 4X game or something but like in a much more compact much more Euro ee package like and it just to your point Nick like even when I have bad games I mean I literally am coming off a 10 game losing streak tonight like I might be exaggerating slightly but I'm and then I crushed you and I was like but not once did I say like oh no like our friend hung has just beat me so many times in a row and and then every night I'm like hey let's do it again it's

let's do it again like you free it's 11 o'clock at night you're free for a quickie Arc Nova like I mean it's just I find this game to be very addictive and highly satisfying and and in a way that just scratches so much of what I enjoy about board gaming um in part because of of that feeling Nick that it just no matter what happens to me in the game I have a good time and that is something I know I said in that episode and that's something that that remains true yeah I think a lot of it is that you have built something and 100 that's I think a really sexy gameplay Loop and I don't mean a lot of games have you building something at the table right some big Center map but it's like you are building something I have my board I have my zoo and my cards there's I think a lot of ownership over your experience in this game yeah yeah and you have a lot of ownership about going through the pieces of of running the zoo you know those action cards that you have in front of you they're just everything that you need to do you know you need to have cards cool there's a cards button to to draw cards okay well you need to put these in enclosures you build them you got to put them in there okay well you do the animals card like each one of these things really seems just in line with the plan that you're putting together and I I think that the way like you don't have to do them all in a row like it feels like this game could have totally existed in a different structure where we all had the

cards phase and then we all had a building phase and then we all had to putting the animals down phase because you're going to do all these things but the way it gets decoupled from one player to the next and the way you have ownership over how quickly you you run these things you know I've talked to people who've played this a few times you know one of my friends after playing it once uh a very competent Euro gamer asked me what percentage of the time do you activate things in the five slot versus other slots and I thought about it and I said I I think maybe like 20 to 30 percent of the time you know usually I'm hitting the other spots and he was really surprised by that he thought it would be a lot more than that and talking to other people and I've asked this question to other people and I've heard people say oh like 80 or 90 like oh yeah I I pretty much always just running the thing that's in the in the five slot and I think that that just shows that people can approach this game from different perspectives but from my personal perspective I love that a lot of these actions are only conditionally better with higher uh numbers so it really does make sense to just keep you know popping things when they're at the right number not necessarily the biggest number so you could get them back up again quickly and that's a little bit of a a loop that I find really great to think about you know should I build right now to build that size three so the bill goes back down again so that in two more turns it's back to the size three spot so I can build another size three I mean that makes a whole lot of sense especially early on in the game and I think this is just one of the the many little puzzly things that that becomes satisfying to me I think it's kind of an understated uh brain path for me to go through yeah yeah I think it's

almost like you're not building an engine but you're you're super running one you're just you're just running an engine that was already created for you that you get to you know basically push push all the different pedals on does that make sense like you know I think it's interesting that it's action selection of your own actions I mean it's what I love about Concordia too it's like this concept of like you get to pick what you do sure yeah and how you do it but you're not you could say oh that's like work replacement you have those spots on the board but but it but it's not because there's no competition the people over it and the Order of them and the way you you choose them and your ability to use them and the value of of using them that part alone is so engaging let alone what you then do with it you know to your point John yeah the freedom is nice and the the games that are truly miserable are the ones essentially where you've accidentally backed yourself into a corner and there is there there's nothing like this is a game where you can actually just basically do nothing and you could you could have put yourself in a position or gotten really unlucky but more likely you just didn't have the like crazy foresight you needed to um to not take any actions and then those are the game experiences that I think can lean on the like very miserable side yeah and yet and yeah like I want to say something to that Nick because like I do agree with you right like you can put yourself in that position and and it can be it can not only be difficult to get out of but it also can just be frustrating particularly as other people are doing things and then and then seeing yourself

losing Tempo and like this game because of the way the game is like it's a player driven end game and these two tracks have to cross and it's it's uncertain there there is a there's a Tempo to it and it's a much more tactical game than it is strategic like it for me actually I think it's the perfect balance because there is a ton of strategy and there's a there's a ton of tactics on there they're actually maybe more evenly weighted but but it is those tactics you know come out quite a bit especially um in kind of that race to the Finish but I what I want to say kind of to your point about that misery is is that for me compared to other games and I'm particularly thinking of the Italian designers the the grand Austra Hotel the school speaking of another game we played around the same time which I don't think any of us have played again no since then no no you know even I you know I I love Messina 1347 I love Grand Australia but those games when you fall apart like I feel like you completely and utterly fall apart there's like nothing to do there's no hope of getting back into the game it's over you had your 12 turns or whatever and you you're done and the people around you are taking these extraordinary long pop-up turns and I know that there's a quality of that here but for me I actually think one of the advantages

