How Does BLACK FOREST Stand Up to GLASS ROAD? My Take on this Uwe Rosenberg Implementation
Transcript
Hey everybody, Kimberly here and I'm super excited to share with you a deeper dive into Black Forest which is designed by Uve Rosenberg and um Tito Loren. Now this is a re-implementation of Glass Road from 2013 designed by U Rosenberg and so over 10 years later we're revisiting and not just that there are some new elements, new components um that elevate this game and make it just a little bit more complex. Uh BGG actually ranks this 3.22 out of five on the complexity rating, which puts it into the the red zone. And uh Glass Road is 2.95 out of five. So you're going to see like a quarter of a point of a complexity bump uh here. And that also comes with time. The original Glass Road was about an hour game and designed that way. 20 to 80 minutes it says, but this is going to be a 1 hour to twohour experience. So, what makes this game longer and a little bit more complex?
I'm going to jump into that as the very first of my favorite features of this game. Now, I was introduced to Black Forest the night I arrived at Board Gamegeeek Con 2024. I'd been flying all day, traveling all day, just dumped my stuff off in my room, went downstairs, and this was the first and only game of that day that I arrived that I played. And what a nice introduction to the convention that this game was to me. So, I had not revisited Glass Road in a while, even though it is a favorite. I actually have it on the shelf right over there. Uve Rosenberg is a favorite designer of mine, but it was easy to get into and all of us were familiar with Glass Road at the table, but only one of us had actually played. So, it was one instructor and then four players and we just jumped right into it. So, this is going to be the main board. And this is one of the biggest differences that you're going to see from uh Glass Road to Black Forest. And I think it's a fantastic feature because it's not set in stone. the design on the board is, but you'll notice that there are these different kind of villages that are all spaced around with different routes and they have different images. So, what you're going to do is shuffle up all of the backs of these reindeers, so to speak. And then you're going to flip them into place going like this, and you're going to pop them in where they belong. Then you'll go to the little foxin and you're going to say, "Okay, here's little foxy
another foxy. We'll do this foxy, this one, and that fox. Got it? Mouse. Here's a mouse in. Here's another mouse in. And then lastly, you got the owls. So, this is how you're going to set up the game to give this combination uh opportunity variety. And I think that's huge. That is so important because on your turn, what you're going to do is the first thing is you can spend a commodity. Um, and that's going to be an optional thing to spend a commodity, but commodities are really important in this game. And this little rucks sack you're going to see here, um, it's going to uh, essentially keep you from moving your wheel because in this game, much like glass road, you have dual wheels of commodities and not commodities, but uh, resources. I don't want to get the names confused. Gosh darn it. If the there are so many different resources in this game, I cannot keep them straight. So, I call them as I see them. So, I'll do my best to call them what they are, but I just look at the picture and then I just say what I see. And so, um, that's going to hopefully help out other people who are watching, but there is a list and description of exactly what those resources are. But then you'll take your figure here and you're going to at the very beginning of the game simply just place them in a space between two of these different uh tiles. And you are going to be activating one tile and then activating the other tile as long as you can do it, which is the strategy of the
game is to go someplace where you can get two actions or two different tile activations. And so when you're moving around, you're trying to figure out where can I place my figure. Um, this is going to be a great place to go and get resources. For example, every lake you have gives you one yellow grain. This one says you pay a wood and you get four coal. And this is essentially going to be that resource board. It is a dual um wheel where you've got all of your resources in their starting locations. You've got your um essential compasses pointed in the correct direction and they this will move on the track, but only when this space becomes vacant. So if you gain like rice pudding, you will move this up until you actually are bonking on something here that is essentially blocking you from continuing the movement. But this is how your wheels are going to move. You get one of those yellow grain things. Oh my gosh, this moved. And now you've got a glass.
Glass is the pinnacle of resources. It's the highest resource uh that you can earn. only three. Essentially, it's on this space all by itself, much like all these provisions and rucks sacks over here, you're going to see. So, that's essentially how these are going to move because you're essentially gaining the resources. But when you gain resources and the wheel moves, the resources on this side depreciate. It's a fascinating uh push and pull, which I find really, really satisfying. I love that feature. So, this is a feature I like. I really like this feature. Now, when you have to move in the future, it comes back to you for your turn and you go to the movement phase before you go to the actions. You have to move from this space, but you don't have to move from that particular village. You could just go to a different con uh connected to different tiles. It could be even this one because you really need to do this one again.
So, that's what you do when you're inside of a city. Now, if you have to move, you need to pay the amount of these rucks sacks from your board to then cross over from one to the next. And you're going to see that there are even smaller roads that are going to get you to opportunities um for doing jobs, which is another feature I really, really enjoy. But if you move into a space where there is another player, you have to pay them a resource of your choice. They take that resource and you lose that resource. And so that is a fascinating choice too with your strategy going places where maybe other players aren't or if you just can't help it. You have to go there and you essentially are paying them to go in the same town as them, but you can never go in the same space. Really, really cool features. So, let's talk about jobs.
When a player has moved their wheel, as you can see over here, I'm going to move these down a little bit and move these over. when they move their wheel and it essentially kicks that little uh diploma, that little scroll over here. You're going to gain a resource of your choice, which is what that wild symbol means. Uh so let's say we got wood. Then you're also going to add a job to the public area. And jobs are down here in this bottom corner. They are shuffled up at the start of the game. And then you're going to reveal a job. And this job is going to go to its location. So you're going to look on the board for where you see this particular symbol and it's up here in the corner. So I'm going to put that job right there in that space. So if a player essentially goes to a location with a job, they are going to be able to do the job which is paying resources to gain a set number of things um instead of visiting the trades people inside of a village. And so if there is one that's here, let's say this one um got put in here from here, you would go to any of these locations to complete the job, but you don't get to do what's in between the trades people. So these jobs are really, really good. Now, they come out and when players succeed and they take them, one replaces it. And you essentially will have jobs out on the board based on the number of players.
