Cities Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
at number two I have cities now this is a familyfriendly weight game about trying to build cities of course uh this is designed by Steve Finn and Phil Walker Harding so two designers of great pedigree there and it's a very simple game mechanically as you are trying to build this 3x3 grid and populating it with these kind of features that will go in the Parks features that will go in the water as well as building buildings by stacking these plastic blocks um on top of each other now the game play is super simple and it works a little bit like a worker placement game but more of a a drafting variant of that as you have four rows on the board with four different kind of components that will be added to your city so the first row is going to be a scoring card which will score you points based on different factors things like score one point for every Green Building at least one high or score um two you know one point for every two spaces in your biggest field these things we've seen before so that's the first segment the second segment is going to be the actual tiles or the foundation in which you can build the things on and these might determine other objectives that you are trying to reach towards um the third row is going to be these features that you're going to be filling up with your you know your parks with benches and fountains and things the more different features you have in your Parks the more points you'll get so simple set collection and the final row is going to be these
plastic buildings where you can stack them on the matching colored spots within your city so not only are you trying to build the city to of course tailor them to be um to contribute towards those scoring cards even objective that you've s drafted but there are also public objectives that you are racing to achieve and these public objectives are variable and there are quite a few of them in the game and they all are kind of assigned to a different famous city in the world so for example the New York one will score you points based on your your biggest park or trying to get to a certain amount of Park as quickly as possible um to kind of represent you know Central Park you'll also score points based on skyscrapers so you want tall buildings and and also having like Avenues of the same buildings or having whole rows completed of buildings which is not an easy thing to achieve so again you're racing to get these objectives you might get some you know second place points or third place points if you are a little bit behind the other players but of course the points will be distributed accordingly so very simple stuff um it only takes well it only takes about half an hour to play and maybe even quicker than that at two players because with the two- player variant you are playing um four rounds instead of eight and you're placing double the amount of workers on the board each round now I like the idea of this one I like again how simple it is um and that you are tailoring your strategy as you go um and I do like I suppose the main the main
feature of the game or the the main kind of feeling of the game was supposed to be that turn a what do you go for first because if you go for the scoring objective first then you're probably giving up Priority in taking one of the other ones um there's a sort scarcity of what you want that you know that turn a really does shine through so you do need to factor in what do I need right now what can I maybe take a turn or two to get because although it's a really good card I don't think my opponent wants it so therefore I can put it behind on priority order so I do like the way that you have to prioritize which of these actions you want to take and you can't go there for a second time to take a second action so I really do like that factor this is real scarcity to get what you want sometimes that shines through stronger than other times because there might be times where you think you know I don't really care about going there anymore because I know that's mine anyway um and both of them are are fine I can make do with either of them so maybe it could have been the volume of that that turna could have been turned up a little bit more at times because a lot of the time you times you can make do with what you have anyway and generally do all right but I appreciate this this is who that game's designed for it is very introductory it is quite light um not only in terms of the rules but also in terms of the decision space and unfortunately although I I love how smooth the gameplay is I love the potential of the game I think that maybe it's a little bit too
light for me and the choices are a little bit too obvious a bit like River of gold I would have and even AOL Los I would have liked to have seen an extra wrinkle or two just to add a little bit more seasoning to the game to make it a little bit more interesting as it stands again objectively I can really sing its Praises it does a great job of doing what it should do kind of fits that King Domino Vibe um but for my collection and looking this more subjectively um I don't think it's going to quite cuss the cut the mustard to be a keeper within my collection uh it's a game that I would probably never turn down playing because it is very pleasant very enjoyable um but do does it deserve its space on my own shelves when space is a premium I don't quite think so and it's that's a narrow Miss as well so um unfortunately I want it to be a little bit more than it actually is and maybe that's me yeah maybe me kind of fantasizing what it could be rather than what it actually is and what it's trying to be so that is cities