to the length of the game and this is probably the thing that I like most about it is that I have never played a game of Arc number where I truly felt like I was out of it and if anything I felt like this is one of the rare games that I think you have time to you know scramble fall apart foible around whatever like I don't like not know what you're doing or have a long con game and like still get it together by the mid game and have a shot like it's just for me one of the rare gaming experiences where I feel like I can either have a great plan and kind of consistently execute it or there's a gonna be enough time that if my first my starting hand sucks or if something else goes wrong or I make a mistake I will have time to make up for it I will have time to adjust it's not over because I played one bad action yeah and that's something I really like about this game I think that's because it's not an engine building game like it really isn't and I think some people expect it to be uh you know it's often uh compared to terraforming Mars and depending on your definition I think terraforming Mars is much more of an engine building Style game but in Arc Nova most of what you do is done once you do it you build that building and then you put an animal into it and that's it like that animal gets you a certain number of points maybe it gives you an effect you can you know move this around or draw a couple extra cards but that's it you don't have like

a monkey engine you don't have a predator engine you can have a combo you could put together if you have a bunch of predators and you play another one to like continue getting uh the benefit from drawing if you draw into the cards that does that but it's not like something that just keeps happening over and over again sure the more points you have the more money you get so you can talk about that a little bit but you know you talking about being able to get back in the game I think it's because this game is all about popping off at the right time like you can put together explosive humongous turns and then Peter out and do nothing for like five turns after that as you're like okay well now I'm just like doing this and I'm putting a tiny little animal in there like you you don't want to have your uh Grand Finale and then miss not get to the Finish Line um like it's all about hitting that at the right time and so I think you've probably seen that happen before as well Anastasia where like somebody explodes ahead of you and you're like well how am I gonna catch up and then well then you have your stuff all come together and then you explode as well and and now they're kind of gassed out to a certain extent and it kind of depends on who gets Across the Threshold at the end uh first so I just think it's it's interesting I think a lot of people have the wrong conception of what this game really is because of how it can be compared to so many other Euro games that have a lot more engine building mechanics in them yeah yeah I so first of all I do I definitely agree that it is more tactical than it is strategic and I think that is a boon and I also will agree that if if the wheels come off you still get to play the game like

you might have a sort of three four rounds that are really bad but then you get to then break comes and you get some more money and you get to start like taking your actions again um I think my I don't have the same sort of uh positivity that like I'll be able to come back I'm of the opinion that the the rubber banding in this game is quite weak um there are some strategies that have unrealized gains uh and they they might come into play later but I don't think there's really any rubber banding or very little rubber banding and for those of you who are listening I did this dumb thing where I play games by myself and I play multiple seats in the game and so it's a dumb thing hold on hold on hold on I just want to clarify what this is if you've ever doubted the pure Brilliance of Nick plays four player Arc Nova in Hot Seat against himself four versions of himself and then at the same time plays an async game with me I'm just I just want to point out that he can do that all at once and we all wonder why Nick always wins well so that's your point the point here after the episode a handful of those games that I play with myself right the top to bottom score you know is is 15 or 20 points for all the way from first to fourth place but then I also played a game where I blew myself out by like 45 points in a game where like the score starts at like like a hundred-ish

right like your scale score is like somewhere from like 100 to 150 or ignore the negatives and all that confusing stuff but like 100 to 150 is like the score that you're looking at over the course of the game and I regularly see people lose this game by 50 40 points like a third of the score scale yeah and that is it myself to myself included right like there's there's something oddly snowbally in a game that like doesn't have you know like you said it's not an engine there's no like kind of there is an income system but the income is very muted you know once you get that is the rubber banding right is it the income once you get past a certain point it doesn't get like crazy you know larger but you might have a couple certain cards in play that just make such a big difference or you might just have cards that have absolutely no Synergy whatsoever and then you're just kind of like it feels more like you are treading water and I just I I find myself with that that feeling every once in a while where it's just like yeah I'm I'm I'm just trying to get through um more than like everything is popping off and you know to your point Anastasia like that can be okay because as you were saying John right like each of the pieces are are discreet and actually sometimes you can feel like oh I'm in trouble and it ends up working out okay yeah yeah well I mean I think the elephant in the room for this game is the deck of course right yeah I mean yeah like you're talking about you know you're playing