Because if you have a four-player game, it's going to take every player a different amount of time to activate their little scroll symbol. But that means that every time someone does that, you get to add a new contract or a new job. And so there's going to be jobs out here um based on the number of players in the game, which I think is a really really cool feature. It is a race and it is a kind of gamble where it's going to show up on the board and what resources are necessary because some players will be set up better to accomplish those jobs much faster and more efficiently than you will. But hopefully the next job will actually be tailored more to what your gameplay is. So that's really what's going out here on the board. And I find that fascinating. I like it. I like it a lot. I love that you get to do two trades people. I also like that it costs these little rucks sacks just to get places. Um, and you have to really manage that on your player board. And I really like that there is a trigger to get to these specialty job tiles. And those are going to go out randomly on the board um, based on the shuffling here. They are set in stone placed on the board themselves. So, they're going to come out and there's going to be one for every one of those spaces, but you never know when and where they're going to appear. Um, and then you've got this whole resource management. This is the game. This is where most the fun is had.
Um, and trying to figure out like exactly exactly when to move your pieces so that you can move this and trigger what you need, especially over here gaining the glass. So, let me talk a little bit about your player board. This is going to be your player board right here. And every time you get glass, which is going to be this symbol right here, it says move your uh glass up one. When you get glass and you get to the top, you're going to be gaining an extension to your area cuz you're building up your kingdom. You're building up your area plot. And as you see here, when you have starting tiles, you're going to be gaining things like these forests. So, you can cut down the forests. You can also keep a boar. And then you'll also have an opportunity to uh essentially have your lakes and then you're going to have your fields as well. And so you can keep these animals in these basic pens, but you're going to want to upgrade. And so that's where all the buildings come in. So while you have spaces here that you'll fill in for all of your woods, your farmlands, and your lakes, you're going to want to essentially, you know, like count them up to gain things, but maybe uh cut them down. like here's cutting down trees to gain wood. And this one gives you a chance to build a building. Those are going to be the things that you take so that you can continually grow. And this is going to be one of the opportunities you can to grow is this super fancy house. This is a one to three player side board. And the cool thing about this is you've got
all these specialty tiles and there are going to be many number ones that you pick from and the top two are going to be number one tiles. Then you've got several twos. This one's a two right here for the thermal baths. And then you've got several threes. And this is going to be a level three. So you're always going to have a nice balance of tiles that you can come and pick. But these are all one and that's it. They do not get replaced. You only pick those four for the entire game. So players are looking at the tiles that they can use um to essentially buy and then place. Oh, I have three glass. I have three wood, three coal, and two waters. I'm going to place my thermal baths right here into my plot. And now I've got 10 points at the end of the game. So, you're going to be essentially going for these building actions. So, this is going to be the one set of buildings.
And then this is probably the most challenging part of the game and I think maybe the most overwhelming. So, these are going to be the 36 tiles in the game. Here are the bag of the 36 tiles. And you just place them out in their space that they say. And these are all going to be upgrades that you can put to your um player area on your board that are essentially going to be focused on these particular things right here. So they activate, they give you ongoing abilities, they give you immediate actions or bonuses or benefits. They might be endgame victory point scoring based on certain criteria. And the thing about this is it's overwhelming. You know, looking at these tiles and you're thinking, "Oh my gosh, there's so much out there. What do I start with? Where do I go? How do I begin growing up my area? Where do I go on my turn that allows me to invest in these buildings?"
And of course, first come, first serve. Once this tile is gone right here, it's gone forever. Now, there are uh two sides, so it's going to give some variety to your tiles. So, if you pick up this tile right here, for example, this tile is 11. You'll put this on the 11 spot. It's the potach manufacturer, but it says 11A. And then the other side of it says renderer. So, there are A and B sides for each of these tiles. There are requirements down the side, and then there is the benefit or bonus in the center. So, that's how these tiles are going to work. So you can see everything all at once. Everything is out there. Everything is open. This is the the player boards are open information. The wheels are open information. The jobs are open information. And of course the trades people are too. So it's more complex than Glass Road and I think it requires a play or two to kind of get the hang of. But this is a nice juicy game. It is a way it is a nice strategy game. And what a lovely introduction to, like I say, board game for me to show up and jump into um this implementation of Glass Road. And it's just a little bit juicier, a little bit more complex. And so I had a fantastically fun time with this. I think it's delightful and I think it's replayable simply because these tiles go out into specific spaces, but shuffled up randomly. You also have A and B sides. You also have multiple of these buildings on the special building side that you get to shuffle in and see
different combinations of. And of course, your strategy is going to change for every single game, particularly based on the amount of players. Now, on BG, it says this game is best with two. I'm not a fan of having a neutral player pawn in the game where players have to move it. And so for me, I'm actually going to say three to four players for this game is my ideal game. And with a seasoned, you know, maybe expert players if you'd like to play this game specifically. If I'm playing Glass Road, it's going to be for a lighter game night for uh maybe uh entry- level gamers that are trying to get into strategy games. That's what I'm going to offer is Glass Road. But this is going to be a game I sit down and play with my fellow gamers and really just enjoy.
It's a lovely, lovely revisit of Glass Road and I'm really glad they did because I think it's really, really cool. So, a lot to like with Black Forest and a ton of replayability. So, that's going to be my take on this and thank you for watching. I'll see you later, folks. Bye.