Skip to main content
Loading video...

Crafting the Cosmos - TCbH Mini Review

Transcript 5:11

You know, it's a bummer. Crafting the Cosmos is probably going to be my biggest gaming disappointment of the year, and it kind of has nothing to do with the gameplay itself. I got to preview this game at PAX Unplugged last year and was really stoked for it. I even listed it as one of my favorite games of the year back in January. And I I finally got my hands on a review copy. And well, I got to say that I really like the snappy gameplay and a lot of the systems that are at play here. Crafting the Cosmos is not going to be hitting the table again for me. But first, some context. In Crafting the Cosmos, you play as cosmic forces trying to build the best universe. You'll do this by wielding the powers of space, time, energy, and life itself. Each turn, you'll move your marble and optionally a few other marbles in a central rondelle. The places you move them to determine what sorts of little goodies you'll get this round on top of one powerful star and action.

Once you finished gathering the resources on your turn, generally the next player can start theirs. So once everybody gets a hang of it, this game flies by. And I like this game quite a lot, especially if you can play with people who have played before. The teach is a bit timeconuming just cuz there are so many different point salad type systems at play here. Now, if that were the only issue, we'd be in pretty good shape here. But we got to talk about the production of this game, which is both paradoxically bonkers and bland. Let's start with the life forms. Without context, these aren't bad components. They're meant to represent life stabilizing as star systems create nebuli for them to occupy. They're two-sided with one side representing unstable protoife forms and the other representing stable life. To signify this, when you stabilize a life form, you flip it from the purple side to the green side.

But within context, I hate this piece. It's so small that it frequently gets blocked by the stars you place around it, which means it's a little bit like a game of operation as you have to finagle your way through hydrogen and helium just to flip it over. And the stars surrounding it hold onto their spots you insert them into on the playerboard pretty well. But that means if you ever have to flip a star into a supernova or just move that star around the board, you risk it popping the board up a bit, which can mess up how you have your life form set up. Next, we got to talk about storage. This game is incredibly ambitious with its central Rondell system, which is a nifty gimmicky gameplay system that is pretty attention-g grabbing when it's on the table. But because of it, storing this game sucks. There is almost no consideration given to keeping things in place in this box. Unless you keep this game perfectly flat at all times during storage, the pieces are going to get all jumbled up, meaning it will take 5 to 10 minutes from when you open the box to sort everything back to where it should be, just so you can begin setting the game up. I get it. We're spoiled in 2025 with sculpted, beautiful inserts, and I'm not expecting the moon, but the design of the game board actively works against getting it to the table. And the icing on the cake is that the art is just blah, which is kind of surprising because Zman and Office Dog have really

knocked it out of the park with some other games that we've covered recently, such as River of Gold and the Fellowship Trick Taking Game. These cards right here are meant to represent the raw powers of space and time, the energies of the cosmos that you are using to trade in for reoccurring power-ups that completely change how you approach the game. But because of the art, they just kind of feel flat. This game also uses icons a lot, which isn't a bad thing. In fact, I think it could be great. But how can you publish a game so reliant on iconography in 2025 without reference cards? Teaching this game is silly because it's meant to be simultaneous play to a degree. That's one of the fun things about it. But without an icon reference for players, there are frequent stops to explain what different symbols mean. So yeah, like I said, a bummer. There is a game in here that I like, and there are some systems in here that I really want to see play out, but time and time again, Crafting the Cosmos gets in its own way. This game is a pain to set up, to teach, and even to play.

If you don't think these production issues are issues, then there is a really cool game within here for you to discover. But for me, the physicality of the board game is just as much a part of the experience as the gameplay itself. And because of that, I don't see this game making it to my table again.

Progress saved