against yourself and you have these potential massive swings and well maybe the person who won by a lot they drew into their combo better and and I think you know the number one complaint I hear about this game and I really do think we should talk about it is car draw luck uh and is that a bad thing um because I've heard the whole range of opinions from other people and it is true like it's an enormous deck of cards and this you absolutely should not try to draw something that's going to be good for you you should just deal with what you have but I mean the last time you and I played Anastasia before this a two-player game I I just drew so many of these predators and then I drew the Predator conservation card and then I drew the lion that scored for all the Predators I had already and and I won by one point and uh one point like literally one point did I beat you or did the deck beat you I don't know you know it's so funny because when you when you think about this and I do want to add this caveat to to what I said because I to go to what you said Nick about there's not a lot of rubber Bandy and and it is true we should we should all remember that the the girl who said she just lost 10 games in a row is the one who was like I never felt like I was out of it like I don't actually know to what extent winning is like possible because for me the experience is not always about you know winning um I'm always attempting to win but you know in terms of the actual success of that I'm not sure if my math would add up based on you know these horrible

draws and I want to I want to acknowledge that because of the game we just played you know it was a three-player game and Nick had a terrible hand draw at the beginning he told us that he continued to tell is that he drew dozens of times I felt like dozens of times he continued to try and draw cards and it never really came together I mean Nick you you you still ended up in third by one point right to John so you you kind of brought it back but I caught up I caught up right like and it was a nice experience to catch up but like I I just felt like I was losing oh yeah he did he felt like he was losing a game I felt like I was kind of consistently ahead for most of the game and then frankly I didn't tank my lead and let's be clear I have done plenty of games where I've done exactly what John said and I have like had this a great turn and then or great several turns and then tanked my lead and I think that I'm gonna go back to what John was trying to bring up which is the cards and that is to say that the deck and the randomness are what make this game possible for every single thing that we are saying and and I I mean that is the best and then and like the worst of ways and you know in that the episode that we did about Arc Nova initially like that was my biggest complaint I said you know there's a ton of Randomness if you don't like that like it was my biggest concern and yet I I think that actually for me where the deck falls into that is that

this game just wouldn't be what it is without the the possibility the magic the uncertainty the unknown just the the literal fabric of the game that are are the cards that you draw you can draw into something amazing you can dig for something amazing you can you mean to let go of a strategy because you can't get what you want I mean adapting to that adapting to what's in your hand adapting to what comes out in the card River it's just it it's just part of the game and I I I wouldn't change that if anything at this point I just want more just one more card yeah preach honestly so well sad yeah I mean there's almost like a a gambling slot machine result from that deck I mean in that game when I drew that lion I just I yelled you're like so happy you draw a card and just this extreme Elation and you know there's the you know 30 other times I drew a card and I was like this is work this isn't good but then every now and then you know you hit the jackpot and you're like oh my gosh I got so lucky and then you're like did you actually get so lucky how many cards did you draw until that actually happened it's it's just an interesting endorphin thing that that does really work I love I love the point I think that the the card deck is the lifeblood of the game and like you know like I said earlier this game has thrown out the window my expectations for what people are willing to tolerate yeah it seems like too much Randomness for me for a long game for I don't even I guess it's a heavy game right like I think it is a heavy game it's a lot I mean is it

like are we I mean I compared it to Gaia project last time and like I don't know what I think I was wrong well it's a lot more tactical than guy projects like guy projects it is tons of long-term strategy this game it doesn't break my brain in the same way right well I think because you can't think as long term and and you're looking at what's in front of you yeah yeah yeah exactly and sure you could trip and fall in Arc Nova but generally something you did an hour ago does not trip you up now it's something you did 10 minutes ago yeah exactly ruin your in yours like in this game where I like where I didn't know what to do I was building these like five enclosures and the two of you were like oh my God what do you have planned I was like I have nothing planned but maybe I'll draw into fives and if not I can play four guys there like there are ways to sort of like hedge and and that's nice right that you can kind of like start setting up and moving in a direction um even even if you don't have a perfect game plan on the spot and that's okay yeah I think a lot of it it's just this game is very much about the journey but the destination is fun like winning is fun you know you want to be competitive but it's it's so much about the journey do you get there like sometimes I just kind of feel like kind of not necessarily sad but like when the game is over you're like oh okay well I guess the game is over now like I was enjoying doing that I think that's where the addictive uh part comes in because I'm not thinking oh I want to play this again so I win next time like oh I want to play this again so I can be playing

it again yeah So speaking of the deck I actually am curious on another thing that we talked a lot about in that our first episode about Arc Nova you know which is the mean cards essentially and how much have we played with or without them since or do we still feel the same way and if our opinions have changed yeah well I've not used them since I've literally played one game with the mean cards out of those 18. is that the first one just that first that was the very first game that's literally all the time yeah yeah I mean I'm the same way I I played I played that first game and I played one other on BGA and it's because I I forgot to click peaceful and then I used the card and like demolished like the other play I felt so bad like I I like I was like uh it didn't feel good it didn't feel good I didn't like it but you know I I am glad to have played it again to kind of be reminded of that because it is part of the game but I think Nick you have played more than I think I I have I've started playing with them again not because I like them but because I'm preparing for a tournament and I thought that I don't know if the tournament's gonna use them as rules so I just didn't want to be blindsided by their effects yeah um I still kind of hate them uh I think very much our first gameplay was one of those game experiences uh well okay let

me take a step back I think most of the time the the mean cards don't have a very terrible effect on the game I think in a lot of games that you play them maybe one in ten games you play them they're like there maybe someone gets hit it's not that big a deal but every once in a while like you play it and it's like it's done at a point where it's early in the game and it just completely hamstrings a player or maybe multiple players but it's usually like one player who gets like hamstrung and it's not even necessarily the player who's winning like you might look and be like well it can only attack the person with the most appeal but as we know having the most points in the game does not necessarily mean that you're winning and especially in a game that has two kinds of victory points it definitively doesn't mean that you're winning yes and so it just has these like kind of really frustrating moments that I don't think are worth the moments where they actually are kind of fun I feel like in the early game I'm spending enough time trying to focus on like how soon is someone going to activate the break like I might have enough time to get what I want to do done well I have enough money and and let alone focusing on those elements of it but also just the the nature of a game that we've talked about is so satisfying for what you are building for what you're creating and your hope is what you are creating is well frankly better than everyone else's but then to to so directly attack someone for it now having said that I I do recognize a lot of people play this game with the Attack cards I'm actually honestly shocked at

how many games I see on BGA of people like so rarely actually do I feel like I see people you know posting games with you know peaceful mode uh on it so so I imagine and I'd be actually curious you know for people listening to this if you have played Arc Nova and you want to comment in the comments like I'd be curious how do you play it because I am genuinely curious like how many people play the game with these negative cards I mean for me I feel exactly the same way I fell 18 months ago I don't lose anything from it and and it definitely it doesn't add anything and if anything it takes away but I also like playing games I don't feel like Arc Nova's multiplayer solitaire but I guess you know from a strict definition it could be and that doesn't bother me at all so I've been pretty clear that I don't like to be a mean player except I guess if you're Nick and you're winning and I feel and then you're positively gleeful there's there's two I think there's two kind of primary forms of interaction in the game that to me say yeah this is not as multiplayer Solitaire as some other games that I've played and it is it's the tempo of the break stuff and paying attention to that and then the racing for the conservation points like I will say one thing that I actually really like about playing this on BGA compared to playing on tabletop simulator or in real life which by the way in real life does anybody else feel like the pieces are very small it always throws me off um I'm I'm genuinely trying to think

anything put in here I do please guys if there's anything to know about me that is not a marker whether or not I played the game for me yes um but the vast majority of my plays have been actually physical uh you know yeah probably you know not maybe not vast majority but 10 out of those 18. yeah I think in my mind I've played it with you John but I I honestly don't know if I have anyways that's not important but clearly the inclusions in particular just feel so teen seeded me I don't know why are they really yeah they're so tiny but on BGA it immediately just tells you how many tags a person has you don't need to like scope out their whole board or anything like that so it's nice to be like oh you've got three Predators I've got four so I got a little bit of wiggle room before I need to go for my conservation or you know I'm I don't want to risk it I'm gonna like I I like that it's very easy to see the tags uh in that format yeah yeah for sure so I have just a couple of so there's a couple of other things we said at that podcast so I'm just curious where we where we land on so I can't remember if this was the game where we came where Nick you coined that phrase uh game of restrictions or if it was something else that I just started using it around this time standby it was this game was 100 so I I almost forgotten that we'd said that about this game because I know I now use that term all the time do you still feel like this is a game of restrictions yeah it's I think it's I feel like I'm playing and this is not

a criticism it's like just a comment I feel like I'm playing to make sure that I don't put myself into a bad Corner more often than playing to do something explosive or amazing um so you know I I'm careful about when I'm gonna run out of money what's gonna happen with my cards and I'm gonna have to you know discard them or how can I use them beforehand I was very bad at that in the game if we just played um but that's the kind of stuff that I it keeps me up at night you know so I do think it's a game of restrictions I do stand by that and and I don't think that makes it bad I just I just to me that is what it is you know and to me that that lends itself towards that you know tactical nature that we've been talking about yeah I think if anything The Arc Nova has forced me to become a better tactical player like to to I Really this game I think in a really good way really exercises that muscle of like you can't do everything you have to let things go I can only focus on like one plan in my hand or maybe the plan maybe the cards in my hand they don't work with the goals or they don't work with the way my action cards are laid out like you just there's a lot of times where you just you have to make a choice and you have to kind of go with that BGA also I think for all of it's It's pluses and minuses it also forces me there's no take backs I mean we talked a lot about how nice it is amongst us that we often kind of let ourselves kind of fix things and address things and we ran into that several times tonight you can't you can't take it back that is a that downside of a playing on that particular medium and um

you know I think this is a game that that does benefit from that when you have the opportunity to do that I think that helps a little bit with with letting it be a little bit more forgiving but I also think you know to kind of circle back on on kind of where we start and where we are now one big thing that that has kind of come up is is is knowing the arc The Arc of this game the timing of this game helps I think with understanding those restrictions and like I know something we didn't do in our first game which I've reflected on a lot it's like we didn't understand that you like needed to break we didn't understand that you like needed to play the sponsors card for money but the sponsors card is like your way of controlling the tempo your way of giving yourself money I thought it was like oh in the last worst case scenario use it for money and move the break and now it's like oh no like 80 of the time I smash that thing to move the coffee break token yeah exactly to make that happen and and and that's so essential because that first break is kind of everything and I remember that actually being another thing Nick that you you kind of wanted to Lop off like the first round of the game and I'm curious if you either of you still kind of feel that way that the the beginning of the game is too slow or it feels like you know I think Arc Nova preludes would be an improvement yeah do you feel the same way I do I mean I yeah I do I I well I guess it depends on the context like I don't mind playing it the way it is forever um I don't necessarily need to be shorter because I know what I'm getting

into and I sit down to play the game but going back to First Impressions I I just can't help but focus on the people who would potentially love this game that are never going to play the second time because they had such a miserably long first play and I think for that the arcade will Prelude type thing would be amazing like like so many people like this game already imagine if it didn't have this frequent awful first impression would it be number one number four yeah no 100 all right so final question guys to this is the one thing that I remember from this podcast before I went and relisted to it this was the only thing that I I really remembered all through these 18 months was Nick saying uh it wasn't worth the work so I want to know now Nick was it worth the work yeah I was wrong I don't you don't play something 50 or 60 times it wasn't worth it I'll eat those words I think it's certainly worth the effort to get into it you know it's yeah a lowly 18 games um yeah absolutely I think it's it it's worth it um you know I've I've definitely had a an arc we're using it all the time every time we say Arc in this game in this podcast I remember when I played it uh seven times uh which was relatively soon after we had recorded that episode

um at that point I had played if I remember correctly all of the asymmetric boards maybe I'd played it eight times um but I played all the boards except map of zero I don't think I ever got around to playing that one but that's a training wheels map so and I remember feeling like okay well I think I'm kind of done with Arc Nova like I I tried all the maps and played them all once and um my my motivation kind of lulled a lot and I didn't really touch it for a couple of months and and I think that's probably around when I made that top 10 list and I put it in the number two slot and um and then I think my wife Jessica was like one day she's like hey look we haven't played our couple months let's play it so we played a game and I was like oh man this is really fun and suddenly I found myself wanting to play it again and we played it like within the next week and then again and again and so I just wanted to articulate this this interesting curve of excitement where like you know the first play was terrible and then the second and third play I was like starting to get really high on it all the way up and then I lulled again around the seven or eight and now I feel like I'm just going up and up and up like I feel like every single time I play it now and I'm about to play 18.

um I'm even more enthusiastic about it and I I'm not really sure why maybe it's just because I finally fully come to accept what kind of game it is and the kind of experience I'm going to be getting from it um and maybe I'm just so used to not playing games all that often that I kind of figured I was done with it um when I'm actually not and so to come full circle back to your question that I already answered uh yeah it was totally worth it um I think even just for those seven games you know even if I never actually went back to it and picked it up I think that's that's a lot of fun that I had in those um in those experiences uh and especially so now that it's it's just continuing on into the sunset for me and apparently all of us yeah well everyone thanks for listening to us talk about this game for a second time for another hour persistent and consistent well as we mentioned earlier we're trying to get nominated for the golden Geeks don't forget to check in the the comments so you can uh you can see the link that you need to click on so that you can you can get us up there and get us nominated we'd really appreciate it uh and other than that thank you everyone for listening I hope you have a wonderful week and if you want to comment on this make sure you head over to YouTube you can put comments in the YouTube version of this podcast uh thanks everyone wow

wow

Progress saved